Leaked live export aid plan fuels fears funding won't help sheep farmers
The say the leaked plan "from the Canberra bubble" demonstrates the department's incompetence.
Under the Commonwealth's $139.7m live export transition assistance package, $45.5m was earmarked for sheep producers and the associated supply chain to assist them in preparing for the end of the live sheep trade in May 2028.
In 2021-22 the West Australian sheep and wool industries were worth $1.35 billion.
(
ABC Mid West Wheatbelt: Jo Prendergast
)
A leaked draft document from the Department of Agriculture, Fisheries and Forestry (DAFF), marked "confidential", is circulating within the WA sheep industry and reveals how the government is planning to distribute the money to sheep producers, truck drivers and shearing contractors.
Farmers argue that $45.5m is not enough, and the department appears to agree with its notes on the risk and sensitivities of its funding plans.
The document notes $15m to be spent developing satellite feedlots and confinement feeding may have "insufficient funds to make a strategic difference".
Under the draft plan, shearing contractors could receive $30,000 for retraining.
(
ABC Mid West Wheatbelt: Jo Prendergast
)
A department note on a plan to spend $5m to create a new long-term strategy to build confidence and shape a direction for the sheep meat and wool industries "identifies a range of potentially expensive priorities, beyond the scope of the $5m allocated".
Corrigin-based sheep producer Steven Bolt said the leaked document made him question if the government was taking the process seriously.
"It's just incompetence from the department,"
he said.
Mr Bolt said many businesses impacted by a shrinking sheep flock — such as pasture seed cleaners or ram breeders — were not considered in the report.
The document reveals producers can apply for $150,000 in grants, matched dollar for dollar, for confinement feeding.
Under the plan, sheep producers would receive a financial advice and a business planning grant of $40,000, if they had sent an average of 1,000 sheep per year for the past three years to live export.
Grants of $30,000 are planned for trucking and logistics companies and for employers of shearers, wool classers and shed hands.
"The funds that are available will never be anywhere close to enough to mitigate the damage that has been caused, or provide sustainability or growth in the industry going forward,"
Mr Bolt said.
WA Farmers president Steve McGuire.
(
ABC Great Southern: Andrew Chounding
)
'Looking for an easy solution'
WA Farmers president Steve McGuire said the planned spend did nothing to reduce risk and restore confidence in the sheep industry, labeling it a "shemozzle" from "the Canberra bubble".
"They're looking for an easy solution, but there is no easy solution, and this is what we warned them about from day dot, and they did not listen,"
he said.
"So $30,000 for a trucking company, that will buy one tipper, and the idea that shearing contractors will become agricultural employment brokers? Good luck with that."
Mr McGuire said the ability of live export to take large numbers of sheep at certain times of the year provided a risk-management tool that the government had provided no alternative to.
"Until processors offer a contract a year ahead … no-one is taking the risk away from the farmer," he said.
The wool industry is a valuable employer in regional areas.
(
ABC Mid West Wheatbelt: Jo Prendergast
)
In February, DAFF held 16 co-design workshops with industry and community across WA, where it asked for ideas on how to create confidence and profitability in the sheep industry without live export.
On its website, DAFF says industry funding programs are expected to open in July after a co-design process with regional communities and industry.
"The department is aware of the inadvertent distribution of a draft document which reflects early internal planning for one component of the phase-out of live sheep exports by sea assistance program," a department spokesperson said.
"
A range of options are still in development by the department. The document has not been provided to the government.
"
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
ABC News
4 hours ago
- ABC News
PM announces economic development plan at Garma
Prime Minister Anthony Albanese has announced funding for a new First Nations Economic Partnership, a collaboration between the Commonwealth and First Nations people.
The Advertiser
a day ago
- The Advertiser
Premier stakes leadership on national power cable deal
One of the nation's biggest energy projects has been given the green light, with a Liberal premier fighting to form government staking his leadership on the deal. The multi-billion-dollar Marinus Link cable will boost electricity transmission between Tasmania and Victoria and is seen as pivotal in increasing green energy investment. Tasmanian Premier Jeremy Rockliff signed up to the joint Victoria and Commonwealth investment contract on Friday, while in caretaker mode and a day before the deadline. Mr Rockliff has been lashed by Labor, the Greens, as well as several independent crossbenchers whose support he needs to form government, over a "sham" process. He says Marinus Link will deliver 2000 jobs and $400 million per year in extra revenue to Tasmania and that power prices will be lower than without the cable. Craig Garland, one of four independents on the cross bench, has said he won't be able to support a Liberal government over their "secret" rushed decision. It leaves the Liberals, who have 14 seats ahead of Labor's 10, with one less cross bench option to sure-up the required 18 parliamentary votes needed to govern. Non-Liberal MPs were given a confidential briefing on the project on Tuesday, while the whole-of-state business case wasn't released before the deal was signed. "If I fall because of this project ... I will know in my heart of hearts I have done the right thing by Tasmania and Tasmanians," Mr Rockliff told reporters. "This is not about me, this is not about Craig (Garland). This is about the young people in Tasmania and their kids and their grandkids. "Staking my leadership is what I do." Independents Kristie Johnston and Peter George were also critical of the process, with the latter saying Mr Rockliff was undermining the prospect of a full-term, well-run minority government. Mr Rockliff said the "deal of the century" had capped Tasmania's equity share at $103.5 million - 4.27 per cent of the project's cost. However, the business case forecasts an increase in state net debt to $19 billion in 2031/32 as a result of the project, which includes a power station redevelopment and land-based transmission line. Tasmania's major industrial customers also face "very large" increases in transmission prices, compared to a no-Marinus-Link scenario. Construction of stage one, a 750-megawatt undersea cable, is expected to start in 2026 and finish in 2030. Federal Energy Minister Chris Bowen said the project was a cornerstone of his government's commitment to reducing emissions and creating jobs in regional communities. Supporters of Marinus Link are confident the cable will lead to greater green energy investment in Tasmania, which can be exported into the national grid. Labor leader Dean Winter supports Marinus Link, but earlier this week said he was unable to back the deal on such short notice. He has given Mr Rockliff "first crack" at forming government but has also reached out to the cross bench, who he is prepared to work with to avoid going back to the polls. Tasmania's snap election on July 19, the second in two years, was called after Mr Rockliff lost a no-confidence motion critical of his budget management and infrastructure delivery. One of the nation's biggest energy projects has been given the green light, with a Liberal premier fighting to form government staking his leadership on the deal. The multi-billion-dollar Marinus Link cable will boost electricity transmission between Tasmania and Victoria and is seen as pivotal in increasing green energy investment. Tasmanian Premier Jeremy Rockliff signed up to the joint Victoria and Commonwealth investment contract on Friday, while in caretaker mode and a day before the deadline. Mr Rockliff has been lashed by Labor, the Greens, as well as several independent crossbenchers whose support he needs to form government, over a "sham" process. He says Marinus Link will deliver 2000 jobs and $400 million per year in extra revenue to Tasmania and that power prices will be lower than without the cable. Craig Garland, one of four independents on the cross bench, has said he won't be able to support a Liberal government over their "secret" rushed decision. It leaves the Liberals, who have 14 seats ahead of Labor's 10, with one less cross bench option to sure-up the required 18 parliamentary votes needed to govern. Non-Liberal MPs were given a confidential briefing on the project on Tuesday, while the whole-of-state business case wasn't released before the deal was signed. "If I fall because of this project ... I will know in my heart of hearts I have done the right thing by Tasmania and Tasmanians," Mr Rockliff told reporters. "This is not about me, this is not about Craig (Garland). This is about the young people in Tasmania and their kids and their grandkids. "Staking my leadership is what I do." Independents Kristie Johnston and Peter George were also critical of the process, with the latter saying Mr Rockliff was undermining the prospect of a full-term, well-run minority government. Mr Rockliff said the "deal of the century" had capped Tasmania's equity share at $103.5 million - 4.27 per cent of the project's cost. However, the business case forecasts an increase in state net debt to $19 billion in 2031/32 as a result of the project, which includes a power station redevelopment and land-based transmission line. Tasmania's major industrial customers also face "very large" increases in transmission prices, compared to a no-Marinus-Link scenario. Construction of stage one, a 750-megawatt undersea cable, is expected to start in 2026 and finish in 2030. Federal Energy Minister Chris Bowen said the project was a cornerstone of his government's commitment to reducing emissions and creating jobs in regional communities. Supporters of Marinus Link are confident the cable will lead to greater green energy investment in Tasmania, which can be exported into the national grid. Labor leader Dean Winter supports Marinus Link, but earlier this week said he was unable to back the deal on such short notice. He has given Mr Rockliff "first crack" at forming government but has also reached out to the cross bench, who he is prepared to work with to avoid going back to the polls. Tasmania's snap election on July 19, the second in two years, was called after Mr Rockliff lost a no-confidence motion critical of his budget management and infrastructure delivery. One of the nation's biggest energy projects has been given the green light, with a Liberal premier fighting to form government staking his leadership on the deal. The multi-billion-dollar Marinus Link cable will boost electricity transmission between Tasmania and Victoria and is seen as pivotal in increasing green energy investment. Tasmanian Premier Jeremy Rockliff signed up to the joint Victoria and Commonwealth investment contract on Friday, while in caretaker mode and a day before the deadline. Mr Rockliff has been lashed by Labor, the Greens, as well as several independent crossbenchers whose support he needs to form government, over a "sham" process. He says Marinus Link will deliver 2000 jobs and $400 million per year in extra revenue to Tasmania and that power prices will be lower than without the cable. Craig Garland, one of four independents on the cross bench, has said he won't be able to support a Liberal government over their "secret" rushed decision. It leaves the Liberals, who have 14 seats ahead of Labor's 10, with one less cross bench option to sure-up the required 18 parliamentary votes needed to govern. Non-Liberal MPs were given a confidential briefing on the project on Tuesday, while the whole-of-state business case wasn't released before the deal was signed. "If I fall because of this project ... I will know in my heart of hearts I have done the right thing by Tasmania and Tasmanians," Mr Rockliff told reporters. "This is not about me, this is not about Craig (Garland). This is about the young people in Tasmania and their kids and their grandkids. "Staking my leadership is what I do." Independents Kristie Johnston and Peter George were also critical of the process, with the latter saying Mr Rockliff was undermining the prospect of a full-term, well-run minority government. Mr Rockliff said the "deal of the century" had capped Tasmania's equity share at $103.5 million - 4.27 per cent of the project's cost. However, the business case forecasts an increase in state net debt to $19 billion in 2031/32 as a result of the project, which includes a power station redevelopment and land-based transmission line. Tasmania's major industrial customers also face "very large" increases in transmission prices, compared to a no-Marinus-Link scenario. Construction of stage one, a 750-megawatt undersea cable, is expected to start in 2026 and finish in 2030. Federal Energy Minister Chris Bowen said the project was a cornerstone of his government's commitment to reducing emissions and creating jobs in regional communities. Supporters of Marinus Link are confident the cable will lead to greater green energy investment in Tasmania, which can be exported into the national grid. Labor leader Dean Winter supports Marinus Link, but earlier this week said he was unable to back the deal on such short notice. He has given Mr Rockliff "first crack" at forming government but has also reached out to the cross bench, who he is prepared to work with to avoid going back to the polls. Tasmania's snap election on July 19, the second in two years, was called after Mr Rockliff lost a no-confidence motion critical of his budget management and infrastructure delivery. One of the nation's biggest energy projects has been given the green light, with a Liberal premier fighting to form government staking his leadership on the deal. The multi-billion-dollar Marinus Link cable will boost electricity transmission between Tasmania and Victoria and is seen as pivotal in increasing green energy investment. Tasmanian Premier Jeremy Rockliff signed up to the joint Victoria and Commonwealth investment contract on Friday, while in caretaker mode and a day before the deadline. Mr Rockliff has been lashed by Labor, the Greens, as well as several independent crossbenchers whose support he needs to form government, over a "sham" process. He says Marinus Link will deliver 2000 jobs and $400 million per year in extra revenue to Tasmania and that power prices will be lower than without the cable. Craig Garland, one of four independents on the cross bench, has said he won't be able to support a Liberal government over their "secret" rushed decision. It leaves the Liberals, who have 14 seats ahead of Labor's 10, with one less cross bench option to sure-up the required 18 parliamentary votes needed to govern. Non-Liberal MPs were given a confidential briefing on the project on Tuesday, while the whole-of-state business case wasn't released before the deal was signed. "If I fall because of this project ... I will know in my heart of hearts I have done the right thing by Tasmania and Tasmanians," Mr Rockliff told reporters. "This is not about me, this is not about Craig (Garland). This is about the young people in Tasmania and their kids and their grandkids. "Staking my leadership is what I do." Independents Kristie Johnston and Peter George were also critical of the process, with the latter saying Mr Rockliff was undermining the prospect of a full-term, well-run minority government. Mr Rockliff said the "deal of the century" had capped Tasmania's equity share at $103.5 million - 4.27 per cent of the project's cost. However, the business case forecasts an increase in state net debt to $19 billion in 2031/32 as a result of the project, which includes a power station redevelopment and land-based transmission line. Tasmania's major industrial customers also face "very large" increases in transmission prices, compared to a no-Marinus-Link scenario. Construction of stage one, a 750-megawatt undersea cable, is expected to start in 2026 and finish in 2030. Federal Energy Minister Chris Bowen said the project was a cornerstone of his government's commitment to reducing emissions and creating jobs in regional communities. Supporters of Marinus Link are confident the cable will lead to greater green energy investment in Tasmania, which can be exported into the national grid. Labor leader Dean Winter supports Marinus Link, but earlier this week said he was unable to back the deal on such short notice. He has given Mr Rockliff "first crack" at forming government but has also reached out to the cross bench, who he is prepared to work with to avoid going back to the polls. Tasmania's snap election on July 19, the second in two years, was called after Mr Rockliff lost a no-confidence motion critical of his budget management and infrastructure delivery.
Sky News AU
a day ago
- Sky News AU
Mike Pezzullo warns AUKUS will demand an ‘all-consuming' national effort and raises questions over Australia's readiness
Former Home Affairs Secretary Mike Pezzullo has issued a blunt warning about the scale and urgency of Australia's AUKUS commitments, saying the nuclear submarine programme will demand a national effort on par with Medicare. Speaking to Sky News Australia following revelations that the Department of Defence has extended its timeline for a key AUKUS review, Mr Pezzullo said the initiative must become a whole-of-society undertaking as he raises concerns about whether Australia, and its US partner, can deliver. 'In military terms, AUKUS is as big a programme relative to our military capability as Medicare is to health,' he said. 'It's like having the military version of Medicare. It's something that's got to become an all-consuming, focused effort that transcends Commonwealth, state, territory governments into industry, academia, the training pipeline through both universities and vocational educational training institutions.' The extended review is now expected to include wider consultations with the UK Government, US Congress, and other stakeholders, including industry. Pezzullo said the review would likely centre on three key concerns: Australia's readiness, US industrial capacity, and the long-term strategic implications of Australia acquiring eight nuclear-powered submarines. 'The Americans will want to assess that because if we're not ready, then they'll put an X against that or a question mark at least,' he said. He pointed to recent comments by Admiral Caudle, the incoming head of the US Navy, who told the Senate Armed Services Committee that America's submarine output must double to meet both domestic and allied needs. 'He said a 10 or 20 per cent lift in productivity will not cut it. We have to double the productivity,' Pezzullo said. 'If he's saying that, we should be concerned because it then becomes a question mark as to whether there's any available for us.' Even if production and training targets are met, Pezzullo believes the US still harbours concerns about the strategic direction of the partnership. 'The fundamental concern I think Americans really have is, are we putting all this investment in to create an autonomous, independent Australian capability that we'll never be able to jointly use, or are they willing to talk to us about that joint use?' Turning to Australia's short-term naval posture, Pezzullo flagged a critical capability gap between 2025 and 2032, when the first Virginia-class submarine is expected to arrive, arguing the government must act urgently to extend the life of the existing Collins-class fleet. 'If we can't extend Collins to get us through that seven-year gap, we've got a real problem,' he said. While some have suggested a leasing arrangement or interim acquisition, Pezzullo said a more radical solution could also be on the table. 'The more radical innovative approach is to go full Ukrainian and go for a very large fleet of uncrewed long-range, medium-range and short-range vessels to undertake missions,' he said. 'They're not as capable as a submarine but if you have lots of them, you might be able to fill the gap.'
