
Lawyer drops Judicial Appointments Commission court challenge after Azalina signals reform
In a press statement today, Syed Amir Syakib Arsalan said he was withdrawing the case, as the government recently said it was willing to look into reforms on how judges are appointed in Malaysia.
'This decision follows recent public statements by the Honourable Minister of Law and Institutional Reform, YB Datuk Seri Azalina Othman Said, who has acknowledged that the Judicial Appointments Commission Act 2009 ('JAC Act') is open to improvement and that the government is willing to engage with all stakeholders in efforts to reform and strengthen the
legislative framework governing judicial appointments.
'Given the government's clear position and willingness to address the concerns raised, I am of the view that the constitutional challenge is no longer necessary at this juncture,' he said in his statement.
'With the recent appointments of the Chief Justice and President of the Court of Appeal having been completed in accordance with Article 122B of the Constitution, I am also satisfied that there is no immediate prejudice or uncertainty affecting the leadership of the judiciary,' he also said later in the same statement.
Syed Amir Syakib Arsalan had on April 8 filed his lawsuit against the Malaysian government and the JAC.
In his lawsuit, he had wanted the courts to invalidate both the JAC and the JAC Act 2009.
He had also wanted a court order for the prime minister to follow the constitutional process for the appointment of judges without what he described as 'interference' by the JAC.
Previously, he had also applied to bring 16 questions on constitutional law to the Federal Court.
Both the main court challenge and the lawyer's bid to refer the 16 constitutional questions to the Federal Court have not been heard yet, and both have now been dropped.
Last Wednesday, the High Court reportedly scheduled September 11 to hear the Malaysian Bar's application to get the JAC's meeting minutes from January 2023 until now, before it hears the application to refer the constitutional questions.
In announcing his dropping of the entire court challenge today, Syed Amir Syakib Arsalan said he had filed the lawsuit 'in good faith' to test whether the JAC Act is valid constitutionally, to raise awareness of its alleged structural shortcomings, and to encourage public discussion on the need for institutional safeguards that are consistent with the Constitution.
He urged the Malaysian government to study the questions he had raised about the process to appoint judges in Malaysia, as well as whether the Federal Constitution needs to be amended to align the JAC framework with the country's constitutional structure and values.
When contacted by Malay Mail, Syed Amir Syakib Arsalan's lawyer Daniel Annamalai confirmed that his client had today filed in court for the case to be discontinued and withdrawn.
Hashtags

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles


Malay Mail
2 minutes ago
- Malay Mail
IGP: Foreign intelligence behind kidnapping, firearms cases in Malaysia, Palestinians urged to stay low-key
KUALA LUMPUR, July 23 — Police have confirmed they are investigating cases linked to foreign intelligence agencies in Malaysia, as security is tightened to counter external threats and safeguard Palestinians residing in the country. In a statement today, Inspector-General of Police Datuk Seri Mohd Khalid Ismail said the Royal Malaysia Police (PDRM) remains fully committed to protecting national security and sovereignty amid suspected foreign interference. 'There have been incidents reported and investigated by PDRM believed to have been orchestrated by foreign intelligence entities,' he said. 'Among them are two cases: one involving the kidnapping of a Palestinian national, and another involving the possession of six firearms — both allegedly linked to foreign operatives.' Mohd Khalid said police are closely monitoring the entry of foreign nationals, working in coordination with key agencies such as the Immigration Department, the Border Control and Protection Agency and Interpol. 'The Royal Malaysia Police (PDRM) remains vigilant in its efforts to prevent and address various external threats that could jeopardise national security,' he said. 'This includes any agendas driven by foreign intelligence agencies that may attempt to interfere with or undermine the country's stability and sovereignty.' The IGP also advised Palestinians living in Malaysia to maintain a low profile to avoid being targeted. 'Palestinians are advised to maintain a low profile to avoid becoming targeted individuals, and to report any suspicious activity to the police,' he said in the statement. As part of its long-term strategy, he added that PDRM is strengthening cooperation with both local and international agencies through continuous intelligence sharing. 'PDRM is also engaged in strategic collaboration with relevant government agencies involved in national security through continuous exchange of information and perspectives at both national and international levels,' he said in the statement. The IGP's statement underscores Malaysia's broader concern over foreign actors operating within its borders, particularly in light of heightened geopolitical tensions and covert activity in the region. 'PDRM remains committed to ensuring the security of Malaysia and the wellbeing of its people,' he added.


Malay Mail
2 minutes ago
- Malay Mail
IGP warns of foreign operatives threat, urges caution for Palestinians in Malaysia
KUALA LUMPUR, July 23 — Police have confirmed they are investigating cases linked to foreign intelligence agencies in Malaysia, as security is tightened to counter external threats and safeguard Palestinians residing in the country. In a statement today, Inspector-General of Police Datuk Seri Mohd Khalid Ismail said the Royal Malaysia Police (PDRM) remains fully committed to protecting national security and sovereignty amid suspected foreign interference. 'There have been incidents reported and investigated by PDRM believed to have been orchestrated by foreign intelligence entities,' he said. 'Among them are two cases: one involving the kidnapping of a Palestinian national, and another involving the possession of six firearms — both allegedly linked to foreign operatives.' Mohd Khalid said police are closely monitoring the entry of foreign nationals, working in coordination with key agencies such as the Immigration Department, the Border Control and Protection Agency and Interpol. 'The Royal Malaysia Police (PDRM) remains vigilant in its efforts to prevent and address various external threats that could jeopardise national security,' he said. 'This includes any agendas driven by foreign intelligence agencies that may attempt to interfere with or undermine the country's stability and sovereignty.' The IGP also advised Palestinians living in Malaysia to maintain a low profile to avoid being targeted. 'Palestinians are advised to maintain a low profile to avoid becoming targeted individuals, and to report any suspicious activity to the police,' he said in the statement. As part of its long-term strategy, he added that PDRM is strengthening cooperation with both local and international agencies through continuous intelligence sharing. 'PDRM is also engaged in strategic collaboration with relevant government agencies involved in national security through continuous exchange of information and perspectives at both national and international levels,' he said in the statement. The IGP's statement underscores Malaysia's broader concern over foreign actors operating within its borders, particularly in light of heightened geopolitical tensions and covert activity in the region. 'PDRM remains committed to ensuring the security of Malaysia and the wellbeing of its people,' he added.

Malay Mail
32 minutes ago
- Malay Mail
Teo Nie Ching: RM100 SARA aid via MyKad ensures transparency and direct benefits
KUALA LUMPUR, July 23 — The one-off RM100 cash assistance to be disbursed to all Malaysian adults through MyKad under the Sumbangan Asas Rahmah (SARA) programme is a targeted approach that ensures transparency so that the aid reaches the people directly, said Deputy Communications Minister Teo Nie Ching. She said the mechanism allows every Malaysian aged 18 and above to use the assistance to purchase essential items while preventing unnecessary or harmful spending. 'I believe SARA has clear benefits as it can be used specifically for purchasing basic necessities, and not for buying cigarettes, alcohol, or other non-essential items. 'So with the aid channelled through MyKad, I think this initiative can truly benefit all Malaysians aged 18 and above,' she said in a phone interview with Bernama Radio today. Teo said this in response to Prime Minister Datuk Seri Anwar Ibrahim's special announcement on the initiative in conjunction with the National Day 2025, which involves an allocation of RM2 billion and will benefit over 22 million of the country's population. Meanwhile, Teo also welcomed the doubling of the Rahmah Madani Sales programme allocation from RM300 million to RM600 million this year, which she said would allow more people, especially those in the B40 group, to access essential goods at lower prices. 'Prices at Rahmah Madani Sales are incredibly affordable. For instance, I recently visited one in my area last weekend, and a pack of instant noodles was sold at RM3.70, while in regular supermarkets it's at least RM4 or more, sometimes even reaching RM5. 'We also saw eggs and many other necessities being sold at very low prices. So I believe this expansion will greatly benefit more communities, especially in the B40 group,' she said. Teo also lauded the government's plan to set the price of RON95 petrol at RM1.99 per litre through a fuel subsidy targeting mechanism. 'This new RON95 price of RM1.99 per litre is excellent news for all Malaysians. It also ensures a clear distinction between locals and foreigners, where only Malaysians enjoy the subsidised rate. Foreign nationals should not benefit from our government's fuel subsidies. With this move, all Malaysians stand to benefit,' she said. Earlier today, Anwar announced several key initiatives as part of the Madani Government's appreciation for the people, including a one-off RM100 SARA aid via MyKad for all Malaysian adults, postponement of toll rate hikes for 10 highways, and a lower subsidised RON95 petrol price of RM1.99 per litre. — Bernama