The BBC has questions to answer about the Diane Abbott affair
The veteran MP for Hackney North and Stoke Newington was once again suspended by the Labour Party this week after saying she did not regret writing a 118 word letter to The Observer in 2023 which argued that 'Irish, Jewish and Traveller people (and redheads)… undoubtedly experience prejudice… but they are not all their lives subject to racism '.
At the time, she withdrew the remarks and apologised and was suspended before being reinstated at the last minute to stand as Labour's candidate in last year's general election.
Now she's changed her tune, telling Radio 4's Reflections programme: 'Clearly there must be a difference between racism which is about colour and other types of racism,' suggesting that a black person's skin colour is visibly notable, whereas being Jewish is not.
First question: this BBC interview was pre-recorded in May – so why is the broadcaster only now asking whether her remarks are inflammatory? Did it not realise that at the time, too busy, perhaps, broadcasting 'inaccurate' Gaza documentaries and preparing Glastonbury coverage that would see Bob Vylan chant: 'Death, death to the IDF?'
Secondly, why didn't the interviewer, James Naughtie, challenge Abbott with her own words, on the BBC's Question Time on April 26, 2018, when she suggested that the Haredi Jews in her constituency were a target for anti-Semitism 'because of the costumes they wear'?
She cannot have it both ways. She cannot say that Jews don't suffer the same racism as black people because they're white (even though a lot of Jews have dark skin) and then claim that they are the victims of racism because they are so obviously Jewish.
I wonder if she would refer to Muslims who wear traditional clothing – or African or Caribbean people – as wearing 'costumes' and therefore open to abuse?
Abbott claims it is 'obvious this Labour leadership wants me out'. On the basis of this evidence, who can blame them?
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Daily Mail
13 minutes ago
- Daily Mail
Now shut migrant protest hotel: As demonstrators clash again in Epping, Tories demand that Labour listen to local concerns and move asylum seekers
Labour faced mounting pressure last night to shut the asylum hotel at the centre of angry protests. But ministers stayed silent as senior Tories joined demands for migrants to be removed from The Bell Hotel in Epping, Essex, over 'legitimate' concerns about crime. As frustrated organisers of the growing demonstrations said they would not stop until it was closed, fresh clashes broke out outside the hotel yesterday, despite a heavy police presence to separate rival groups of protesters. The demonstrations were triggered after Ethiopian man Hadush Kebatu was charged with sexually assaulting a schoolgirl just days after he arrived in Britain in a Channel dinghy. Police chiefs have already described the unrest at The Bell as a 'signal flare' for another summer of disorder. Epping Council voted unanimously last week to urge the Government to close it. But Treasury minister James Murray refused to comment yesterday when asked why the Government has not listened to the demands. He told Sky News: 'I'm not going to comment on specific cases, but I do understand people's frustration. 'And whilst, obviously, there can never be any place for criminal violence, there's absolutely a right for people to protest about this.' It came after polling found that immigration has overtaken the economy to become voters' biggest concern about the country after the NHS. The survey by Opinium found 49 per cent of people put immigration among their top three concerns – a seven-point increase since May. Meanwhile, Sir Keir Starmer could also come under pressure to act from Donald Trump when they meet in Scotland today, after the US President said he had 'sealed our borders' in America and urged Europe to follow suit. Shadow Home Secretary Chris Philp told the Mail: 'Ministers must recognise the strength of feeling from the public about this hotel, listen to their genuine and real concerns, and shut it down. 'The Government has lost control of our borders. They need to listen to the public anger on this issue and deport all illegal immigrants immediately upon arrival. 'I am furious we are being overwhelmed by illegal immigrants. What has happened at The Bell is a consequence of that.' Opposition leader Kemi Badenoch said 'agitators' were coming in to whip up trouble, telling GB News: 'The Conservatives have been calling for that hotel to be closed down, because you have to show people there is a response when they have legitimate concerns.' Kebatu, 38, is due to be tried for allegedly trying to kiss a schoolgirl as she ate pizza in Epping on July 7, eight days after he arrived in the UK. He denies sexual assault, inciting a girl to engage in sexual activity and a charge of harassment. There were more ugly scenes outside The Bell yesterday when up to 1,000 demonstrators clashed. Around 400 protesting against the migrants – mostly locals – gathered after lunch, with counter-protesters, including of pro-Palestine groups and trade unions, arriving at around 4pm, and staying for barely an hour. Despite police from 31 forces including Merseyside and Lancashire separating them, at least three people were arrested. Sarah White, 40, who organised the protest against the hotel, said: 'We won't stop. Today has been a great opportunity for our voices to be heard. We've got the message out there that we don't want these hotels. 'This, I think, has been the biggest – there's more to come. We need to feel safe – we don't currently. It's shocking. We won't stop until that hotel is closed.' Maureen Chapman, 73, said she felt 'under threat', adding: 'I have grandchildren living locally. We want this closed and we won't stop until it is. Despite police from 31 forces including Merseyside and Lancashire separating them, at least three people were arrested 'These people moaning, would they want it at the end of their street?' The Home Office said: 'The Government is reducing expensive hotel use as part of a complete overhaul of the asylum system. 'From over 400 asylum hotels in summer 2023, costing almost £9million a day, there are now less than 210. We want them all closed by the end of this Parliament. 'People rightly want to see a robust and effective asylum system and we have a duty to support people who would otherwise be destitute and sleeping rough while their case is decided.'
Daily Mail
13 minutes ago
- Daily Mail
Labour ditches plan to charge inheritance tax on payments made to bereaved military children
Labour has ditched plans to hit the grieving children of military personnel with a tax on their bereavement payments. In October Rachel Reeves announced plans to make relatives in receipt of off-duty death-in-service payments, other than spouses or civil partners, pay inheritance tax from April 2027. This means children and unmarried partners of soldiers who died from illness while off-duty, would have been subject to a tax on their payments. But the Chancellor was forced to back down from her Budget announcement after mounting pressure from members of the Armed Forces, who called it a 'corrosive' plan. The Government confirmed to The Daily Telegraph that after a consultation with Armed Forces organisations it had decided to withdraw the proposals. A spokesman said: 'From April 6, 2027 all death in service benefits payable from registered pension schemes will be out of scope of Inheritance Tax, regardless of whether the scheme is discretionary or non-discretionary.' The latest climbdown comes after Ms Reeves was forced to scale down plans to scrap the universal winter fuel payment and reforms to the welfare system. Mark Francois, the Tory Armed Forces spokesman, said he welcomes the reversal decision 'though it represents another U-turn by this Labour Government'. He added: 'I am pleased that common sense has now finally prevailed.' An HM Treasury spokesman said: 'It's right that we are excluding all death in service benefits from inheritance tax while still achieving the Government's objective of removing inconsistencies between pension schemes.'
Daily Mail
13 minutes ago
- Daily Mail
Taunted to the tune of Chirpy Chirpy Cheep Cheep, Epping's mums refused to back down: RONAN O'REILLY
Blink and you'd have nearly missed them. It was just after 4pm when the rent-a-crowd from Stand Up To Racism descended on The Bell Hotel on the edge of Epping. They were on their way home again within three-quarters of hour. Cynical observers might suggest that many of them had long journeys and they didn't want to get home too late. They were there, of course, to stage a counter-protest against the latest demonstration by local people over the hotel being used to house migrants. The controversy has been growing since Ethiopian asylum seeker Hadush Gerberslasie Kebatu was accused of sexually assaulting a 14-year-old girl eight days after arriving in the UK. Kebatu, 38, who had been staying at the hotel, denies all three charges he faces. Police shepherded around 500 of the Left-wing protesters into a field by the hotel after stressing earlier that they had a 'really robust plan' to deal with trouble. Their warning came after hard-Right activist Tommy Robinson indicated last week he planned to attend and would be 'bringing thousands more with me' – before apparently changing his mind. Credit where it is due, the Stand Up To Racism mob certainly succeeded in making themselves heard. There may be question marks over their commitment, but there was nothing wrong with their vocal cords or lung capacity. To the tune of Middle Of The Road's 1970 hit Chirpy Chirpy Cheep Cheep, they taunted the opposing crowd over Robinson's no-show with goading chants of 'Where's your Tommy gone?' There were some more predictable choruses of 'Say it loud, Say it clear, Asylum seekers welcome here' and placards with slogans such as 'Unite against the Far Right', 'No to Racism, No to Hatred'. There was also an exchange of abuse with the anti-hotel side, who were stationed only a few yards away. And then they departed in a sea of banners and flags, including - almost inevitably – a smattering in the Palestinian colours. Last week, the Mail revealed that the protests against the decision to requisition The Bell Hotel for migrants were spear-headed not by hard-Right activists but a group of local mothers, spurred into action by the perceived threat to their daughters. 'I think women are naturally more tolerant – we have got to put up with men after all – but when you start to threaten our children, then we snap,' said Orla Minihane, a mother of three teenagers who has become a vocal council candidate for the Reform Party. Yesterday, before the arrival of the Stand Up To Racism protesters, police had kept a discreet presence at the rail station. By 1pm, however, officers in riot gear were in position five yards apart outside The Bell. Behind them, the hotel itself was surrounded by 8ft security barriers. Reinforcements had been drafted in from forces across Britain, including Cheshire, Lancashire, Leicester and Wales as well as both the Met and City of London Police, to assist Essex Police. Officers had banned face coverings to root out troublemakers. Across the High Road, residents demanding the hotel's closure were gathering, some draped in Union Jacks, others waving St George's Crosses. Placards were emblazoned with slogans such as 'Protect our Kids', 'Defend our girls, deport foreign criminals' and 'Make Britain Great'. Judging by people I spoke to, most of the crowd, which was pretty evenly split by age and gender, were either part of the immediate community or from nearby areas. Local hairdresser Kelly Hill said: 'This isn't fair. The Government has to be held to account. We have rights as well.' Stan Booth said: 'I have sympathy for people who are genuinely seeking asylum or have had to flee their own countries for legitimate reasons. But it is unreal what we have here. Nobody knows who they are, where they've come from or what they have done.' The migrants were also stuck behind security barriers, prompting one protester to put up homemade 'prisoner of war' signs on the bars. Someone else lightened the mood at one point by playing the theme music from The Great Escape over a sound system. Meanwhile, cheers rang out as excerpts from historical speeches were played. They included Winston Churchill's famous wartime address to the House of Commons on June 4, 1940, when he declared: 'We shall never surrender.' There were cheers, too, when a clip was played of Margaret Thatcher in Parliament, warning of 'international chaos' if we 'get to a situation where illegal immigrants cannot be returned to their country of origin'. Yet despite the occasional moments of levity, the atmosphere among the protesters was one of grim determination. One of the organisers, 40-year-old Sarah White, said: 'This is about sending a clear message that we don't want a hotel in our town housing undocumented men. 'It needs closing down. No area should have them.' Rose Thomas, from Basildon, said: 'There's already a strong message. We don't want hotels full of men from foreign countries.' Nor were the protesters without the backing of fellow locals. Over the course of several hours, practically every third or fourth driver tooted their car horn in support. It is difficult to see the residents of this quintessentially English town giving up their fight soon.
