Brazil Supreme Court Holds Social Media Platforms Liable for User Content
Six of the 11 Supreme Court judges voted to hold platforms responsible for third-party content seen as illegal, in a decision that could result in fines against social media companies for not removing some users' posts in the country.
The decision could impact the business of platforms including Meta's Facebook and Instagram, as well as TikTok, Elon Musk's X and other internet giants, such as Alphabet's Google, in a market of more than 200 million people.
Only one justice so far voted to not change the current law on the matter, which says that the companies can only be found responsible for third-party content on their platforms if the firms do not comply with a legal decision ordering the content removal.
Writing for the majority, Justice Gilmar Mendes said current Brazilian law represents "a veil of irresponsibility for digital platforms."
"Even if they are informed of the occurrence of crimes on their platforms, they (currently) cannot be held responsible for damages caused by keeping this content online, except in the case of a court order," he said.
Asked to comment, Meta sent a 2024 statement where it had said that a decision holding platforms responsible could make them "liable for virtually all types of content even without having been notified."
In a statement sent before the vote which gave the court a majority, Google said the current Brazilian law regarding social media can and should be improved, "as long as procedure guarantees and criteria are set to prevent legal uncertainty and the indiscriminate content removal."
TikTok and a representative of X in Brazil did not immediately respond to requests for comment.
The court did not agree on the scope of the decision, such as what types of content would be considered illegal. The court's head, Luis Roberto Barroso, said he will work with the court members to find a consensus.
Four judges still need to vote in the trial, which has been rolling over for months. Votes previously cast can still be changed, although that is not common. The trial is set to resume on Thursday.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Star
36 minutes ago
- The Star
Culture key for M+C Saatchi as agency rolls out fresh proposition
PETALING JAYA: The ability to grasp and effectively resonate with culture has become critical for driving brand growth in today's media landscape. With the growing fragmentation of media, audiences are now more spread out and difficult to reach. 'The role of the marketer in building brands has been fundamentally challenged and is more complex than ever,' said Justin Graham, Asia-Pacific chief executive officer of M+C Saatchi Group. As a result, it is essential that agencies quickly adapt. In light of this rapidly changing environment, M+C Saatchi Group recently unveiled its global 'Cultural Power' framework, developed to unite deep cultural insight with creative strategy across all its touchpoints. 'We're bringing this notion of creating and curating Cultural Power to the centre of our proposition. Recognising that brands are built through culture, it's an extraordinary space for us to understand short-term and long-term trends, and how brands can be built in an enduring way,' said Graham. This proprietary approach aims to go beneath the surface data to uncover cultural truths that shape consumer behaviour. 'While data shows us behaviours, culture reveals the values and tensions behind them,' he explained. Underpinning the framework is the Cultural Power Index, M+C Saatchi's AI-powered, data-driven diagnostic and insights tool developed to measure a brand's cultural power and identify its effect on business performance. Using AI-enhanced analysis and expert workshops, the index examines and compares brands around the world, tracking brand desire, influence, and presence. From there, it then also takes into account cultural moments and their impact. Graham: While data shows us behaviours, culture reveals the values and tensions behind them. — ART CHEN/The Star 'We live in a dynamic world where there are constantly new trends, movements, and shifts in how people think about themselves and how they relate to the culture,' Graham said. 'What are the moments that brands should be buying into? What are the ones that are not relevant to them at all? We've all seen brands that have jumped onto something and thought, why is that bank involved in that funny TikTok trend? Why is that telco company doing this?' To help brands harness their cultural power, the index provides these insights and translates them into strategy to deliver authenticity and emotional resonance. Additionally, its real-time tracking component monitors shifts in cultural perception, ensuring brands are able to stay ahead. As the framework rolls out across the group's global network, Graham shares that each market will see a level of localisation based on its unique cultural context. 'I think it will look very different, as there are various nuances within Malaysia, Singapore, and Australia. 'In fact, the Malaysian market has arguably embraced brands into the cultural context more than others, whether it be festivities, religious holidays, or cultural moments. So there seems to be more permission for brands to drive cultural resonance and cultural power here in Malaysia.' Datin Lara Hussein, chief executive officer and founder of M+C Saatchi Malaysia, adds that the ethos of using culture as a springboard has guided some of the agency's most resonant past campaigns, such as Axiata's 'Getaran Story'. Ahead of Merdeka celebrations, the brand launched a film titled Getaran Pertama, which followed the journey to form the first choir that would sing the national anthem for a new independent Malaya. Featuring documentary-style interviews providing first-hand accounts, the film showcased how Malayans of different races and backgrounds came together in an emblematic unity that echoed the hopes for the new nation. 'It was a very human, heartfelt story that avoided cliché. We were able to find the real people, who are in their 80s now, but were young kids back in 1957,' Lara said. 'It's about finding that nuance that's going to have an impact and make a difference, as opposed to superficial storytelling.' The Cultural Power identity refresh, she noted, further cements M+C Saatchi's commitment towards embedding cultural knowledge at every stage so that clients can connect on a strategic and human level. Graham adds that this approach often brings a multiplier effect that extends beyond traditional lines between bought media, earned media, owned media. 'On the owned media side, it is also about how we can create culturally resonant and relevant stories and experiences within organisations, so that it's as meaningful for the people that work there as it is for the customers that they're talking to,' he said. 'It's really broadening out the scope of what a brand can look like, and showing how it is one of the most powerful assets an organisation can have.'
The Star
20 hours ago
- The Star
TikTok Germany moderators raise alarm over layoff plans
BERLIN: Content moderators at the German branch of social media giant TikTok sounded the alarm Thursday about what they say is a plan to replace them with artificial intelligence, potentially putting platform users at risk. Around 50 people gathered for a protest near the offices of TikTok Germany, among them some of the 150-strong "trust and safety" department in Berlin, who say management are threatening to fire them en masse. Holding a banner reading "we trained your machines, pay us what we deserve", the protestors said TikTok had already overseen one round of layoffs last year and demanded it reverse plans to fully close the department. The content moderators are tasked with keeping content such as hate speech, misinformation and pornography off the platform, which claimed more than 20 million users in Germany as of late 2023. The row in Germany comes amid a global trend of social media companies reducing their use of human fact-checkers and turning to AI instead. In October, TikTok – which has 1.5 billion users worldwide and is a division of Chinese tech giant ByteDance – announced hundreds of job losses worldwide as part of a shift to AI-assisted content moderation. TikTok did not reply to an AFP request for comment. The moderators at TikTok Germany are being supported by the union who say that the company has refused to negotiate and that strike action is being prepared if this continues. One of the moderators, 32-year-old Benjamin Karkowski, said that staff had been "shocked" when they learned of TikTok's current plans via a message from management. Another one of the moderators, 36-year-old Sara Tegge, says that the artificial intelligence used by the company "cannot tell whether content discriminates against certain groups and it can't judge the danger of certain content". She cited an example in which the AI flagged innocuous content about Berlin's annual LGBT+ pride as breaking TikTok's guidelines on political protests. If the company moves ahead with its plans she "certainly fears" users may be exposed to greater danger. Showing support at Thursday's demonstration was Werner Graf, leader of the Green party's lawmakers in Berlin's state assembly. "These people have been fighting so that the Internet isn't permanently overwhelmed" with "fake news and hate speech", he said. "We in the political arena must make clear that checking content... can't simply be left up to AI, we must legislate to make sure it's done by humans," he went on. – AFP
Malaysiakini
21 hours ago
- Malaysiakini
Amanah VP: PAS obsessed with toppling Anwar as Kelantan spirals
Amanah vice-president Mahfuz Omar has accused PAS of prioritising efforts to unseat Prime Minister Anwar Ibrahim over addressing pressing issues in Kelantan, including drug abuse, smuggling, and rising social problems. The former PAS leader, in a statement today, claimed the Islamist party has become more invested in 'street strategies and TikTok propaganda' over governance.
