
Why the next 28 days are crucial for Erin Patterson after being found guilty of killing three people in mushroom murder
Patterson's estranged husband Simon's parents, Don and Gail Patterson, 70, and aunt Heather Wilkinson, 66, all died in hospital days after Patterson served them beef wellington laced with death cap mushrooms in July 2023.
Heather's husband Ian Wilkinson also fell seriously ill from the deadly lunch but survived.
The jury's guilty verdicts came after seven days' deliberation at the end of an 11-week trial in the Victorian town of Morwell, in the LaTrobe Valley.
Following the verdict, Patterson was transferred back to Melbourne's Dame Phyllis Frost Centre where it is believed she is being held in protective custody.
On Sunrise on Tuesday, criminal defence lawyer Ruth Parker and former homicide detective Charlie Bezzina spoke about a possible appeal from the convicted murderer.
'Technically the rule is that you have 28 days to appeal your conviction. But, realistically, the court will grant leave to appeal out of time for such big cases, where there is so much evidence and transcript,' Parker told hosts Natalie Barr and Matt Shirvington.
'Ultimately, I think that if she has the option to appeal she will.'
Both Parker and Bezzina said Patterson was looking at a significant sentence.
'We haven't seen a case like this where there have been three people killed at the same time, in circumstances such as these, where they haven't gotten life (in prison),' Parker said.
'The issue will be whether she gets a parole period or non-parole period.
'I think there's a way to go with this one. She can definitely appeal out of time. The focus for her lawyers will be trying to get her the least possible sentence.'
Bezzina said life in prison would be difficult for Patterson.
'It would be quite difficult, the fact of being segregated. There is code in the prison system about attacking or causing harm to children and the elderly. So, ultimately, she's not going to do her time easy,' Bezzina said.
'I think given the fact one murder count carries life imprisonment, I would expect the three life imprisonments, possibly with a very high parole date.
'She'll get parole. I would be very surprised if she gets life with no parole. I think parole will be set.
'The judge will have to take into account her whole circumstances when she gives their plea material and how she will be undergoing sentence.
'It will be a difficult time for her.
'That's a long time she will be suffering in jail. So, ultimately, we will be interested to see what the Justice comes back with.'
Patterson on the stand
Parker said while it was unusual for Erin Patterson to take the stand to give evidence, in this case it was necessary.
'Unfortunately, they (the defence) were put in a position where she had clearly lied to police during her record of interview,' Parker said.
'The only way they were going to get her version across or the version that the defence were promoting was to call her, and to put these things to her.
'But it must have been a terribly stressful situation, calling your own client is always deeply uncomfortable.
'She was in the witness box for a number of days. But unfortunately, I think that that was the only choice that they had.'
Evidence
Bezzina praised the detective work in the case.
'They had to go with their best case possible,' Bezzina said.
'This involved a lot of medical evidence, toxicology evidence, so forth and so on and witnesses also.
'You go where the evidence takes you and we have electronic evidence, we saw them bring in the dog from the Federal Police to look for electronic devices.
'We have the phones ... ultimately, very, very significant because the police know the high burden to prove a case beyond reasonable doubt.
'This was one of the massive cases, and ultimately, they're responsible to the family and to the community of Victoria to give them answers and bring someone to justice.'
Complex case
Parker said she had previously thought the complex case could end in a hung jury.
'I don't think I ever really formed that view (we'd get a guilty verdict) until the verdict,' Parker said.
'It was an unusual case in the sense there were lots of conflicting accounts.
'Ultimately the jury (felt) beyond reasonable doubt on the evidence collected she was guilty of murder on three counts and attempted murder on another.'

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles


West Australian
4 hours ago
- West Australian
G8 Education announces major overhaul with CCTV rollout, more parental control after childcare worker arrested
Parents are set to be given more control over who is involved in their child's personal care routines, while CCTV is set to be rolled out across all 400 of G8 Education's childcare centres. G8 education operates Creative Garden Early Learning Centre in Point Cook in Victoria where Joshua Dale Brown, 26, allegedly abused eight children between April 2022 and January 2023. It is alleged some of the children were as young as five months. In a statement to investors, G8 Education on Tuesday announced a broad package of additional safety measures in response to the allegations. The company confirmed it was accelerating the rollout of CCTV to every centre it operates nationwide following trials in several of their centres. G8 will also expand its use of Individual Learning Plans to allow parents to nominate preferences about which educators handle their child's personal care, including nappy changes and toileting. G8's managing director and chief executive Pejman Okhovat said he and his team had been meeting personally with families in Victoria in the wake of the allegations against their former employee. 'These allegations are deeply disturbing, and our hearts go out to the children and families involved,' he said. 'I am deeply sorry for the unimaginable pain caused to our families and what they are going through, 'Our primary focus right now is on supporting all families who are impacted, as well as our team members in Victoria. 'We are continuing to work with Victoria Police, the Victorian government and other authorities as part of their ongoing investigation and are doing everything we can to give them the best chance of achieving justice for the children and families involved.' The company has also committed to commissioning an independent review of the incident once the criminal proceedings are concluded, to further strengthen its child safety procedures. G8 said that, while it already has comprehensive child safety policies in place, including banning devices in childcare rooms, mandatory reporting protocols, and ongoing staff training, it recognises the need to go further. Beyond its own network, G8 has called for broader sector reform, including the establishment of a national educator register, a unified Working with Children Check across states, and a national register of early childhood workers employment history. Authorities have released the details of all 20 childcare centres where Brown worked, including the dates of his employment. Parents and caregivers of 1200 children have been directed to have their kids tested for sexually transmitted infections out of an 'abundance of caution'.


Perth Now
4 hours ago
- Perth Now
Major changes after childcare worker arrest
Parents are set to be given more control over who is involved in their child's personal care routines, while CCTV is set to be rolled out across all 400 of G8 Education's childcare centres. G8 education operates Creative Garden Early Learning Centre in Point Cook in Victoria where Joshua Dale Brown, 26, allegedly abused eight children between April 2022 and January 2023. It is alleged some of the children were as young as five months. Joshua Dale Brown has been charged with 70 offences involving eight children at a Point Cook childcare centre. Picture Supplied. Credit: Supplied In a statement to investors, G8 Education on Tuesday announced a broad package of additional safety measures in response to the allegations. The company confirmed it was accelerating the rollout of CCTV to every centre it operates nationwide following trials in several of their centres. G8 will also expand its use of Individual Learning Plans to allow parents to nominate preferences about which educators handle their child's personal care, including nappy changes and toileting. G8's managing director and chief executive Pejman Okhovat said he and his team had been meeting personally with families in Victoria in the wake of the allegations against their former employee. 'These allegations are deeply disturbing, and our hearts go out to the children and families involved,' he said. 'I am deeply sorry for the unimaginable pain caused to our families and what they are going through, 'Our primary focus right now is on supporting all families who are impacted, as well as our team members in Victoria. 'We are continuing to work with Victoria Police, the Victorian government and other authorities as part of their ongoing investigation and are doing everything we can to give them the best chance of achieving justice for the children and families involved.' Joshua Brown worked at Creative Gardens Early Learning Centre in Point Cook from October 2021 to February 2024: Supplied Credit: Supplied The company has also committed to commissioning an independent review of the incident once the criminal proceedings are concluded, to further strengthen its child safety procedures. G8 said that, while it already has comprehensive child safety policies in place, including banning devices in childcare rooms, mandatory reporting protocols, and ongoing staff training, it recognises the need to go further. Beyond its own network, G8 has called for broader sector reform, including the establishment of a national educator register, a unified Working with Children Check across states, and a national register of early childhood workers employment history. Authorities have released the details of all 20 childcare centres where Brown worked, including the dates of his employment. Parents and caregivers of 1200 children have been directed to have their kids tested for sexually transmitted infections out of an 'abundance of caution'.

Sky News AU
6 hours ago
- Sky News AU
A trip to the tip, hospital visit and beef wellington leftovers: Photo exhibits from murderer Erin Patterson's trial released
Photos shown to the jurors who determined Erin Patterson's fate as a triple murderer have been released by the court. Patterson on Monday was found guilty of murdering her former in-laws Don and Gail Patterson, and Gail's sister Heather Wilkinson by serving a toxic beef wellington lunch in July 2023. Patterson was also convicted of the attempted murder of Heather's husband and local church pastor Ian Wilkinson, who survived the meal after a lengthy stint in hospital. A tranche of exhibits, released by the Victorian Supreme Court following the verdict, have given a glimpse into Patterson's home during a police search in the aftermath of the toxic meal. Further footage shows Patterson's hospital visit in the days after the lunch, as well as her trip to the tip to dump a food dehydrator. Inside Patterson's home after toxic lunch An annotated photograph shows where each lunch guest sat at the table during Patterson's beef wellington lunch. The image depicts Ian at the head of the table with his wife Heather to his left and Gail to his right, while Don sat opposite Erin. On August 5, 2023, Patterson's home was searched by police and a number of items were seized, including a computer. Detective Leading Senior Constable Stephen Eppingstall told the trial he was the main officer tasked with staying by Patterson's side during the search. Patterson was allowed to move around her home but an officer was with her at all times, he said. Mr Wilkinson gave evidence during the trial that the beef wellingtons were dished out as individual serves on different coloured plates. The church pastor said there were five plates in total, four grey ones and another which was an orangey-tan colour. Patterson served herself a portion of food on the odd plate and then carried it to the table, he said. The defence argued Patterson did not own a full set of matching plates in her home. The beef wellington leftovers The court heard the beef wellington recipe was sourced from a RecipeTin Eats cookbook. During her testimony, Patterson claimed she bought the fresh mushrooms used in the meal from Woolworths, as well as dried ones from an Asian grocer in Melbourne's south-east. She had stored the dried mushrooms in a Tupperware container. Patterson told the court she had dehydrated and foraged for mushrooms in the past, and feared some may have mistakenly been mixed into her beef wellington meal. She denied the poisonings were deliberate. Leftovers of the meal were later retrieved from a red bin at her property by police and provided to pathology and toxicology for testing. The testing came after Patterson's four lunch guests were admitted to hospital due to being critically unwell in the days after the lunch. CCTV released of Patterson's trip to the tip During the trial, the court was played CCTV footage of Patterson dumping a food dehydrator at the Koonwarra Transfer Station and Landfill on August 2, four days after the lunch. Stills of the footage, which have now been released, show Patterson carrying a large item from her red SUV as she walks towards a large green shed. The trial heard the operations manager of the group which runs Koonwarra Transfer Station was contacted by police on August 4 in relation to the CCTV footage. The manager asked one of his employees to look for the item depicted in the footage, which was dumped in an e-waste bin. The worker then found what he described as a microwave-type dehydrator. Police went to the tip to pick up the appliance the following day. The hospital saga Patterson presented to Leongatha Hospital about 8am on July 31, but discharged herself against medical advice only about five minutes after she arrived. Dr Chris Webster told the jury he tried to call Patterson three times after she left the hospital amid fears for her health. He left her three voice messages, and later called police as he was concerned for the mother-of-two's welfare. At this stage, Don and Gail had been transferred to Dandenong hospital, while Ian and Heather were at Leongatha. Patterson returned to the hospital a few hours later and was transferred to Monash Medical Centre with her children after doctors were told the kids had eaten leftovers of the meal. The jury delivered their guilty verdict on Monday after seven days of deliberations, bringing to a close what has been 10 weeks of proceedings in the regional Victorian town of Morwell. The prosecution argued Patterson's lunch was intentionally laced with death cap mushrooms, but the mother-of-two denied the poisonings were intentional. Prosecutors further argued that Patterson faked a cancer diagnosis to lure her guests over for lunch as she needed advice on how to break the medical news to her children. Her estranged husband Simon Patterson was invited to the lunch, but pulled out of the gathering the day before by text message. It is not yet known when the mother-of-two will be sentenced.