‘Tired of this crap': Liberal MPPs rally around Bonnie Crombie after criticism from Nate Erskine-Smith
in the wake of the broadside against her fired by former rival Nate Erskine-Smith
.
With Crombie facing a leadership review at the Ontario Liberals' annual general meeting Sept. 12-14 in Toronto, Erskine-Smith wrote an 1,177-word email blast urging 'change in our party.'
'Of course I have an interest,' acknowledged the Beaches-East York MP,
who was runner-up in the provincial leadership in 2023
and then
briefly served as federal housing minister
before being demoted by Prime Minister Mark Carney.
Erskine-Smith criticized Crombie and her team for 'trying to socialize the idea that an untenable 51 per cent mandate is an acceptable result' at the September review, insisting 'two-thirds support should be the minimum expectation.'
Sources told the Star that some Liberals have privately complained to Carney's office about the MP's intervention Friday.
But given
Erskine-Smith's public grumbling
that he felt '
disrespected
' when the prime minister removed him from cabinet, it's unlikely any such appeal would have much effect.
Liberal MPPs, meanwhile, took to social media to defend Crombie with some choice words for the backbencher.
'The Ontario Liberal leadership isn't a backup plan or safety net. Building for the future takes hard work and someone who is going to stick it out,' said MPP Stephen Blais (Orleans).
That's a reference to Erskine-Smith doing little to help the Grits after losing the leadership contest, including in the Feb. 27 snap election won by Premier Doug Ford's Progressive Conservatives with 43 per cent of the popular vote.
The MP insisted he 'was happy to work for a winning campaign in support of local MPP Mary-Margaret McMahon, an energetic force in community engagement' in February.
MPP Stephanie Smyth (St. Paul's), one of the five newly elected Liberals, praised Crombie for returning the party to official status in the legislature, taking 30 per cent of the vote and improving fundraising.
'Let's not go backwards,' said Smyth.
Still, the Liberals' inefficient vote led to just 14 seats in the 124-member legislature compared to 80 for the PCs. The NDP held 27 seats with just 18.5 per cent of the vote. Mike Schreiner's Greens won two ridings and Independent Bobbi Ann Brady was re-elected.
Crombie failed to win a seat, losing Mississauga East-Cooksville to Tory Silvia Gualtieri, a setback for a three-term Mississauga mayor. She has said she will contest a byelection when a viable riding opens up.
Rookie MPP Rob Cerjanec (Ajax) said he was 'tired of this crap' from Erskine-Smith and other insurgents.
'The last campaign had its issues and the seat result wasn't what we wanted but there were also some successes. I've had good conversations with Bonnie Crombie about what went wrong and what we need to do to win,' said Cerjanec.
'She agrees we need to do things differently. Another leadership race isn't going to help us build the party.'
Liberal House Leader John Fraser emphasized he 'will be supporting Bonnie at the AGM' and implored other Grits to do so.
'Our cause is a collective one, not one of personal ambition,' said Fraser in a veiled shot at Erskine-Smith.
MPP Andrea Hazell (Scarborough-Guildwood) noted she has 'always been passionate about women in leadership and I support Bonnie Crombie in bringing Ontario back on track.'
Newly elected MPP Jonathan Tsao (Don Valley North) praised the leader for putting 'our party first.'
'While others chase headlines, she's laser-focused on one thing: standing up for the people of Ontario and defeating Doug Ford and the PCs next election,' said Tsao.
MPP Lucille Collard (Ottawa-Vanier) said although she supported third-place finisher Yasir Naqvi in 2023, Crombie 'has shown skill in growing our party's appeal and presenting serious policy.'
'You may not agree with her on everything, and that's fine. The OLP has momentum and the last thing we need is another leadership race,' said Collard.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Hamilton Spectator
40 minutes ago
- Hamilton Spectator
As Donald Trump's trade war grinds on, support for Doug Ford's PCs hits new high, poll suggests
Premier Doug Ford is flying high. In fact, Ford's three-term Progressive Conservatives have never been higher in Abacus Data's tracking poll . Conversely, Marit Stiles's New Democrats are at an all-time low in the research firm's monthly survey. The Tories, re-elected Feb. 27 with 43 per cent of the popular vote , sat at 50 per cent support in the poll, ahead of Bonnie Crombie's Liberals at 28 per cent while Stiles' NDP languished at 13 per cent and Mike Schreiner's Greens were at six per cent. 'It's all good news here for the premier and the PC government right now,' Abacus president David Coletto said in an interview Thursday. Coletto noted the ongoing trade war launched by U.S. President Donald Trump is helping Ford's political fortunes, much as the tariff tiff has boosted Prime Minister Mark Carney's federal Liberals. 'Because Premier Ford has been so focused on responding to Trump from day one … he's really come to be seen as this stable force that's giving enough people in the province confidence that he's focused on the things they want him to be focused on,' he said. 'Despite concerns around the health system or affordability, they aren't blaming him or his government for those pain points in their life.' Abacus surveyed 1,000 Ontarians from July 10 through July 15 using online panels based on the Lucid exchange platform. While opt-in polls cannot be assigned a margin of error, for comparison purposes, a random sample of this size would have one of plus or minus 3.09 percentage points, 19 times out of 20. It was conducted before Ford hosted Carney and the premiers at the annual Council of the Federation summit in Huntsville , which dominated the domestic news earlier this week. Much was made of the fact that the rookie prime minister, who is also performing well in public-opinion polls, stayed over at the premier's Muskoka cottage Monday night . 'There's an alignment that clearly exists in how both Ottawa and Queen's Park are viewing this moment. In a crisis, Canadians are looking to their leaders. People are looking for stability in a world of uncertainty' said Coletto. That can make for difficult political terrain for opposition leaders like Crombie, who faces a Liberal leadership review in September , and Stiles to navigate. 'At 28 per cent, the Liberals under Crombie are where they were at last month. That's a little bit lower than (the 30 per cent of votes) they got in the election,' said the pollster. 'These numbers aren't great news, but they're not bad news. They show that she's making progress and her impressions are improving,' he added, pointing out the party is 'holding its support and it has as large as an accessible pool of voters as the Conservatives do.' That's a reference to 54 per cent of respondents saying they would consider voting Liberal while 53 per cent would look at the Tories and 40 per cent would think about casting a ballot for the NDP. 'Even though (Crombie is) not the leader of the opposition, she's certainly attracts more attention and is more well known in the province (than Stiles).' The provincial New Democrats are the Official Opposition in the legislature despite finishing with 18.5 per cent of the popular vote in February. At 13 per cent, the NDP is down from its previous low of 14 per cent last month . 'If the Ontario Liberals have benefited from a halo effect from Carney, then the provincial NDP has had the opposite. The anchor of the federal NDP collapse has continued to pull that party down,' he said. 'It's not that Marit Stiles is personally any more disliked than she was. It's just the NDP is receding in a lot of Ontarians minds, and so that that's going to be a real challenge for the provincial party, unless the federal one gets its act together,' said Coletto. In terms of personal popularity, Ford was at 46 per cent positive, 33 per cent negative for a plus 13 per cent favourability rating with 19 per cent of respondents neutral and two per cent unsure. Stiles was at 28 per cent positive, 24 per cent negative for plus four per cent with 30 per cent neutral and 18 per cent uncertain. Schreiner was at 25 per cent positive and 21 per cent negative for plus four per cent with 34 per cent neutral and 21 per cent unsure. Crombie was at 33 per cent positive and 32 per cent negative for plus one per cent with 24 per cent neutral and 11 per cent uncertain.
Yahoo
3 hours ago
- Yahoo
Will Frank White recall get delayed? What county legislators and lawsuits say
As the future of a planned recall election for County Executive Frank White Jr. heads to the courts, the Jackson County Legislature may be changing its tune to support pushing the vote to a later date. Legislators had initially set the election date for Aug. 26. But in the face of multiple legal challenges and concerns from local election boards, they introduced an ordinance Monday supporting a Nov. 4 election to recall White, a Democrat and former Royals Hall of Famer who has served as county executive since 2016. The ordinance suggests that Nov. 4 — when a county election is already scheduled — would be the next most appropriate date if a 'lawful election date' could not be found within 60 days of when voters submitted the petition prompting a recall vote, which is the timeline outlined in the county's charter. Supporters of the recall effort submitted signatures to the Kansas City and Jackson County election boards, which certified 43,011 valid signatures on June 30, breaking the required signature threshold by 109 names. Along with vocal organizers in Eastern Jackson County, many of the signatures were collected over the course of two years by a dark money political action group. White's opponents have cited disagreement with his handling of Jackson County's property tax assessments in recent years, as well as the 2024 tax question that would have funded a new Royals stadium in the Crossroads. White's chief of staff Caleb Clifford said that he and White are concerned that the legislature introduced an ordinance around a Nov. 4 election while the older ordinance supporting an earlier date still stands. 'Moving forward with setting an election date without first rescinding the prior ordinance and ensuring full legal compliance could result in two unlawful, unbudgeted elections, costing taxpayers millions and requiring the County to once again draw from out dwindling emergency reserves,' Clifford said. The scheduled Nov. 4 election is already set to include a ballot measure about amending the Jackson County Charter to make the role of county assessor an elected position starting in November 2028. Currently, Jackson County is the only county in Missouri where the county assessor is appointed rather than elected. Third District At-Large Legislator Megan Smith (formerly Marshall) sponsored the ordinance supporting a Nov. 4 recall, which was assigned Monday to the legislature's Intergovernmental Affairs Committee. Smith was the only legislator to abstain from a July 18 vote overriding White's veto of an earlier ordinance recommending an August 26 special election. The Jackson County and Kansas City election boards have been advocating for a Nov. 4 date for multiple weeks, arguing that state and federal law afforded them a longer timeline to administer an election. During the July 18 vote, Smith echoed their concerns, noting that an August election date may disenfranchise voters overseas who will not receive ballots in time or voters who need to vote early or by absentee ballot. Forcing an election in violation of state law could open the door for other lawsuits or election results to be invalidated in the future, Smith said. 'I don't know if [the legislature] will get something done before the courts do,' said Tammy Brown, Republican Director of the Jackson County Election Board. 'We'll be happy either way whenever they get settled.' The legislature and election boards have been involved in conflicting lawsuits, both of which ask the Jackson County court system to issue guidance on when a recall election should take place. A lawsuit filed July 9 by four Jackson County residents, including former chairs of both the Democratic and Republican parties of Jackson County – Phil LeVota and Mark Anthony Jones, respectively – asked the court to mandate an Aug. 26 election regardless of any action from either White or the legislature. The next day, the Jackson County and Kansas City election boards filed their own lawsuit, arguing that the proposed Aug. 26 date could not be legally enforced. 'We have certain federal and state laws we have to follow,' Brown said. 'We understand that they wanted a very speedy, quick election, but all of our elections start 10 weeks out, so we had to follow the law and that's what we've done. That's why we had to file the lawsuit.' As of Tuesday, both lawsuits have been consolidated into one case. Jackson County judge Mary Wayne Seaton will hear the combined lawsuit on Aug. 1. Meanwhile, some Jackson County residents and organizations are calling for White to resign before a special election proceeds. The Urban Council, a coalition of civil rights organizations in the Kansas City area affiliated with the Urban Summit, joined LeVota and Sixth District Legislator Sean Smith last week in demanding that White step down. White has said that he would support a Nov. 4 election, while LeVota has called for a special election in September or October if the courts ruled against an Aug. 26 date. Both White and LeVota have said that running the recall question during a special election outside of Nov. 4 would cost taxpayers about $2 million. If Smith's ordinance supporting a Nov. 4 election passes, White would have 10 days to veto it, at which point the legislature could overturn a veto with a supermajority of six votes — as occurred with the previous ordinance supporting an August 26 recall election. However, the final decision on the timing of a recall election for now rests on a judge's decision. 'It's up to the courts at this point,' Brown said. 'We'll have to see what happens.' Solve the daily Crossword
Hamilton Spectator
3 hours ago
- Hamilton Spectator
Mark Carney names Arctic ambassador in meeting with Inuit leaders
OTTAWA — Prime Minister Mark Carney appointed Nunavut's Virginia Mearns as Canada's first Arctic ambassador on Thursday, as his Liberal government seeks to strengthen ties between Ottawa and the country's north at a time of increased geopolitical instability. Carney made the announcement behind closed doors after kicking off a summit with Inuit leadership in Inuvik, N.W.T., that's meant to focus on the implementation of Ottawa's controversial major projects law. 'There are new threats that have emerged, physical threats, virtual threats, tangible threats,' the prime minister said alongside eight members of his cabinet. 'We take those threats seriously, we take our responsibility to defend all Canadians seriously. It's the first thing we think about when we get up in the morning.' Mearns is senior director of Inuit relations for the Qikiqtani Inuit Association, an organization that represents more than half of Inuit living in the Canadian Arctic. She has held a number of roles within the Nunavut government, including in intergovernmental affairs. Her new position was created under former prime minister Justin Trudeau's government, when then-foreign affairs minister Mélanie Joly unveiled a new Arctic foreign policy plan in December. The plan notes that the position was established 'to ensure that the Canadian Arctic remains a region that is stable, prosperous and secure,' to advance Canada's polar interests, to work with Arctic and non-Arctic states, and to raise the profile of Indigenous rights in the region. Mearns will start in the role on Sept. 15. Arctic security is only part of Thursday's wide-ranging agenda. Inuit Tapiriit Kanatami president Natan Obed, who is co-chairing the meeting of the Inuit-Crown Partnership Committee with Carney, said Thursday that he also planned to raise key priorities like supports for children, the housing crisis in the north, and the need for essential community infrastructure. 'We come, as Inuit, understanding that the government of Canada will always have priorities, and the Inuit will always have priorities. Where we meet in the middle is where we can do the best work,' Obed told Carney. The primary reason for Thursday's summit, however, is the Building Canada Act, part of a contentious law known, prior to its passage, as Bill C-5. The legislation was introduced to respond to Canada's trade dispute with the United States, and was rushed through Parliament in June. It grants Ottawa temporary powers to sidestep environmental laws and regulations to fast-track 'nation-building' projects like pipelines, ports and mines. The law, and its hasty introduction, prompted criticism that it was putting Indigenous rights and environmental protections at risk. 'Really, what the act does is it creates conditions for the federal government to be more effective and efficient in our part of the partnership,' Carney said. 'For too long the attitude in Ottawa has been, 'Why should a project be done?' as opposed to …'How do we help the project to move forward?'' Thursday's gathering is the prime minister's second of three such meetings. Last week, he met with hundreds of First Nations leaders in Ottawa to air out grievances and chart a path forward after the law's passage. Carney suggested at that meeting that he was focused on implementing the law in partnership with First Nations rather than amending it, and pledged to participate in further regional consultations. While some chiefs left the confab expressing cautious optimism about the closed-door discussions, others left the summit early, believing the federal government's attempts at consultations were hollow and flawed. Carney is set to meet with Métis leadership at a later date.
