logo
Sovereignty of the Scottish people is a chimera that we must make real

Sovereignty of the Scottish people is a chimera that we must make real

The National18-07-2025
And I entirely subscribe to Jim Murphy's notion (Letters, Jul 15) that 'until this movement stops confusing theory with force, and starts acting like a people denied their nation – not petitioners in someone else's parliament – we will never be taken seriously, at home or abroad'.
The only difficulty I have is, what does a people denied their nation actually look like? If we're to believe the views of Professors Crawford and Boyle as set out in Annex A, Opinion: Referendum on the Independence of Scotland International Law Aspects: 'Scotland certainly was extinguished as a matter of international law, by merger either into an enlarged and renamed England or into an entirely new state.' Follow that with the views of Ciaran Martin, Professor at the Blavatnik School of Government, University of Oxford but in a previous incarnation as Constitution Director (2011-2014) within the Cabinet Office and at the centre of the Edinburgh Agreement negotiations: 'Ultimately there are no constraints on what Westminster can do to block a lawful path to Scottish independence if it's so minded. There are, in effect, only two things that matter. One: The law is in [[Westminster]], Two: The votes are in Scotland. So if these two forces clash, one has to give way to the other'.
READ MORE: Will John Swinney surprise us with a courageous election manifesto?
So the choice would appear to be between social disruption (not easy to control in the highly likely instance that the UK deployed agents provocateurs) and the alternative that we make real the chimera that is the sovereignty of the Scottish people.
That it exists is well established with the Claim of Right of 1689 and subsequent iterations in the Scottish Constitutional Convention 1989, Holyrood and [[Westminster]] debates. The only problem is, we can't find the switch to flick or handle to pull to bring it to life as the lawyers tell us it's not justiciable.
What would make the chimera real is the incorporation of the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights (ICCPR) into Scots law. Jim Murphy is anxious that 'constitutional change in states founded on parliamentary sovereignty cannot be achieved through legal argument alone. It requires political authority that transcends existing legal limits – exercised by the people themselves, not their parliamentary proxies – through actions that alter the facts on the ground'.
READ MORE: Legal rights without enforcement are merely political ornaments
This is precisely the power of Article 25(b) of the ICCPR, which would allow for a 'home grown' referendum of Scotland's citizens and the emancipation of direct democracy in our country.
It's good to talk. If it so happens to follow on from a majority of independence-minded MSPs being elected to the new Holyrood Parliament in May, so much the better for undisputed validation of the sovereign will of our nation by 'actions that alter the facts on the ground'.
All the more reason, then, to support PE2135: Implement the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights (ICCPR) in Scottish legislation' at the Citizen Participation and Public Petitions Committee in our 'pretendy parliament'.
Iain Bruce
Nairn
REGARDING the government admitting that the previous government released details of Afghan supporters and that this was done by a "defence" civil servant. Firstly, none of the newspapers reporting this mention if he/she has been dismissed, and secondly, would you be happy with your defence in such hands?
Paul Gillon
Baintown, Leven
Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

Donald Trump exposed a prime minister hopelessly out of his depth
Donald Trump exposed a prime minister hopelessly out of his depth

Telegraph

timean hour ago

  • Telegraph

Donald Trump exposed a prime minister hopelessly out of his depth

SIR – Donald Trump may have an idiosyncratic personality, but he does appear to be right about many more things than our struggling Government ('Trump: Cut taxes and stop the boats', report, July 29). On free speech, net zero, North Sea oil, illegal migration, the European Union, defence, inheritance tax on farmers and even the London Mayor, Mr Trump's views reflect a greater understanding of Britain's interests than those of Sir Keir Starmer and his ministers. Michael Staples Seaford, East Sussex SIR – The President of the United States hosted our Prime Minister at his Scottish golf course. At every opportunity he lectured the hapless Sir Keir on low taxation, low immigration and the Mayor of London. It was what, in boxing, is referred to as 'a whooping'. Fully merited, too. Tim Wright London SW3 SIR – What a great honour it must have been for Sir Keir Starmer to be welcomed into Scotland by President Trump. Tony Gorman Ickenham, Middlesex SIR – I watched the exchanges between President Trump and our lame-duck Prime Minister with astonishment. When Mr Trump was asked by the attendant press for his thoughts on free speech, a clearly rattled Sir Keir hastily reminded us that we have had it in this country for a very long time. Why, then, have police been recruited to scour the internet for people voicing their fears over the outrageous numbers of illegal migrants reaching our shores on a daily basis (' Police unit to monitor anger over migrants ', report, July 27)? I suspect Sir Keir's views on free speech differ somewhat from those of the rest of the country. Valerie Aldred Bath, Somerset SIR – I agree with President Trump's description of Sir Sadiq Khan. However, can you imagine what an outcry there would be if Sir Keir Starmer sat in the Oval Office and made comparable criticisms? Ray Brooksbank Aylesbury, Buckinghamshire SIR – If anything highlights Labour's dire communication skills, it is the Cabinet minister Peter Kyle's attack on Nigel Farage ('F arage is on the side of Jimmy Savile, says minister', July 29). On a day when the media should still have been dominated by the Prime Minister's meeting with the US President, Sir Keir found himself competing for coverage with Mr Farage. While many in Labour may dislike David Dinsmore, the former Sun editor recently appointed to a senior government communications role at the heart of government, they need him. Michael Edwards Haslemere, Surrey

Lowering voting age could deepen class divide in schools due to lack of political literacy among teenagers
Lowering voting age could deepen class divide in schools due to lack of political literacy among teenagers

The Independent

time3 hours ago

  • The Independent

Lowering voting age could deepen class divide in schools due to lack of political literacy among teenagers

The decision to lower the voting age to 16 could widen the inequality divide among teenagers in the UK due to the lack of political education in school. Academics have warned that the move to extend the vote to 16 and 17-year-olds risks only benefitting those from wealthier backgrounds, unless all students are given equal access to citizenship education. Recent research from the University of Roehampton found specific classes on politics and democracy have been provided unevenly across the country, with more affluent schools likely to receive dedicated lessons. It also found that pupils with university-educated parents are more likely to discuss politics at home, and feel more confident engaging in political debates. This results in teenagers from low income households often being at a disadvantage in terms of understanding parties and voting systems, which the research concluded 'compounded class-based disparities'. 'Votes at 16 is an important milestone, but without proper political education in every school, we risk widening the democratic gap between privileged and disadvantaged teenagers', said Dr Bryony Hoskins, Professor of Political Comparative Social Science at the University of Roehampton. 'The students most likely to benefit are those already surrounded by political knowledge and encouragement, leaving disadvantaged young people behind again. 'The result is a political system that feels unrepresentative and irrelevant to many young people. If we ignore this, votes at 16 could actually entrench inequality.' Labour's manifesto committed the party to lowering the voting age to 16 in line with Scottish and Welsh elections. Sir Keir Starmer said it was 'important' to lower the voting age, as 16-year-olds were old enough to work and 'pay in' through tax, so should 'have the opportunity' to say how they wanted their money spent. But a poll of 500 16 and 17-year-olds conducted for ITV News by Merlin Strategy found only half said they thought they should be allowed to vote, and only 18 per cent would definitely vote. Labour stood to gain the most, with 33 per cent saying they would back the party, while 20 per cent said they would choose Reform UK and 18 per cent the Greens. A EU and UK Research and Innovation project was trialled on 900 pupils earlier this ear, and found that a five-lesson political literacy programme improved students' belief in their own ability to engage with politics. 'We now have clear evidence that short, structured lessons that use inclusive education methods can make a real difference,' said Professor Hoskins. 'This should be part of every young person's education and not a postcode lottery.' Ahead of the next general election, researchers are calling on the Department of Education to ensure political literacy becomes a compulsory part of the national curriculum.

John Swinney schmoozed Donald Trump days after ‘whipping up' protests over president's Scots visit
John Swinney schmoozed Donald Trump days after ‘whipping up' protests over president's Scots visit

Scottish Sun

time3 hours ago

  • Scottish Sun

John Swinney schmoozed Donald Trump days after ‘whipping up' protests over president's Scots visit

Click to share on X/Twitter (Opens in new window) Click to share on Facebook (Opens in new window) JOHN Swinney schmoozed Donald Trump as the US President ended his trip to Scotland — days after 'whipping up' protests over it. The First Minister said the pair had enjoyed a 'pleasant' dinner and swapped gifts ahead of the opening of Mr Trump's new Aberdeenshire golf course today. Sign up for Scottish Sun newsletter Sign up 10 The US president left behind previous rows as he hailed the First Minister as 'terrific' and 'a special guy' Credit: Getty 10 John Swinney schmoozed Donald Trump as the US President ended his trip to Scotland Credit: PA 10 Ambassador Warren Stephens and First Minister John Swinney at the New Course Credit: PA 10 Donald Trump waved as he boarded Air Force One at RAF Lossiemouth today Credit: Getty Before jetting off on Air Force One, Mr Trump said of the SNP leader, who dubbed himself Full-on John: 'He's a very special guy.' The pair revealed their unlikely bromance after bonding at a posh dinner where they chewed over hot political topics — plus beef and langoustines. The US president, in a cheery mood at the opening of his latest Scots golf course, left behind previous rows as he hailed the First Minister as 'terrific' and 'a special guy'. And the SNP supremo told how he'd forged a 'positive relationship' with the US leader after 'perfectly courteous' talks on whisky tariffs and aid for starving kids in Gaza. He also revealed they'd enjoyed a 'very pleasant' private chat. There had been fears the pair's first meeting at the Menie Estate in Aberdeenshire would be awkward after Mr Swinney publicly backed Mr Trump's rival Kamala Harris in last year's presidential election. And last week the First Minister was accused of whipping up demos when he called on those planning to protest against the five-day private visit to 'do Scotland proud'. But there was no sign of any lingering resentment as the President singled out Mr Swinney and showered him with praise at the glitzy ceremony in Balmedie. While addressing an audience of VIPs beside the first tee of his new 18-hole links, Mr Trump gestured to the First Minister to stand up in the temporary grandstand. He then said: 'John Swinney is a terrific guy. He loves golf and he loves the people of this country. Donald Trump's Secret Service probes major security breach on Scotland visit after attempt to smuggle person onto plane 'And we really appreciate it. He's a very special guy.' The glowing praise followed a short official meeting between the two politicians this morning. And the night before they had been seen in 'deep conversation' for more than an hour while seated together at a banquet-style dinner at the Trump International resort. Guests enjoyed a seafood starter of langoustine, followed by a beef main course then a trio of desserts featuring Scottish fruits. GOLF SWIPE By Conor Matchett JOHN Swinney rejected claims £180,000 in taxpayer cash for a golf tournament at Donald Trump's Aberdeenshire course was an attempt to 'butter up' the US President. The First Minister was forced to defend the decision to spend the sum to help support the Nexo Championship in Scotland next month. Asked if it was an effort to 'butter up' Mr Trump, he said: 'No, I think what I was trying to do is to make sure that a tournament that was coming to Scotland could be properly promoted.' Sources said Mr Swinney came good on his vow to raise awkward 'critical' issues with Mr Trump. They included his ten per cent import tariffs on Scotch, which are hammering the whisky industry, plus the desperate crisis in Gaza. The Nats boss also buttered up the golf-mad tycoon by showing him snaps of his 14-year-old son Matthew playing the sport. And in an exchange of gifts, Mr Swinney presented Mr Trump with a framed 1921 census form showing the entry for his late mum Mary Anne MacLeod plus a historic map of the Isle of Lewis, where she was born. In return, the President gave the First Minister a figurine of bald eagle, the US national emblem. Other guests at Monday night's private dinner included PM Sir Keir Starmer — who had earlier flown from Ayrshire with Mr Trump on his Air Force One jet — and Scots golf legend Colin Montgomerie. After the ceremony, Mr Swinney was quizzed over his dealings with the controversial visitor. 10 Donald Trump and Prime Minister Keir Starmer on Air Force One Credit: The White House 10 Other guests at Monday night's private dinner included Scots golf legend Colin Montgomerie Credit: Getty 10 The First Minister was accused of whipping up demos against Trump Credit: Getty 10 Donald Trump with sons Eric Trump and Donald Trump Jr Credit: Reuters It was suggested he had previously been seen as a 'Trump sceptic', with one reporter asking: 'Has he won you over?' The SNP boss replied: 'I have a job to do, which is to use every opportunity to protect and promote the interests of Scotland. 'Obviously, I've had a very extensive opportunity in the course of the last 24 hours or so to engage with the President of the United States to set out issues that matter to people in Scotland, domestically and internationally. 'And I've used that opportunity to raise issues around, for example, trade and tariffs, particularly the effect on Scots whisky. 'Also international issues around Gaza and Ukraine — and especially on the humanitarian crisis in Gaza, where I implored the President to use his influence.' ANAS' BIZ BOOST VOW By Conor Matchett ANAS Sarwar pledged to build closer links with Donald Trump's businesses if Labour wins next year's Holyrood election. The party's Scots chief claimed the US leader's resorts have been hamstrung by SNP policies. After meeting Trump International boss Sarah Malone, he said: 'They have not always felt as if Scotland is a good place to do business.' He admitted to having many 'political disagreements' with the American but added: 'He does genuinely have an affinity and love for Scotland. 'If we can harness that then that is a positive in terms of economic outcomes.' Lib Dem MP Susan Murray urged Mr Trump to drop 'damaging' whisky tariffs. Mr Swinney was asked about critics in his own party and beyond who claimed he should not have agreed to meet Mr Trump. Last week Scots Green co-leader Patrick Harvie branded his decision as 'tragic' and 'out of step with Scotland's values'. But Mr Swinney insisted: 'I think people in Scotland would generally think that if I, as First Minister of Scotland, have an opportunity to protect and promote the interests of Scotland to the President of the US, I should take that opportunity.' The Nats chief sought to play down any suggestions of cosiness, explaining that he'd 'had a perfectly courteous set of discussions with President Trump'. Asked if their relationship was warm, he replied: 'I think we've got a positive relationship, yes.' Mr Swinney added: 'I was sitting alongside the President. The Prime Minister was sitting on the other side of the President.' He said everyone sat at the table had chatted, adding: 'The majority of the discussion was privately between the President and myself — and it was very pleasant.' The First Minister also revealed: 'I took the opportunity to show President Trump a photo of my son playing golf on Tiree a few weeks ago. He commented that my son has a beautiful swing — which my son was very pleased to hear about.' TAX 'RIGGED' AGAINST OIL DONALD Trump blasted Sir Keir Starmer's windfall taxes on North Sea oil — insisting the resource is a 'treasure chest for the United Kingdom'. He wrote on his Truth Social network: 'The taxes are so high that it makes no sense. They have essentially told drillers and oil companies, 'We don't want you'. 'Incentivize the drillers, fast. A vast fortune to be made for the UK, and far lower energy costs for the people!' FM John Swinney said Mr Trump had handed a dossier on oil and gas taxes during their breakfast meeting, but stressed such taxes were not under his control. Mr Trump had earlier praised Aberdeen as the oil capital of Europe and branded wind turbines 'ugly monsters'. Mr Swinney said: 'I expressed the view that we have about priorities on renewable energy." Mr Swinney claimed his meet-up with Mr Trump could end up boosting our whisky industry, which is facing the prospect of forking out an additional £4million a week to export our national drink to the US, due to ten per cent tariffs. He said: 'I was trying to encourage the President to look at the possibility of an exception for Scotch whisky. He concluded our discussions this morning by saying to me that I should follow up the issues that we had discussed.' The First Minister explained he'd already taken the issue 'forward' with the US Ambassador, Warren Stephens — who he sat next to at yesterday's golf course opening. He added: 'My team will be following this up in due course.' Asked if he is now confident that there will be an exemption for Scotch or a reduction on whisky tariffs, Mr Swinney said it was 'too early to predict that'. On Monday, President Trump had appeared not to know there was an issue with our national drink when asked about it ahead of a meeting with the Prime Minister. He told Sir Keir: 'We'll talk about that. I didn't know whisky was a problem.' This afternoon Mr Trump enjoyed a round at his new course before beginning his journey home. He was flown from Menie to the RAF base at Lossiemouth, Moray, in his Marine One helicopter. The US president then walked with his grandkids Chloe, 11, and Spencer, 12, to board Air Force One for the flight back to the States. 10 Trump walks with his grandchildren Chloe and Spencer to board Air Force One Credit: AFP

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into a world of global content with local flavor? Download Daily8 app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store