College fees: Students and parents feel ‘betrayed' by prospect of contribution charge rising
and their parents cannot wait until October's budget to find out how much the student contribution charge will be for the upcoming academic year, the
Dáil
has heard.
Social Democrats
TD
Jennifer Whitmore
told Minister for Finance
Paschal Donohoe
members of the public believed a promise in the programme for government about reducing college fees 'and they have been betrayed'.
Ms Whitmore was speaking as the controversy over whether students would have to pay €2,000 or €3,000 in September was raised in the Dáil for the third day running. The student contribution was €3,000 but was reduced to €2,000
as a temporary cost-of-living measure and then rolled over for two more years.
Sinn Féin justice spokesman Matt Carthy said Mr Donohoe was the fifth minister who had failed to clarify what level of fees would have to be paid. He said Taoiseach Micheál Martin, Tánaiste Simon Harris, Minister for Further and Higher Education James Lawless and Minister for Public Expenditure Jack Chambers had not been able to do so.
READ MORE
'Between you all you cannot answer the most simple question,' he said.
Mr Lawless sparked the controversy when he told RTÉ radio on Sunday that without a cost-of-living package in the budget, students would have to pay €3,000 'as things stand'. The issue has sparked divisions between Coalition partners Fianna Fáil and Fine Gael.
In the Dáil
on Wednesday, Mr Lawless said
he was 'fighting within the resources available' for 'the best possible outcome' within the budgetary process.
On Thursday, Mr Carthy said the 'same question that's being anxiously asked in kitchen tables all around the country' was whether the fee would be €2,000 or €3,000 and that an answer was needed.
Jennifer Whitmore TD: 'Families cannot budget like that.' Photograph: Sam Boal/Collins
Mr Donohoe, however, outlined that 143,000 students and their families benefit from free fees while 60,000 benefit from lower fees. He said there was further investment in student facilities and in helping to improve the quality of education.
He said 'budget by budget, we make changes that we believe are affordable' and the Government will adopt measures that are affordable, 'that we know we can fund, that we know we can build upon'.
[
Coalition sharply divided over third-level fees
Opens in new window
]
Mr Donohoe said Mr Lawless, Mr Chambers and himself 'are very clear' that following 'temporary measures' when inflation was 'so high', they were looking at 'other measures that can make a difference'.
Ms Whitmore said: 'I'm really astonished that you think it is okay to tell families, 'wait until the budget and we'll clarify matters for you'. That is four months away and families cannot budget like that.'
The Minister said 'those families also have other needs and issues' they want progress on and Government has to make affordable and sustainable decisions.
Mr Carthy called on the Minister to 'come down from your ivory tower and answer the question' about fees.
Mr Donohoe told him the difference between those in Government and Mr Carthy is 'we are interested in solutions rather than sound bites'.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Irish Times
an hour ago
- Irish Times
Student accommodation developer challenges decision to rezone land near UCD to open space
Dún Laoghaire-Rathdown Council's decision to rezone lands owned by a student accommodation developer from residential to open space was done for valid planning reasons, the High Court has been told. The council made the argument in defending an action brought by developer Colbeam Ltd, which is challenging the local authority's 2022-2028 county development plan arising from the rezoning decision. Colbeam has sought to build a 698-bed student accommodation complex at Our Lady's Grove, Goatstown Road, Dublin 14, which is about 850 metres from University College Dublin (UCD). The developer previously secured planning permission from An Coimisiún Pleanála for the development, but this decision was quashed following a separate, successful High Court challenge. READ MORE Colbeam had bought the site in 2017 from the Congregation of the Religious of Jesus and Mary for €13 million. The land – which had been part of a wider campus that includes Our Lady's Grove primary and secondary school – was zoned residential under the council's 2016-2022 county development plan, which was in effect at the time of the purchase, Colbeam has said. But before adopting the 2022-2028 county development plan, councillors adopted motions to rezone Colbeam's land from residential to open space. On Thursday, David Browne SC, for the council, said councillors adopted motions to rezone primarily for planning-based reasons. These included consideration for open space at the Our Lady's Grove campus and concerns about incremental development on that space. Colbeam has argued that councillors had regard for 'irrelevant consideration' in adopting the motions to rezone. But Mr Browne said that if the principal reason for the rezoning decision was a planning one then that was a valid decision. Mr Brown said certain remarks made by councillors in debating the rezoning motions were indicative of 'marginal' considerations in the decision to rezone and should not invalidate the decision. On Wednesday, Neil Steen SC, for Colbeam, had argued that councillors had regard for 'irrelevant consideration' in adopting the motions to rezone. One of these irrelevant considerations arose from purported comments made at the meeting by Fine Gael councillor Barry Saul, one of the members who initially proposed to rezone the land. In advancing the argument to rezone the lands, Cllr Saul referred to 'a failure of moral obligation' on the part of the Congregation of the Religious of Jesus and Mary to maintain a required level of open space on their lands, Mr Steen said. The open space requirement arose from an 'institutional land' designation. Mr Steen said Mr Saul made it explicit that part of his intention in supporting the rezoning was to address this 'failure'. Counsel said moral obligation was an irrelevant consideration in the decision to rezone. Mr Steen said his clients were entitled under legislation to a decision uncontaminated by irrelevant considerations. He said if the court found councillors took an irrelevant consideration into account in making the decision to rezone then the decision should be quashed. Mr Justice David Holland will give his ruling at later date.
Irish Times
2 hours ago
- Irish Times
Evergreen corporate taxes insulate public finances from trade turmoil
Analysts have been monitoring the Department of Finance 's monthly exchequer numbers like hawks. Any sign of a slowdown in multinational profitability as a result of US tariffs and/or a weakening global economy is likely to manifest in Ireland's corporate tax numbers. Receipts from the business tax generated a record €28 billion last year (excluding the Apple tax money) and are the reason why Ireland is running a sequence of budget surpluses instead of deficits like many of its peers in Europe. In May, corporate tax receipts fell by 30 per cent but department officials brushed off suggestions this was related to the current turmoil around US trade policy, blaming 'once-off factors' instead. READ MORE [ Public finances boosted by another spike in corporate tax receipts Opens in new window ] They were right. The June returns, which we got yesterday, show the tax channel generated €7.4 billion last month, which was €1.5 billion or 25 per cent up on the same month last year. This means that on a cumulative six-month basis, receipts are already up (on last year) by 7.4 per cent at €13.1 billion and headed for another record year-end total of close to €30 billion. Ireland, with its big multinational sector and heavy reliance on exports, is perched rather precariously in the middle of a brewing transatlantic trade war and a global retreat from free trade. But the two big sectors that drive exports and corporate tax here – pharmaceuticals and IT – are outside of US president Donald Trump's current tariff dragnet. And while Trump has threatened to impose tariffs on pharmaceutical imports and/or reduce the sector's relatively high pricing in the US, for now the industry remains highly profitable and the Irish tax numbers reflect that. The June corporate tax numbers, which reflect payments from companies with financial years ending in December (the list includes Google, Meta, Microsoft and Intel) tend to be indicative of the annual trend and the November numbers (the most important month) bode well for the public finances as a whole. 'Unless there is a sharp fall in the economy, it would be reasonably anticipated that there might be a fairly strong November figure,' the department's chief economist John McCarthy said. In an attempt to temper expectations around the seemingly evergreen corporate receipts, Minister for Finance Paschal Donohoe said he expected to see a 'decline' at some point but it could be 'a number of years away'. 'I believe we will see the growth that we've had over the last few years begin to stabilise, and I saw some evidence of that last year when we actually missed our revised corporate tax forecast for 2024 by €1 billion,' he said. His cautious outlook contrasts with that of the Irish Fiscal Advisory Council, which expects receipts from the business tax to rise by about €5 billion from 2026 onwards as additional revenue from the new minimum tax rate of 15 per cent flows in. Several big taxpayers here have also been availing of generous tax-cutting capital allowances that are due to run out, meaning they will be liable to pay more tax – another factor likely to drive receipts. Whether these bumper receipts are being put to good use is a different matter with Donohoe noting there would be €16 billion saved in the two State funds by the end of this year.
Irish Times
3 hours ago
- Irish Times
The Irish Times view on Ireland's rising population: a landmark moment
The island of Ireland, marked by exodus and population decline for most of the last 200 years, now finds itself in an era of demographic renewal. For the first time since the Famine, the population of the island exceeds seven million. This is a landmark moment, not just in statistical terms but in historical resonance. It signals a new chapter in the island's story, one that brings both promise and pressing challenges. According to a joint analysis by the Central Statistics Office and the Northern Ireland Statistics and Research Agency, the population of the island grew by 26 per cent between 2002 and 2022. That growth has been uneven: the Republic's population surged by 31 per cent, while Northern Ireland's grew by a more modest 13 per cent. The Republic now stands at just over 5.1 million people, the North at 1.9 million. These differences reveal diverging social, economic, and migratory trends. In the Republic, immigration has played a transformative role. Northern Ireland has seen slower growth, with a markedly older demographic profile. Racial and ethnic diversity has also grown more markedly south of the Border. These demographic shifts, while bringing new vibrancy and diversity, also demand inclusive policy planning, especially in education, housing and public services. Nowhere is the impact of this growth felt more acutely than in housing. In the Republic, over two million permanent dwellings exist but more than 240,000 are officially listed as unoccupied, a figure long disputed and still in need of closer scrutiny. Meanwhile, fewer than one in 10 homes are provided by local authorities or voluntary housing bodies, far below the North's 15 per cent. READ MORE The story has a spatial dimension, with some areas – Fingal in north Dublin, Castlereagh in Co Down – experiencing rapid growth while parts of Donegal and north Antrim stagnate. Managing these imbalances requires all-island strategies. The challenges ahead in housing, transport, healthcare, education, integration and sustainability cannot be resolved in silos. Too often, the island's two jurisdictions have approached common problems in parallel, sometimes at cross-purposes. The pressures of demographic expansion demand deeper co-ordination. Infrastructure, in particular, cries out for harmonisation. From the Derry-Donegal corridor to cross-border public transport, digital connectivity and energy networks, the case for North-South alignment is pragmatic, not political. Effective planning rooted in shared data and shared goals is the best defence against fragmentation and waste. Ireland has turned a demographic corner, returning to a population last seen before the trauma of the 1840s. The opportunity is clear; so too is the responsibility to meet the moment together.
