How companies can RTO without sparking a wave of resignations and a surge in quiet quitting
As companies across sectors, like Starbucks, Amazon, and Dell, have been calling employees back into the office, BI spoke to several workplace experts about the practice. They broadly agreed that when handled poorly, RTO can have a negative impact on your employees' motivation, morale, and retention.
"If you're enacting an RTO, you have to be ready for worst-case scenarios that may damage your ability to compete, at least in the medium term," Melissa Swift, who worked at Deloitte and Korn Ferry and now runs a workplace consultancy, told BI.
However, not all RTOs are created equal, and the experts agreed that there's a common mistake that makes RTO worse: unequal enforcement.
"There's nothing worse than feeling like your coworkers are better treated without any reason," Thomas Roulet, a professor of organisational sociology and leadership at the University of Cambridge in the UK, told BI. "Equity issues do negatively affect motivation."
Swagatam Basu, a senior director of research in Gartner's HR practice, said inconsistent mandates can create "compliance without commitment." In a 2024 survey of 6,466 employees and managers in 14 countries, Gartner found that RTO mandates made employees 10% less likely to stay and increased the number of employees "quiet quitting" by 19%.
The three experts also agreed that RTO doesn't have to have a negative impact on your workforce.
Here's how to RTO the right way.
Data, dialogue, and gradual change
Each of the management experts BI spoke to said RTO policies work best when they are flexible and give managers a say. They also offered some key pieces of advice:
Go about it gradually
Roulet said five-day RTO mandates "do not work."
He said companies should use "more progressive shifts," such as moving from two to three days, in order to help people get used to the change.
Make employees want to come in
Swift said leaders should "understand the rhythm of people's working days," lest they order people "into situations where they cannot get their work done."
She said the noise of open-plan offices and phone calls can cause issues. Dell offered employees noise-defending headphones after they complained RTO had made the workplace too noisy, a source previously told BI.
Many RTO mandates are designed by senior leadership, but Basu said managers underneath them are "key."
"When equipped to lead through RTO, they can build flexible work models that preserve trust and performance," he said.
"The ideal is not hybrid or fully remote," said Cooper. "It's when a line manager negotiates with each team member what works for them and for the business. That gets higher productivity, better job satisfaction, and fewer sick days."
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Yahoo
8 hours ago
- Yahoo
Gartner (IT) Experienced Modest Declined in Q2 Amid Government Spending Cuts
Baron Funds, an investment management company, released its 'Baron Asset Fund' second-quarter 2025 investor letter. A copy of the letter can be downloaded here. U.S. stocks rose amid volatility caused by tariff policies and Middle East tensions. Early April risk-off sentiment was fueled by Trump's 'Liberation Day' tariffs, seen as more severe than expected. U.S. equities rose after April 8, driven by favorable trade news, strong earnings, dovish Fed signals, and AI momentum, reaching record highs by quarter's end. During the second quarter, the fund was up 7.85% (Institutional Shares) compared to an 18.20% gain for the Russell Midcap Growth Index. In addition, please check the fund's top five holdings to know its best picks in 2025. In its second-quarter 2025 investor letter, Baron Asset Fund highlighted stocks such as Gartner, Inc. (NYSE:IT). Established in 1979, Gartner, Inc. (NYSE:IT) is a research and advisory company that operates through research, conferences, and consulting segments. The one-month return of Gartner, Inc. (NYSE:IT) was -15.40%, and its shares lost 29.34% of their value over the last 52 weeks. On July 31, 2025, Gartner, Inc. (NYSE:IT) stock closed at $338.65 per share, with a market capitalization of $26.065 billion. Baron Asset Fund stated the following regarding Gartner, Inc. (NYSE:IT) in its second quarter 2025 investor letter: "Modest declines from the Fund's sizable positions in Gartner, Inc. (NYSE:IT) and Roper Technologies, Inc. also contributed to relative weakness in the sector. Syndicated research provider Gartner was negatively impacted by reductions in government spending in its public sector business. We estimate U.S. federal exposure accounts for about 5% of Gartner's total research contract value, with about half from the Department of Defense and intelligence organizations, and half from civilian agencies. While federal budget scrutiny remains high, we believe Gartner's services deliver significant value to users, including the potential for hard dollar savings. Its private sector business appears well positioned for sustained growth, and management is adept at exercising cost controls to support margins and free cash flow generation. The company's balance sheet is in excellent shape, and we expect management to take advantage of this drawdown through aggressive share repurchases." A businessperson using modern technology to analyze and research airline performance. Gartner, Inc. (NYSE:IT) is not on our list of 30 Most Popular Stocks Among Hedge Funds. As per our database, 51 hedge fund portfolios held Gartner, Inc. (NYSE:IT) at the end of the first quarter which was 57 in the previous quarter. Gartner, Inc.'s (NYSE:IT) first quarter revenue was $1.5 billion, representing a 4% year-over-year increase. While we acknowledge the potential of Gartner, Inc. (NYSE:IT) as an investment, we believe certain AI stocks offer greater upside potential and carry less downside risk. If you're looking for an extremely undervalued AI stock that also stands to benefit significantly from Trump-era tariffs and the onshoring trend, see our free report on the best short-term AI stock. In another article, we covered Gartner, Inc. (NYSE:IT) and shared the list of best information technology services stocks to invest in. Madison Large Cap Fund initiated a position in Gartner, Inc. (NYSE:IT) during Q2 2025. In addition, please check out our hedge fund investor letters Q2 2025 page for more investor letters from hedge funds and other leading investors. READ NEXT: The Best and Worst Dow Stocks for the Next 12 Months and 10 Unstoppable Stocks That Could Double Your Money. Disclosure: None. This article is originally published at Insider Monkey. Error in retrieving data Sign in to access your portfolio Error in retrieving data Error in retrieving data Error in retrieving data Error in retrieving data
Business Insider
9 hours ago
- Business Insider
Read AT&T CEO's frank response to employee feedback about a 5-day RTO mandate
Roughly seven months after AT&T called workers back to the office five days a week, CEO John Stankey has a message for employees: Get on board or get out. In a lengthy Friday memo addressed to "all AT&T managers" that was obtained by Business Insider, Stankey shared his thoughts on the results of the company's employee engagement survey. The AT&T CEO said he is "not surprised" by the declining self-reported employee engagement level and touched on some changes the company is going through. The note was, in part, to help workers identify where their "professional expectations" may be "misaligned with the strategic direction of this company," he wrote. "If you are of the small minority that shared comments similar to, 'I have heard this nonsense before and I'll ignore things until this goes away…' or 'things were just fine the way they were…' there might be a disconnect between you and your current professional choice," Stankey wrote. According to the memo, 79% of respondents said they feel committed and engaged with their work. The survey results represent over 99,000 employees, which is 73% of the company. AT&T told BI that the company has no additional comments on Stankey's memo because it "speaks for itself." "We run a dynamic, customer-facing business, tackling large-scale, challenging initiatives," Stankey wrote. "If the requirements dictated by this dynamic do not align to your personal desires, you have every right to find a career opportunity that is suitable to your aspirations and needs." "That said, if a self-directed, virtual, or hybrid work schedule is essential for you to manage your career aspirations and life challenges, you will have a difficult time aligning your priorities with those of the company and the culture we aim to establish," Stankey added. AT&T has undergone a series of changes this year, starting with replacing a hybrid schedule with a five-day in-office mandate. Some AT&T employees previously told BI that it became difficult to obtain office desks and parking spaces amid the RTO push, while the telecom's rival, Verizon, saw the office mandate as an opportunity to recruit AT&T workers interested in hybrid schedules. In the memo, Stankey addressed the "right to expect to work in a professional, well-maintained, and functional facility" and the ongoing and coming investments into office hubs. Stankey is the latest CEO to tell employees to get on board with a return-to-office policy or go elsewhere. He also described the company's transition as a shift away from some elements, including "loyalty, tenure, and conformance with the associated compensation," to "a more market-based culture —focused on rewarding capability, contribution, and commitment." "When I read comments lamenting disruption, I tried to pick my brain for an example of another 100+ year old company that didn't have to disrupt itself to secure sustainable relevance," he wrote. "I am still searching for the first example." So far, AT&T shares have risen more than 21% in 2025, and the company posted robust earnings that met analyst expectations over the past two quarters. "I know change like this is difficult and can be unsettling for some," Stankey said in the memo. "However, as General Eric Shinseki so eloquently stated, 'If you dislike change, you're going to dislike irrelevance even more.'" Read AT&T CEO John Stankey's full memo: A Message from John Stankey My Observation on our Employee Survey results To: All AT&T Managers Thank you to the over 99,000 employees who responded to this year's Employee Survey. Your feedback helps us understand what we need to focus on—and how we need to communicate — as we strive toward our goal of ranking in the top third of Fortune 100 companies in employee engagement. It is incredibly encouraging that 73% of our employees took the time to respond to the survey, with 79% of those respondents feeling committed and engaged with their work at AT&T. While this is reassuring, especially considering the amount of change we've navigated as a company recently, it wasn't a surprise to me that we fell short of our engagement goal. Nor was it a surprise that scores declined since our 2023 survey. We are midstream on a multi-year journey to build the company we want, not simply optimize the one we have — and I believe your feedback accurately reflects where we are. In the survey you asked for transparency in communication from leadership. Although not my best in terms of brevity, the purpose of this multi-page note is to share a few of my thoughts with you directly while your leaders work with you to prepare their action plans. After reading this, I'm hopeful you will understand my perspective on the company we are working to build and what we can and will do to respond to elements of your feedback. This note may also help you identify areas where your professional expectations might be misaligned with the strategic direction of this company. Most points outlined below have been communicated in other forums and with your leadership, but this is my attempt to articulate how all the pieces fit together. Let me start by setting some context on what has been underway at AT&T over the last 4 years. To secure our long-term success as a company, we concluded that a shift in our operating culture was essential. For those of you who are fans of management science, this shift can be characterized as moving away from an orientation on hierarchy and familial cultural norms and towards a more externally focused and competitive market-based culture. I understand that some of you may have started your tour with this company expecting an "employment deal" rooted in loyalty, tenure, and conformance with the associated compensation, work structure, and benefits. We have consciously shifted away from some of these elements and towards a more market-based culture — focused on rewarding capability, contribution, and commitment. We believe this is the only way to succeed in the dynamic, technologically driven markets where we operate. I know change like this is difficult and can be unsettling for some. However, as General Eric Shinseki so eloquently stated, "If you dislike change, you're going to dislike irrelevance even more." Many of your survey comments indicate agreement with this notion — a desire for our company to evolve to better support our customers and each other. If you are of the small minority that shared comments similar to, "I have heard this nonsense before and I'll ignore things until this goes away…" or "things were just fine the way they were…" there might be a disconnect between you and your current professional choice. It takes every one of us, moving in the same direction, to win against the competition, sustain our business, and create rewarding and interesting challenges for employees who want to work in a market-based culture. Changes to compensation, pensions, benefits (paid time off, care leaves, mental health support), delayering, work locations, and workplace environment are all in service of this change. When I read comments lamenting disruption, I tried to pick my brain for an example of another 100+ year old company that didn't have to disrupt itself to secure sustainable relevance. I am still searching for the first example. I suspect our willingness to disrupt ourselves is the under-pinning of why this company approaches 150 years of relevance — from fixed to mobile, TDM (Time Division Multiplexing) to IP (Internet Protocol), and narrowband to broadband to name a few. I recall at every turn there were parts of the organization advocating to maintain the status quo, and I suspect hindsight would tell us we are happy we chose change — as messy as the journey might have been. Your Survey Feedback Now to the survey. There was quite a bit to unpack in your feedback, but like any business imperative, focus and prioritization are essential. Your collective data and comments were analyzed to extract the most critical themes outlined in this note. You will hear more specifics from your respective leaders around these themes in the coming weeks. 1. Career and professional growth I agree with the sentiment that everyone should understand potential career opportunities and career paths we have here at AT&T. With that, you should have a solid sense of the contribution required in your current role, and what can be done to earn more responsibility to push professional pursuits to a higher level. Many leaders have not yet fully addressed this expectation within their own organizations. Our shift to hub locations was a pivotal step to more effectively achieve this goal. Concentrations of employees enables the teamwork, mentorship, and visibility that, when combined with performance and contribution, can better equip you to advance your career. While we have made strides to get more people into fewer places, we have more work to do to align complimentary work functions in the right places. I expect all department leaders to complete this work — to thoughtfully consolidate coordinating functions and career paths to reduce the ongoing need to relocate for growth and development. 2. Capabilities to do your job You deserve tools, processes, and capabilities that help you serve our customers effectively, without being hindered by internal process friction or system constraints. While we've made progress with legacy migrations and infrastructure upgrades, there's still a long way to go. We find ourselves at the midpoint in what is a long and technically challenging journey. You have my commitment that improving these capabilities remains a top priority. We are committed to allocating resources and attention to ensure we see tangible benefits of our record levels of investment in these areas, and we'll continue to update you on these improvements. 3. Where we work You are right to expect to work in a professional, well-maintained, and functional facility. Another reason we established a focused set of hubs was to allow us to invest in our workplaces and bring them to a more common standard. This was something we never would have been able to achieve while operating in 500+ metropolitan areas. It's also why we need to continue exiting under-utilized real estate (the remnants of deferred maintenance from a long string of mergers and acquisitions) to free up resources to invest in our core locations. The fact is real estate transitions require sustained efforts over several years to arrive at the place we desire and you deserve. Some of you are in a location where enhancements are actively underway or even completed. Others may be unaware of changes that are coming in short order. We will more actively share where we are making investments, what has been accomplished, and what is on the horizon. We agree with the feedback you shared, and we are taking this seriously. I expect we all will be required to demonstrate some patience and flexibility as we work towards a better place. 4. Culture Your collective comments about culture may be the most difficult to synthesize. This topic is a bit like beauty — it's all in the eyes of the beholder. Many of you suggest a desire to improve upon what you're observing as "daily norms." I wish I could summarize a set of actions that could quickly guarantee our transition to the market-based cultural norms I described earlier. But I don't think a short-term list of actions or programs would suffice. Believe me, there is nobody more impatient for this outcome than yours truly. Changing and embracing a workplace culture is like learning a language — knowledge grows in a variety of ways and develops over time. Like learning a language, you gain proficiency by practicing in the real world. We need to commit to learning the language together so we can all share a common "shorthand." To that end, we will be doing some additional work illustrating what market-based culture norms look like in practice — and sharing some prompts that can be applied in your daily work life. We'll keep coming at this cultural evolution from every angle — but I have to ask you to commit. Commit to adjusting your own behaviors and actions without looking to your right or left (or above) to see what everybody else is doing. A favorite quote by W. Clement Stone comes to mind: "So many fail because they don't get started." Please jump in and avoid the human tendency to blame the neighbors for the problems in the neighborhood! We will all change at a slightly different pace, and that's to be expected. 5. Personal wellbeing I understand that many may find the demands of your daily lives challenging and difficult. Elder care, job stress, child rearing challenges, economic uncertainty, community unrest, technology anxiety — the list can get long. While no company can address how the combination of these dynamics might impact your specific circumstances, we can work to support employees in a way that improves their ability to manage what life throws at them. Our decisions to maintain industry-leading healthcare, change time-off policies, augment leave structures, offer financial counseling, and enhance mental health benefits are examples of overt decisions we have made on this front. Despite rising medical costs, we intend to hold management medical contributions flat for the 2026 renewal cycle. We continue to test new approaches to services and care in the workplace and are seeing some promising models emerge that may warrant implementing at scale. These are just some examples of how we are constantly evaluating how we can best support you in managing life dynamics, and you can expect more updates in the coming year. Now, onto some additional context and expectation setting. How we work together The most challenging things we do here at AT&T require unwavering teamwork - it's essential that we attract and promote talent that embraces working together to deliver results. When you think about what we are doing to transform this company - efforts like legacy sunset, fiber deployment, wireless network modernization, moving down market in Business, BSS/OSS (Business Support System/Operations Support System) platform migrations, digital/online/omni channel enablement, core routing network consolidation, and 5G standalone core - these are all efforts that require inter-departmental collaboration and coordination. They constitute the bulk of our $23 billion annual investment. This work is far more demanding and challenging than our efforts to keep the train on the tracks during enforced COVID isolation. -person collaboration and predictable presence improves each team's ability to execute effectively on large, complex projects. Our customers expect us to be here to serve their needs. Our third-party partners need to be able to consistently depend on times to collaborate. Our employees deserve reliable support with their current responsibilities and impromptu guidance for continued development. This is why we work in person, together, during common hours. We run a dynamic, customer-facing business, tackling large-scale, challenging initiatives. If the requirements dictated by this dynamic do not align to your personal desires, you have every right to find a career opportunity that is suitable to your aspirations and needs. That said, if a self-directed, virtual, or hybrid work schedule is essential for you to manage your career aspirations and life challenges, you will have a difficult time aligning your priorities with those of the company and the culture we aim to establish. Does this mean there isn't room for emergencies or special circumstances? Of course not. will always try to support that which can't be planned for — or that which needs to be deliberately planned for — and I expect any leader to manage their organization accordingly. Contribution, trust, and effectiveness Our cultural tenants include our intent to Win as One. Implicit in this commitment to one another is that we all carry our part of the load aid measurably contribute to the priorities the team. As technology and the "information economy" evolves, each of our respective contributions are going to become increasingly measurable. In addition to information garnered from performance reviews, peer feedback, assessments work history, and certifications (to name a few), we analyze patterns of behaviors from broad cohorts (aggregated data). This allows leaders to identify behaviors that are obvious outliers, supplemented with the broadest set of information available, to determine if the behavior being evaluated is consistent with our stated priorities and employment expectations. An employee's data must significantly differ from their peers — to a level harming team cohesion, compensation, and inconsistent with our Win as One philosophy — before an individual's name is linked to any behavior. Some may view this approach as a matter of trust, and that perspective is understandable. In several forums, I've expressed concerns that past data indicated more outliers than we'd like. If we overlook these outliers, it can impact overall trust in leadership and coworkers, especially among those who consistently contribute and uphold our standards. Addressing these exceptions is important to ensure we're fair to the vast majority of employees who support their colleagues and deliver for the organization every day. Next steps I hope this clarifies how we've prioritized action planning around your feedback — and transparently explains why some concerns and desires expressed may not be entirely aligned with our strategic direction as a company. While it's natural to feel uneasy during times of conflict and change, the greatest source of lasting anxiety is when expectations aren't aligned or discussed openly. Determining the best way to address new challenges and position the company for long-term success is constantly on our minds as leaders. I truly believe that this approach is the way to attract and retain customers, secure necessary resources from our investors, and offer meaningful employment to as many of our folks as possible. As difficult as it is to balance all these stakeholders, I am confident that we are on the right track. Your leadership team will be outlining our path forward in response to the survey in more detail. Until then, I ask that each of you explore your own opportunities to make a difference. While there will certainly be actions and initiatives that require sponsorship from senior leaders, our collective success also depends on each of us taking ownership where we can. Rather than waiting for others to act, I encourage everyone to share their ideas and take initiative. As I said at the beginning, we are midstream on a multi-year journey to build the company we want, not simply optimize the one we have. Your feedback makes us better, and we have many strong capabilities and attributes to leverage. John
Business Insider
12 hours ago
- Business Insider
Job seekers say it's bleak out there — and now the data agrees
The latest job report confirms what many job seekers have been feeling: The market really is that bad. For those who have been applying to thousands of jobs or slogging through grueling interview rounds only to get passed over, the numbers aren't likely surprising. "Things have ebbed and flowed," Stephanie O'Neill, a job seeker based in Los Angeles who has been on the job hunt for 10 months, told Business Insider. "A couple months ago, it seemed like it was picking up, but it appears to be slowing down again." The July jobs report revealed that 73,000 jobs were added in July, less than the expected 106,000. The unemployment rate also increased to 4.2%, a slight increase from 4.1% in June. Another standout detail from the report was the "larger than normal" revisions to May and June's job growth — meaning the earlier months were worse than previously thought. Job growth was hotter a couple of years ago when there was a lot more churn during the Great Resignation. The job market has slowed down in recent years, adding to job seekers' struggles. The Bureau of Labor Statistics confirmed to Business Insider that its commissioner was terminated on Friday following criticism from President Donald Trump who said the data was a "major mistake" and "The Economy is BOOMING under 'TRUMP.'" A skills mismatch Laura Ullrich, the director of economic research in North America at the Indeed Hiring Lab, told BI that the revisions "reinforced" her thinking over the last few months that the labor market is softening"considerably." "We have a quite lopsided jobs market in terms of the jobs that are available and the skills that people have for work," Ullrich said. Ullrich pointed to the healthcare and social assistance sector as an example. While the sector has been adding many jobs, many of those positions require specialized skill sets, education, or training. That disconnect is something 49-year-old Damon Duncan has experienced since 2021, when he was laid off from a sales engineering role. He said he's been "underemployed" since, or doing jobs that don't fit his skill set. Duncan's now working in a cold-calling sales role with colleagues who graduated from college last year, he said. "This has been a continuous battle for almost four years," Duncan, who's applied to thousands of roles, told BI. O'Neill said she applied to around 512 positions and landed about 20 interviews, mostly from referrals. Despite working in tech for over two decades, she said she's been considering alternative, non-corporate career paths like teaching. Job seeker struggles didn't start this summer While the latest data validates how job seekers have been feeling, for many, it's been a challenging market for a while. Job openings have slowed from over 12 million in March 2022 to a much cooler 7.4 million as of June. Quits have also slowed from its March 2022 peak during the Great Resignation as people are changing jobs less in a job market with fewer hires. Joseph Leemon, a job seeker based in Michigan, said he's been searching for a job for nearly three years. He's applied to around 2,000 roles and he's only had four interview requests. "I'm beginning to think that something is really amiss," Leemon told Business Insider. "Because I am not one that is trying to apply for CEO, C-suite type jobs for hundreds of thousand dollars. I am looking for mostly customer support, operations." Another job seeker, Paul Lambert, was recently laid off from an IT support managerial role. In his two months on the job market, he said he's applied to about 100 jobs since and has only had three interviews. "It's definitely been not easy to even be seen in this market," Lambert told Business Insider. Despite the challenges, Lambert said his job hunt so far isn't drastically different than what he experienced after being laid off in 2023. Lambert said he had to take a low-paying job about four months into his job search at the time to take care of his family. He said it took over a year to find a job that matched what he was looking for. Lambert said he feels like once the tariff uncertainty fades, the market will adjust. However, he said he also feels concerned about companies pausing on hiring new employees once Q4 approaches. "That's my big concern," Lambert said. "Am I going to be able to land employment before Q4 when budgets have been spent and a lot of people really aren't hiring?"
