logo
Did Big Tech just outfox the China hawks?

Did Big Tech just outfox the China hawks?

Politico16 hours ago
One of the most dizzying pivots in American policy toward China happened just last week, when two chipmakers — Nvidia and AMD — said that Donald Trump's White House had effectively given its blessing to let them sell high-end artificial intelligence chips to China.
Just in April, the White House had banned sales of Nvidia's H20 and AMD's MI308 chips to China. Recent administrations spent years trying to contain China's ambitions in tech — and particularly in AI. My colleague Gabby Miller called it 'policy whiplash' in her Morning Tech newsletter on Thursday.
China hawks in Congress are up in arms, worried that the H20 compute power could enable the country to develop state-of-the-art AI models. Republican Rep. John Moolenaar (R-Mich), chair of the House China Committee, sent a letter to Commerce Secretary Howard Lutnick on Friday insisting on a briefing about the decision. Democratic ranking member Raja Krishnamoorthi said the move would 'hand our foreign adversaries our most advanced technologies.'
(In fairness, these are not the most advanced technologies — Nvidia's highest-end AI chips are still illegal to export to China.)
What's really going on here? Is this just Trump being strategically unpredictable in the middle of a stuck trade negotiation with China? Or is he taking the industry's side against the national-security community?
Possibly either. Or both. But to longtime observers, this is also an attempt to take another position in a years-long argument: If countries are going to develop AI, the thinking goes, it's far better to have it built on American tech.
Proponents of the H20 exports contend that they further national security by keeping the world dependent on the U.S.'s AI hardware, as well as fortifying its market power. During a CNBC interview on July 15, Lutnick argued that Nvidia's sales get China's developers 'addicted to the American technology stack.'
This is also the argument Nvidia CEO Jensen Huang has been making, according to the New York Times.
Nvidia told DFD in a statement, 'America wins when the world builds on the U.S. technology stack. The Government made the best decision for America, promoting U.S. technology leadership, economic growth, and national security.' AMD did not respond to an inquiry.
Patrick Moorhead, a former VP at AMD, said a strong market position is important to keeping Chinese competitors at bay. 'Any dollar that's not going to Nvidia is going to Huawei,' he told DFD.
Part of the policy tension is simply over risk tolerance, Moorhead said. The national-security community — especially military and defense officials — typically 'just want to take all risk off the table,' he said.
Businesses, of course, thrive on a measure of risk — especially when they see big gains at stake. This was clearly in evidence when Trump brokered deals to send tens of thousands of high-end chips to Gulf countries in May, over objections that it would open the door to chip smuggling.
'The White House seems to be prioritizing the economic gains [...] and they have a philosophy about why that won't create challenges on the national security side,' said Michael Horowitz, a deputy assistant secretary of defense under Biden who had concerns that the exports could be harmful in the long term. 'Given the way that China aggressively harvests American technology to improve its military, there are reasons to be nervous.'
A White House official told DFD on background that the administration sees its application process for selling chips like H20, which Biden did not restrict, as creating a middle path that promotes the industry while addressing serious national security concerns.
In the classic Washington game of 'who's winning,' it looks like this round goes to the chipmakers over the hawks. AI and chip companies have been 'been pretty good at convincing the president to take some measure of risk,' said Moorehead.
Nvidia CEO Jensen Huang seems to have masterminded this particular about-face. He's been in regular contact with White House allies to protest against export controls, and reportedly convinced Trump to change course on Nvidia's chip sales to China in early July.
National security wonks aren't so sure this will work to keep China dependent on America's tech stack. China has been investing more than any other geographic region on building up domestic manufacturing capabilities since 2023. 'Even if China has access to U.S. chips and architectures, they're strategically aware enough to know that they shouldn't rely on a competitor for a technology this vital,' Janet Egan, a senior fellow at the Center for a New American Security, told DFD.
'At the end of the day, Chinese firms are going to be actively trying to create alternative ecosystems regardless,' she said.
The industry's initial victories on export controls aren't set in stone. Since Trump set the H20 restrictions in the first place, only to revoke them, he could easily pull another 180 in the future. In fact, national security concerns are reportedly holding up UAE chip deals.
Plus, the industry-hawk dichotomy can be a bit reductive when it comes to this debate. Chris Miller, a Tufts University historian who wrote the book 'Chip War,' told DFD that chip exports can help or hurt different parts of the tech industry — Anthropic notably called for strong controls on advanced microchips in April.
'Obviously chip companies, at least in the short run, benefit from selling more chips, but then AI companies in the U.S. probably lose out by having stronger Chinese competitors,' he said.
In a storyline as complex as chips, China and AI, perhaps it's more accurate to look at Big Tech as a collection of different industries, whose interests don't always align. On the question of the new H20 exports, Miller said: 'It depends on which industry you're talking about — you get different answers.'
China-linked hackers breach Sharepoint
China-backed groups hacked Microsoft's SharePoint service, the American tech giant said Tuesday, as POLITICO's John Sakellariadis and Dana Nickel report. They add the U.S. has yet to name a culprit.
The hack hit some 100 targets, which began to notice the security breach last week. Microsoft named three groups based in China — Linen Typhoon, Violet Typhoon and Storm-2603 — as being responsible for the hack. It added that Linen Typhoon and Violet Typhoon are Chinese state actors. Internet researchers told POLITICO that the cyberattack exploited a SharePoint flaw to remotely access servers belonging to dozens of organizations around the world.
Microsoft said in a statement that it was 'coordinating closely with [the Cybersecurity and Infrastructure Security Agency], [Department of Defense] Cyber Defense Command, and key cybersecurity partners around the world throughout our response.' The company's threat intelligence team also recommended that SharePoint customers install its latest security updates and antivirus programs.
A U.S. official told POLITICO that government investigators suspect the hackers were able to infiltrate four to five federal agencies. Officials told John and Dana they had not yet determined how or whether China was involved in the attack.
The Chinese embassy in Washington did not respond to POLITICO's inquiries.
Congress wants answers on AI.gov
Senate Democrats are pressing the Trump administration on the development of an AI chatbot known as AI.gov for federal employees.
POLITICO's Morning Tech team obtained a letter that 15 Senate Democrats sent to the Department of Government Efficiency initiative and the General Services Administration inquiring about AI.gov. The letter, helmed by Sen. Brian Schatz (D-Hawaii), requests information on the application's use cases, data privacy safeguards and protections against bias.
'Poorly planned AI deployments can risk disrupting workflows and fostering distrust, especially when workers are not adequately trained or consulted,' the letter reads.
The outlet 404 Media was the first to report on the government's AI.gov efforts in June. Based on information from GitHub and audio from internal meetings, 404 Media found that federal officials had considered incorporating AI coding agents and an analytics feature to track AI use across government teams.
post of the day
THE FUTURE IN 5 LINKS
Stay in touch with the whole team: Aaron Mak (amak@politico.com); Mohar Chatterjee (mchatterjee@politico.com); Steve Heuser (sheuser@politico.com); Nate Robson (nrobson@politico.com); and Daniella Cheslow (dcheslow@politico.com).
Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

The US decision to leave UNESCO again puts a spotlight on what the agency does and why it matters
The US decision to leave UNESCO again puts a spotlight on what the agency does and why it matters

Yahoo

time23 minutes ago

  • Yahoo

The US decision to leave UNESCO again puts a spotlight on what the agency does and why it matters

PARIS (AP) — With the support of international partners and the mobilization of $115 million, the U.N. cultural agency UNESCO recently helped rebuild the Iraqi city of Mosul after it was devastated by the Islamic State group. The restoration of the historic city's iconic Al-Nouri Mosque and Al-Hadba Minaret was just one of many programs run by the U.N. Educational, Scientific and Cultural Organization, which is in the spotlight because the United States is leaving it once again. The decision to pull U.S. funding and participation from UNESCO will deal a blow to its work preserving cultural heritage around the world. President Donald Trump exited the agency during his first term, accusing it of promoting anti-Israel speech. The Biden administration had rejoined UNESCO in 2023 after citing concerns that China was filling the gap left by the U.S. in UNESCO policymaking. Beyond the diplomatic disputes, here's a look at the work that UNESCO does: World Heritage Sites UNESCO names World Heritage sites, including landmarks like the Great Wall of China, the Egyptian pyramids, the Taj Mahal and the Statue of Liberty, and gives them special protection under its World Heritage Sites program. Its World Heritage Committee each year designates sites considered 'of outstanding value to humanity' and intervenes when sites are in danger of destruction or damage. The program provides countries with technical assistance and professional training to preserve the sites. It now also includes 'intangible' heritage such as folk songs and traditional dances, crafts and cooking in its lists. A World Heritage site designation is coveted and seen as a boost to tourism. Holocaust Education Like the rest of the U.N., UNESCO was created in response to the horrors of World War II, and particularly Nazi crimes. Amid concerns that the agency's Arab members have used UNESCO to pass anti-Israel resolutions, UNESCO has worked in recent years on Holocaust awareness projects. That includes educational materials and organizing visits to former Nazi concentration camps. Empowering Girls UNESCO works to improve literacy, with a special focus on girls in countries hit by war or disasters who get little or no schooling though programs such as the Malala Fund for Girls' Right to Education. In Tanzania, for instance, over 2,500 girls benefited from the creation of safe spaces in 40 secondary schools, The agency provides teacher training and materials and encourages programs for girls to pursue careers in science. Climate Change One of the agency's goals is coordinating climate knowledge and improving international education about how global warming occurs and affects people around the world. Over 30 UNESCO programs are designed to help its members adapt to climate change and favor sustainable development. Ethics of Artificial Intelligence UNESCO adopted in 2021 what it calls 'the first and only global standard-setting instrument on the ethics of artificial intelligence.' Applying to all 194 member states, the recommendation emphasizes the protection of human rights and dignity, grounded in principles like transparency, fairness, and human oversight of AI systems. Operating without the U.S. UNESCO director general Audrey Azoulay said the U.S. decision to leave was expected and that the agency has prepared for it. While the U.S. had previously provided a notable share of the agency's budget, UNESCO has diversified its funding sources. 'Thanks to the efforts made by the organization since 2018, the decreasing trend in the financial contribution of the US has been offset, so that it now represents 8% of the organization's total budget compared with 40% for some United Nations entities,' Azoulay said. She added that the agency's overall budget has increased and that it has the steady support of "a large number of member states and private contributors.' Solve the daily Crossword

Trump visit will ‘undoubtedly stretch' police resources, superintendents warn
Trump visit will ‘undoubtedly stretch' police resources, superintendents warn

Yahoo

time23 minutes ago

  • Yahoo

Trump visit will ‘undoubtedly stretch' police resources, superintendents warn

US President Donald Trump's upcoming visit to Scotland will 'undoubtedly stretch' police resources, a senior officer has warned. Chief Superintendent Rob Hay, president of the Association of Scottish Police Superintendents (Asps), said the visit of the US President would require a 'significant operation across the country over many days' from Police Scotland. His comments come in the wake of similar concerns from the Scottish Police Federation (SPF) – the body which represents rank and file officers. However Scottish First Minister John Swinney has insisted policing will not be put in a 'detrimental position' as a result of the visit. Mr Trump is due to arrive in Scotland on Friday for a five-day private visit to his his golf resorts in both Ayrshire and Aberdeenshire. During his time in Scotland the President will meet both Prime Minister Sir Keir Starmer and Mr Swinney. However, police officers are raising concerns about the impact of the trip, with Mr Hay stating: 'The private visit of President Donald Trump to Scotland at the end of July will require the Police Service of Scotland to plan for and deliver a significant operation across the country over many days. 'This will undoubtedly stretch all our resources from local policing divisions to specialist and support functions such as contact, command and control.' Police superintendents and chief superintendents will have 'key leadership roles' for the visit, he added, saying they would be taking responsibility for areas such as planning and resourcing, intelligence gathering, command and control communications, armed operations, public order, and other specialist functions. Mr Hay urged the public to be aware of the 'significant demands that will be placed on policing services during this period' – adding these result from not only the Presidential visit but the 'many popular events that Scotland hosts in the summer months, which bring thousands of tourists to our country and rely upon partnerships with policing to support their safe delivery'. His comments came as SPF general secretary David Kennedy warned the police response to the visit could impact on the service it provides to the public in Scotland. A major policing operation is being put in place both the visit and any protests that may spring up as a result of it, with Police Scotland seeking officers from other areas of the UK to bolster its numbers. Asked about the visit, Mr Kennedy told BBC Radio Scotland: 'Anyone who says it won't affect it (policing in Scotland), I can't believe that's the case. 'It will affect it. 'You may be waiting in the past for so many hours for a police officer to arrive, that could double now, you may be waiting for more time for them to arrive. 'Obviously, emergency calls will take priority, but it will affect communities in Scotland. 'We've been asking long and weary to have more police officers in our communities in Scotland and all this does is take them away from that at this time.' Asked if the quality of policing will be impacted by the visit, Mr Kennedy added: 'It will be seriously affected, it has to be. 'There's not enough police officers for it not to be affected.' Concerns have also been raised about the cost of the policing operation, with officers likely to cancel rest days to ensure adequate staffing. But speaking to the PA news agency on Tuesday, Mr Swinney said talks are ongoing between Police Scotland and the Scottish and UK governments on funding, asserting that policing in Scotland will not be put in a 'detrimental position' as a result. Mr Kennedy also reiterated calls from Assistant Chief Constable Emma Bond for those seeking to protest to do so peacefully. Ms Bond has already said a 'policing plan will be in place to maintain public safety, balance rights to peaceful protest and minimise disruption'. She added: 'The visit will require a significant police operation using local, national and specialist resources from across Police Scotland, supported by colleagues from other UK police forces as part of mutual aid arrangements. 'Officers make sacrifices every day to keep people safe, and their dedication and professionalism is the reason we manage to deliver significant operations.'

US Treasury's Bessent says Trump has leverage with tariff rates
US Treasury's Bessent says Trump has leverage with tariff rates

Yahoo

time23 minutes ago

  • Yahoo

US Treasury's Bessent says Trump has leverage with tariff rates

WASHINGTON (Reuters) -U.S. President Donald Trump has created a lot of leverage on trade with his letters on tariff rates, U.S. Treasury Secretary Scott Bessent told Bloomberg Television in an interview on Wednesday. "President Trump is creating this leverage by saying: if you don't want to negotiate with me, I've sent you a letter with a high rate. Have at the high rate or come and negotiate in better fashion," Bessent said. Error in retrieving data Sign in to access your portfolio Error in retrieving data Error in retrieving data Error in retrieving data Error in retrieving data

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into a world of global content with local flavor? Download Daily8 app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store