Impractical to expect manufacturers to reshore to US, says biz group
PETALING JAYA : Malaysian manufacturers should not be expected to shift their production to the US to avoid newly imposed tariffs, a key business group has said.
In a statement to FMT, the Malaysian International Chamber of Commerce and Industry (MICCI) described the proposal, associated with US president Donald Trump, as impractical for most local firms.
While large multinationals with deep capital reserves and global footprints may benefit from it, MICCI said such a move would pose a major obstacle for small and medium enterprises (SMEs), the backbone of Malaysia's industrial sector.
It said that setting up production in the US would create substantial cost pressures, including through higher labour and raw material expenses, as well as foreign exchange risks, given the strength of the US dollar against the ringgit.
'For many businesses, the compounded effect of these factors could easily outweigh any tariff relief and undermine business sustainability,' the statement said further.
'It is simply not a commercially viable solution for most Malaysian manufacturers.'
The group stressed that relocating production is a complex, long-term investment that requires careful evaluation of supply chain readiness, customer proximity, access to skilled labour, and long-term cost stability.
Instead, MICCI urged the government to strengthen Malaysia's trade position through diplomatic engagement with the US.
It also called for greater support for local manufacturers via incentives for digitalisation, automation and export market diversification.
On July 7, the US announced a 25% tariff on Malaysian goods effective Aug 1. In a letter to Prime Minister Anwar Ibrahim, Trump said the tariff was necessary to address the 'unsustainable' US trade deficit with Malaysia, which he described as a threat to the US economy and its national security.
Pointing out that no tariffs would be imposed if Malaysian companies chose to manufacture in the US, Trump promised to fast-track approvals to facilitate relocation to US shores.
However, the Small and Medium Enterprises Association of Malaysia (Samenta) urged policymakers and businesspeople not to place too much emphasis on Trump's suggestion, adding that national policy should not be dictated by foreign political cycles.
Samenta chairman William Ng told FMT that Malaysian businesses should instead focus on building resilience, scalability, and long-term competitiveness, rather than reacting to 'policy short-termism'.
He acknowledged that co-investments and strategic partnerships with US entities may make sense for selected large firms and high-margin producers.
Such businesses should receive government backing on a case-by-case basis, he said, especially if they result in job creation or technology transfers that benefit Malaysia.
'But I can't think of many Malaysian brands or products that would thrive under such arrangements. This highlights the urgent need for us to innovate and move beyond being mere assemblers,' he said.
'For the vast majority of Malaysian manufacturers, especially SMEs, relocation is not a viable option. Costs for raw materials, labour, compliance and land are far higher in the US.
William Ng.
'Even with the 25% tariff, Malaysia still holds a significant cost advantage. At most, we might consider shifting operations to countries with lower tariffs, but only if we believe these reciprocal tariffs will persist beyond the current US administration.'
Ng called for Malaysia to speed up trade diversification efforts, especially through under-utilised free trade agreements, like the Regional Comprehensive Economic Partnership and Comprehensive and Progressive Agreement for Trans-Pacific Partnership.
He said the current tensions should serve as a wake-up call for Malaysia to reduce reliance on a single export market and to strengthen its domestic manufacturing base.
'The heavy-handed way in which the tariffs are being imposed sends a worrying signal to exporters—especially our SMEs and mid-tier firms that depend heavily on the US market—that it's time to diversify, and quickly,' said Ng.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Sun
24 minutes ago
- The Sun
China eyes new measures to boost economy
BEIJING: China has a 'plentiful' toolbox to avoid an economic slump in the second half of the year, its commerce minister said yesterday as he admitted it faced a 'very severe and complex situation'. Growth hit 5.2% in the second quarter, official data showed Tuesday, but analysts have warned that more must be done to boost sluggish domestic consumption as exports face the knock-on effects of global trade turmoil. Retail sales rose far less than expected last month and were much weaker than May, suggesting efforts to kickstart consumption have fallen flat. 'We are still facing a very severe and complex situation. Global changes are unstable and uncertain. Some of our policies will offer some new responses according to the times and circumstances,' Wang Wentao told journalists at a news briefing. 'Our toolbox is plentiful, and we will be fully prepared.' Asked specifically about China's reliance on exports, Wang suggested the government was preparing policies to 'further stimulate the momentum of our consumption development'. 'China's economy is improving, and the long-term fundamentals have not changed, the consumption market's characteristics of great potential, strong resilience and vitality have not changed,' he said. Wang also namechecked Beijing-based toymaker Pop Mart, whose Labubu monster dolls have become a must-have item internationally, adorning the handbags of celebrities such as Rihanna and Dua Lipa. 'We are also promoting new forms of consumption... for example Pop Mart, these kinds of new trends, new fashions and styles... the Labubu phenomenon has swept the world,' he said. Beijing is battling to shift towards a growth model propelled more by domestic demand than the traditional key drivers of infrastructure investment, manufacturing and exports. That desired transformation has become more urgent since Donald Trump came to office. The US president has imposed tariffs on China and other key trade partners, disrupting trade norms and threatening Beijing's exports at a crucial time for its economy. The two superpowers have sought to de-escalate their row after reaching a framework for a deal at talks in London last month, but observers warn of lingering uncertainty. Wang said yesterday that despite 'storms and rain', Washington remained an important trading partner. Even though China-US trade has declined proportionally for each country, overall bilateral trade has remained stable, Wang said. In a sign of progress, US tech giant Nvidia said this week that it would resume sales of its H20 artificial intelligence chips to China after Washington pledged to remove licensing restrictions that had halted exports. China's commerce ministry acknowledged the US decision in a statement yesterday afternoon, even as it called for Washington to 'abandon its zero-sum mentality'. Nvidia CEO Jensen Huang has met with Chinese leaders this week in Beijing, telling journalists Wednesday that his firm was 'doing our best' to serve the country's vast semiconductor market. – AFP
Malaysian Reserve
24 minutes ago
- Malaysian Reserve
US to impose steep anti-dumping duty on battery material from China
WASHINGTON — The United States unveiled on Thursday preliminary anti-dumping duties of 93.5 percent on imports of a key battery component from China, after looking into a petition on the matter. Final determinations regarding duties on graphite are expected in early December, according to the US Commerce Department. Its investigation came after a petition by the American Active Anode Material Producers, an ad-hoc coalition including US graphite producers, late last year. Graphite is an important raw material used in making anodes of batteries, and China is a dominant player when it comes to its processing capacity of graphite. The duty could raise temperatures in the global electric vehicle supply chain, potentially adding to costs for automakers who rely on the material for production. The products covered under the investigation includes active anode material, whether or not they are contained in finished batteries. China and the United States are now engaged in negotiations about their broader economic relationship after reaching a framework for a deal last month, stepping back from the brink of a spiraling trade war. Asked about the new graphite duties, Beijing's foreign ministry said Friday that 'the essence of China-US economic and trade cooperation is mutual benefit and win-win results'. 'It is hoped the US side will conscientiously abide by the rules of the market economy and maintain the healthy and stable development of China-US economic and trade relations,' spokesman Lin Jian said. The US Commerce Department's notice came after Washington took aim at solar imports from Southeast Asia as well earlier this year. Since returning to the White House in January, President Donald Trump has also separately targeted sector-specific imports with tariffs, including 50 percent duties on imported steel and aluminum, alongside other levies on autos. — AFP
The Sun
24 minutes ago
- The Sun
Japan's SMEs ready to adapt to Trump tariffs
TOKYO: Small and medium-sized firms (SME) like Mitsuwa Electric that form the backbone of Japan's economy have weathered many storms over the decades, and company president Yuji Miyazaki is hopeful they will also withstand Donald Trump. As part of a campaign against friend and foe, the US president has threatened 25 % tariffs on imports of Japanese goods from Aug 1, having already imposed tough levies on its vehicles, steel and aluminium. However, Miyazaki told AFP that he was confident. 'We are providing very specialised products for specialised industries, where it is difficult to change suppliers or supplying countries just because of boosted tariffs,' he said on a tour of the 92-year-old firm. 'I'm not worried too much, because if American companies can't produce parts on their own, they have no choice but to import those parts regardless of tariffs,' the descendant of the firm's founder said. With 100 employees, Mitsuwa Electric is not a household name. But like millions of other SMEs that account for 99.7 % of Japan's companies, it is world-class in its specialist niche. It began making light bulb filaments and now produces coils, rods, needles, plates, pipes and wires for a range of goods including car lights, photocopiers and X-ray machines. In 2022, it won a Guinness World Record for the smallest commercially available metal coil, with a diameter around half that of a human hair. Mitsuwa's customers are across Asia, Europe and North America and include Japanese engineering giant Toshiba and Toyota-affiliated parts maker Koito Manufacturing. Miyazaki said the impact of US tariffs on the company's business is limited so far, with one auto sector customer asking it to lower prices. 'All we can do is to adapt to any changes in the business environment,' Miyazaki said. Prime Minister Shigeru Ishiba has sent his tariffs envoy Ryosei Akazawa to Washington seven times since April to try to win relief from the tariffs. US Treasury Secretary Scott Bessent was due to meet Ishiba and Akazawa yesterday in Tokyo. But the prime minister's apparently maximalist strategy of insisting all tariffs are cut to zero have been criticised in some parts, especially as Aug 1 approaches. US-bound exports of Japanese vehicles – a sector tied to 8% of Japanese jobs – tumbled around 25% in May and June. The lack of a deal isn't helping Ishiba's popularity ahead of upper house elections on Sunday that may end Ishiba's premiership after less than a year. What bothers Japanese firms is Trump's unpredictability and the complexity of the tariffs, according to government-backed SME support organisation Jetro. Since February, the group has received more than 2,000 enquiries from members about US tariffs, with a flood of requests since June asking for 'the latest information' as the deadline approaches. Mitsuwa Electric boss Miyazaki admits worrying about Trump's threat of pharmaceuticals tariffs of 200%, or if medical equipment is targeted. He said that its wide product range and diverse customer base have protected it so far. This is also vital for other firms to survive, said Zenkai Inoue, an SME expert and professor at the Kyushu Institute of Information Sciences. 'I'm proposing a 'tricycle strategy', which means you have to have (at least) three customers in different regions,' he told AFP.
