'Shameful': national work-with-kids system long overdue
State and federal ministers have been scrambling to fast-track reforms to Australia's childcare sector after it was revealed on Tuesday a Melbourne carer was charged with more than 70 sex offences.
Joshua Dale Brown allegedly abused eight children aged under two at a Point Cook facility in the city's southwest from April 2022 to January 2023.
The 26-year-old, who had a valid working with children clearance, was not known to police or subject to any complaints before his arrest in May.
The Royal Commission into Institutional Responses to Child Sexual Abuse called on the federal government in 2015 to "facilitate a national model" for working with children checks.
Robert Fitzgerald, one of five members of the royal commission, said the recommendation remained unfulfilled.
"My view is that is shameful," the now-age discrimination commissioner told AAP.
"Ten years on, that job should have been completed and the fact that it isn't means there are gaps in our child safeguarding regime."
Every state and territory maintains separate working with children schemes with different rules and requirements.
Victoria, Queensland and NSW have all committed to reviewing or tightening up their regimes.
Uniform schemes would not completely negate the risk of child sexual abuse but would be an important first step, Mr Fitzgerald argued.
A 2022 Victorian ombudsman report exposed "serious flaws" in the state's scheme after former Melbourne City Mission worker Alexander Jones was convicted of sexually assaulting a child in 2018.
Jones was investigated for multiple alleged sexual offences in NSW but granted a permit in Victoria because his national police check was clean, as he had not been charged.
It remains the case that people under investigation for serious offences can hold a working with children check in Victoria.
Only criminal charges or a regulatory finding can lead to it being revoked.
Strengthening working with children checks will also be discussed at a meeting of state and federal attorneys-general in August.
Victoria's Minister for Children Lizzie Blandthorn said national reform work was "frustratingly slow".
Federal Education Minister Jason Clare described the system as complicated but conceded the reforms have taken "too bloody long".
Fellow senior frontbencher Clare O'Neil said she didn't have a good answer for why the royal commission's recommendations had been left on the shelf.
"A lot of these predators would pass a working with children check," she said.
The crisis has also cast a spotlight on educator-to-child ratios across the country.
The ratios do not require more than one carer to be around a child or group at any given time, unlike the Netherlands' "four eyes" principle.
A father whose two children attended the Point Cook childcare centre wants CCTV installed throughout the facility and questioned the lack of staff supervision.
"There should also be two people there at all times," said Satbir, who didn't want his surname included.
NSW has flagged a trial of CCTV cameras in centres, while an urgent Victorian review is looking at making the technology mandatory.
1800 RESPECT (1800 737 732)
National Sexual Abuse and Redress Support Service 1800 211 028
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Sky News AU
an hour ago
- Sky News AU
Opposition Leader Sussan Ley says attempted attack on East Melbourne Synagogue an act of 'hate'
An attack on a Jewish synagogue has been condemned by Sussan Ley who declared the incident an act of "hate". An unknown man is understood to have entered the grounds of the synagogue on Albert Street in East Melbourne about 8pm on Friday night. The alleged offender poured a flammable liquid at the front entrance of the East Melbourne Synagogue, before allegedly setting it on fire and fleeing the scene on foot in a westerly direction. About 20 people were inside the synagogue enjoying a Shabbat dinner when the incident happened, but they safely self-evacuated out the back of the building. The Opposition Leader said the act was "horrifying". 'This is not protest,' she wrote on social media platform X. 'This is hate. And it has no place in Australia.' Victorian Liberal MP David Southwick said the Jewish community 'deserves protection, not platitudes'. 'A second arson attack on a synagogue in Melbourne, this time on the Sabbath along with a Jewish restaurant in the CBD,' he said in a statement. 'The perpetrators and organisers must be found and brought to justice. My thoughts are with every members of the Jewish community affected by these vile attacks.' 'We cannot let these haters hijack our streets, our city, or our state. We must stand united against anti-Semitic violence.' Former Liberal treasurer Josh Frydenberg said Australia had to continue trying to stamp out antisemitism. 'When you firebomb a synagogue with people inside & attack a local restaurant because it's owned by Jews, it's NOT about Israel, it's NOT about protest, it's a hate crime,' Mr Frydenberg wrote on X. 'Violent anti-Semitism is a threat to us all & until it's called out for what it really is, it will continue!' No injuries have been reported. Firefighters attended the scene and put the blaze out, but it was fortunately contained to just the front door. Victoria Police have confirmed the investigation is now with the detectives from the Counter Terrorism Security Investigation Unit. The incident is not being treated as a terrorism incident, but the investigation will look at the "intent and ideology" of the person or persons responsible to determine if the incident is actually an act of terrorism, a police statement said. Police have released an image of a man who detectives want to speak to in relation to the matter. The man is described as being aged in his mid 30's, having a beard and long hair. He was wearing a dark blue or black jumper, black pants and black beanie when pictured. Detectives are also investigating potential links to two other overnight incidents, including a public order incident and an arson and criminal damage to a business. Northwest Metro Region Acting Commander Zorka Dunston told media on Thursday afternoon it was "incredibly lucky" that no one was injured the incident. "I'd like to make it very clear that we do recognise that these crimes are disgusting and abhorrent. But at this stage, we are not declaring this a terrorist incident," she said. "... Whilst I acknowledge that the fire itself may be small in nature, we are taking this investigation incredibly seriously. And given there were 20 people inside the building at the time, the outcome could have been a lot more devastating. "This was clearly a targeted fire and we will not accept any acts of antisemitism or hate-based crime."
West Australian
3 hours ago
- West Australian
Australia's Jewish communities need increased protection, Opposition tell Prime Minister
Prime Minister Anthony Albanese has been urged to do more to protect Australia's Jewish communities following an arson attack on an east Melbourne synagogue on Friday night. Some 20 people were inside the synagogue at the time of the incident, in which flammable liquid was poured on the front door and set alight. The occupants managed to escape via the rear of the building and no one was injured. Shadow attorney-general Julian Leeser said Mr Albanese needed to follow the lead of other world leaders in lifting efforts to protect Jewish communities from hateful attacks against the backdrop of conflict in the Middle East. Mr Leeser said the PM had ignored a letter, sent on June 15, from Opposition leader Sussan Ley, shadow minister for home affairs Andrew Hastie and himself which had stressed the need for greater protection. 'This is a very sad day for Australia . . . one of the oldest synagogues in Australia has been fire bombed,' he told reporters on Saturday. 'It's a synagogue that bespeaks the rich and long history of the Jewish people in this country. There's even a prayer for the King there that goes back to Queen Victoria's time in both Hebrew and English. 'This is an attack on all Australians. It is not just an attack on the Jewish community and it sickens me, but yet again the Jewish community is having to put up with these attacks, and the increasing anti-Semitism people think has gone away but continues, sadly, unabated.' Mr Leeser said the Opposition was putting the PM on notice to take more steps to protect the Jewish community. 'I don't know that he's done all he can here,' he said. 'We're calling on him to explain what measures he has taken to protect the Jewish community, and if he didn't take increased measures, why he didn't take increased measures at that time.' Mr Leeser said there needed to be increased police presence and security around Jewish community buildings. 'We have got to put an end to the hate that we see in this country,' he said. Victorian premier Jacinta Allan has condemned the synagogue attack as 'disgraceful behaviour by a pack of cowards'. 'That this happened on Shabbat makes it all the more abhorrent,' she said in a statement. 'Any attack on a place of worship is an act of hate, and any attack on a Jewish place of worship is an act of anti-Semitism.' On Saturday, police released the image of a man detectives want to speak to about the incident. He has been described as being of Caucasian appearance, believed to be in his 30s with a beard and long hair. Damage from the fire was contained to the front entrance.
7NEWS
6 hours ago
- 7NEWS
Former child abuse detective says some Australian daycare centres putting profit over safety
Some daycare centres are putting profits over safety, and working with children checks are barely worth the paper they are printed on, a veteran child abuse detective says. Kristi McVee has become a leading child safety expert since leaving the force and said that — 'time and time again' — educators at for-profit centres across Australia who speak up or report alleged inappropriate behaviour are either dismissed or vilified. 'In my opinion ... the management of this is the problem ... because they're not taking it seriously or they're worried about their reputation and they're putting profit over safety,' she said. 'So I would like to see centre management and these companies that run these centres be held accountable or more accountable.' The national spotlight has been turned directly onto the safety of kids in daycare centres after childcare worker Joshua Dale Brown allegedly abused eight children at a facility at Point Cook in Melbourne 's southeast. Brown, 26, worked in at least 20 centres since 2017, for which a list and set of dates have already been made public. Victoria Police said they continue to investigate further details of his employment history as a matter of priority after parents reported discrepancies in the listed dates. The families of 1200 children have been told to get their infants tested for sexually transmitted infections as a precaution. Brown had a valid working with children check and was not known to police or subject to any complaints before his arrest in May. Speaking generally about flaws in the system, McVee said working with children checks are only useful on the day they are issued, and only if someone has been charged. 'Each state has different policies around when police notify working with children's if someone's been investigated or charged,' she said. 'In some states they only let them know when they've been charged, some states let them know when they've been investigated.' A former royal commissioner has slammed governments for dragging their feet on creating a national regime for working with children checks after an inquiry in 2015 issued the recommendation. Robert Fitzgerald, one of five members of the royal commission, said it was shameful the recommendation remained unfulfilled. 'Ten years on, that job should have been completed and the fact that it isn't means there are gaps in our child safeguarding regime,' the now-age discrimination commissioner said. Every state and territory maintains separate working with children schemes with different rules and requirements. Victoria, Queensland and NSW have all committed to reviewing or tightening their regimes. State, territory and federal education ministers are due to meet in August and they will discuss safety measures, including the introduction of CCTV in centres and a national register of childcare workers. NSW has flagged a trial of CCTV cameras in centres, as an urgent Victorian review examines making the technology mandatory. South Australia is considering cameras and fast-tracking mobile phone bans in childcare centres while Western Australia is conducting a child safety review into facilities there. McVee said cameras in childcare centres could be a solution but also a 'double-edged sword' if they are relied too heavily on. 'There is always going to be blind spots ... and there's always the possibility of human interference,' she said. 'People do destroy evidence if they don't want to be held accountable or they're scared of their reputation being damaged. 'I think there needs to be a lot more done to hold centres and these people who are responsible for our children, who take thousands and thousands of dollars from families, to account. 'There needs to be stricter penalties for them.' The Albanese government has plans to fast-track legislation to allow funding to be stripped from centres that don't meet standards, while spot checks will be introduced to limit fraud. McVee's advice to parents is to use correct anatomical terms and language for private parts. 'The reason for that is when I was interviewing children (as a detective), a lot of children who used pet names couldn't tell me what actually happened to them,' she said, adding it could help in the rare chance they need to explain what happened to police or even in a courtroom. 'In Western Australia, we would accept if they explained what that body part did... because a lot of little children don't have that terminology down pat yet. 'But, a lot of the times if they can't explain where, then no, it doesn't count. 'So it's really important children understand what their body parts are. 'If you use nicknames at home, that is really easy for people who want to harm children to actually abuse them, because in a lot of the cases ... these predators or groomer will use nicknames to gamify this abuse, especially with little children.'
