Put tax changes on hold, engage stakeholders to ensure clarity, urges former Sabah CM
Datuk Seri Yong Teck Lee, who leads the Sabah Progressive Party, said recent policy shifts have confused both consumers and businesses.
'This is not just about paperwork. Harsh and unclear enforcement risks destroying small businesses and livelihoods,' he said in a statement Tuesday (June 17).
Yong was referring to the recent government announcements involving the revised sales and service tax (SST) structure — which expanded SST coverage from 6% to 8% for certain services starting March 1 — as well as upcoming e-invoicing requirements, fuel subsidy rationalisation plans, and stamp duty adjustments.
He said tax enforcement was pressing ahead despite unclear guidelines and fragile economic conditions.
He outlined three key principles that should guide any tax system — clarity in rules, affordability of rates, and predictability in enforcement.
'People must be able to understand their obligations without confusion. Rates must be reasonable, especially when so many are already struggling. And enforcement must not punish those trying to comply,' he said.
He added that the ongoing changes fail to meet these principles, undermining trust, deterring investment, and worsening hardship for families and small enterprises.
Yong also called on the Inland Revenue Board (LHDN) to hold off on enforcing the new tax rules until proper procedures are in place and businesses are financially ready to comply.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Star
39 minutes ago
- The Star
‘Swift action key to price stability'
Subject to tax: Fruits for sale at shops in Petaling Jaya. — AZHAR MAHFOF/The Star PUTRAJAYA: Among ways to prevent unnecessary price hikes is to strengthen existing mechanisms for price monitoring and enforcement, says a consumer rights activist. Federation of Malaysian Consumers Associations (Fomca) secretary-general Saravanan Thambirajah said this is one of the most immediate actions the government could take. 'When prices of essential items are being hiked up arbitrarily or without justification, there must be swift investigation and enforcement by the authorities. 'The Domestic Trade and Cost of Living Ministry's call for consumer associations to serve as its eyes and ears is a good initiative, but it will only be effective if reports from the ground lead to real action,' he said. Saravanan added that the government must focus on transparency to prevent the public from becoming victims of inflated prices or being wrongly taxed. 'When consumers know the market price of goods, they are in a better position to make informed choices. 'Fomca has begun receiving feedback from consumers regarding price hikes associated with the recent increase in the SST (sales and service tax) from 6% to 8%. 'Consumers are still confused about which products and services are affected. 'This confusion creates a fertile ground for abuse. Some traders may raise prices unjustifiably, citing the tax increase as the reason, even for items that are not actually taxed,' he added. Saravanan said Fomca's role was not only to inform and educate consumers on their rights but also to relay their concerns to the relevant enforcement bodies. 'For the mechanism to work well, consistent and visible enforcement is needed to ensure traders do not misuse the sales tax revision as a pretext for profiteering,' said Saravanan. Similarly, Malaysian Consumer Friendly Organisation vice-president Azlin Othman said the government should monitor logistics costs as well as establish a more balanced tax policy and make regular inspections at business premises. 'Quick and consistent action is important to protect consumers and maintain price stability,' said Azlin. Consumers' Association of Penang president Mohideen Abdul Kadeer said stronger enforcement was needed instead of waiting at the last moment for consumers to lodge complaints of getting cheated. 'The government should set up help desks or mobile units to proactively receive feedback. 'Traders who cheat consumers must be brought to court and face the maximum penalty,' added Mohideen.
The Star
39 minutes ago
- The Star
‘Don't let traders play the expanded SST card'
PETALING JAYA: The expanded Sales and Service tax (SST) may have a limited short-term effect on inflation, and to prevent dishonest traders from profiteering, economists say Malaysians play a crucial role in curbing unnecessary price hikes. They advise consumers to be vigilant when shopping and avoid buying products from dishonest traders. Economist Geoffrey Williams said consumers must be tough on companies that exploit the implementation of the expanded SST and raise prices unnecessarily. He said they can report such companies for profiteering to the authorities or even name the company on social media. 'Naming and shaming profiteers online is very effective, as well as boycotting the worst offenders. 'But, this requires group action where NGOs and consumer groups can play a role,' said Williams. He also said companies could play a role by being transparent with prices and having comparisons with their competitors. 'Those that treat customers well will keep and gain customers and those with bad attitudes will lose business,' said Williams. He added that consumers should be aware of which products are affected under the expanded SST when they go shopping. 'If they see prices rising on products that had the same tax rate, they can report it to the authorities for profiteering. 'The effect on inflation will be limited and temporary because this is a one-off effect on only a small sample of goods and services. Most of the consumer price index constituents are unaffected,' added Williams. He was commenting on the SST expansion which began on July 1 which saw zero rate taxes remaining for essential goods, while a rate of 5% to 10% was imposed on non-essential items. An 8% service tax will be imposed on rental or leasing services, with no tax imposed on residential housing, reading material, monetary leasing and tangible assets outside Malaysia. A 6% service tax will be levied on construction work services related to infrastructure, commercial and industrial buildings. Socio-Economic Research Centre executive director Lee Heng Guie said consumer activism played a crucial role in addressing unnecessary price hikes and Malaysians themselves should be vigilant and report any unjustified price hikes to the authorities. 'To manage price pressures, the government can improve price monitoring, providing clear communication to the public, and strict enforcement of tax compliance to prevent price gouging,' said Lee. He also said the government could implement awareness campaigns and maintain clear guidelines as well as strict enforcement of tax compliance to prevent excessive profiteering. The inflationary effects from the implementation of the expanded SST, he said, was not expected to have a lasting impact on the country. 'While price adjustments are anticipated, particularly on non-essential items and services estimated between 0.5 and 1 percentage points in the short-term, this will likely taper off over time,' added Lee. He said low- and middle-income earners were likely to be affected by the expanded SST implementation despite exemptions on essential items and cash handouts such as Sumbangan Tunai Rahmah by the government. 'The increase in SST on a broader range of goods and services can lead to price hikes across the supply chain, ultimately impacting consumers, especially those in the lower and middle income brackets. 'While direct consumer impact is limited, some businesses, particularly those relying on rented premises in sectors like logistics, manufacturing, and retail, may experience increased costs due to the service tax on leasing and rental services. 'This could potentially be passed on to consumers,' added Lee. Carmelo Ferlito, economist and chief executive at the Centre for Market Education think tank, argued that the prices of some goods may increase, but stressed that the government should not intervene. 'There are already too many price distortions in the Malaysian economic system,' he said. Inflation was a generalised and persistent increase in the level of price due to the quantity of money increasing, outpacing the growth of the economy's output of goods and services, he said. 'Taxes do not create inflation, government spending does. 'There will instead be inflation if the government expands the money supply to counter the effects of SST,' added Ferlito.
The Star
an hour ago
- The Star
Profiteering complaint to clampdown in 24 hours
PUTRAJAYA: The Domestic Trade and Cost of Living Ministry will take action against traders for increasing prices exorbitantly 24 hours upon receiving complaints from the public. Advising the public to report such traders, Minister Datuk Armizan Mohd Ali (pic) said the complaints must have full information on the items and the prices. 'I welcome complaints from the public because this requires public participation. 'A detailed complaint will make it easier for us to investigate,' he said in a press conference after an appreciation event for the ministry's strategic enforcement partners in Putrajaya yesterday. Armizan also advised businesses to consult the ministry's Enforcement Department before they raise prices. 'We have a calculator to guide businesses on whether or not their hike amounted to profiteering. 'We also advise businesses to discuss with the Customs Department and the Finance Ministry,' he added. Armizan also said two companies have agreed to postpone their planned price reviews on the ministry's advise. 'The two companies informed on July 1 that they had postponed their price adjustments to a later date,' he said. During the July 1 meeting, he said the two companies did not mention that the implementation of the expanded Sales and Service tax (SST) was among the reasons they had to review their prices. 'They said the increases were due to operational costs and logistics, as well as the implementation of the minimum wage order because they have a huge workforce. 'However, when they announce the price hike, my ministry has the prerogative under the Price Control and Anti-Profiteering Act 2011 (Act 723) to ensure that price reviews are fair. 'If there are profiteering elements, we will issue a written notice for them to answer to,' he added. Armizan said from 2021 to May 31 this year, his ministry recorded over 2,800 cases handed over by enforcement agencies. Giving a breakdown of the cases, he said in 2021, a total of 250 cases were recorded followed by 2022 (615), 2023 (790), 2024 (822) and 335 cases from Jan 1 to May 31 this year. 'All these cases involve various issues, including the smuggling or embezzlement of subsidised products, with a combined value of RM199. 96mil,' said Armizan. Most cases, he added, were handed over to his ministry by the General Operations Force (PGA) with 1,146 cases, followed by the marine police (866), police (661) and the armed forces (69). 'The consistent increase shows that inter-agency cooperation has not just contributed to the success of the enforcement operation, but also increased the effectiveness of protecting consumer rights,' added Armizan. Last month, the Finance Ministry said the expanded SST would begin July 1 when a sales tax of 5% to 10% would be imposed on certain non-essential goods. Putrajaya had announced that imported apples, oranges, mandarin oranges and dates will be exempted from the SST. Also exempted are beauty services such as manicure, pedicure, facial and hairdressing. The Finance Ministry also said the registration threshold for businesses in leasing, rental and financial services have been raised from RM500,000 to RM1mil, which will limit the number of small businesses affected.
