Conservation group calls for Chatham Rise orange roughy fishery closure, bottom trawling ban
Photo:
Mountains to Sea
A conservation group says the country's largest orange roughy fishery is "past the brink" of collapse - but shutting parts of it down will not be enough to save it.
The Ministry of Primary Industries (MPI) has begun consultation on this year's orange roughy catch limit, and has included the option to close the East and South Chatham Rise fishery.
In the early '80s and '90s, 20,000-30,000 tonnes of orange roughy were pulled out of the ocean every year in the area that spans the Chatham to the sub-Antarctic Islands - known as the Chatham Rise or ORH 3B.
But an MPI review this year estimated some orange roughy populations had reduced by up to 90 percent.
The Deep Sea Conservation Coalition said closing a section of the Chatham Rise fishery was a start, but not enough - and wanted to see a
blanket ban on bottom sea trawling
in all orange roughy breeding grounds.
Meanwhile, a case over orange roughy management decisions in 2023 will wrap up on Wednesday at the High Court in Wellington.
Citing the years following the "gold rush" of the '80s and '90s, Deep Sea Conservation Coalition's Karli Thomas said the proposal to shut down parts of the orange roughy fishery was nothing new.
However, she said the current proposal was significant, given the size of the fishery, and a first in recent years.
After reducing the catch limit by 40 percent in 2023 - from 7967 to 4752 - due to sustainability concerns, MPI is asking for feedback on further reductions for the Chatham Rise orange roughy fishery.
The options include a catch limit reduction by 23 percent, 42 percent or 60 percent, with the fourth option seeing the closure of the sub-fishery, the East and South Chatham Rise, and the fastest return to healthy stock levels.
Thomas said her group would submit in support of the fourth option - but was sceptical that alone would save the fishery when modelling suggested some parts of it were already collapsed.
Deep Sea Conservation Coalition's Karli Thomas.
Photo:
Supplied / Deep Sea Conservation Coalition
"We're definitely past the brink.
"All the modelling is showing that 80 percent of the population has gone, in some cases more than 90 percent is gone, and that's generally considered the point of collapse for a fishery."
She said the fishery's "disastrous state" was a reflection of poor management and wanted to see a complete ban on bottom sea trawling of the fish's breeding grounds and habitat - the impacts of which, she said, were two-fold.
"Its habitat is being destroyed, because bottom trawls basically
plough through coral gardens
, and secondly these fish are being targeted in the very places - the seamounts (underwater mountains) - they go to breed.
"So, if we're also disrupting their life cycle - the fish really just don't stand a chance."
She said a single orange roughy trawl brought up six tonnes of coral last year.
MPI director of fisheries management Emma Taylor said bycatch of that scale, while unfortunate, was very rare.
"There are a range of measures in place to minimise the effect of fishing on coral and other habitats, including closures to prevent dredging and trawling on 32 percent of New Zealand's seabed."
Despite a catch limit of 4752 tonnes in the 2023-2024 year, only 2691 tonnes of orange roughy were reportedly caught.
The figures followed a gradual increase in catch limit size, after a quota low of 3600 tonnes in 2012-2013.
A MPI survey of orange roughy stock at the East and South Chatham Rise in 2023 found stock levels were either "flat or declining" - and inconsistent with a previous assessment. That assessment was later rejected.
Taylor said the uncertainty about the state of the orange roughy stock led to the precautionary and significant 40 percent catch limit reduction.
The management decisions in 2023 are currently being challenged in the High Court at Wellington, with the Environmental Law Initiative claiming the Minister of Oceans and Fisheries failed to consider the harmful effects of bottom trawling in the Chatham Rise.
A video still showing orange roughy swimming up to one kilometre below the surface off the South Island.
Photo:
SUPPLIED
Taylor said in the time since, there had been significant work done to update the model used to assess the fishery, "as well as acoustic surveys and other research into the state of the fishery".
New information showed more needed to be done to put the "fishery back on track to meet sustainability targets", she said, and Fisheries New Zealand was asking for public feedback on a range of options - including closure.
A May 2025 assessment estimated orange roughy stock levels between 8-18 percent of the original biomass (population). The target management range is 30-50 percent.
Taylor said orange roughy fisheries had been closed in the past due to concerns about sustainability, as had other fisheries.
"Following this consultation, we will prepare advice for Fisheries Minister Shane Jones to make decisions on any changes, which would come into effect for the fishing year starting 1 October 2025."
Consultation runs until 28 July.
The orange roughy, which lives at depths of up to 1.5km, is slow growing and can live up to 120-130 years - with some reaching more than 200 years-old.
Thomas said their long life cycle made them particularly vulnerable to overfishing.
She said although they began breeding in their mid-twenties to thirties, it was not until they were in their seventies or eighties that they spawned every year.
She said the ocean had an amazing ability to recover, but it would likely take a human lifetime for the orange roughy to bounce back.
Sign up for Ngā Pitopito Kōrero
,
a daily newsletter curated by our editors and delivered straight to your inbox every weekday.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
RNZ News
11 hours ago
- RNZ News
Fairlie restaurant severely damaged after fire
Carnegies Restaurant on Allandale Road in Fairlie. Photo: RNZ/Rowan Quinn A restaurant in southern Canterbury is severely damaged after a fire. Fire crews were called to Carnegies Restaurant on Allandale Road in Fairlie at around 6:30am on Saturday. The building was found in flames. A Fire and Emergency (FENZ) spokesperson said five fire trucks and a support vehicle were still at the scene four hours later. The fire had been mostly extinguished by 10:30am, but not before it destroyed much of the restaurant's ceiling. An RNZ reporter at the scene said the smell of smoke permeated throughout the small town. FENZ said nobody was inside the building at the time, and a fire investigator was working to determine the cause.
RNZ News
15 hours ago
- RNZ News
Country Life: City to Farm - how leftovers are giving back to the land
Jenny and Phil Grainger, part of the City to Farm project, have experimented with swales, composted with food scraps from urban areas, to improve water retention and nourish the soil on their banana grove at Waitoki Photo: RNZ/Sally Round It's prep time in the kitchen at Evelyn Page Retirement Village in Orewa, north of Auckland, and another load of food scraps has just gone into the bin. Senior lead chef Dylan Hatt sprinkles some special sawdust over the top and closes the lid. A few kilometres away in rural Wainui, a dedicated team of Year 8 students in masks and gloves, are collecting caddies from the classrooms and emptying the lunchtime food scraps into larger bins, tamping down the gloop to a gleeful chorus of "eew" and "yuck". A few more kilometres inland, a banana farmer is at his specially built "jetty" unloading dozens of wheelie bins of food scraps into a "fast feeder" which spreads the fermented waste into ditches lined with biochar . He then covers it all with mulch and leaves it to nourish and build the soil. This is the chain created by City to Farm - a project run by Hibiscus Coast Zero Waste (HCZW) - to stop food waste going into landfill, to lower greenhouse gases and nourish local farmland. "This is a way for everybody to participate in climate action with their food scraps, just sending them off to the farm," HCZW trustee Betsy Kettle told Country Life . Follow Country Life on Apple Podcasts , Spotify , iHeart or wherever you get your podcasts. City to Farm collects food scraps once a week from 25 collection points in the district including kindergartens, cafes and restaurants, schools and the retirement village. Partially grant-funded, it has diverted more than 350 tonnes of food scraps from landfill since it started in 2019. The food scrap producers pay to have their scraps taken which also helps fund the operation, Kettle said. "We don't call it waste. No, these are resources," she said, lifting the lids of bins in the basement of the retirement village. They have woody mulch and biochar in the base to help with the pickling process known as bokashi . A bokashi bin at Two Spoons, a cafe in Arkles Bay, which has been with the project since it started in 2019. Photo: Supplied The bins are strapped down to make them airtight, ready for the weekly pick-up truck which then transports the bins to the banana farm for further composting and integrating with the soil. One of the retirement village's residents spotted the project in the local paper and it took on a life of its own, village manager Jill Clark said. "There's no extra work. It's just so routine. Now that's just what we do, because we've been doing it so long." Betsy Kettle, one of the drivers of the City to Farm project, checks out one of the specially adapted food scrap bins at Ryman's Evelyn Page Retirement Village Photo: RNZ/Sally Round It's also become normal for the children at Wainui School. "When we started it, we didn't really know what to think of it. We kind of just like, did it, and we were sort of like, 'eew'," Year 8 student Madison Freestone said. "But now we do it all the time, and we do find it cool. We find it fun. We learn new things all the time." Madison and three other Year 8s form a dedicated team of food waste busters at the rural school. The Year 8 student team in charge of food scrap recycling in the school vegetable garden. From left to right - Arielle Oswald, Leah Andrell, Morgan Price, Madison Freestone Photo: RNZ/Sally Round The bokashi method doesn't attract rodents, a particular problem with composting in a rural setting, principal Gillian Bray explained. The fertiliser created from leftovers is feeding the school vegetable garden as well as City to Farm. Kettle said City to Farm provides schools with special food scrap caddies and a little stand that also takes paper and the hard recyclables. She said they talk to the children about the link between food scraps and greenhouse gases when placed in landfill, as well as the way food scraps, together with biochar, can build topsoil and create a carbon sink. The City to Farm project, run by Hibiscus Coast Zero Waste, collects food scraps from 25 centres - retirement villages, schools, kindies, restaurants and cafes - to be turned into compost for soil improvement on farms nearby Photo: RNZ/Sally Round Wainui School's recycling hub where food scraps are turned into nutrient rich fertiliser Photo: RNZ/Sally Round The Year 8 girls have taken to educating too and they're very strict about what can't go in the caddies. "Any liquids, such as yoghurt, you know, juices, that type of stuff, no whipped cream, no meat, because the meat can make maggots grow and it's gross. "Yeah, and obviously no rubbish. So, if someone does something wrong, we remind them that they can't put that stuff in the bin. And we tell them what they can and can't put in the bin, so that they know for next time." Teacher Nick Wotton who leads the project at the school says the girls have taken the task on with gusto. "Our goal is for our students to be more sustainable and environmentally responsible, and I think this, starting with the girls, is a way to sort of embed that in our students and in our culture as a whole." Down the road from Wainui School, Phil and Jenny Grainger are hosting lunch at a large table. Big bunches of bananas decorate their off-grid home from which wafts a delicious aroma. Jenny has made a banana curry from bananas grown out of the once poor soil, which has been nourished by six years of food scraps. "When we first came here, there was hardly a worm on the place," Jenny said. The land was also dry and hydrophobic, repelling water. Phil and Jenny Grainger looking out over their growing banana farm, fuelled with food scraps Photo: RNZ/Sally Round The couple, former dairy and kiwifruit farmers, took on the task of taking in the food scraps to see how soil could benefit and "to sequester carbon", Phil said. They experimented with banana swales, digging ditches and building up banks for the plants with biochar and the fermented scraps topped with mulch. Rainwater and organic matter were then able to infiltrate the clay soil. They also developed systems to make food scrap application more efficient and not so messy, and now apply the scraps once a month using a fast feeder and orchard tractor. Food scraps line a planting bed which is then topped with compost, creating healthy topsoil from waste Photo: Supplied "Initially, it was having a car trailer trying to unload these wheelie bins and tipping and mud and stuff and it was disgusting and terrible," Phil said. The Graingers have planted more and more banana plants as the food scraps initiative has grown, and they've had the soil tested and learnt more about growing the fruit. Other challenges emerged on-farm including rats and flies but surprisingly, odours were minimal, likely due to the bokashi fermentation process which prevented putrefaction, Kettle said. "Although the work was messy, the impact was undeniable." The Graingers are now transitioning into producing bananas commercially. Kettle says her husband did some sums and they reckon half of Auckland's food scraps could be diverted from landfill onto 400 hectares of farmland. They'd like more farmers and communities to be involved. "The City to Farm system is meant to model a small-scale, decentralised, local-resources-for-local-use system that, hopefully, other community groups will trial in their areas. "And if we could do that, then we would be… helping the whole planet, and the farmers would be heroes. They'd be climate heroes." Learn more: Sign up for Ngā Pitopito Kōrero , a daily newsletter curated by our editors and delivered straight to your inbox every weekday.
RNZ News
a day ago
- RNZ News
Life on rations: What it was like to eat a wartime meal
Ann Hunt sharing her recipes from Summerset retirement village in Flatbush Auckland. Photo: RNZ / Marika Khabazi During the Second World War and the years that followed, New Zealand, like much of the world, faced a time of austerity - especially when it came to food. Rationing, coupons and making do became part of everyday life with things like tripe, makeshift butter and fidget pie on the menu. Cookbooks from this period are all about making food go further and letting nothing go to waste. With the cost of food a struggle for many families today, RNZ's Checkpoint had a chat with some of those who can remember this time to get some tips. Ann Hunt and Patricia McFarland live at Summerset retirement village in Flatbush Auckland. They have some thoughts about the current cost of groceries. "I would not like to be in a family at the moment trying to provide good, healthy, fresh food for my family because I look at the prices in the supermarkets and I think how on earth can a family afford those prices? "The dairy and the butter and the cheese is just beyond a joke," Ann said. Patricia agreed it is very hard for families. "We have so many takeaways now that a lot of children now would grow up not knowing any different comparing to some of the food that you'd buy in the supermarket, there probably isn't much difference in price." Each of them have memories of food rationing which began in 1942 and lasted until 1950. Ration books were registered with local shops and contained a page of "emergency counterfoils" to be used if you were away from home and unable to get butter or sugar from the local grocer. Hunt grew up in Auckland and was five years old when the Second World War came to an end. For the next several years life on rations continued. "My job as a probably more like five to seven [year old], was to walk the 1.5km to the shop once a week to get whatever for food was on ration, the milk or the butter, particularly flour." To keep their food fresh, her family used an ice chest and preserved eggs in a jar of jelly. "I'm not quite sure what kind of gel it was, but it was my worst thing I had to do was put my hand in and get the egg out for my mother." She said food was basic, but it was all they knew, they had sandwiches for school, and a banana if you were lucky. Her recipes are collected in a little red cookbook which is now hard to read and in pieces, passed down through the generations with handwritten recipes. Everything was homemade growing up - but due to rationing they often had to make do without butter or eggs. Her wartime recipe is Myrtle's pudding which came from her mother-in-law. "It used a tin of unsweetened condensed milk and condensed milk and evaporated milk were on everybody's shelves because half the time you couldn't get fresh milk." Other ingredients mixed in are sugar, gelatine, lemon juice and vanilla. "Very like some of the puddings that are now fashionable to buy the blancmanges and things like that, beat until thick and pour it into a tin and set it." Patricia McFarland was just six months old when the war broke out, living in the UK in Shropshire. "I had to go to school with a gas mask on my back and when I got to school, the infant mistress, there were three of us who started school that day, she said, 'please put your gas masks on stand up in that corner there and sing Baa, Baa Black Sheep'." Their school lunches were mostly meat, vegetables and steamed pudding. At home it was a different story. "All we could have for tea, was bread and jam that was all there was, except my brother liked condensed milk sandwiches or HP sauce sandwiches but there was no such thing as meat." McFarland recalled three ration books growing up for babies, children and adults. Things like cheese were scarce. "My father as a treat on a Sunday night, he used to have his portion of cheese he'd have bread and cheese and we would have toast and dripping, which is out of the roast we'd had during the day." Her recipe is an emergency "Fidget pie" with carrots, potatoes, swedes and onion, covered in gravy or cheese and pastry. Patricia McFarland's Fidget pie recipe. Photo: RNZ / Marika Khabazi "So it would all go in that and cover it with pastry that would be an issue in itself because we didn't have much in the way of butter. "If it said six ounces of butter or six ounces of shortening, they'd use two ounces of butter, two ounces of margarine which is pretty awful and two ounces of lard, so you mix that all up to make the pastry." Ann Hunt and Patricia McFarland are hopeful food prices will come down for future generations but said their war time recipes might help those looking to make do with less.
