Bid to bring back pesticide in France sparks unprecedented petition
The so-called "Duplomb law" has stirred public anger for permitting a return of acetamiprid -- a chemical known to be toxic to pollinators such as bees and to ecosystems. It was adopted on July 8 but has not yet come into effect.
The legislation, named after the conservative lawmaker who proposed it, was presented in parliament as a measure to "reduce constraints" on French farmers.
But its move to bring back acetamiprid prompted a 23-year-old master's student to launch a petition against it which quickly snowballed, gathering support from many people, including actors and several leftwing lawmakers.
The French parliament's official website showed it had accumulated more signatures than any other. At 8:30pm Saturday the counter had passed 620,000.
The petition's author, Eleonore Pattery, who describes herself as "a future environmental health professional", called the new law a "scientific, ethical, environmental and public health aberration".
"It represents a frontal attack on public health, biodiversity, the coherence of climate policies, food security, and common sense," she said.
- A 'bee killer' -
Acetamiprid has been banned in France since 2018, but remains legal within the European Union.
The insecticide is particularly sought after by beet and hazelnut growers, who say they have no alternative against pests and face unfair competition.
On the other hand, beekeepers have described the chemical as "a bee killer".
Its effects on humans are also a source of concern but, in the absence of large-scale studies, its risks remain unclear.
The petition calls for the "immediate repeal" of the law and a "citizen-led consultation involving health, agricultural, environmental and legal stakeholders".
Petitions do not in themselves trigger a review or repeal of the legislation but unprecedented public support may prompt renewed parliamentary discussion on the matter.
Under French rules, if a petition reaches 500,000 verified signatures, the National Assembly may choose to hold a public debate limited to the content of the petition itself.
In late June, before the law's passage, several thousand demonstrators — including farmers, environmental organisations and scientists — rallied across France calling for the bill to be withdrawn.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Citizen
3 hours ago
- The Citizen
Parliament fire: Over R500m already spent as restoration project now expected to cost R4.4bn
The reconstruction of Parliament is expected to be completed in late 2026. Smoke billows out of the National Assembly building after the fire at Parliament on 2 January 2022 in Cape Town. Picture: Gallo Images More than R500 million has already been spent on repairing Parliament after a fire in 2022, with the total cost of the reconstruction project now projected to reach R4.4 billion. This was revealed during a meeting of the joint standing committee on the financial management of parliament on Friday. MPs received updates on the investigation into the fire that destroyed parliament, which was not insured, as well as progress made in the ongoing restoration efforts. The Development Bank of South Africa (DBSA) provided detailed briefings on the restoration process, while officials from the auditor-general's office dealt with the financial management of the project. Sections of the National Assembly and Old Assembly buildings suffered major damage during the fire on 2 January 2022. The reconstruction is expected to be completed in late 2026 following delays that have extended the original deadline. Zandile Mafe, who admitted to starting the fire and was charged with terrorism and arson, was declared unfit to stand trial in December 2023. Parliament fire: Restoration progress Chuene Ramphele, DBSA group executive for infrastructure delivery, said during the meeting that work was initially stalled as the parliamentary site was treated as a crime scene and secured by police. 'Technically, the work actually started in March 2023,' he told the joint committee. Ramphele said that significant progress had been made since work officially began, including the construction of 155 offices for MPs on Plein Street. 'At this stage, our focus is primarily on the refurbishment,' he said. ALSO READ: Macpherson accused of being 'weak' after saying he's being sidelined over Parliament fire He said that demolition works were completed in March 2024 and came in under budget at R73 million, saving R2 million in the process. Due to design changes and necessary statutory approvals, the initial R2 billion budget had risen. 'When we concluded the detailed designs, you'll see that we started to be very sure of what are the detailed costs,' Ramphele said. 'After the final approval and the designs, the budget for both the refurbishment of the National Assembly and Old Assembly buildings amounted to R3.6 billion.' Watch the meeting below: Ramphele also said the DBSA is applying a risk-monitoring approach to minimise the impact of unforeseen challenges, such as bad weather, given the tight timeline. The revised total budget includes R900 million allocated for upgrading the information and communications technology (ICT) infrastructure. National Assembly construction Ramphele said that Raubex Construction was awarded a R2.27 billion contract to work on the new National Assembly wing. 'The site was handed over in April after having appointed [the company] in December 2024,' he said. He noted that the delay was caused by difficulties in obtaining a construction permit from the department of labour. READ MORE: Parliament quietly reclaims its power 'We could not start if we did not have the construction permit and also making sure that the occupational safety issues are intact to avoid any issues because our biggest risk that we want to mitigate is to ensure there is no fatality on the site or any particular kind of incident.' Ramphele told the committee that guarantees are in place to manage the contractor's performance in case of failure to deliver. 'Other things about the project contract management in place is how we are going to manage the penalties and the penalty regimes that are going to apply in that regard.' Timelines At the moment, work is focused on the basement and structural foundations, including support pillars for two additional floors and a new roof structure. 'At this point in time, the work is happening underground,' he said, adding that 'we want a climate resilient Parliament'. Ramphele said that once the three basement levels are complete, the team will begin construction of the first through sixth floors, including beams and slabs. READ MORE: Parliament allocates R71m for medical aid for former MPs This phase will take approximately 12 months, with the project expected to reach 40% completion by April 2026. Interior finishes – including flooring, toilets, offices, committee rooms, the public gallery and a banquet hall – will require another 18 months, pushing projected progress to 75% by September 2026. Ramphele said the full restoration of the new National Assembly is expected to be completed within 20 months. 'At that point, we will be looking at commissioning the building. In particular we are looking at November 2026. So at that time, the building will be practically complete.' Old Assembly restoration According to Ramphele, a contractor for the Old Assembly building was appointed last month. The R1.3 billion project is expected to take 18 months. Ramphele confirmed that the site has already been handed over to the contractor. He concluded with an update on the overall cost of the parliamentary restoration. 'So far, we have already spent, with what has been happening and what we have done, R574 million. 'Ultimately, the entire programme of Parliament is at a cost of around R4.4 billion with the major items being the National Assembly and Old Assembly.' NOW READ: Reconstruction of Parliament to finally begin – will include gym, sauna and daycare centre
The Star
7 hours ago
- The Star
Minister Gayton McKenzie insists Kenny Kunene was 'set up' in DJ Sumbody murder case link
Ex-convict turned politician Gayton McKenzie, the leader of the Patriotic Alliance, insists his former inmate and party deputy president Kenny Kunene was 'set up' after he was found at the home of DJ Sumbody's alleged killer. 'If there's a murder that happened and there are only two suspects, me and Kenny, I must be the main suspect. You know, Kenny could've had a gun, had a fly,' McKenzie said on the sidelines of the National Assembly in Cape Town on Wednesday afternoon. 'That guy has such a soft character. Let me tell you, the mistake with him - that's my fight with him always - is that he's too accessible. You call Kenny and ask, 'Where are you?' He says, 'I'm in the squatter camp; there's a party going on.' Next time, 'I'm in the suburbs meeting someone.' He's never at home. He's always busy, and he's accessible.' McKenzie, who also serves as Minister of Sports, Arts and Culture and met Kunene while the two were in prison years ago, strongly defended him, maintaining Kunene had no involvement and was likely 'set up.' 'But I can tell you, man, he doesn't believe it was a setup, but I do…He says to me, 'No, no, it wasn't a setup. It was pure coincidence.' I said to him, 'You were there during the time of the arrest.' I have no proof, but I can't say for a fact - I just have a gut feeling.' He said only a proper investigation can prove what really happened. 'People must also know we've worked very hard to rebuild our reputation coming from jail. We've worked very, very hard. We will never - and I'm speaking for Mr. Kunene - we will never risk that by associating with these guys, even if they did this thing,' McKenzie said. 'If they are guilty... I was just looking at this thing - one gun killing ten people.' 'These are images from the crime underworld. Why would we even mix with criminals? I know about crime. When I heard that one gun killed ten people, I already knew we were dealing with crime figures.' 'I want to congratulate the cops again - I'm glad they caught them, and you will not find me or Mr. Kunene in the company of such people. What happened was very unfortunate,' he added. McKenzie added that a law firm to investigate Kunene's involvement would be announced on Friday. On Tuesday, McKenzie also defended Kunene after he was found at the home of the alleged mastermind behind DJ Sumbody's murder, saying that 'he is innocent and has got nothing to hide.' Speaking in a Facebook Live session on Tuesday night, McKenzie said he had spoken to Kunene on Monday while he was in Namibia and was assured Kunene had done nothing wrong. 'He said, 'Yeah, I went there.' He was supposed to meet someone, and that person told him to meet at that house and sent a location pin. It was his first time at the house,' McKenzie said. He said Kunene told him he did not know the owner of the house, identified as Sandton businessman Katiso 'KT' Molefe, who was arrested on Monday in connection with the 2022 murder of DJ Sumbody, whose real name was Oupa John Sefoka. 'When he got there, they were just sitting... He doesn't know Molefe,' McKenzie said. 'He knows the other guy who sent the location pin. The police came, told everyone to get on the floor. Kenny complied.' According to McKenzie, police asked Kunene if he knew Molefe. However, Kunene said he did not and explained someone else had sent the location. Police searched his phone and found no communication with Molefe, McKenzie said. 'They came back and said, 'Kenny, we're sorry. Here's your phone. You can leave,'' he added. IOL News previously reported that Kunene later confirmed that he was at Molefe's house at the time of the arrest. He said he was there with a young journalist from his media company to allow Molefe to respond to the murder allegations. McKenzie said he received several calls from journalists asking whether he believed Kunene's version of events. '100%, I do. I believe in him 100%. Let me tell you who Kenny Kunene is. People think Kenny is my friend. Kenny was my friend - he's now a brother to me.' McKenzie added that Kunene inspired him to turn his life around in prison. 'Kenny is the godfather of my children. I'm the godfather of his. I don't even hang out with Kenny... he's a socialite; I'm not. But I know Kenny, and I know he's not a violent person.' He also claimed that Kunene admired DJ Sumbody and other deejays. 'He loved DJ Sumbody. He had nothing to gain by being involved in such a thing. That's not him,' McKenzie said. 'I personally think he was set up. Kenny doesn't believe that, but I do. I can't prove it yet, but this thing smells like a setup.' McKenzie has since announced that he placed Kunene on a 30-day leave of absence from his role as MMC and from all party duties pending the outcome of the internal investigation. 'It's the hardest thing I've ever had to do - ask Kenny Kunene to step aside. But the party must always come first. No one is bigger than the party.' He said a team of independent lawyers would be appointed to probe Kunene's presence at Molefe's home, with findings expected within 30 days. 'This is a serious allegation. Even though I believe he's innocent, the matter must be thoroughly investigated,' McKenzie said. Kunene's visit came just as there was a major breakthrough in the DJ Sumbody murder case. On Tuesday, the Alexandra Magistrate's Court granted the state a seven-day postponement in the case involving four men charged in the November 2022 triple murder. The accused, Michael Pule Tau, Tiego Floyd Mabusela, Musa Kekana, and Molefe, face charges of murder and conspiracy to commit murder for the deaths of DJ Sumbody and his bodyguards, Sibusiso Mokoena and Sandile Myeza. Prosecutors said the postponement was necessary to investigate new leads following the suspects' arrests across Gauteng earlier this week. [email protected] IOL Politics
The Star
7 hours ago
- The Star
MK Party calls for secret ballot in no-confidence vote against Ramaphosa
Thabo Makwakwa | Published 2 hours ago The uMkhonto weSizwe Party (MK Party) has formally requested that the upcoming motion of no confidence against President Cyril Ramaphosa be decided by a secret ballot to safeguard Members of Parliament (MPs) from potential reprisal. On Friday, the party's parliamentary leader, Dr John Hlophe, wrote to National Assembly Speaker Thoko Didiza, urging her to exercise discretion in allowing MPs to vote confidentially. In his letter, Hlophe emphasised the importance of privacy in such a critical vote, citing constitutional principles and judicial precedents. 'A secret ballot will ensure that Members of Parliament can exercise their constitutional duty freely and without fear of intimidation or reprisal,' he stated. 'This is particularly important given the sensitive nature of the motion and the potential political consequences for individual members.' According to Hlophe, the MK Party's request is rooted in the 2017 Constitutional Court ruling in United Democratic Movement v Speaker of the National Assembly, which affirmed that the Speaker has the discretion to permit a secret ballot, guided by constitutional principles of accountability, transparency, and individual conscience. 'Justification for a secret ballot includes protection against intimidation, safeguarding the integrity of the voting process, and ensuring that the outcome accurately reflects the will of the Members,' Hlophe wrote. The motion, submitted last week, accuses President Ramaphosa of failing to address soaring crime rates, economic mismanagement, and lapses in national security. The party also claims that Ramaphosa's leadership has eroded public trust and allowed the country to unravel. Recent allegations by KwaZulu-Natal Police Commissioner Nhlanhla Mkhwanazi, who accused political interference within law enforcement agencies, have fuelled the controversy. In light of these revelations, the MK Party opposes Ramaphosa's decision to retain Police Minister Senzo Mchunu, who has been placed on leave amid ongoing investigations. The party contends that the president's move undermines the independence of law enforcement and jeopardises public confidence. Furthermore, the MK Party has challenged Ramaphosa's decision in the Constitutional Court, contesting his move to place Mchunu on special leave and the appointment of Professor Firoz Cachalia as acting Police Minister. In the letter, Hlophe urged the Speaker to consider the constitutional and judicial precedents. 'We kindly request that this submission be considered in line with the Constitution, the Rules of the National Assembly, and relevant judicial precedents. We further request that the Speaker consult with relevant stakeholders and decide on this matter at the earliest opportunity, given the urgency of the motion.' [email protected] IOL Politics
