Ohio workers waiting on long-delayed pandemic unemployment benefits will have to keep waiting
Franklin County Common Pleas Judge Michael Holbrook has decided to delay his order directing the state to chase down unemployment benefits from the COVID-19 pandemic. His decision to stay his ruling allows the state to continue its appeal without having to get the ball rolling on securing the outstanding funding.
According to Ohio workers who brought the lawsuit, there could be as much as $900 million in stranded benefits.
SUBSCRIBE: GET THE MORNING HEADLINES DELIVERED TO YOUR INBOX
The case centers on a round of supplementary benefits from early in the Biden administration. DeWine, like more than a dozen other Republican governors, turned that funding down arguing it would make people less likely to return to work.
But a state appeals court determined Ohio's unemployment statutes require the governor to secure all 'available advantages' and turning down the extra funding violated that charge. Earlier this month, Holbrook ordered DeWine 'take all action necessary' to secure the outstanding unemployment funds. The governor is appealing that decision.
In his order, Judge Holbrook acknowledged, 'while this court believes that the entry of a partial stay is in the best interest of all the parties, it is compelled to act within the bounds of the law.'
Attorneys for the workers had argued even if the judge agreed to stay parts of his ruling, the state should at least begin contacting federal officials about transferring money.
Ohio workers want court to order Gov. DeWine to protect unused unemployment funds
Holbrook's order cited procedural rules and Ohio Supreme Court precedent that effectively gives the state the benefit of the doubt when it comes to appeals. Under Civil Rule 62, government officials or agencies are entitled to a stay while their appeal plays out — in one case Holbrook referenced, 'as a matter of right.'
DeWine contends the appropriate course of action is to stay Holbrook's order because holding off would maintain the status quo. Attorney General Dave Yost, who represents the governor's office in court, argued court rules and Ohio supreme court precedent require a stay.
'The Supreme Court of Ohio has repeatedly interpreted Rule 62 to grant an automatic stay in favor of a state agency or state official,' Yost argued in court filings. 'And it has held that trial courts who refuse to do so err, regardless of the circumstances.'
Yost added that taking a wait-and-see approach to the appeals process is the best way to avoid confusion. It's been three years, Yost explained, since the program in question was shuttered. If the state follows the lower court judge's ruling immediately, but later wins the appeal of that decision, Ohio 'would need to un-enroll from the program yet again.'
Arguing before Judge Holbrook, Assistant Attorney General Ann Yackshaw argued that program enrollment data is now three years out of date, and that restarting the program will cost money. Although the Department of Labor covered administrative costs when the program initially ran, she argued federal officials have sent mixed signals about whether they will continue to do so.
'Denying the stay here would mean that the private taxpayers will be spending potentially millions of dollars to get the pandemic system back up and running and get it updated,' she said.
If it turns out the federal government refuses to cover costs or the state's appeal eventually succeeds, that money would be wasted.
'Once we go down that path, spend this money, we can't un-ring that bell,' she said.
Former Attorney General Marc Dann is representing the Ohioans who lost out on those supplemental benefits. In his brief opposing the state, Dann argued they're relying on a judicial rule when state and federal law should supersede it.
Federal law prioritizes getting unemployment benefits into the hands of workers who need them, and it requires the state to have coordinating language in its statutes as well. The point being that agencies can claw back funding later, but an unemployed worker needs help covering rent and groceries immediately.
'Thus, while the State can appeal this Court's judgment,' Dann's brief argued, 'it cannot use the appeal as a basis to further delay payment of (unemployment) benefits.'
He pointed to a 1970s case out of California in which the state's benefits agency delayed payment while an employer appealed an applicant's eligibility. The U.S. Supreme Court rejected California law as 'invalid and unenforceable' because it conflicted with the federal statute, Dann said.
Like the state, Dann argued, the point of a stay is to maintain the status quo, but with a new presidential administration in place and a budget process under way, 'the country's fiscal affairs are, to say the least, in flux.' The funding necessary to provide the missing benefits is vulnerable to clawback, and he insisted the best way to maintain their availability is to have them in hand.
'A stay should only be for the purpose of maintaining the status quo while the appeal proceeds,' he insisted. 'The only way to safely maintain the status quo would be to order the governor to ask for the money.'
Dann argued that even if Holbrook agreed that a stay was warranted for other parts of his order, like disbursing the lost unemployment funds, he should maintain the portion directing the state to start the process. But even if Holbrook nodded to the wisdom of a partial stay, he declined to take that step, and instead put his order on hold for the time being.
In an emailed statement, Dann wrote 'we are of course going to appeal this decision.'
He went on to note that they are separately trying to get the appeals court to force the governor's hand, and officially request the money from the U.S. Department of Labor.
'Why the governor continues to refuse to ask for and at least hold on to the $900 million in benefits to 330,000 Ohioans is still a mystery,' he said adding, 'we hope the governor will reconsider his decision and ask for the money so that its not reappropriated and lost forever, forcing us to perhaps have to sue the state for the money.'
Follow Ohio Capital Journal Reporter Nick Evans on X or on Bluesky.
SUPPORT: YOU MAKE OUR WORK POSSIBLE
Hashtags

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Yahoo
24 minutes ago
- Yahoo
RNC Chair Whatley to run for North Carolina Senate seat with Trump's support
Republican National Committee (RNC) Chair Michael Whatley is planning to run for Senate in North Carolina to succeed retiring Sen. Thom Tillis (R), a source familiar confirmed to The Hill. The source said Whatley will run with President Trump's blessing for the seat, confirming Politico, which first reported the news. The development comes after former RNC co-Chair Lara Trump, the president's daughter-in-law, was openly considering a bid for the seat. Politico reported she has decided against a run. Whatley's candidacy tees up one of the marquee Senate races of the midterms, as former Gov. Roy Cooper (D) reportedly plans to jump in next week. Cook Political Report currently rates the seat as a 'toss-up.' Two people familiar with the decision told Politico that President Trump believes Whatley is in a strong position to face Cooper, a popular former two-term governor seen as Democrats' best chance of winning the seat. They said Lara Trump will declare her support for Whatley and will appear with him soon, with a public announcement coming in the next week to 10 days. While Whatley has never run for elected office before, he does have background in North Carolina politics. He is a former chief of staff for former Sen. Elizabeth Dole (R-N.C.) and served as chair of the North Carolina GOP for almost five years before being tapped by President Trump to become RNC chair. A GOP operative told The Hill that Sen. Tim Scott (R-S.C.), the chair of Senate Republicans' campaign arm, met with Whatley about a potential Senate bid, and the organization has been floating him as a possible replacement for Tillis since January. They said internal and public polling indicate a pro-Trump Republican would be in the strongest position for the party to hold the seat. The decision from Tillis, a two-term incumbent viewed as somewhat more moderate and less closely tied to the president, to retire at the end of his term scrambled the field for the seat, which already was shaping up to be one of the most watched races of 2026. His seat and the one held by Sen. Susan Collins (R) in Maine are seen as the two best chances for Democrats to pick up seats next year. But on the Republican side, Lara Trump appeared to have the 'right of first refusal,' as one strategist put it, as she considered whether to run for the seat. She had previously considered a Senate run in 2022, as well as contending to be picked to fill Secretary of State Marco Rubio's Florida Senate seat last year, but she ultimately decided against both, not closing the door to a run entirely. Lara Trump announced she would not seek the North Carolina seat in a post on the social platform X later Thursday, saying she made the decision after 'much consideration and heartfelt discussions' with her family, friends and supporters. 'I am deeply grateful for the encouragement and support I have received from the people of my home state whom I love so much,' she said. 'While I am not running in this election, my passion for Making America Great Again burns brightly, and I look forward to the future, wherever that leads.' But with her passing on a Senate bid again, Whatley would be the big name in the race for the GOP, coming off of the party's success in the 2024 presidential election. A few other possible candidates have been rumored to be considering bids, but receiving the president's backing would certainly be a major boost for Whatley, if any other candidates compete. Whatley winning the nomination would confirm what Tillis's retirement made all but certain: Next year's GOP candidate will be more closely tied to Trump than Tillis is. It would likely set up a match between Whatley and Cooper in the general election. Axios reported Cooper is set to launch his Senate campaign next week, giving Democrats in the state and nationwide their desired candidate. Democrats have seen much more success in recent years in gubernatorial races in North Carolina than federal races, having not won a Senate seat there since 2008. But the party is hopeful it can finally get over the hurdle with Cooper. Senate Democrats' campaign arm touted Lara Trump's decision against running, saying the GOP is 'facing the latest in a string of embarrassing recruitment failures as they lose their 'first choice' candidate.' 'While Republicans descend further into chaos in North Carolina, Democrats will flip this seat in 2026,' spokesperson Maeve Coyle said. Brett Samuels contributed. Updated at 12:03 p.m. EDT Copyright 2025 Nexstar Media, Inc. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed.
Yahoo
an hour ago
- Yahoo
Disgraced former US Rep. George Santos to begin serving his 7-year fraud sentence
NEW YORK (AP) — Disgraced former U.S. Rep. George Santos is expected to begin serving a seven-year prison sentence on Friday for the fraud charges that got him ousted from Congress. The New York Republican pleaded guilty last summer to federal wire fraud and aggravated identity theft charges for deceiving donors and stealing people's identities in order to fund his congressional campaign. He must report to federal prison before 2 p.m. It's unclear where he'll serve his time, though a federal judge has recommended that Santos be housed in a facility in the Northeast. Santos and his lawyers declined to comment to The Associated Press ahead of him reporting to prison. The federal Bureau of Prisons, meanwhile, said it doesn't discuss the status of inmates until they're officially in custody. As Friday approached, though, the loquacious former lawmaker, who turned 37 on Tuesday, wasn't shy about sharing his morbid fears about life behind bars. 'I'm not trying to be overdramatic here. I'm just being honest with you. I look at this as practically a death sentence,' Santos told Tucker Carlson during an interview. 'I'm not built for this.' In a Thursday interview with Al Arabiya, a Saudi state-owned news organization, he said he'll serve his sentence in a minimum-security prison 'camp' that he described as a 'big upgrade' from the medium-security lockup he was initially assigned to. On X this week, Santos posted a video clip of Frank Sinatra's 'My Way.' 'And now, the end is near. And so I face the final curtain," the singer aptly croons. Other posts took a darker tone. 'I'm heading to prison, folks and I need you to hear this loud and clear: I'm not suicidal. I'm not depressed. I have no intentions of harming myself, and I will not willingly engage in any sexual activity while I'm in there,' he said on X. "If anything comes out suggesting otherwise, consider it a lie … full stop.' In April, a federal judge declined to give Santos a lighter two-year sentence that he sought, saying she was unconvinced he was truly remorseful. In the weeks before his sentencing, Santos said he was 'profoundly sorry' for his crimes, but he also complained frequently that he was a victim of a political witch hunt and prosecutorial overreach. Santos was elected in 2022, flipping a wealthy district representing parts of Queens and Long Island for the GOP. But he served for less than a year and became just the sixth member of the House to be ousted by colleagues after it was revealed he had fabricated much of his life story. During his winning campaign, Santos painted himself as a successful business owner who worked at prestigious Wall Street firms when, in reality, he was struggling financially. He also falsely claimed to have been a volleyball star at a college he never attended and referred to himself as 'a proud American Jew' before insisting he meant that he was 'Jew-ish' because his Brazilian mother's family had a Jewish background. The cascade of lies eventually led to congressional and criminal inquiries into how Santos funded his campaign and, ultimately, his political downfall. Since his ouster from Congress, Santos has been making a living hosting a podcast called 'Pants on Fire with George Santos' and hawking personalized video messages on Cameo. He has also been holding out hope that his unwavering support for President Donald Trump might help him win a last-minute reprieve, though the White House said this week that it "will not comment on the existence or nonexistence" of any clemency request. ___ Follow Philip Marcelo at


New York Post
an hour ago
- New York Post
George Santos bids dramatic farewell to supporters, critics before he begins 87-month prison sentence: ‘The curtain falls'
Former Rep. George Santos posted a theatrical farewell on social media Thursday night, just hours before he was to begin serving a federal prison sentence for fraud and identity theft. 'Well, darlings… The curtain falls, the spotlight dims, and the rhinestones are packed,' Santos wrote on X. 'From the halls of Congress to the chaos of cable news what a ride it's been! Was it messy? Always. Glamorous? Occasionally. Honest? I tried… most days. To my supporters: You made this wild political cabaret worth it. To my critics: Thanks for the free press.' The former New York congressman is expected to report to federal custody Friday to begin serving an 87-month sentence, just over seven years, after pleading guilty in 2024 to wire fraud and aggravated identity theft. Santos was assessed the maximum sentence in April by US District Judge Joanna Seybert. He was also ordered to pay nearly $374,000 in restitution and forfeit more than $205,000 in fraud proceeds. His guilty plea followed a sweeping investigation into campaign finance fraud, donor identity theft and false COVID-era unemployment claims. 5 Former Rep. George Santos leaves Federal Court after his sentencing in Islip, NY on April 25, 2025. PETER FOLEY/EPA-EFE/Shutterstock 5 Santos blows a kiss to the cameras as he leaves a federal courthouse in Islip, NY on Oct. 27, 2023. REUTERS 'This prosecution speaks to the truth that my office is committed to aggressively rooting out public corruption,' said US Attorney John J. Durham, who called the sentence 'judgment day' for Santos and justice for his victims. Nassau County District Attorney Anne T. Donnelly said Santos 'traded in his integrity for designer clothes and a luxury lifestyle.' Prosecutors shared how Santos and his campaign treasurer, Nancy Marks, doctored donor reports to qualify for national Republican party funding. They fabricated contributions from Santos' family and falsely reported a $500,000 loan from Santos, though he had under $8,000 in his accounts. Well, darlings… The curtain falls, the spotlight dims, and the rhinestones are packed. From the halls of Congress to the chaos of cable news what a ride it's been! Was it messy? Always. Glamorous? Occasionally. Honest? I tried… most days. To my supporters: You made this wild… — George Santos (@MrSantosNY) July 24, 2025 He also stole credit card information from donors, including 'victims he knew were elderly persons suffering from cognitive impairment or decline' and made unauthorized charges to fund both campaign and personal expenses, according to the DOJ. Santos also used a fake political fundraising company to solicit tens of thousands of dollars which he spent on 'designer clothing.' During the pandemic, Santos fraudulently claimed over $24,000 in unemployment benefits while employed at an investment firm. He also submitted false congressional financial disclosures to the House. 5 Former Rep. George Santos arrives at federal court for his sentencing on April 25, 2025. AP 5 Former Rep. George Santos leaves federal court on Aug. 13, 2024. Bloomberg via Getty Images 5 Santos appears in a social media post in June 2025. George Santos/ X Santos was elected in 2022 after flipping New York's 3rd District for the GOP. His résumé was easily debunked. He falsely claimed academic degrees, Wall Street jobs and family ties to the Holocaust and 9/11. He was expelled from Congress in December 2023 after a scathing ethics report, becoming just the sixth member ever removed from the People's House. Santos has remained publicly active after his sentencing, selling video messages on Cameo and making social media posts. His tweet concluded, 'I may be leaving the stage (for now), but trust me legends never truly exit.' Unless pardoned, Santos is expected to remain incarcerated until at least early 2032. He has reportedly appealed to President Donald Trump for clemency. The White House and Santos did not immediately respond to Fox News Digital's request for comment.