New Zealand is undoing Jacinda Ardern's disastrous energy legacy
The earlier ban, enacted in 2018, was a major part of Ardern's idealistic plan to shepherd the country of five million into a bright and limitless 'clean, green and sustainable' carbon-free future built on renewables rather than fossil fuel. It also threatened to shut out the nation's lights.
At the very least, critics warned at the time, it would likely lead to a future of economic instability – all the more so because any replacement solar, wind and battery storage might not come on track fast enough to make up for dwindling gas fields. Ardern found herself accused of virtue-signalling on a particularly grand scale.
That criticism appeared to have been borne out in New Zealand after companies such as the energy supplier Genesis Energy were subsequently forced to import coal – which has higher emissions – and the spectre loomed larger of hitherto unimaginable blackouts in the near term.
In May, the national grid operator Transpower said that, as a consequence of the policy, the country's gas fields were dropping much faster than expected, New Zealand was now at risk of experiencing electricity outages as early as 2026. In the meantime, electricity prices have surged by more than 10 per cent.
Among the most vocal critics of Ardern's ban was not a member of the conservative opposition National party, but a maverick member of her own cabinet, Shane Jones.
Jones, a roly-poly figure with a reputation for breaking ranks with his Labour party on 'woke' issues, subsequently left for a new role as deputy leader of the populist New Zealand First, which has since become a junior coalition party in Luxon's conservative government elected to office in 2023. He now serves as the country's resources minister.
The new legislation he helped author was meant to be one of the new government's first items of legislative business, but parliamentary glitches saw it shelved until yesterday's vote.
What Jones describes as Ardern's 'unwieldly' environmental vision for the South Sea has drawn obvious comparisons with Sir Keir Starmer's one for the North Sea – but the two situations have their differences. Unlike New Zealand, the UK is connected to an international grid and has access to nuclear power. The Kiwis have none of those advantages.
Nevertheless, the binning of Ardern's flagship policy was opposed by all three of New Zealand's opposition parties, in particular Sir Keir's Labour counterparts who first ushered in the 2018 ban.
Labour's energy and resources spokeswoman, Megan Woods, said upending the ban was a 'very potent symbol' of a dysfunctional government 'out of touch with ordinary New Zealanders and more intent at doing the bidding of multinational oil and gas companies.'
Yet even supporters of the turnaround acknowledge that those companies may be slow to return to a local market whose policies could yet switch again should Labour regain office at next year's general election.
In a statement on Thursday, Jones reiterated that the earlier policy had always been 'ill-fated' and had 'exacerbated shortages in our domestic gas supply by obliterating new investment in the exploration and development needed to meet our future gas needs.'
New Zealand's volte-face comes amid growing criticism of Keir Starmer's North Sea shutdown, with US President Donald Trump saying this week that Britain was wasting a 'treasure chest' of oil and gas
In an earlier interview with this writer in his parliamentary office, Jones said he welcomed the American administration's international influence in putting paid to 'shallow juvenile thinking' around environmental adventurism.
'I'm hoping that Trump's influence will permeate,' he said.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Independent
38 minutes ago
- The Independent
Labour does not deserve to win next election if it does not deliver change, says Reeves
Labour does not deserve to win the next election if it does not succeed in changing the country, Rachel Reeves has said, acknowledging that some voters were disappointed with the party's time in office. Speaking at the Edinburgh Fringe festival, the chancellor said she is 'impatient for change' but said ministers 'can't do everything straight away, all at once.' It comes amid growing concern over the direction of Sir Keir Starmer 's government from voters on both the left and the right, with the prime minister's approval rating hitting an all time low last month. Speaking to Iain Dale, Ms Reeves said: 'The reason people voted Labour at the last election is they want to change and they were unhappy with the way that the country was being governed. 'They know that we inherited a mess. They know it's not easy to put it right, but people are impatient for change. 'I'm impatient for change as well, but I've also got the job of making sure the sums always add up – and it doesn't always make you popular because you can't do anything you might want to do.' 'You certainly can't do everything straight away, all at once', she said, adding that Labour did not 'deserve' to win the next election if it fails to deliver the change it promised. The chancellor also claimed the government has got the balance 'about right' when it comes to taxation, amid mounting questions over how the government will raise the money to fill the black hole in the public finances left by a series of major U-turns and spending commitments. 'Of course you're going to disappoint people. No one wants to pay more taxes ', she said. 'Everyone wants more money than public spending – and borrowing is not a free option, because you've got to pay for it. 'I think people know those sort of constraints but no one really likes them and I'm the one that has to sort the sums up.' It comes just days after former Labour shadow chancellor Anneliese Dodds urged the government to consider a wealth tax at the next Budget in order to plug holes in the public finances. Ms Dodds - who quit Sir Keir Starmer 's government in February over the PM's decision to cut the foreign aid budget to fund a boost in defence spending – warned that spending cuts will not 'deliver the kind of fiscal room that is necessary'. Last month, Sir Keir's support among the public reached new depths of minus 43 after a U-turn on cuts to welfare worth £5 billion, polling showed. The survey, first reported by The Sunday Times, also found that just a year after coming to power, seven in 10 voters think Sir Keir's government is at least as chaotic as the Tories' previous term. That includes one in three voters, who believe it is more so.
Reuters
an hour ago
- Reuters
UK threatens jail for people smugglers who advertise on social media
LONDON, Aug 3 (Reuters) - People smugglers who use social media to promote their services to migrants seeking to enter Britain illegally could face five years in prison under plans announced by the government. Prime Minister Keir Starmer's Labour government is under huge political and public pressure to cut the number of migrants arriving illegally in small boats from France. More than 25,000 people have made the crossing so far this year. Analysis by the Interior Ministry showed around 80% of migrants arriving on small boats had used social media during their journey to find or communicate with people smugglers. Under a new offence, which will be added to legislation already passing through parliament, individuals who post online to advertise services that facilitate a breach of immigration laws will face fines and prison sentences of up to five years. It is already an offence to facilitate illegal immigration to Britain, but the government said its latest plan would give law enforcement agencies another option to disrupt the criminal gangs that profit from organising the crossings. Last month, the government launched a new sanctions regime allowing it to freeze assets, impose travel bans and block access to the country's financial system for individuals and entities involved in enabling irregular migration.
Spectator
4 hours ago
- Spectator
Reeves couldn't be more proud of crippling the economy
Rachel Reeves strode onto the stage at the Edinburgh festival in a black jumpsuit and an orange scarf. Iain Dale, in a dark maroon jacket, kicked with a dare. 'Try, if you can, not to use the phrase '13 wasted Tory years' or '22 billion pound black hole.'' 'What else am I going to talk about?' said Reeves. She's a much warmer and funnier soul than her TV image suggests. Dale asked about the awkward moment when she wept during PMQs in June. 'I was having a bit of a day, a difficult day at work,' she said vaguely. 'There was stuff going on. But it's different for me. The cameras are on me. But most people have days at work when they cry.' Dale asked if her troubles had been exacerbated by the Tory leader, Kemi Badenoch, who mentioned in the chamber that she 'was looking miserable.' 'Well, it was a fact, wasn't it,' said Reeves. So why not just skip PMQs? asked Dale. 'I thought I was OK,' she said. 'Obviously, I wasn't. But I thought I was.' Dale asked about her childhood and her early involvement in politics. Her parents were primary school teachers who voted Labour but weren't party members. Aged 17, appalled by the ruinous state of her school, she decided to join the Bromley Labour party. 'The playground was freezing in winter and the library had been converted into a classroom. There just weren't enough textbooks to go round.' She was inspired by Blair's slogan, 'education, education, education' and she campaigned in the 1997 election alongside her younger sister, Ellie, now an MP and chair of the Labour party. At university, she was known as a political wonk and her friends bought her a framed portrait of Gordon Brown for her 19th birthday. The chancellorship, she said, was always in her sights. 'The office has existed for 800 years and it's about time we had a female chancellor. But it shouldn't have taken 800 years.' After Labour's victory last July, she invited Brown to the Treasury which he hadn't visited since 2007. She asked him how old he was when he became chancellor. He told her he couldn't remember. 'I'm only 46,' she said. This jogged his memory. 'Well, I was 45.' Dale asked if Brown likes to call her and offer political advice. 'He doesn't phone,' she said. 'He sends me emails with quite a lot of capital letters.' And does he point out her mistakes? 'No. But he does have a lot of ideas,' she said diplomatically. Brown isn't the only former chancellor who wants access to his successor. She's on friendly terms with Rishi Sunak's chancellor, Jeremy Hunt. 'Jeremy's been in Number 11 a couple of times, had a cup of tea with me, and given good advice.' Dale asked if she expected to meet Donald Trump on his forthcoming state visit and she didn't seem to care either way. 'I suppose so,' she said, airily. 'I met Macron a few weeks ago.' Did she have a message for Trump? She ducked the question and praised her own government. 'We've got our trade deal with the US. One of the best trade deals in the world. At the G7, all the finance ministers want to find out how we got our trade deal.' Dale invited her to say a word in favour of Brexit which enabled the UK to dodge the tariffs levied by America on the EU. She refused to do so. Instead she talked about the levels of global investment arriving in Britain. She mentioned a figure of '£125 billion' but much of this involves carbon capture and renewables produced by GB Energy. The funds are being underwritten by state subsidies. 'We're investing public money to leverage in that private money,' she said. In other words, foreign investors are being bribed to set up shop in the UK. But she likes anything that involves net zero. She regards the Labour party as the saviour of this self-harming energy policy. 'The Tories legislated for [net zero] but are rowing back on it. And Reform are coming out with all sorts of conspiracy theories.' Asked if she regretted any part of her 2024 budget, she gave herself a glowing review. She even praised the wildly unpopular National Insurance rise because it allowed her to sink an extra £25 billion in the NHS. The UK economy is in great shape, she seems to believe. And she twice quoted this odd-looking statistic. 'In the first quarter of this year, the UK had the fastest growing economy in the G7.' Dale asked about Your Party (or 'Jezbollah' as he called it) created by Jeremy Corbyn and Zara Sultana. Reeves laid the blame on Corbyn's hunger for power despite failing to become prime minister in 2017 and 2019. 'He gave us Labour's worst result since 1935. He's been rejected twice. But he's got a big ego.' Reeves is surprisingly cool about introducing new wealth taxes. She said the government already takes a big chunk with inheritance tax and capital gains tax. 'I'm not keen to do what Switzerland does with a wealth tax. And we may lose money.' But her abiding instinct is to expand the state and to pay for it by increasing taxes. A hard-left questioner from the floor asked her to 'stop scoring own goals' and tax people more. 'But we have increased taxes,' she cried in outrage. 'Last year's was the biggest tax-raising budget ever.' That's how she thinks. She's crippling the economy and she couldn't be more proud.
