logo
Mujib, Tagore, Now Ray: Culture Crackdown In Bangladesh Post Hasina Ouster?

Mujib, Tagore, Now Ray: Culture Crackdown In Bangladesh Post Hasina Ouster?

NDTV4 days ago
The demolition of legendary filmmaker Satyajit Ray's ancestral home in Bangladesh's Mymensingh has yet again spotlighted the cultural shift in the neighbouring country after the Sheikh Hasina government was ousted and a new dispensation led by Nobel Laureate and economist Muhammad Yunus took charge.
The months following the change of guard in Dhaka have seen India-Bangladesh ties nosedive. While India has flagged reports of attacks on Hindi minorities, Bangladesh has demanded that New Delhi stay out of its internal matters and extradite Sheikh Hasina. This comes after decades of close partnership between the two countries and is also significant against the historical backdrop of India's support in Bangladesh getting its freedom from Pakistan in 1971.
Another transformation has followed the leadership change. Bangladesh appears to be shedding its past, its cultural history and its shared heritage with India. And in doing so, iconic cultural centres are being neglected at best, and destroyed at worst.
Here are a few instances
February 2025: A part of the ancestral house of Sheikh Mujibur Rahman, the founding president of Bangladesh and Sheikh Hasina's father, is demolished. This Dhaka residence is where the hero of the Bangladesh liberation movement was murdered along with nearly 50 members of his family and staff.
June 2025: The ancestral home of Rabindranath Tagore at Shahzadpur in Bangladesh's Sirajganj district was vandalised by a mob following a dispute between a visitor and a museum staff over a parking fee. The mob damaged the auditorium and attacked an official. The museum was temporarily closed, and a probe was initiated.
July 2025: Legendary filmmaker Satyajit Ray's ancestral home in Mymensingh is being demolished. Bangladesh authorities argue that the structure, belonging to Ray's grandfather and litterateur Upendra Kishore Roy Chowdhury, is being demolished after "necessary approvals".
According to an IANS report, officials from Dhaka's Department of Archaeology admitted that their repeated requests to protect the building went unheard.
India has offered cooperation in repairing and restoring the historic structure. "Given the building's landmark status, symbolising Bangla cultural renaissance, it would be preferable to reconsider the demolition and examine options for its repair and reconstruction as a museum of literature and a symbol of the shared culture of India and Bangladesh," the Ministry of External Affairs said.
A Shared Culture
Before the Radcliffe Line hacked parts of Punjab and Bengal in 1947, setting off a bloody human migration, Bengal was partitioned in 1905 too. While the move was largely aimed at easing administration, it was seen as a 'divide and rule' attempt, and such was the backlash that the British were forced to reverse it.
And then, the 1947 Partition happened. Millions of Bengalis left their homes, towns and families behind as they started life as refugees in Kolkata and several parts of the Northeast. Like their counterparts in Punjab, they could never forget their lost home. This longing transcended borders and also enriched a shared cultural heritage.
Bengali music, literature and cinema have never been divided, nor have Bengal's cultural icons. The cultural centres in Bangladesh connected to Ray and Tagore are significant against this backdrop. Their neglect and vandalism imply an indifference to this cultural heritage and a distancing of a section of Bangladesh from these cultural icons, who once commanded equal admiration on both sides of the border.
Amid reports about Ray's ancestral residence, West Bengal Chief Minister Mamata Banerjee posted on X, "The Ray family is one of the foremost bearers and carriers of Bengali culture. Upendrakishore is a pillar of Bengal's renaissance. Therefore, I believe this house is intricately tied to the cultural history of Bengal. I appeal to the Bangladesh government and all the conscientious people of that country to take steps to preserve this heritage-laden house. The Indian government should pay attention to this matter."
Bangladesh vs History
As Sheikh Hasina fled Dhaka amid nationwide protests, an iconic image played on TV screens and phones across the world. A section of protesters toppled a golden statue of Sheikh Mujibur Rahman on Bijoy Sarani. It was an iconic sight. Sheikh Mujibur Rahman was not just Sheikh Hasina's father. Called 'Bangabandhu', he was the revolutionary who led Bangladesh to freedom. To destroy his statues and vandalise his ancestral residence goes beyond the public sentiment against his Prime Minister daughter. It signals a society's disowning of its history and a desperate attempt to distance itself from its liberation movement, based primarily on language.
In fact, the protests that ousted Hasina were triggered by the Awami League government's policy to reserve 30 per cent of government jobs for descendants of veterans who fought in the 1971 war of independence from Pakistan. Most of these people were linked to the Awami League. Bangladesh has a huge unemployment problem and many of its young nationals were born in a free country. For them, the reservation for the 1971 veterans limited their opportunities. They protested, and when Hasina tried to crush this protest, it grew only stronger.
Is Islamism Growing In Bangladesh?
Reports of atrocities against minority Hindus have sparked a buzz that Islamic fundamentalism is gaining ground in Bangladesh after the Awami League government was ousted. The Jamaat-e-Islami, which supported Islamabad during the 1971 War of Liberation and was banned by Sheikh Hasina, has returned to the political landscape and is now eligible to contest elections.
Bangladesh has a paradoxical constitution. It says that the state religion is Islam, "but the State shall ensure equal status and equal right in the practice of the Hindu, Buddhist, Christian and other religions". It adds that the principle of secularism shall be realised by eliminating communalism, by abuse of religion for political purposes and by preventing discrimination on religious grounds.
In fact, when Bangladesh became independent, it did not have a state religion. It was in 1988 when military dictator Hussain Muhammad Ershad pushed Parliament to recognise Islam as the state religion. In 2011, the then Sheikh Hasina government stressed secularism, but Islam remained the state religion.
With the change of guard, Bangladesh is again at the crossroads. The National Consensus Commission, tasked with leading critical democratic reforms, discussed this issue too. About 38 political parties debated recommendations to change the terms of the Constitution from "secularism" to "pluralism". "Although most parties rejected the idea of pluralism, they recommended incorporating some form of protection for minorities," said Ali Riaz, the commission's vice president.
Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

First time Maha CM placed Hindi above Marathi: Supriya Sule on language row
First time Maha CM placed Hindi above Marathi: Supriya Sule on language row

Business Standard

time2 minutes ago

  • Business Standard

First time Maha CM placed Hindi above Marathi: Supriya Sule on language row

Amid the ongoing Hindi-Marathi language row, NCP-SCP MP Supriya Sule took a jibe at Chief Minister Devendra Fadnavis, questioning who might be pressuring him to prioritise Hindi over Marathi. Speaking with the reporters on Saturday, Supriya Sule said, "I am very concerned about Devendra (Fadnavis) Ji. Who is pressuring him?... Under whose pressure is he doing this? This is the first time that Maharashtra's Chief Minister is placing Hindi above Marathi..." Meanwhile, Maharashtra Navnirman Sena (MNS) chief Raj Thackeray hit back at BJP MP Nishikant Dubey's controversial "patak-patak ke maarenge" remarks. In a counter-attack, Raj Thackeray said, "A BJP MP said, 'Marathi logon ko hum yahan pe patak patak ke maarenge'... You come to Mumbai. Mumbai ke samundar mein dubo dubo ke maarenge." Reacting to Dubey's remarks, the MNS chief asserted that he will not compromise on matters related to the Marathi language and the people of Maharashtra. He further said that those who live in Maharashtra should "learn Marathi as soon as possible." "I will not make any compromises over Marathi and the people of Maharashtra. Those who live in Maharashtra, to them I would like to say, 'learn Marathi as soon as possible, wherever you go, speak Marathi'. In Karnataka, they fight for their language. Even a rickshaw puller knows that the Government is standing behind him over language. Similarly, you are like a pillar and speak in Marathi only. This is what I have come to request all of you," Thackeray said while addressing a gathering in Mumbai. Taking a dig at the Maharashtra leadership over the language policy, Thackeray said, "Maharashtra CM Devendra Fadnavis had said that they would make Hindi language compulsory (in schools)... Maharashtra CM is fighting for Hindi. Marathi should be made mandatory in all schools. But instead, you are speaking about making Hindi mandatory." The Maharashtra Government had revoked the government resolutions (GRs) on the three-language policy, introducing Hindi as the third language in primary schools. The government has decided to set up a committee to take a relook into the three-language policy. Fadnavis announced that the government resolutions (GRs) issued in April regarding the three-language policy in primary schools have been cancelled. The first GR had made Hindi a compulsory third language for students from Classes 1 to 5, and the second GR made it optional.

Women, girls unsafe under DMK rule in TN, says AIADMK chief Palaniswami
Women, girls unsafe under DMK rule in TN, says AIADMK chief Palaniswami

Business Standard

time2 minutes ago

  • Business Standard

Women, girls unsafe under DMK rule in TN, says AIADMK chief Palaniswami

AIADMK general secretary Edappadi K Palaniswami has expressed concerns over the escalating crimes against women in Tamil Nadu, claiming that even young girls were not safe. He alleged that criminals were getting emboldened and flayed the ruling DMK for not ensuring safety for girls and women. Addressing a rally here on Saturday as part of his statewide campaign to "protect people, and redeem Tamil Nadu", Palaniswami said, "the culprit who allegedly raped a ten-year-old girl in Gummidipoondi is yet to be arrested. Young girls, women and even elderly persons are not safe in the DMK rule." "Do you want such a government to continue?" the former CM asked, and the crowd replied with a thunderous "no". Speaking at Vedaranyam, famous for the salt sathyagraha against the British, Palaniswami said people were disillusioned' on all fronts with the present DMK regime and "they are ready for another Satyagraha - this time against the DMK to vote out that party in next year's Assembly election." Earlier, Palaniswami, accompanied by party seniors, visited the Basilica of Our Lady of Health, also known as the Velankanni church, lit a candle and offered prayers. While addressing a roadshow in Nagapattinam, he paused for a few minutes from his campaign vehicle till the Muslims in the neighbourhood completed their evening prayers.

Rahul Gandhi's 'I fight RSS, CPM ideologically' remark triggers INDIA bloc rift
Rahul Gandhi's 'I fight RSS, CPM ideologically' remark triggers INDIA bloc rift

India Today

time34 minutes ago

  • India Today

Rahul Gandhi's 'I fight RSS, CPM ideologically' remark triggers INDIA bloc rift

Rahul Gandhi made the remark during an event in Kerala. Rahul Gandhi equated RSS and CPI(M), causing unrest in INDIA bloc Left leaders raised concerns in virtual meeting, calling remarks divisive CPI(M) leader MA Baby criticised Gandhi's comments as uninformed Congress leader Rahul Gandhi's recent remarks equating the RSS and the CPI(M) sparked unease within the INDIA bloc, with Left leaders raising the issue during the alliance's virtual meeting on Saturday, according to sources. The comments, made by Gandhi at an event in Kerala, were flagged as inappropriate and potentially divisive by leaders of the Left parties, who warned that such statements could send the wrong message to cadres on the ground. Gandhi, the Leader of Opposition in the Lok Sabha, said during a speech in Kottayam on Friday that he fights both the RSS and the CPI(M) ideologically, but his main complaint against them is their lack of "feelings" for the people. "I fight them in the realm of ideas and in the realm of speech. But, my biggest complaint is that they do not have feelings for the people," he said while addressing a memorial meeting to mark the second death anniversary of former Kerala Chief Minister Oommen Chandy. "If you are in politics, feel what people are thinking, listen to them, and touch them. The real tragedy in Indian politics today is that very few people are actually feeling what others are feeling," he added. Sources said CPI leader D Raja raised the issue during the INDIA bloc's online meeting, without directly naming Rahul Gandhi. He is learnt to have said that such remarks, equating the Left with the RSS, should be avoided as they create confusion among cadres and can damage the unity of the alliance. Another leader present reportedly pointed out that when the INDIA bloc began its journey, the common slogan was 'Desh Bachaao, BJP Hataao', and that no one should make statements that foster conflict within the bloc or draw comparisons between the Left and the RSS. CPI(M) General Secretary MA Baby had strongly criticised Gandhi's comments earlier, calling them "unfortunate" and a reflection of a lack of understanding of the political realities in Kerala and India. In a scathing video message posted on X on Friday, a day before the INDIA bloc meeting, Baby said, "The very fact that he in a way equated the CPI(M) and RSS betrays the absence of a correct understanding of the role of CPI(M) and RSS in Kerala or India." He reminded Gandhi that the Congress government in 2004 could not have been formed without the support of the Left. "Rahul Gandhi only needs to recall how Mr Manmohan Singh could not have formed a government in 2004 without the support of CPI(M) and other Left parties. Congress did not command a majority in Lok Sabha after the 2004 election," he said. Taking a jibe at Gandhi's political record, he said, "Rahul Gandhi represented Wayanad, where he did not have to fight the RSS or BJP but a CPI candidate. I hope and wish that he would be more serious while speaking against CPI(M)." Gandhi had contested against CPI candidate Annie Raja in Wayanad and later vacated the seat after winning from Rae Bareli, which was then won by his sister Priyanka Gandhi Vadra in the bypoll. Baby further said, "We will make independent criticisms, but we will never equate the Congress with the BJP or RSS." He stressed that while the CPI(M) has often criticised the Congress on economic issues, it has done so in a "friendly manner". He added, "So, it was quite unfortunate that, in a very casual and sweeping manner, Mr. Rahul Gandhi put CPI(M) and RSS together as his ideological enemies. People can reflect upon it." He also questioned Gandhi's awareness of his own party's historical role in combating the RSS in Kerala. "I do not know whether Mr Rahul Gandhi knows what the record of the Congress in Kerala in fighting the RSS," Baby said. Both the Congress and CPI(M) are part of the INDIA bloc, an alliance of opposition parties formed to challenge the BJP in the 2024 Lok Sabha polls. However, in Kerala, the CPI(M)-led Left Democratic Front and Congress-led United Democratic Front remain direct political opponents, with the BJP trying to expand its presence in the state. Meanwhile, the INDIA bloc meeting also saw parties resolve to raise several issues during the upcoming Parliament Monsoon Session, including the Pahalgam attack and the alleged threat to voting rights in Bihar due to a special revision of electoral rolls. The bloc is also planning a protest march to Jantar Mantar on July 23-24 over the voter list revision issue, with details of the plan currently being finalised. Congress leader Rahul Gandhi's recent remarks equating the RSS and the CPI(M) sparked unease within the INDIA bloc, with Left leaders raising the issue during the alliance's virtual meeting on Saturday, according to sources. The comments, made by Gandhi at an event in Kerala, were flagged as inappropriate and potentially divisive by leaders of the Left parties, who warned that such statements could send the wrong message to cadres on the ground. Gandhi, the Leader of Opposition in the Lok Sabha, said during a speech in Kottayam on Friday that he fights both the RSS and the CPI(M) ideologically, but his main complaint against them is their lack of "feelings" for the people. "I fight them in the realm of ideas and in the realm of speech. But, my biggest complaint is that they do not have feelings for the people," he said while addressing a memorial meeting to mark the second death anniversary of former Kerala Chief Minister Oommen Chandy. "If you are in politics, feel what people are thinking, listen to them, and touch them. The real tragedy in Indian politics today is that very few people are actually feeling what others are feeling," he added. Sources said CPI leader D Raja raised the issue during the INDIA bloc's online meeting, without directly naming Rahul Gandhi. He is learnt to have said that such remarks, equating the Left with the RSS, should be avoided as they create confusion among cadres and can damage the unity of the alliance. Another leader present reportedly pointed out that when the INDIA bloc began its journey, the common slogan was 'Desh Bachaao, BJP Hataao', and that no one should make statements that foster conflict within the bloc or draw comparisons between the Left and the RSS. CPI(M) General Secretary MA Baby had strongly criticised Gandhi's comments earlier, calling them "unfortunate" and a reflection of a lack of understanding of the political realities in Kerala and India. In a scathing video message posted on X on Friday, a day before the INDIA bloc meeting, Baby said, "The very fact that he in a way equated the CPI(M) and RSS betrays the absence of a correct understanding of the role of CPI(M) and RSS in Kerala or India." He reminded Gandhi that the Congress government in 2004 could not have been formed without the support of the Left. "Rahul Gandhi only needs to recall how Mr Manmohan Singh could not have formed a government in 2004 without the support of CPI(M) and other Left parties. Congress did not command a majority in Lok Sabha after the 2004 election," he said. Taking a jibe at Gandhi's political record, he said, "Rahul Gandhi represented Wayanad, where he did not have to fight the RSS or BJP but a CPI candidate. I hope and wish that he would be more serious while speaking against CPI(M)." Gandhi had contested against CPI candidate Annie Raja in Wayanad and later vacated the seat after winning from Rae Bareli, which was then won by his sister Priyanka Gandhi Vadra in the bypoll. Baby further said, "We will make independent criticisms, but we will never equate the Congress with the BJP or RSS." He stressed that while the CPI(M) has often criticised the Congress on economic issues, it has done so in a "friendly manner". He added, "So, it was quite unfortunate that, in a very casual and sweeping manner, Mr. Rahul Gandhi put CPI(M) and RSS together as his ideological enemies. People can reflect upon it." He also questioned Gandhi's awareness of his own party's historical role in combating the RSS in Kerala. "I do not know whether Mr Rahul Gandhi knows what the record of the Congress in Kerala in fighting the RSS," Baby said. Both the Congress and CPI(M) are part of the INDIA bloc, an alliance of opposition parties formed to challenge the BJP in the 2024 Lok Sabha polls. However, in Kerala, the CPI(M)-led Left Democratic Front and Congress-led United Democratic Front remain direct political opponents, with the BJP trying to expand its presence in the state. Meanwhile, the INDIA bloc meeting also saw parties resolve to raise several issues during the upcoming Parliament Monsoon Session, including the Pahalgam attack and the alleged threat to voting rights in Bihar due to a special revision of electoral rolls. The bloc is also planning a protest march to Jantar Mantar on July 23-24 over the voter list revision issue, with details of the plan currently being finalised. Join our WhatsApp Channel

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into a world of global content with local flavor? Download Daily8 app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store