Mental Health Bill bypassing health committee ‘sets a dangerous precedent', says chair
Bringing the
Mental Health
Bill straight to the Dáil and bypassing the Oireachtas health committee is 'not in line with best practice' and 'sets a dangerous precedent for the rest of this term', its chairman has said.
Last week, Minister for Mental Health
Mary Butler
secured Cabinet approval of the Government's committee-stage amendments to the bill, which will significantly overhaul the State's mental health laws.
A spokesman for the Minister said 'given the already busy agenda' of the Health Committee, she decided to bring the Bill to the floor of the Dáil 'where every Deputy will have the opportunity to speak on the committee-stage amendments to the Bill'.
[
Admitting a patient without consent and not treating them isn't 'care' - it's imprisonment
Opens in new window
]
Pádraig Rice, chairman of the health committee, wrote to the Minister on Thursday criticising this decision.
READ MORE
Mr Rice, the
Social Democrats
' spokesman on health, said the committee had agreed to undertake extra sessions each week to progress the Bill.
'It is therefore with disappointment, and some frustration, that we learned [on Wednesday] of your plans to bypass the joint committee and bring the Bill straight to the Dáil,' his letter said.
'This Bill is of significant importance and deserves due consideration. Taking this Bill and the hundreds of amendments that are being proposed and expected in the Dáil is not in line with best practice, does the issue a disservice and sets a dangerous precedent for the rest of this term.'
Mr Rice said following his appointment as chair, he expressed an intention to 'work in a spirit of co-operation and partnership with Government and opposition alike'.
'I would appreciate if a similar approach was reciprocated,' he added, requesting the Minister to reconsider her decision.
A spokesman for the Minister said she is 'determined to ensure the Mental Health Bill progresses to enactment before the end of the year'.
'The Bill has been in development for many years, and received support from all sides of the house at second stage last autumn.
'This is far from unprecedented, and many bills have been taken through committee stage on the floor of the House. As Chief Whip, the Minister will ensure the Bill is afforded ample time on the Dáil schedule to allow all of the amendments to be debated fully,' the spokesman said.
If enacted, the new mental health bill will regulate the Child and Adolescent Mental Health Services (Camhs) and other community services for the first time.
It will also allow 16- and 17-year-olds the right to consent to mental healthcare as they already can for physical health.
Under amendments brought to Cabinet this week, an individual who is involuntarily admitted to an acute psychiatric unit can be detained for up to 42 days, an increase on the 21 days previously proposed under the bill.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Irish Times
11 minutes ago
- Irish Times
State must increase spending by €265bn by 2050, Central Bank's Makhlouf warns
Government spending will need to increase by about €265 billion over the next 25 years to pay for an ageing population, more housing and cutting emissions, Central Bank governor Gabriel Makhlouf has said, as he called for a credible spending rule to help prevent future downturns. 'While the State's Future Ireland Fund (FIF) will go some way to paying for what is needed in the years ahead, 'the FIF will be insufficient – on its own – to fund the higher level of public expenditure that will be required to meet the needs of an older population and to fund climate and housing investment,' Mr Makhlouf wrote in his pre-budget letter to Minister for Finance Paschal Donohoe , which was published on Monday. Spending 'will need to rise by 6.5 percentage points of national income (GNI*), or €265 billion, between 2025 and 2050 to fund higher age-related spending and the additional public investment required to meet housing and net zero targets,' he added in the letter, which is considered a key part of the budget planning process. Amid what he described as 'heightened uncertainty' around the global economy, Mr Makhlouf urged the Government to broaden the tax base, amid concerns about how reliant the exchequer is on a small number of companies and individuals to pay maintain its tax revenue. READ MORE Overseas multinationals generated about a fifth of all tax and PRSI in 2023, Mr Makhlouf said, while about 8.5 per cent of tax payers accounted for 56 per cent of personal income taxes paid. Given that backdrop, the Government should install a 'credible' spending rule in the upcoming budget. [ Government must 'anchor' spending as Ireland faces potential permanent economic hit from tariffs, official says Opens in new window ] 'To avoid a repeat of past mistakes and to shift budgetary policy away from an excessive short-term approach, the Government should commit to a credible fiscal anchor for budgetary policy to ensure the overall fiscal stance is suitable, guards against procyclicality and boom-bust dynamics and safeguards long-run fiscal sustainability,' Mr Makhlouf wrote. Successive governments have previously pledged to cap the increase in so-called core spending at 5 per cent per year. Yet in the years since that pledge was introduced, successive ministers have broken that rule. IATA Director General Willie Walsh on airline profits, air fares and why the Dublin Airport passenger cap makes Ireland a laughing stock Listen | 35:56 Mr Makhlouf has been critical of such moves in the past, noting it would likely boost inflation. 'It is important that policy supports rigorous expenditure control – not least of current expenditure – and enables the enforcement of sustainable increases in overall net government expenditure over time,' the governor added. On housing, the Mr Makhlouf noted that public money on its own 'will not be sufficient to address the housing and wider infrastructure gaps that have emerged. Fiscal and broader public policy should more actively consider reforms to crowd-in private investment and to promote productivity growth.' He pointed to measures that could quicken the planning process for housing, adding that such measures which would reduce the delays and costs were needed to help ensure the long term benefits of such projects feed into long-term growth. Mr Makhlouf also pointed to the need for investment in new technologies in the construction sector to help boost large scale projects especially for housing and infrastructure.
Extra.ie
an hour ago
- Extra.ie
Government ‘throwing the kitchen sink' at fixing homelessness crisis
The Government has 'thrown the kitchen sink' at the homelessness crisis, a minister of state has said. Christopher O'Sullivan TD said that it has been a really 'difficult challenge to tackle', but that it is a priority for the Housing Minister. His comments come as the latest figures released on Friday show homelessness has reached another record high. Christopher O'Sullivan. Pic: Fianna Fáil Some 15,747 people are now in emergency accommodation during the last week of May, including 4,844 children. Last week, Children's Ombudsman Dr Niall Muldoon said that the government's housing initiatives consistently fail children. Mr O'Sullivan told RTÉ's The Week In Politics programme: 'The figures at the moment, they're not acceptable, and I don't think anyone is saying for one second that they are. 'The Government is acutely aware that there is a housing crisis, and there is a significant issue with homelessness, which we're trying to tackle. 'Obviously, we're particularly struck by the words of the Children's Ombudsman… This is a really, a really difficult challenge to tackle. 'That's been proven over the last number of years, and we have thrown the kitchen sink [at] it, but I will say this, there's no doubt that it's a priority for the Taoiseach, it's a priority for this Government. Housing Minister James Browne. Pic: Sam Boal/Collins Photos 'Working with [Housing Minister] James Browne, I'm in the Department of Housing as Minister of State, I know that this is a priority for him. 'These stories, these, I suppose, testimonies I know motivate him. They motivate him to make change. They motivate him to make a difference on homelessness. 'That is why the very first piece of legislation that Minister James Browne introduced in the House was around preventing homelessness.' Social Democrats TD Gary Gannon, who has backed a redress scheme for children living in emergency accommodation, said there is too much reliance on the private model. He remarked: 'We need to have the State getting back and building in a massive, significant way.'
Irish Independent
3 hours ago
- Irish Independent
Clare county council elects new cathaoirleach
Cllr Paul Murphy (Fine Gael) was elected as Cathaoirleach for the 2025-2026 term and standing beside him as Laes-Cathaoirleach is Cllr Clare Colleran Molloy (Fianna Fáil). Fianna Fáil councillor Alan O'Callaghan handed over the seat of Cathaoirleach, reflecting on his term, with Clare winning the All-Ireland for the first time in 11 years being on his his highlights. Cllr O'Callaghan thanked his family and friends for support through the year. 'To everyone here in the chamber, to all the members you were respectful of the chair, and I really appreciate that.' 'We leave no one behind. And that is very important as a local authority. Bring everyone along with you.' In response to the departing of Cllr O'Callaghan as the first citizen in the chamber, councillors remarked on his fun-loving professional demeaner that always ensured matters of business were handled within meeting times and gave each councillor the 'freedom' they needed, says Michael Begley who was elected Cathaoirleach in 2018. Cllr John Crowe nominated Cllr Paul Murphy saying that he is a 'real team member for all of us'. Cllr Murphy is the first person elected Cathaoirleach from Clarecastle in the history of the council and was praised for being a trustworthy and dependable councillor for the county. Upon election, Cllr Murphy said: 'It is a huge honour to be sitting here today as Clare County Council. I am deeply privileged to accept this role with your full support.' 'Many hands make light work… this seat belongs to the people and not to myself.' Additionally, Cllr. Clare Colleran-Molloy made history with her election as the first Leas-Cathaoirleach to be elected with American citizenship in Clare County Council. She took over the seat from Cllr. Mary Howard (Fine Gael). Cllr Colleran-Molloy was nominated with praises for her commitment to local government. Accepting the seat she said: 'I will answer the call, and I will do my best to help.' Furthermore, the municipal distracts have proceeded with elections as well. Shannon elected MD Cllr John Crowe as Cathaoirleach, and Cllr Michael Begley as Leas-Cathaoirleach. Cllr Mary Howard is the new Mayor of Ennis having been elected last Thursday with Cllr Pat Daly as deputy Mayor of Ennis. In Killaloe MD, Cllr Pat Burke was elected as Cathaoirleach and Cllr Tony O'Brien as Leas-Chathaoirleach. Finally, in West Clare, Cllr Bill Slattery will be Cathaoirleach for the next year with Cllr Michael Shannon serving as Leas-Chathaoirleach. Funded by the Local Democracy Reporting Scheme.
