logo
We will pay a heavy price for messing up the national grid

We will pay a heavy price for messing up the national grid

The result: a bewildering confusion of complex regulatory measures, inter-business contractual arrangements, short and long-term energy bidding, Contracts for Difference and system planning by politicians instead of independent engineering experts. All create Byzantine complexity, plus rich pickings for lawyers, accountants and speculative investors. It is very bad for consumers. It has also resulted in the death of the UK's electrical engineering industry employment, as the new owners procure plant from outside the UK.
With the necessary requirement to eliminate CO2 emissions and rely on remote, weak, intermittent generation resources and energy storage, all financed by private capital, the system complexity and supply insecurity has increased, as have costs for consumers. All three will continue increasing. Not only will the populace have to endure increasing energy costs, they will have to suffer the psychological consequences of the associated landscape destruction and the increased chance of blackouts, rolling load-shedding and/or voltage reduction.
Sadly, the UK national grid "silver tea set" was sold and it is very unlikely we could ever afford to buy it back again.
Norman McNab, Killearn.
Read more letters
Go local with our democracy
I note with interest your front page lead story on Friday ("Angry, anxious Scots say no to 'strong man' politics", The Herald, April 25) and thank you and the Electoral Reform Society for summarising and quantifying what many Scots feel.
Every year our council leader, senior members of their team and the supporting civil servants do a round of the six wards that make up North Ayrshire Council. The objective is to share good news from the past year and plans for the future. That it is a good thing. The bigger objective is to highlight the inevitable large funding gap for the next year's council budget. Apart from agreeing how tough it must be, the ward audience can offer no meaningful suggestions on how to manage this six-ward council budget.
What better way to 'bringing power closer to our communities' than by identifying the council budget at the ward level, by population to start with? Show local people how money is being spent in their name, in their ward, as a first step. Then create structures that empower them to decide how 'local' priorities are set and money spent to deliver them.
Arran is the only one-ward island in Scotland and an excellent place to start this experiment. We have a locally developed and managed Island Plan, supported by the local and national government. Participatory budgeting and an active community council: all the ingredients to create a ward or island assembly are there. This would establish local priorities and the budget to deliver them. This goes a long way to making sure that as your report says, 'what comes next must ensure decisions are made closer to the people they affect'.
It does not have to happen all at once, but "Scotland in Miniature" could offer a model to engage the 'unheard and disempowered'. In any event, it is worth a try.
Tom Tracey, Brodick.
• I note with interest the Electoral Reform Society survey.
Consider the last nine months since the new Labour Government came to power with promise of change and all the pledges from the party north of the Border that it would defend Scotland at Westminster. To date there is no evidence of that to report; however it can be noted that Scottish Labour MPs have fallen into line behind the PM and Chancellor who are going after the vulnerable and pensioners.
A new Labour Government continuing the cost of living crisis with increases in energy costs, increases in employers, National Insurance and austerity cuts; is it any wonder the general public are disillusioned and angry?
Catriona C Clark, Falkirk.
Why does even Iceland do better?
In questioning why support for Scottish independence has remained high (and in fact is now apparently growing again), Michael Sheridan (Letters, April 23) conveniently ignores the fact that since 2014 Scotland has been taken out of the European Union by Westminster and, in spite of claims to the contrary, our oil and gas resources have not run out (in fact we now have considerably greater access to our vast energy resources, although regrettably this is not reflected in the UK pricing mechanism). In the meantime, the United Kingdom has become increasingly broken – democratically, economically and socially.
In addressing Mr Sheridan's rhetorical questions I would pose some questions of my own that would dispose entirely of his arguments that Vladimir Putin would wish for Scotland to achieve independence in a new constitutional referendum. Would Mr Putin wish the UK to remain isolated from Europe or prefer an independent Scotland to further strengthen and possibly embolden the European Union? The United Kingdom did not substantially honour its commitment to Ukraine under the Budapest Memorandum (1994) when Russia invaded Crimea (2014) and in failing, along with the United States, to take significant action proved not to be a 'last bastion' of support. Would Mr Putin have real cause to think that the UK would act differently in future, unless the United Kingdom itself was to fundamentally change?
Flying kites is a diversionary pastime but if we wish to seriously debate Scotland's constitutional future we should perhaps first consider why other small countries, and even relatively tiny Iceland, can make better progress in advancing the wishes and aspirations of their peoples than a country manipulated for the benefit of the British Establishment by a Westminster Parliament out of touch with the wishes and aspirations of the people of Scotland.
Stan Grodynski, Longniddry.
This is not independence
Why do those who write in support of Scotland leaving the UK and joining instead the EU persist in trying to pull the wool over our eyes by misidentifying that as gaining 'independence"? In reality it would involve our sovereignty passing from Westminster to Brussels, so where is the independence in that? To clarify its intentions, a step in the right direction for the SNP would be for it to rename itself as the STP (Sovereignty Transfer Party), but I won't be holding my breath.
I was an enthusiastic supporter of the original concept of the European Common Market, but not the ever-closer political union which some empire builders seem determined it must become.
Alan Fitzpatrick, Dunlop.
Jamie Greene (Image: Scottish Parliament)
A task for Jamie Greene
Jamie Greene's recent defection to the Lib Dems, while retaining his role as the deputy convener of the Public Audit Committee, will perhaps help to focus the parliament on some of the bread and butter matters fixable without major legislative changes.
To mention but two of these matters: public money paying for paracetamol prescriptions is not value for money and is fixable, and burdening small businesses in Business Improvement Districts (BID) with taxes above 4% of their non-domestic rate is fixable.
Lib Dem compatriots south of the Border will be aware of English BID guideline limits, resulting in most levies being 1%-2.5% of non-domestic rate. In Scotland it is limitless. And levies can go wild. In Alloa town centre, the majority of businesses pay the highest BID levies in Scotland. There is no opt-out, so a tiny unit can be charged as much as 300%. And as a local tax it has to be paid.
With oversight of the Public Audit Committee, as well as influence on the Government's programme, there is a glimmer of hope that this political switch by Jamie Greene will help to resolve some real bread and butter issues.
Daphne Hamilton, Alloa.
Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

Huge blaze breaks out in Scots city centre causing road chaos amid anti-Trump protests
Huge blaze breaks out in Scots city centre causing road chaos amid anti-Trump protests

Scottish Sun

time35 minutes ago

  • Scottish Sun

Huge blaze breaks out in Scots city centre causing road chaos amid anti-Trump protests

Locals have been urged to avoid the area and keep their windows and doors closed CITY CENTRE FIRE Huge blaze breaks out in Scots city centre causing road chaos amid anti-Trump protests Click to share on X/Twitter (Opens in new window) Click to share on Facebook (Opens in new window) A HUGE blaze has broken out in a Scottish city centre, sparking road chaos as hundreds of protesters gather for anti-Trump protests. Emergency crews raced to a property on Jeffrey Street in Edinburgh this morning. Sign up for Scottish Sun newsletter Sign up 6 Crews raced to Jeffrey Street in Edinburgh this morning Credit: Alan Simpson 6 A fire broke out inside a property on the street at 11am Credit: Alan Simpson 6 The fire sparked road chaos as anti-Trump protestors gathered in Edinburgh Credit: Getty The alarm was raised after the Scottish Fire and Rescue Service (SFRS) received reports of a dwelling fire shortly after 11am. Three fire engines and a high-reach appliance scrambled to tackle the blaze in the Holyrood area. Firefighters are currently at the scene as they work to extinguish the flames, and police have shut down surrounding roads. Luckily, no one has been killed or injured as a result of the blaze. However, fire chiefs have urged nearby locals to keep their windows and doors closed as smoke billows into the sky. Everyone has been urged to avoid the area as crews deal with the incident. The fire has caused road chaos across the city centre as hundreds of protesters gather for a mass anti-Trump rally during the president's visit. Many have taken to the streets in both Edinburgh and Aberdeen to voice their opposition to Donald Trump's visit to Scotland. Angry campaigners are listening to speeches and waving creative signs as the American leader enjoys a round of golf at his luxury Turnberry resort. The group that gathered in the citywere seen waving banners with anti-Trump slogans. Donald Trump tees off at luxury Turnberry course during Scots visit One demonstrator even photoshopped a photo of the president's face onto a cartoon devil with horns. A SFRS spokesperson told STV News: 'We were alerted at 11.09am on Saturday, July 26, to reports of a dwelling fire at Jeffrey Street, Edinburgh. 'Operations Control immediately mobilised three appliances and a high reach appliance to the scene, and crews remain on scene as they work to make the area safe. "No casualties have been reported. 'Members of the public have been advised to avoid the area and residents to keep windows and doors closed to prevent smoke inhalation.' Police Scotland confirmed they are assisting fire crews in the area. 6 Luckily, no one was injured as a result of the blaze Credit: Alan Simpson 6 One demonstrated photoshopped the US President's head onto a cartoon devil Credit: Reuters

Hundreds of protesters gather in Scots cities for mass anti-Trump rallies as president golfs at luxury Turnberry resort
Hundreds of protesters gather in Scots cities for mass anti-Trump rallies as president golfs at luxury Turnberry resort

Scottish Sun

timean hour ago

  • Scottish Sun

Hundreds of protesters gather in Scots cities for mass anti-Trump rallies as president golfs at luxury Turnberry resort

Angry campaigners turn out as the American leader enjoys a round of golf at his luxury Turnberry resort DON YER BIKE Hundreds of protesters gather in Scots cities for mass anti-Trump rallies as president golfs at luxury Turnberry resort Click to share on X/Twitter (Opens in new window) Click to share on Facebook (Opens in new window) HUNDREDS of protesters have gathered in Aberdeen and Edinburgh for mass anti-Trump rallies during the US President's visit to Scotland. Angry campaigners are listening to speeches and waving creative signs as the American leader enjoys a round of golf at his luxury Turnberry resort. Sign up for Scottish Sun newsletter Sign up 8 Angry campaigners gathering in Aberdeen 8 An anti-Trump demonstrator holds a cut-out depicting the president Credit: Reuters 8 Protestors gather on the streets of Edinburgh Credit: Getty 8 Stop Trump Scotland protest at the Union Terrace Gardens in Aberdeen Credit: PA In Aberdeen, the group that gathered in the city centre were seen waving banners with anti-Trump slogans - with one demonstrator even dressed as the president with a large papier mache head. Some members of the crowd also showed their support for Palestine, waving Palestine flags. Many carried placards referring to the expletive slogan made infamous by late comedian Janey Godley during the president's 2018 visit. Mr Trump and staff were braced for the mass protests as the American leader displayed his skills on the Ailsa course this moring. He could be seen wearing a USA white baseball cap as he smiled and waved at news cameras. Earlier this morning a large number of police and military personnel were spotted searching the grounds at the resort where Mr Trump is staying. A high-profile security operation was in full swing, with police and others searching the area. Police also have road closures in place, with limited access for locals and members of the media. Last night Mr Trump was in high spirits as his Air Force One touched down at Prestwick. He landed in Scotland in party mood after revealing his plans for a trade deal celebration with Prime Minister Sir Keir Starmer and First Minister John Swinney. Donald Trump tees off at luxury Turnberry course during Scots visit Mr Trump said: "We're going to do a little celebrating because we get along very well." He was welcomed by Scottish Secretary Ian Murray before being whisked to his luxury Turnberry resort 20 miles down the Ayrshire coast. He declared: "There's no place like Turnberry. It's the best course in the world." Villagers waved as the convoy passed through nearby Kirkoswald and later arrived at Turnberry at around 9.30pm. Mr Trump's vehicle passed a small group of protesters on the way to the hotel. Sources told The Scottish Sun protesters would have no chance of getting near Mr Trump despite fears they could storm the resort via the shore. 8 Donald Trump waves to reporters as he plays golf at his Trump Turnberry golf course 8 Trump takes a swing on the Ailsa course Credit: AP 8 One demonstrator even dressed as the president with a large papier mache head

Protests start in Aberdeen amidst Donald Trump visit
Protests start in Aberdeen amidst Donald Trump visit

The National

timean hour ago

  • The National

Protests start in Aberdeen amidst Donald Trump visit

PROTESTS against US president Donald Trump have started in Aberdeen with Scottish Greens MSPs in attendance. Demonstrators have gathered in Union Terrace Gardens with various placards, including several pointing out his previous friendship with disgraced paedophile financier Jeffrey Epstein. See some pictures from the protest below as Scots voice their anger over the president's four-day visit to his Turnberry and Menie estates. (Image: Nick Forbes/PA Wire) (Image: Nick Forbes/PA Wire) (Image: Nick Forbes/PA Wire)Scottish Greens MSP Maggie Chapman spoke at the demonstration, where she took a stance against Trump's comments on the genocide in Gaza and his general politics. "We say 'no' to the genocide in Palestine, and we say 'no' any politician who says that their politics has to be built on hate, has to be built on division, and has to be built on enriching the billionaires while the majority of the rest of the world starve', Chapman said. 'Not in our name. Never in our name. That is why we are here today.' Trump arrived at Prestwick Airport on Friday evening before heading to the Turnberry estate in South Ayrshire. He is expected to visit his Menie estate before opening a new course dedicated to his mother, Mary Anne Macleod, who was raised on the Isle of Lewis. READ MORE: Trump International to receive £180k from Scottish Government for tournament Lewis residents have also taken a stance against the convicted felon, with vintage and home décor store Lewis Revival displaying a banner reading 'Shame on you, Donald John', signed by locals and tourists alike. The business, based just miles away from his mother's birthplace, previously displayed the banner in March after Trump's meeting with Ukrainian president Volodymyr Zelenskyy, though it was subsequently removed by the local council. Elsewhere, protests have started in Edinburgh outside of the US Consulate. Scottish Greens co-leader Patrick Harvie and MSP Ross Greer are set to attend the demonstration in the capital, after the party issued fresh calls for Trump's finances to be investigated by the Scottish Government through an Unexplained Wealth Order.

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into a world of global content with local flavor? Download Daily8 app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store