Hip surgeries: Parents call for independent review by international experts
found almost 70 per cent
of surgeries carried out at the healthcare facilities were not necessary.
On Friday, the
Health Service Executive
(HSE) published an independent audit on hip surgery thresholds for children with developmental dysplasia of the hip (DDH).
It
examined 147 cases across three hospitals
–
Temple Street
, the
National Orthopaedic Hospital Cappagh
(NOHC) and
Crumlin Hospital
. In Temple Street, some 60 per cent of surgeries audited did not meet the clinical threshold for surgical intervention, with this proportion being 79 per cent in NOHC.
Two advocacy groups – the scoliosis advocacy network and Spina Bifida and/or Hydrocephalus Paediatric Advocacy Group – held a meeting with more than 70 affected parents on Sunday evening.
READ MORE
Notes from the meeting show families are unhappy with the HSE's plan to offer all families the opportunity to have their case reviewed by a specialist medical team, believing this will 'only delay meaningful review and support'.
[
Hip surgery audit: Almost 70% of operations in two children's hospitals 'unnecessary'
Opens in new window
]
Parents expressed 'serious concern' about this proposed clinical review pathway because the clinicians who carried out the unnecessary surgeries were not named in the report. The families said they have 'no confidence' in a review process.
Instead, the families have called for an independent clinical review of all DDH surgeries.
'This must be carried out by a panel of international paediatric orthopaedic experts, each with a minimum of 10 years' experience and qualifications equal to or exceeding those of Irish consultants,' the families said.
'A core group of parents will liaise directly with the relevant authorities to ensure the panel has the full confidence of families. The composition of the panel must be formally agreed with the parent group.'
The two advocacy groups also reiterated their call for a full public inquiry into Children's Health Ireland (CHI), stating there was a specific need to examine 'the systemic governance failures that resulted in preventable harm to their children'.
[
Hip surgery audit: How many more times will we hear 'this can never happen again'?
Opens in new window
]
'This inquiry is not optional. Families will directly negotiate the terms of reference with the Minister for Health and will not accept any process that excludes their leadership, scrutiny and approval,' they said.
Following the publication of Friday's report, Minister for Health
Jennifer Carroll MacNeill
announced she has moved to 'strengthen governance and oversight' at CHI and NOHC.
The Minister said this will be done by the appointment of two members of the HSE board to the board of CHI, strengthening the service level agreement between the two bodies and increasing involvement of the Dublin Midlands Region Regional Executive Officer.
Further arrangements are also being considered in relation to this, Ms Carroll MacNeill said.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Journal
5 hours ago
- The Journal
Charlie Bird's wife supporting All-Ireland morning walk in aid of Motor Neurone Disease
THE PUBLIC HAVE been urged to come together and walk 'shoulder to shoulder' by joining a sponsored walk on Sunday, the day of the All-Ireland football final. The walk will take place in Offaly. Organised by a group of Irish sports stars and sporting clubs, the 'Shoulder to Shoulder' walk is in aid of those suffer from ALS, the most common form of Motor Neurone Disease. It will begin the morning of the final at St Brigid's GAA Club, Croghan, Co Offaly starting at 9am. The wife of Charlie Bird, Claire Bird, is supporting the cause. Charlie, the former chief news correspondent with RTÉ, was diagnosed with motor neurone disease in 2021 and passed away in March last year. He raised €3.6m in aid of the Irish Motor Neurone Disease Association and Pieta before his death. Claire said that there is now more awareness around MND and progress has been made in improving the quality of life for ALS sufferers and their families, but 'more is needed'. 'In particular, funds are urgently needed to discover the cause and potential treatments for this cruel disease and that's what we are asking for today. Advertisement 'Every donation and every act of support will make a difference in the fight against ALS and MND so please, wear your jersey for your teammate on 27 July and donate whatever you can afford to support the research that will bring hope to future generations.' One of the organisers of the walk, former Galway GAA player Michael Meehan, said, 'All Ireland Final day is a special day in Irish sport and on this special day, we call on you to join us in a heartfelt show of solidarity to support all our 'teammates' who are facing ALS.' He invited everyone to wear their jerseys and join the walk on the morning of the All-Ireland. 'Anyone who can't join the walk can still support the cause by donating to iDonate and all funds will go towards Research Motor Neurone,' Michael added. The walk is to raise funds for Research Motor Neurone, an Irish charitable organisation, led by Orla Hardiman, Professor of Neurology at Trinity College Dublin, and an international authority on Motor Neurone Disease and related neurodegeneration. MND is a progressive neurological condition in which the nerves that control voluntary muscles stop working. In Ireland, around 155 people are newly diagnosed with the condition every year; there are currently more than 470 people living with MND and ALS in Ireland. It is a challenging and debilitating disease for which there is currently no cure. Galway GAA, Mountbellew-Moylough GAA, Cu Chulainns GAA (London), Leinster Rugby, [Connacht Rugby], Ireland U20 Rugby, Garbally College are among those supporting the walk. Readers like you are keeping these stories free for everyone... A mix of advertising and supporting contributions helps keep paywalls away from valuable information like this article. Over 5,000 readers like you have already stepped up and support us with a monthly payment or a once-off donation. Learn More Support The Journal
Sunday World
6 hours ago
- Sunday World
Boy settles for €3.3m after suffering ‘catastrophic' injury from fall in Dublin park
James Higgins (12), from East Wall, Dublin 3 hit his head at a Dublin City Council-owned park almost 10 years ago A boy who suffered 'catastrophic and life-changing' injuries after he fell and hit his head at a Dublin City Council-owned park almost 10 years ago has settled a High Court action against the local authority and a GP with an interim payment of €3.3 million. Arising from the incident, James Higgins (12), from East Wall, Dublin 3, requires around-the-clock care, is essentially non-verbal, suffers with epilepsy and will be a wheelchair user for life, the court heard on Friday. The interim settlement agreement was reached following mediation, and the case will return to court in six years. The court heard there were complex questions relating to causation and liability in the case. The case had been contested. Kevin Higgins brought proceedings on behalf of his son James against Dublin City Council and Dr John Taylor, claiming they acted negligently and in breach of their duties. Maypark in north Dublin. Photo: Google News in 90 Seconds - July 25th James's counsel Jeremy Maher SC, appearing with Conor Power SC and barrister Conor Roberts and instructed by Gibson solicitors, said James, when he was 2½ years old, suffered 'catastrophic and life-changing' arising from a fall at May Park, Malahide Road, Dublin 5, on December 1st, 2015. Outlining James's case, Mr Maher said the boy, while retrieving a football, fell on an all-weather soccer pitch where slush had accumulated, and hit the left side of his head. Mr Maher said it was their case the pitch was in dangerous condition and should not have been in use, and that Dublin City Council was in breach of its duty and negligent in its management of the park. James was subsequently brought to Dr Taylor's surgery at Ardlea Road, Artane, Dublin 5, Mr Maher said, where it is alleged the GP was negligent and breached his duty in failing to immediately refer the child to hospital. James was later that evening brought to Children's Health Ireland Temple Street. There, it was determined he'd suffered a bleed within his skull, and underwent emergency surgery, Mr Maher said. Mr Maher said this surgery was life-saving, but the damage had advanced to such an extent that James was left with devastating injuries. Counsel said James requires around-the-clock care, is essentially non-verbal, suffers with epilepsy and will never be able to work or live independently. He said James's 'heroic' parents had given up their careers to care for James. He added said that following mediation, the defendants had agreed the interim settlement of €3.3 million on a joint and several basis. Mr Justice Paul Coffey approved the settlement, stating that James's case is a reminder of the fragility of life, and the limitless nature of parental love. He said it was 'deeply humbling' to listen to Mr Higgins address the court about James's condition and their experience of his care.
Irish Times
7 hours ago
- Irish Times
Boy who suffered catastrophic injuries after fall at park settles case with €3.3m interim payment
A boy who suffered 'catastrophic and life-changing' injuries after he fell and hit his head at a Dublin City Council-owned park almost 10 years ago has settled a High Court action against the local authority and a GP with an interim payment of €3.3 million. James Higgins, who is now 12, from East Wall, Dublin 3, requires around-the-clock care, is essentially non-verbal, suffers with epilepsy and will be a wheelchair user for life, the court heard on Friday. The interim settlement agreement was reached following mediation. The case will return to court in six years. The court heard there were complex questions relating to causation and liability in the case. The case had been contested. READ MORE Kevin Higgins brought proceedings on behalf of his son James against Dublin City Council and Dr John Taylor, claiming they acted negligently and in breach of their duties. Jeremy Maher SC, for James, said the boy, when he was two-and-a-half years old, suffered 'catastrophic and life-changing' arising from a fall at May Park, Malahide Road, Dublin 5, on December 1st, 2015. Mr Maher said the boy, while retrieving a football, fell on an all-weather soccer pitch where slush had accumulated and hit the left side of his head. Mr Maher said it was their case the pitch was in dangerous condition and should not have been in use and that the council was in breach of its duty and negligent in its management of the park. James was subsequently brought to Dr Taylor's surgery at Ardlea Road, Artane, Dublin 5, Mr Maher said, where it is alleged the GP was negligent and breached his duty in failing to immediately refer the child to hospital. James was later that evening brought to Children's Health Ireland Temple Street. There it was determined he had suffered a bleed within his skull and he underwent emergency surgery, Mr Maher said. Mr Maher said this surgery was life-saving, but the damage had advanced to such an extent that James was left with devastating injuries. The barrister said James required around-the-clock care, was essentially non-verbal, suffered with epilepsy and would never be able to work or live independently. Mr Maher said James's 'heroic' parents had given up their careers to care for James. Mr Maher said that following mediation, the defendants had agreed the interim settlement of €3.3 million. Mr Justice Paul Coffey approved the settlement, stating that James's case was a reminder of the fragility of life and the limitless nature of parental love. He said it had been 'deeply humbling' to listen to Mr Higgins address the court about James's condition and their experience of his care.
