Critique of South Africa's economic policies: A call for change
Image: Bloomberg
In critiquing South Africa's economic landscape, Professor Sandile Swana, Principal Consultant at the Centre for Strategic Leadership, has condemned governmental policies as "anti-Black", asserting that these strategies were exacerbating the country's existing economic crisis rather than alleviating it.
Swana highlighted the systemic challenges facing Black South Africans, particularly in light of the alarming rate of unemployment ravaging especially the African and 'Coloured' communities.
'The South African eco-system is anti-Black,' he stated, arguing that the macroeconomic policies of the elected government and the Government of National Unity (GNU) have perpetuated conditions ripe for despair.
Swana's remarks underlined a broader societal malaise.
'Black men are being emasculated and incarcerated, and our youth are in a perpetual drug-induced stupor,' he said in calling for a radical re-examination of the support structures available for young Black men.
He lamented the absence of role models akin to the revered figures of the past like Steve Biko and Oliver Tambo. 'We need to produce them,' he insisted.
Video Player is loading.
Play Video
Play
Unmute
Current Time
0:00
/
Duration
-:-
Loaded :
0%
Stream Type LIVE
Seek to live, currently behind live
LIVE
Remaining Time
-
0:00
This is a modal window.
Beginning of dialog window. Escape will cancel and close the window.
Text Color White Black Red Green Blue Yellow Magenta Cyan
Transparency Opaque Semi-Transparent Background Color Black White Red Green Blue Yellow Magenta Cyan
Transparency Opaque Semi-Transparent Transparent Window Color Black White Red Green Blue Yellow Magenta Cyan
Transparency Transparent Semi-Transparent Opaque
Font Size 50% 75% 100% 125% 150% 175% 200% 300% 400% Text Edge Style None Raised Depressed Uniform Dropshadow Font Family Proportional Sans-Serif Monospace Sans-Serif Proportional Serif Monospace Serif Casual Script Small Caps
Reset
restore all settings to the default values Done
Close Modal Dialog
End of dialog window.
Advertisement
Next
Stay
Close ✕
Ad loading
Swana also proposed that a Black Peoples Convention might be necessary to address crucial issues surrounding wealth creation, productivity, morality, and heritage.
'We cannot outsource that to anyone else,' he firmly stated, advocating for a community-led approach to long-term viability and cultural integrity.
Labour expert Michael Bagraim echoed similar sentiments, highlighting that South Africa has faced over three decades of diminishing returns in employment figures.
'Current policies are failing citizens miserably,' Bagraim asserted, pinpointing the last fifteen years as particularly detrimental, with many industries on the verge of collapse.
Bagraim pushed for a fundamental rethink of these policies, proposing that a collaborative dialogue between government and business could reshape the current labour landscape.
Drawing attention to the National Economic Development and Labour Council (Nedlac), he emphasised its capabilities in fostering discussions aimed at restructuring the labour legal framework: 'We already have a body that is set up especially for dialogue.'
Pointing out the changing dynamics of the economic system, Bagraim also noted that proposed amendments to the Labour Relations Act and Basic Conditions of Employment Act could be pivotal for addressing regulatory burdens.
'We need to de-regulate the small business environment,' he said, arguing that job creation was heavily reliant on the burgeoning small business sector.
As calls for deregulation and reduced government oversight intensify, Bagraim's conclusion stands stark: pursuing alternative community dialogues may merely waste time and resources, rather than bring tangible change.
DAILY NEWS
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Daily Maverick
2 hours ago
- Daily Maverick
How SA can transform promises into tangible improvements for all
South Africans want to see tangible improvements in their daily lives. They want to know whether the government is focusing on the right priorities to move the country forward. Development Indicators (DIs), produced annually by the Department of Planning, Monitoring and Evaluation, provide a strategic evaluation of South Africa's development trajectory and the impact of public policies. Aligned with its vision of being a catalyst for the country's development goals, the department produces the Development Indicators to support informed public discourse and evidence-based policymaking. This not only promotes transparency but also positions monitoring and evaluation as a tool for advancing democracy by creating space for diverse views and public engagement in assessing the country's development and exploring future scenarios. As researchers at the Harvard Centre for International Development observe, 'Policy success for whom?' is a crucial question, as perceptions of progress often vary among stakeholders. The Development Indicators 2024 provide a long-term trend analysis up to 2024 and serve as a baseline for the seventh administration to support the implementation of the Medium-Term Development Plan (MTDP) 2024-2029. The findings reaffirm the strategic focus of the Medium-Term Development Plan, of placing inclusive economic growth at the centre of government efforts. They also recognise that while the National Development Plan remains the country's long-term vision, its foundational assumptions have shifted significantly due to demographic changes including migration, the Covid-19 pandemic and global disruptions. It is therefore clear that processes for planning beyond 2030 need to be initiated. The findings are sobering. None of the high-level National Development Plan targets for reducing unemployment, poverty and inequality are currently on track to be attained by 2030. Of the 85 Development Indicators reviewed, about 13 (15%) are on track, while 31 (36%) show promising progress. Population growth has outpaced economic expansion and the recent global disruptions have necessitated revision of medium-term growth projections. The global context is that only 17% of Sustainable Development Goals targets are on track, with a third either stalled or regressing. Higher, inclusive and sustained economic growth is essential for shifting our development trajectory. We must accelerate economic reforms to surpass the 3% growth threshold if we are to meaningfully change outcomes. Inclusive growth must translate into more jobs, rising household incomes and improved wellbeing for all. To reduce household dependence on the social assistance programmes, the country must achieve stronger economic growth that will create jobs and income-generating opportunities and enable more people to participate in the economy and secure their livelihoods. Nonetheless, progress in key areas offers strategic opportunities to accelerate impact: Infrastructure development: Out of 268 priority infrastructure projects, 28 have been completed and about 80 are under implementation across sectors including energy, water, transport and housing. Budget 2025 allocates close to R1-trillion over 2024-2027, to be implemented through state-owned enterprises, municipalities, provinces, national departments and public-private partnerships. This requires both initiating new projects and maintaining existing ones. Labour market transformation: South Africa has built a more diverse labour force, with progressive labour laws advancing representation across race, gender, age and skill levels. Public employment programmes: The Presidential Employment Stimulus has provided work and livelihood support to approximately 2.2 million people since October 2020. The Expanded Public Works Programme created 923,718 work opportunities in 2024/25. Digital transformation: South Africa enjoys near-universal mobile network coverage, with the rollout of 5G gaining traction. Continued reforms in the telecommunications sector and digital public infrastructure initiatives must help to broaden connectivity and inclusion. International relations: South Africa remains an active player on global platforms such as BRICS+, the African Continental Free Trade Area, the G20 and others. Environmental sustainability: Greenhouse gas emissions remain within the country's Nationally Determined Contributions targets, and the marine and terrestrial conservation areas continue to expand. Land reform: 3 million hectares had been transferred (78.1% of the National Development Plan target). Focus must now shift to enhancing land claims processes, post-settlement support and the diversified use of land, including agriculture, tourism, housing and cultural preservation. Public finances: Gross tax revenue and compliance have improved, accompanied by sustained progress in audit outcomes at both the national and provincial levels. Education: Near-universal access to early childhood development for children aged 5-6 and basic education for ages 7-15 has been achieved, with gender parity across most educational levels. However, attention must now focus on improving school infrastructure, the quality of education and expanding the capacity of universities and Technical and Vocational Education and Training institutions to meet the growing demand and skills needs of industry. Health: Positive gains in life expectancy and reductions in maternal and child mortality point to improved health outcomes. Modernisation of the public health system and the rollout of the next phase of the National Food and Nutrition Security Plan are among the critical next steps to bring South Africa on par with its BRICS+ peers on health outcomes. Basic services: More than 80% of households have access to electricity, clean water and sanitation. Ongoing efforts aim to expand access through annual household connections, especially in under-served areas, while also ensuring quality of service delivery in local municipalities. Social protection: Expanded social assistance has helped to cushion the poor and enhance human capability. However, long-term reliance on grants must be reduced through employment-led growth. Efforts are being made to accelerate the implementation of key priorities as outlined in the Medium-Term Development Plan to build an inclusive economy and achieve National Development Plan ambitions. The Medium-Term Development Plan 2024-2029 outlines priority areas for consolidating progress while addressing persistent development challenges. Strategic interventions include: Implementing the Energy Action Plan, Digital Public Infrastructure Roadmap, and Freight Logistics Roadmap to deliver on their objectives. Modernising mining, agriculture and manufacturing, and promoting new growth sectors such as services. Enhancing export diversification and trade resilience. Leveraging international relations to attract investment, expand trade, tourism and access technology. The success of South Africa's economic growth strategy will be tested by the country's ability to maintain its status as Africa's largest economy; enhance the global competitiveness of key sectors and urban regions (e.g. Johannesburg, Cape Town, Durban); generate inclusive employment growth; and reduce long-term dependence on social support, particularly among working-age adults. Operation Vulindlela has unlocked critical reforms. The second wave of structural reforms are taking off, focusing on improving local government, expanding digital public infrastructure to broaden connectivity and inclusion, and building city regions that foster dynamic, business-friendly environments. Accelerating inclusive growth is critical to ensuring that no one is left behind. This means creating jobs, raising household incomes and improving well-being for all citizens — especially for historically marginalised groups. Achieving this requires economic redress, and equitable access to opportunities and spatial transformation, among others. Prioritising empowerment of women, youth and persons with disabilities should be central to these efforts. The Department of Planning, Monitoring and Evaluation continues to support government institutions in translating policy intentions into development results. The department does this through coordination of planning across government, monitoring of implementation and supporting performance management of ministers and heads of departments (HoDs) to hold them accountable for delivering results. Where service delivery fails, we intervene through frontline support to ensure that community concerns are swiftly resolved. We want to strengthen consequence management for poor performance and service delivery breakdowns. And we want to strengthen collaboration with social partners (business, labour and civil society) to foster a culture of service delivery excellence. DM
Daily Maverick
2 hours ago
- Daily Maverick
What does it mean to be South African? Navigating identity in a complex democracy
In a Daily Maverick webinar asking 'What does it mean to be South African?', professors William Gumede and Pierre de Vos joined Zukiswa Pikoli to delve into identity, citizenship and inclusion 30 years into South Africa's democracy. Here are 10 takeaways. 1. Defining South Africanness: A contested and plural concept The webinar highlighted that defining 'South Africanness' is contested terrain, especially 30 years into democracy. Unlike monocultural countries, South Africa's identity is plural and layered, based on multiple identities and an acceptance of difference rather than a single shared culture, language or race. 2. The Constitution as a 'civic religion' While South Africa boasts diverse cultures and languages, the Constitution and its democratic institutions serve as a common civic identity, a 'civic religion' that binds citizens together. It's seen as a crucial pillar for a country with a deeply divided past. 3. Beyond Western models of nationhood Traditional Western models of nationhood, often based on shared culture or language, don't fully apply to South Africa. The country's identity must be more embracing, incorporating the best elements of its diverse past, present, histories and cultures. 4. Addressing xenophobia and exclusion A critical concern raised is the potential for national identity to be used for exclusion, leading to xenophobia and other forms of discrimination. The discussion emphasised the need for a shared commitment and recognition of interdependence to foster a functional constitutional democracy. 5. The role of, and pressure on, the Constitution The Constitution, with its core values of human dignity, equality and freedom, is an aspiration. However, it faces immense pressure as visible inequalities persist, leading some to question whether these values are truly shared or merely promises unfulfilled. The document itself cannot act; it is about how people and institutions behave. 6. Transforming individual identity towards a broader South Africanness A significant challenge is to transform individual, narrow self-identities (e.g. based on race or ethnicity) into a broader South African identity. This requires more engagement in families, schools, workplaces and communities to foster a sense that one's specific group identity is just a piece of a larger South Africanness. 7. Cultivating empathy and solidarity across difference A crucial missing element in South Africa's nation-building project is empathy and solidarity across different groups. People tend to have empathy for those similar to them, but extending this compassion to those who 'don't look like you' is vital for a stronger common South Africanness. This needs to be actively taught and nurtured, starting in schools. 8. The peril of politicised identity The country's national identity is deeply intertwined with politics. When governance is poor, corrupt or incompetent, or when politicians exploit divisions for votes, it undermines the common South African project. There is a strong call for consequences for politicians who sow division. 9. Reimagining commemorations and recognising diverse contributions Commemorative days and national memory-making need to move beyond focusing solely on politicians or political parties. There's a strong need to memorialise the diversity of South African society, including forgotten and excluded individuals, artists, institution builders and sports stars, celebrating a broader range of contributions to the nation. 10. The importance of recognising and refining indigenous identities While recognising and bringing back indigenous identities erased by apartheid is crucial, it is equally important to critically evaluate and remove anti-democratic or anti-constitutional elements within these identities (e.g. patriarchy). The goal is to integrate the valuable aspects of indigenous identities with the constitutional value of equality. The discussion highlighted the ongoing journey of defining and strengthening South Africa's identity, emphasising the complexities of diversity, the role of foundational values and the need for active engagement from all citizens. DM
Daily Maverick
2 hours ago
- Daily Maverick
Crypto Corner: They cut the music at the altcoin party, but innovation is still pumping
If you're trying to use your crypto rather than trade it, the real question is: how should you respond to the ups and downs of a volatile market? I was going to talk about altcoins maturing and becoming more stable, predictable investments, but then the market plunged last week. XRP dropped almost 20% in a single day. Bitcoin briefly tumbled below R2.1-million. Ether was hit hard too. Yet we had started the week with analysts hyping Ethereum's institutional appeal and setting price targets for ether beyond R70,000. We even had Pokémon cards getting the non-fungible token treatment on Solana. What gives? Crypto markets are volatile – by now that's no revelation. But if you're trying to use your crypto rather than trade it, the real question becomes: how should you respond to these ups and downs? South Africans can at least rely on some market innovation on the licensed exchanges. Binance recently partnered with Peach Payments and MoneyBadger to allow crypto payments at major online merchants. Using your Binance app, you can now buy bed linen or even a spade from local stores using stablecoins, without the gas fees (transaction costs on Ethereum) or volatility. This shift from speculation to utility is important. Sure, altcoins might offer eye-watering gains during a bull run, but everyday-use cases are what will determine crypto's staying power. And it seems like that's where our local industry is leaning. Luno, for instance, announced tokenised stock trading last week, where you can invest in major US companies. So there's a lot going on. Binance Africa legal adviser Larry Cooke called the Peach Payments partnership a 'breakthrough moment' for crypto payments – and he's not wrong. With MoneyBadger already processing more than R7-million in crypto payments this year and expanding rapidly, South Africans are moving from HODLing (buy and hold or as the crypto bros would say – holding on for dear life) to spending. If the price charts make you queasy, maybe shift your focus. Use your crypto for groceries, gadgets or even municipal bills, and leave the day trading to the whales. That way, you're not just riding the waves but doing something useful: nurturing your portfolio while the market sorts itself out. DM This story first appeared in our weekly Daily Maverick 168 newspaper, which is available countrywide for R35.
