No commitment to scrap two-child benefit cap until funding is clear
Further calls to scrap the controversial policy were made by Labour backbenchers on Tuesday, during a Conservative-led debate focused on retaining the cap.
There were more than 1.6 million children living in households in England, Wales and Scotland affected by the two-child benefit limit in April, according to figures published by the Department for Work and Pensions last week.
Work and pensions minister Alison McGovern said the Child Poverty Task Force will look at 'all the levers across incomes, costs, debt and local support that we can pull to prevent poverty, including social security reform'.
Speaking during the opposition day debate, she added: 'Our universal credit review is considering ways that the system can improve in order to stabilise family finances and provide routes into good work.
'And on the two-child limit, specifically, the consequences, as I've said in my speech, of the Conservative choices made over the past decade and a half are clear for all to see.
'We have rightly said many times we will not commit to any policy without knowing how we are going to pay for it.'
Labour MP for Rochdale, Paul Waugh, said: '59% of families (who) have more than two children, on universal credit, are in work, and that's far from the feckless parent caricature that we've heard today from the Conservatives.
'And more importantly, does she agree with me that actually it's the children (who) should come first, and because the children should come first, we should urgently scrap the two-child cap as quickly as possible?'
Ms McGovern declined to respond directly to Mr Waugh's question, instead arguing that the Conservative Party 'only wants to divide people'.
Labour MP for Alloa and Grangemouth Brian Leishman also said 'the Government should lift it immediately', adding: 'Having a child is a blessing, not a blessing everyone receives, and the two-child cap is an inherently cruel policy that punishes the least advantaged.
'The idea that a third or a fourth or a fifth child is worth less than the first two is beyond wicked.'
Conservative shadow work and pensions secretary Helen Whately had described the welfare bill as a 'ticking time bomb' as she opened the debate.
She added: 'We have brought forward this debate today on the two-child limit, because somebody has to make the case for fiscal responsibility, for living within our means, for fairness, for making sure work pays, and for keeping the two-child cap.'
MPs rejected the Conservatives' motion that the benefit cap should remain, with 106 voting in favour, 440 against, majority 334.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Independent
29 minutes ago
- The Independent
Starmer has worked to ‘cultivate' relationship with Trump, says minister
Sir Keir Starmer has put a 'lot of effort' in to 'cultivate' a relationship with US President Donald Trump, a Cabinet ally of the Prime Minister has said. With Mr Trump having said he will meet Sir Keir in Aberdeen later this month during a private visit to Scotland, Scottish Secretary Ian Murray said holding talks with the president is the 'right thing to do'. He said US tariffs and the situation in Ukraine could be on the agenda for those discussions. Scottish First Minister John Swinney will also meet the president – who recently voiced his support for the oil and gas sector over wind power projects. In a BBC News interview, Mr Trump hailed Aberdeen as the 'oil capital' of Europe and said 'they should get rid of the windmills and bring back the oil'. Mr Trump also said he and Sir Keir will 'refine' the recent trade deal struck between the UK and the US. The agreement reduced tariffs on car and aerospace imports, but questions remain over whether steel imports into America will face 50% tariffs. There is also a baseline tariff of 10% for most other imports – with the Scotch whisky industry now said to be pushing for this to be lowered. Mr Murray said: 'At this stage we have no sight of what the president's programme is, but we do know the First Minister and the Prime Minister will meet him, and it is right for them both to do so.' Speaking on BBC Radio Scotland's Good Morning Scotland programme, the Scottish Secretary added the meetings are 'the right thing to do because those relationships are incredibly important in terms of our own national interest'. He added: 'We should make sure we are working very closely with our allies for the benefit of Scotland and the whole of the United Kingdom.' Saying that doing 'what is in the UK's national interest' is the 'top priority' for the Prime Minister, the Scottish Secretary continued: 'Of course tariffs will be on the agenda I am sure, and the economic situation and the issue of Ukraine and defence. 'All of these issues I am sure will be on the agenda when they speak. 'The bottom line here is that it has taken a lot of effort for the Prime Minister to cultivate this relationship with our strongest ally, that's why we have the lowest tariffs in the world and why we had the first deal done with America in our national interest.' Mr Murray said while the 10% tariff on whisky exports to the US is something the UK Government would like to see lowered, he added the UK's trade deal with India had cut tariffs for sales of the drink there in a 'huge, huge boon to the Scotch whisky industry'.
Telegraph
30 minutes ago
- Telegraph
Cash Isa reforms still on the table, Reeves confirms
Rachel Reeves has left the door open to cutting the cash Isa allowance at the Budget later this year. The Chancellor told City financiers at her annual Mansion House speech on Tuesday that she would 'continue to consider further changes to Isas' over the coming months. Ms Reeves had been expected to use her speech to announce a reduction in the amount savers could put into cash Isas in a bid to encourage more people to put their money into British stocks. Reports suggested this could see the annual cash Isa allowance fall from £20k to as low as £4k or £5k. However she was forced to delay any announcement amid fierce backlash from some of Britain's biggest lenders. The likes of Yorkshire, Coventry and Skipton building societies all opposed the reforms, which they said could restrict their ability to raise the funds needed to provide loans to homeowners. While the Chancellor did not announce any concrete reforms to the cash Isa, Ms Reeves made clear the option was something she was still considering. She said: 'I have confirmed that long-term asset funds can be included in stocks and shares Isas, allowing long-term Isa investors to benefit from this innovative product. 'And I will continue to consider further changes to Isas, engaging widely over the coming months and recognising that despite the differing views on the right approach, we are united in wanting better outcomes for both savers and for the UK economy.' Ms Reeves, who is under pressure to raise taxes in the autumn following a number of government about-turns, urged the financial industry to change its 'negative' narrative around savers investing money in stocks and shares in order to help grow the economy. She said: 'For too long, we have presented investment in too negative a light, quick to warn people of the risks, without giving proper weight to the benefits. And our tangled system of financial advice and guidance has meant that people cannot get the right support to make decisions for themselves.' Nearly a third of people in Britain have a cash Isa – with around £300bn in savings used by building societies to lend to homeowners. Building societies have warned that reducing Isa deposits could make mortgages more expensive and harder to access. Chris Irwin, Yorkshire Building Society's head of savings, said: 'Cash Isas make up 39pc of all building societies' retail savings balances. This provides a vital source of funding to allow us to offer more mortgages to those that need them.' Skipton Building Society and Leeds Building Society were among 49 lenders that wrote to the Treasury last week urging ministers to maintain the current allowance. Other signatories included Debbie Crosbie, Nationwide's chief executive, as well as Hargreaves Lansdown.
BBC News
an hour ago
- BBC News
Honorary degree for Post Office scandal campaigner Sir Alan Bates
Post Office scandal campaigner Sir Alan Bates will be awarded an honorary degree by the University of Alan spent more than two decades working to expose faulty Post Office accounting software which created shortfalls in sub postmaster accounts. The former Exeter resident was to join philanthropists, politicians, entrepreneurs and artificial intelligence pioneers being given honorary degrees this week, the university Alan said the recognition was an honour and thanked the university for its work investigating the impact of the Post Office Horizon scandal. "I feel very honoured to accept this honorary degree from Exeter," said Sir Alan. "Whilst it is many years since I have lived and worked in Exeter, I am well aware of the important work the University of Exeter Law School has undertaken to investigate the impact on the mental health of victims and the families of sub postmasters involved with the Post Office Horizon scandal." Other honorary degree recipients Former Green Party leader and co-leader Caroline LucasFormer Exeter MP and health minister Sir Ben BradshawFormer Conservative Party chair Baroness WarsiFormer Home Secretary and Chancellor of the Exchequer Sir Sajid JavidChief executive of the Met Office Professor Penny EndersbyBBC News analysis editor Ros AtkinsFounder of DeepLearning AI Andrew NgSecretary General of Medecins Sans Frontieres Christopher LockyearArts and culture coach and consultant Pippa WarinWriter Cheryl MorganEntrepreneur and philanthropist Erika Brodnock MBEPhilanthropist and former chair of Exeter's University Council Sarah TurvillChief executive of Advocates for International Development Yasmin Batliwala MBE A total of 6,348 students from 118 different countries are expected to graduate from nearly 170 courses at the university over the next two weeks. University president Professor Lisa Roberts said: "It is always so special to celebrate the amazing achievements of our graduating students with their loved ones, and wish them well as they embark on the next stage of their lives."We are also looking forward to celebrating the impact and achievements of our honorary graduates, who have made such an important contribution to society. Their work is truly inspiring, and we look forward to celebrating with them."
