logo
Environment Secretary urged to apologise for ‘misleading' Scottish water claims

Environment Secretary urged to apologise for ‘misleading' Scottish water claims

Independent5 days ago
The Scottish Government is demanding an apology from UK Environment Secretary Steve Reed for 'inaccurate and misleading' made about water quality north of the border.
Mr Reed came under fire after claiming that under publicly-owned Scottish Water 'pollution levels in Scotland are worse than they are in England'.
The UK Government minister made the remarks to Channel 4 News as he dismissed calls for water services south of the border to be nationalised.
Gillian Martin, the Scottish Government Secretary for Climate Action and Energy, said she was 'extremely disappointed' that Mr Reed had made the 'inaccurate and misleading comments regarding performance in Scotland' as he sought to 'dismiss out of hand the value of public ownership of a key asset like water'.
She wrote to Mr Reed noting that Monday's report from the Independent Water Commission, led by Sir Jon Cunliffe, had found 66% of Scotland's water bodies to be of good ecological status, compared with 16.1% in England and 29.9% in Wales.
And while she accepted the figures for the different countries were 'not calculated on the same basis', Ms Martin stated: 'It is clear that Scotland has a higher performance.'
She insisted that 'much of the improvement' seen in water in Scotland was 'due to significant investment in the water industry to reduce pollution', which she said was driven by both Scottish Water and the Scottish Environment Protection Agency (Sepa).
Ms Martin told the UK Environment Secretary: 'Your comments sought also to undermine the idea of public ownership in the minds of voters, yet this is clearly what the people of Scotland continue to want.
'Indeed, it is the very fact of that public ownership and control which has allowed us to keep water bills lower for people, compared to what people with privatised water supplies in England have to pay.'
Noting that Sepa had found 87% of the Scottish water environment to be of 'high' of 'good' quality – up from 82% in 2014 – she insisted this was 'in part, due to water being a publicly-owned asset, allowing for investment without shareholder returns or the pressure to make profits'.
The Scottish Government minister went on to tell Mr Reed: 'I am therefore asking that you acknowledge that your comments were inaccurate, that you apologise publicly for making them, and seek to correct them.'
Sir Jon's review of water services south of the border did not explore renationalising water companies – with the Government at Westminster opposed to this despite demands from campaigners for a return to public ownership in England.
Mr Reed however warned that nationalisation would cost £100 billion and would slow down efforts to cut pollution.
The UK Government has been contacted for comment.
Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

Rough deal: Social media roasts Trump's golf game after clip appears to show alleged cheating in Scotland
Rough deal: Social media roasts Trump's golf game after clip appears to show alleged cheating in Scotland

The Independent

timea minute ago

  • The Independent

Rough deal: Social media roasts Trump's golf game after clip appears to show alleged cheating in Scotland

Social media users pounced on a clip that appears to show Donald Trump cheating on the golf course during his ongoing trip to Scotland, the latest in a long line of accusations that the president cheats on the fairway. In the video circulated by liberal commentators, a caddy appears to walk ahead of the golf-loving president in his golf cart and drop a ball behind him as the president approaches. 'Trump working hard to bring down grocery prices,' the caption says, making a satirical reference to the president's campaign promises to tackle inflation and costs 'For the morons that think Trump doesn't cheat at golf and wins all those club championships fair and square….watch his caddie here,' another account wrote. The phrase 'commander in cheat' was soon trending on the social media site. 'The video of Trump's caddy doing an Oddjob Slazenger drop isn't a big deal; cheating at golf isn't nearly the worst thing about Trump,' wrote The Atlantic 's Tom Nichols. 'But watching the cult of personality try to explain it away is really some creepy North Korean level stuff.' The Independent has requested comment from the White House. The president has faced a long list of accusations that he doesn't play fair from figures ranging from actor Samuel Jackson to LPGA player Suzann Pettersen. Trump's alleged cheating, which has always denied, is even the subject of a book: Rick Reilly's Commander in Cheat. 'At Winged Foot, where Trump is a member, the caddies got so used to seeing him kick his ball back onto the fairway they came up with a nickname for him: Pele,' Reilly writes in the book. Controversy has always followed Trump, an avid golfer and developer of golf resorts, when he hits the 18 holes. The president has golfed at least 45 days out of his 189 days in office this year, or roughly 24 percent of his second term thus far. In April, the president faced criticism for attending an event from Saudi Arabia-backed LIV Golf while missing the return ceremony for the remains of four dead American soldiers. Others have criticized the president's promotion of his business interests on his own properties. During the Scotland trip, Trump met with European Commission President Ursula von der Leyen at his Turnberry golf course to announce an EU trade deal, and the president plans to attend a ribbon-cutting ceremony on Tuesday for a new course in Aberdeenshire. The White House described the Scotland tour as a 'working trip' while touting that Trump 'has built the best and most beautiful world-class golf courses anywhere in the world, which is why they continue to be used for prestigious tournaments and by the most elite players in the sport.' The president's Mar-a-Lago club and estate in Florida, near one his golf courses, has also emerged as a key hub for lobbying and fundraising, home to visits from tech billionaires and $1-million-per-head fundraising dinners. In the Middle East, meanwhile, the president's family company, the Trump Organization, recently struck a deal to build a golf resort in Qatar, weeks before the nation announced the gift of a $400 million Boeing 747 plane to be used for the new Air Force One. Despite the administration's insistence on cutting government spending, the president has also reportedly drained taxpayers of over $10 million in costs related to his many golf trips, while the Secret Service has spent hundreds of thousands of dollars for the use of golf carts and port-a-potties at Trump's New Jersey golf club. Since retaking office, Trump and his family businesses have taken in hundreds of millions of dollars on business ventures including cryptocurrency, real estate, and branded merchandise. 'He is president and is supposed to be working in the public's interest,' James Thurber, an emeritus professor at American University, told The Associated Press last month. 'Instead, he is helping his own personal interest to grow his wealth. It's totally not normal.'

Fake America Great Again?! Moment Trump's golf caddy appears to surreptitiously drop ball in prize spot before president takes shot
Fake America Great Again?! Moment Trump's golf caddy appears to surreptitiously drop ball in prize spot before president takes shot

Daily Mail​

time2 minutes ago

  • Daily Mail​

Fake America Great Again?! Moment Trump's golf caddy appears to surreptitiously drop ball in prize spot before president takes shot

This is the hilarious moment Trump's golf caddy appears to surreptitiously drop the ball in a prize spot before the president takes a shot. Two golf caddies are seen walking next to Trump who is driving in a golf cart. They then walk ahead and one is seen discreetly dropping the golf ball to the ground. Trump then gets out of the vehicle and approaches it, appearing to pretend it's the shot he made. The viral video shared to X, which has amassed close to 275,000 views, was flooded with comments reacting to the sly move. One said: 'Caddy did that so smoothly. Can only imagine how many times he's done it.' Another commented: 'Trump's notorious golf cheating, like having his caddy secretly drop balls to fake perfect shots, exposes a shameless pattern of deceit that erodes any claim to integrity or leadership.' A third said: 'I want to know how he finds so many caddies to cheat for him.' The viral video shared to X, which has amassed close to 275,000 views, was flooded with comments reacting to the sly move The clip has sparked long-standing rumours that Trump regularly cheats at golf. The US president was accompanied by his son Donald Trump Jr and Bettina Anderson for a round of golf at his Turnberry course in Scotland. Wearing a white baseball cap branded USA, the president waved to press as he arrived in the golf buggy at his resort. His visit to Turnberry is part of a private five-day trip to Scotland, which began on Friday night. Today he met with Ursula von der Leyen for talks on trade relations between the US and Europe.

Footage of Donald Trump 'cheating' on the golf course goes viral
Footage of Donald Trump 'cheating' on the golf course goes viral

Daily Mail​

time2 minutes ago

  • Daily Mail​

Footage of Donald Trump 'cheating' on the golf course goes viral

With President Donald Trump over in Europe, the real-estate magnate decided to visit some of his golf courses and play a few rounds of the sport he loves the most. But a camera captured a moment where one of the caddies in Trump's party decided to help him out more than what is allowed. Video taken from inside a building showed the moment the US president rolled up in a golf cart left of the fairway at Turnberry - with a bunker in front of him and some light fescue to his left. As two caddies walked by, the camera captured one of them stopping, bending down slightly, and dropping a ball in front of the president. Trump got out of his golf cart with a club and approached the dropped ball in what appeared to be an attempt to hit it. The video stops before he takes a swing. The clip went viral on social media, with multiple commenters calling out the 79-year-old for 'cheating'. Trump then got out of his golf cart and approached the ball with club in hand 'Who needs a foot wedge when you have a personal ball dropper???' wrote one commenter on X, formerly Twitter. Another account posted, 'Him and Kim Jong Un would be INSANE scramble partners'. One account which appears to belong to a PGA professional commented, 'Such a perfect metaphor for our Commander-in-Cheat.' ' like I need these fellas as Caddies with the way I hit it anymore,' another post joked. If Trump did indeed hit that ball, it's not the first time that he's been accused of 'cheating' in the past. Earlier this year, film star Samuel L. Jackson accused him of cheating when the pair played a round together. Asked who the better golfer was, the Pulp Fiction actor said: 'Oh, I am, for sure. I don't cheat.' Taking to social media to reply to Jackson, Trump responded by saying he had never played with him on a course. Jackson's opinion is one echoed by fellow actor Anthony Anderson, as he accused Trump of cheating back in 2016. During an appearance on the Late Night With Seth Meyers that year, Anderson said: 'Trump is a great golfer. I'm not going to say Trump cheats. His caddy cheats for him.' Asked on whether he saw Trump cheat with his own eyes, Anderson replied: 'Oh yes, several times. Several times'. He added: 'I mis-hit a ball - it hooked a little left about 20 yards. Trump hit the exact same shot but went 20 yards further left than mine. 'I could not find my ball in this trash. Trump's ball had the fluffiest lie in the middle of the fairway. 'Like I say, I didn't see Trump cheat because he was on the tee-box with me, but his ball was right there in the middle of the fairway.' They follow claims made by sports journalist Rick Reilly, who claimed in 2019 that Trump made second attempts at a shot for no good reason and took credit for other players' shots. Writing for the Sunday Times, he said caddies had given Trump the nickname 'Pele' because he would kick the ball so often to move it to a better position. Describing his opponent's style of play, he said: 'To say Donald Trump cheats is like saying Michael Phelps swims. 'Trump doesn't just cheat at golf. He cheats like a three-card monte dealer. He throws it, boots it and moves it.

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into a world of global content with local flavor? Download Daily8 app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store