logo
Pahalgam is a lapse, but no security or intelligence detail is foolproof: Ex-RAW chief AS Dulat

Pahalgam is a lapse, but no security or intelligence detail is foolproof: Ex-RAW chief AS Dulat

Mint25-04-2025
Pahalgam Terror Attack: While there was certainly a lapse in the Baisaran valley, located in South Kashmir's famed tourist resort of Pahalgam, it would be instructive to remember that no security or intelligence is fool proof and perfect, says former RAW chief and India's leading Kashmir specialist, AS Dulat.
"No intelligence or security detail is foolproof. If that was the case, Mrs Indira Gandhi would not have been assassinated, 9/11 could have taken place and more recently, Hamas would not have launched a surprise assault on Israel in October 2023,' Dulat told this reporter.
Some media reports have speculated about a possible intelligence failure in the case where 26 people were killed by Pakistan-sponsored terrorists. All but one of them were Indian citizens. New Delhi swiftly pointed the finger at Pakistan, downgraded ties and suspended its participation in the crucial Indus Water Treaty between the two countries.
Nonetheless, how was it possible that there was no security detail for miles at a holiday destination in a state where the security cover is intense, particularly for VIPs?
"It is certainly odd but if you look at the Anantnag district, the site of this massacre is not too far from the Amarnath yatra route, which is heavily guarded. Also, in the history of Kashmir, this holy yatra has not been disturbed by terrorists, save for 2017. So, I would say that such a killing is not just a shame but practically unprecedented,' he said.
The one major exception, Dulat acknowledged, was the Chittisinghpura massacre where 35 Sikh villagers were killed on 20 March 2000. Situated in the Anantnag district, the slaying took place on the eve of the US President Bill Clinton's state visit to India. The massacre was a turning point in the history of a troubled Kashmir, where Sikhs had usually been spared terrorist violence.
The Baisaran killings came when the US Vice-President JD Vance was visiting India on a four-day trip.
Asked if there was a change of mind in Islamabad with the new army chief, Gen Asim Munir, spewing the Two-Nation theory publicly, Dulat said that appeared to be the case. `"His predecessor was much less of a hawk. It is unfortunate that the current army chief is speaking a language, which no one in a responsible position should do,' he said.
A prolific author, Dulat is the first Indian spymaster to write a memoir entitled A Life in the Shadows, a book that was well received. He is also the author of two bestselling books, Kashmir: The Vajpayee Years (2014) and The Spy Chronicles: R&AW, ISI and the Illusion of Peace (2018). Dulat's views on India, Pakistan and Kashmir are well-known and sought after. This month, Dulat's revelations in his new book, The Chief Minister and the Spy, have triggered a political storm in Kashmir.
Did he believe that the Pahalgam slaying could be a false flag operation staged by India, given state elections later this year and the rise of Hindutva forces, as some in Pakistan are claiming? According to Dulat, he expected Islamabad to say just that, but it was wide off the mark and totally incorrect.
Prime Minister Narendra Modi has vowed to track down the killers and India must do it, even if they have slunk back into Pakistan. ``The killers should be hunted down in Kashmir if they are here or tracked down in Pakistan. We have the wherewithal,' Dulat said.
No intelligence or security detail is foolproof.
Was Pakistan ready to initiate another border skirmish, now that Kargil was a couple of decades old, Dulat said he could not offer a comment. ``You will need to ask the Pakistani Army that question,' he quipped.
Asked the way ahead in Kashmir, the former RAW chief said that Delhi and Srinagar need to be on the same page. `"While the Prime Minister and Chief Minister (Omar Abdullah) are coordinating well, it is also important to take the Kashmiris along. They should not feel alienated,' Dulat explained.
First Published: 25 Apr 2025, 03:07 PM IST
Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

PM Modi set to sign the India-UK FTA deal. Here's how India benefits
PM Modi set to sign the India-UK FTA deal. Here's how India benefits

First Post

time24 minutes ago

  • First Post

PM Modi set to sign the India-UK FTA deal. Here's how India benefits

India and the United Kingdom are set to sign a free trade agreement (FTA) in the backdrop of Prime Minister Narendra Modi's visit to the UK. India and the UK have been negotiating this bilateral deal for years. India is also trying to negotiate a similar agreement with the United States. But what do we know about the India-UK FTA? What's in it? How do India and UK benefit? read more Follow us on Google News . The deal, which concluded in May, was hailed as 'historic' by Prime Minister Narendra Modi. India and the United Kingdom are set to sign a free trade agreement (FTA). The development comes in the backdrop of Prime Minister Narendra Modi's visit to the UK. India and the UK have been negotiating a deal for years. Modi will meet UK Prime Minister Keir Starmer and hold wide-ranging discussions with him. He will head to the Maldives next on July 25. STORY CONTINUES BELOW THIS AD India is also trying to negotiate a similar agreement with the United States. But what do we know about the India-UK FTA? What's in it? How do India and UK benefit? Let's take a closer look: What we know Negotiations for the deal began in January 2022 under the previous Conservative government. Then prime minister Boris Johnson had ordered negotiators 'to get it done by Diwali in October'. However, the talks over the deal have stretched on for years before concluding in May 2025. Modi in May hailed it as a 'historical deal'. This is India's first such agreement with another nation in over a decade. This is the UK's fourth trade agreement since Brexit. Bilateral trade between the two countries was at $55 billion in 2023/24. The deal includes a double contribution convention – also known as a social security pact – which will help Indian workers. This exempt Indian professionals and companies from social security contributions in the UK for three years — a move described by the Indian government as a 'huge win'. The idea behind it is to stop employers and employees from the burden of contributing to social security in multiple countries. The FTA is extremely detailed – comprising 26 chapters on goods, services, investment, and intellectual property rights. STORY CONTINUES BELOW THIS AD The deal will likely come into effect within a year. It is yet to be cleared by Britain's Parliament. India and the UK are negotiating a Bilateral Investment Treaty (BIT) on a parallel track. India has FTAs with Sri Lanka, Bhutan, Thailand, Singapore, Malaysia, Korea, Japan, Australia, UAE, Mauritius, the 10-nation bloc ASEAN (Association of Southeast Asian Nations), and four European nations' bloc EFTA (Iceland, Liechtenstein, Norway, and Switzerland). India is also currently negotiating FTAs with the US, Oman, the European Union (EU), Peru, and Israel. How India benefits The deal will allow 99 per cent of Indian exports to the UK to fall under zero-duty category. This will boost labour-intensive sectors such as textiles, leather, apparel and footwear, toys, marine product, gems and jewellery. Many of these currently face tariffs ranging from 4 per cent to 16 per cent. Engineering goods, auto components, electric and hybrid vehicles, and sports goods will also benefit. The double contribution pact will be of great help to Indian workers in the UK. It will exempt them from paying into social security for a period of three years. STORY CONTINUES BELOW THIS AD This will save them up to Rs 4,000 crore every year. Under such an agreement, an employee working in a foreign nation is exempt from paying into the social security programme of that nation. Representational Image/ Freepik. The deal will also give Indian yoga instructors, chefs, musicians, and other contractual workers temporary access to the UK. 'The UK is an important market for Indian exporters,' Ajay Sahai, director general of the Federation of Indian Export Organisation, said. It is expected to benefit firms such as Welspun India, Arvind Ltd, Bata India, Relaxo, Tata Motors, Mahindra Electric, and Bharat Forge. It will also increase the flow of investment to India. The UK is currently India's sixth-largest foreign investor. It has already invested $36 billion in India. British firms could partner with Indian companies under the FTA and receive benefits. 'This is a significant agreement,' Vikram Misri, India's foreign secretary, told reporters on Tuesday. Trade minister Piyush Goyal will accompany Modi for the formal signing, a commerce ministry official said. How UK benefits The UK has called this its 'biggest and most economically significant' deal since it signed a similar agreement with the EU. The government has called it a 'huge economic win for the UK' and a 'landmark trade deal'. India will eliminate tariffs on 90 per cent of UK goods. STORY CONTINUES BELOW THIS AD This includes cutting tariffs on Scotch whisky and gin to 75 per cent from 150 per cent. By year 10, this will be reduced to just 40 per cent. Cars being sent to India, which currently face 100 per cent tariffs, will be cut to just 10 per cent. Cosmetics, salmon, chocolates, medical devices, and biscuits will also see tariffs lowered under a quota. UK Prime Minister Keir Starmer The government has called it a 'huge economic win for the UK' and a 'landmark trade deal'. AP British consumers will get the benefits of these products becoming cheaper. Tariffs will also be cut on machinery and aerospace equipment. Firms such as Diageo and carmakers like Aston Martin and Jaguar Land Rover will get a boost. There are around 1,000 Indian companies operating in the UK who employ around 100,000 people. Indian businesses could further invest in healthcare, transport, and energy sectors under the FTA. Additionally, British firms investing in India could receive preferential treatment under the 'Make in India' policy. The Scotch Whisky Association has called the deal 'transformational' The deal is expected to boost the UK economy by $6.5 billion by 2040. STORY CONTINUES BELOW THIS AD Exports to India will increase by $21 billion by that year – around 69 per cent. UK firms will be allowed to bid for non-sensitive tenders in India above Rs 2 billion. The UK says it could allow access to around 40,000 tenders worth Rs 4.09 lakh crore every year.

JACKPOT for India as country has 8.52 million tonnes reserves of rare earth elements, they are located in these cities, names are...
JACKPOT for India as country has 8.52 million tonnes reserves of rare earth elements, they are located in these cities, names are...

India.com

time24 minutes ago

  • India.com

JACKPOT for India as country has 8.52 million tonnes reserves of rare earth elements, they are located in these cities, names are...

JACKPOT for India as country has 8.52 million tonnes reserves of rare earth elements, they are located in these cities, names are... India has about 7.23 million tonnes of Rare Earth Oxide (REO), found in around 13.15 million tonnes of monazite, a mineral that contains both thorium and rare earths. These are mainly located in beach sands, red and teri sands, and inland river areas across several states like Andhra Pradesh, Odisha, Tamil Nadu, Kerala, West Bengal, Jharkhand, Gujarat, and Maharashtra. Apart from this, another 1.29 million tonnes of rare earths are present in hard rock areas of Gujarat and Rajasthan. This information was shared in the Lok Sabha by Minister of State Dr. Jitendra Singh. He mentioned that the Atomic Minerals Directorate for Exploration and Research (AMD), which works under the Department of Atomic Energy, is actively searching for more rare earth minerals across the country. Their work includes exploring coastal areas, river sands, and hard rock regions where these minerals are likely to be found. Discovery of 482.6 million tonnes of rare earth ore Jitendra Singh also revealed that the Geological Survey of India (GSI) has found about 482.6 million tonnes of rare earth ore through 34 different exploration projects across various parts of the country. He also mentioned that in the last 10 years, India has exported just 18 tonnes of rare earth minerals and hasn't imported any during this time. To address the challenges caused by export bans on rare earth magnets by certain countries, Singh said that the Ministry of External Affairs is actively working with other nations and international partners. India is continuing discussions at both bilateral (one-on-one) and multilateral (involving multiple countries) levels to boost cooperation in the peaceful use of nuclear energy, including rare earth minerals and related technologies. These efforts are aimed at keeping supply chains stable and protecting the interests of Indian businesses that rely on these materials. The Ministry of Mines is taking major steps to ensure that India has a stable and secure supply of key minerals, especially Rare Earth Elements. These minerals play a crucial role in producing electric vehicles, clean energy technologies like solar panels and wind turbines, and essential defence systems. To meet this need, the Indian government is forming strong ties with countries that have rich reserves of these minerals. Minerals such as lithium, cobalt, graphite, titanium, and rare earths are in high demand because they are vital to many fast-growing industries. To support these sectors and keep the supply chain strong, the Ministry has also brought in several important policy changes and reforms.

Inside Westarctica Embassy: Luxury Cars, Diplomatic Number Plates, Fake Flags, Crores in Cash & More
Inside Westarctica Embassy: Luxury Cars, Diplomatic Number Plates, Fake Flags, Crores in Cash & More

Time of India

time24 minutes ago

  • Time of India

Inside Westarctica Embassy: Luxury Cars, Diplomatic Number Plates, Fake Flags, Crores in Cash & More

A bizarre and explosive scandal has emerged from Ghaziabad: a fake embassy claiming to represent the unrecognized 'micronation' of Westarctica has been busted by the Uttar Pradesh Special Task Force. High-end cars with diplomatic number plates, morphed pictures with top Indian leaders, stacks of cash, foreign currency, and forged diplomatic documents were found. The mastermind, Harshvardhan Jain, who styled himself as 'Baron HV Jain', duped job-seekers, flaunted fake passports, and even claimed to run a consulate in New Delhi, all under the banner of a fantasy nation founded by a US Navy officer. This video breaks down how one man manipulated loopholes, fooled the system, and ran a fake diplomatic empire in plain sight, while India's agencies scramble to uncover the full scale of the con.#westarctica #fakeembassy #ghaziabadnews #harshvardhanjain #upstf #diplomaticfraud #micronation #westarcticabaron #fakepassports #jobscam #toi #toibharat #bharat #trending #breakingnews #indianews

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into a world of global content with local flavor? Download Daily8 app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store