logo
Utah lawmakers vote to say farewell to fluoridated drinking water

Utah lawmakers vote to say farewell to fluoridated drinking water

Yahoo22-02-2025
A controversial bill to prohibit the introduction of fluoride into public drinking water systems in Utah passed the Senate Friday and is destined to become a new law if Gov. Spencer Cox signs it.
HB81 by Rep. Stephanie Gricius, R-Eagle Mountain, would zap the injection of fluoride, derived from hydrofluorosilicic acid, into drinking water. As a concentrate in its undiluted form, hydrofluorosilicic acid is classified as a hazardous, poisonous material. While it contains fluoride, it also contains arsenic, lead, copper, manganese, iron and aluminum. It is a byproduct from phosphate mining operations.
That chemistry debate came up Friday prior to the Senate's passage of the bill on a 18-8 vote.
Sen. Todd Weiler, R-Woods Cross, argued that fluoride is a naturally occurring mineral and tests show that many communities exceed the dosage amount of injected water systems of .007 parts per million recommended by the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency.
That dosage, however, is under review given a California federal court decision on the issue.
'I don't really have a dog in the fight whether we fluoridate our water or not, but I'm not sure I'm comfortable with the legislature telling Salt Lake City, Brigham City, Helper and Davis County that their local authorities can't do what their residents have voted to do, so that's why I'll be voting no,' he said.
Both Davis and Weber counties have previously voted to introduce fluoride into drinking water by a vote of the citizens, as has Brigham City.
But Senate Majority Leader Kirk Cullimore, R-Sandy, emphasized the bill allows people to go to a pharmacist to get fluoride supplements for dental care.
'This bill does not prohibit anybody from taking fluoride in whatever fashion they want. It just disallows people who do not want fluoride from having to consume fluoride in their water,' he said.
Cullimore's district envelopes Sandy which had a disastrous overfeed of fluoride in 2019.
In that incident, the well's pump was operational, and when an alarm went off and was cleared, the fluoride pump began to work, discharging the fluoride. Because it is 20% denser than water, it displaced the water and was fed by gravity into a portion of the drinking water system.
Residents began to complain as early as Feb. 6 in 2019, when a resident was informed by the public utilities department that it was a water softener problem. The resident, however, didn't have a water softener at the home.
The Utah Division of Drinking Water was notified Feb. 8 and told the city to expand what it was sampling for and the geographic area as well.
In testimony before Sen. Lincoln Fillmore, R- South Jordan, stressed a number of factors.
'My response to those would be that there is a difference between medicated fluoride that is added to water, and the element fluoride that occurs naturally because it exists in our world. All medications come prescribed at a dose. Right? You take Tylenol, you're taking one pill, you are getting 200 milligrams. And you know, any prescription you get you're going to get, you're going to have so much. This is what is right that's judged by medical professionals for your condition. That is not possible when what you do is add medication to a universal good that everyone has immediate access to, but that nobody is drinking the same amount.'
Supporters of the bill pointed out that it is the only 'medication' added to drinking water.
The bill has faced stiff opposition from dental professionals who argue it has been key to improving dental health in children. While getting a prescription may seem easy at first glance, they have emphasized it places undue burdens on communities.
The bill passed 18-8 in the Senate after passing the House. It is up to the governor on what happens next.
Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

Trump signs rescissions bill clawing back foreign aid, NPR and PBS funding
Trump signs rescissions bill clawing back foreign aid, NPR and PBS funding

CBS News

time20 minutes ago

  • CBS News

Trump signs rescissions bill clawing back foreign aid, NPR and PBS funding

Washington — President Trump signed legislation to claw back $9 billion in foreign aid and public broadcasting funding, the first time in decades that Congress has approved a president's request to rescind previously approved funding. White House spokesperson Harrison Fields said Thursday that the package was "officially signed." Both the Senate and House passed the legislation, known as a rescissions request, in overnight votes last week before a July 18 deadline. Each chamber ran into different hurdles in getting it over the finish line ahead of the deadline, after which the funds would have had to be spent as Congress originally intended. The bill targets roughly $8 billion for foreign assistance programs, including the United States Agency for International Development, or USAID. The package also includes about $1 billion in funding cuts for the Corporation for Public Broadcasting, which supports public radio and television stations, including NPR and PBS. Though all but two Republican senators ended up supporting final passage in the upper chamber, some said they had reservations about doing so, especially because they had not received details from the administration about how the broader cuts would impact specific programs. Two major points of contention were funding for a global AIDS prevention program and radio and broadcast stations in rural and tribal areas, which play a critical role in communicating emergency alerts and other information to residents. The final version of the package removed $400 million in cuts to the President's Emergency Plan for AIDS Relief, also known as PEPFAR, in an effort to appease some critics. The administration promised to find funding elsewhere to alleviate the cuts to the rural stations to win over others. Two House Republicans also opposed its passage in the lower chamber. Republicans said they expect it will be the first of multiple packages to claw back funding that they have characterized as "waste, fraud and abuse." Any future request is sure to spark another battle with lawmakers, some of whom have criticized the legislative body for giving up its budget oversight and ceding to the president's demands.

Bipartisan senators seek to prevent Trump from cutting EPA science research office
Bipartisan senators seek to prevent Trump from cutting EPA science research office

The Hill

time22 minutes ago

  • The Hill

Bipartisan senators seek to prevent Trump from cutting EPA science research office

A bipartisan Senate appropriations bill seeks to prevent the Trump administration from cutting the EPA's scientific research office. Text of the appropriations bill, which advanced 26-2 on Thursday, was not immediately available. However, a summary posted online states that the bill 'requires EPA to maintain its Office of Research and Development to ensure cutting-edge research, such as research into the risks from hazardous chemicals like PFAS or contaminated water, continues.' This bipartisan pushback comes as the Trump administration said last week that it wants to eliminate the EPA's Office of Research and Development (ORD). It did announce previously that it wanted to create a different science office known as the Office of Applied Science and Environmental Solutions (OASES). OASES will be within the office of the administrator while ORD is its own office within EPA. Critics of this restructure have warned that it creates the potential for more bias and political influence in what should be independent science. The Trump administration has billed the changes as improving 'the effectiveness and efficiency of EPA operations.' Every year, Congress needs to pass an appropriations bill to fund the government. Doing so requires at least some degree of bipartisan consensus because of the Senate's 60-vote threshold to clear the filibuster. It's not entirely clear whether this provision or any others will remain in a bill that ultimately passes, as both the House and the Senate need to agree. However, its inclusion in the bipartisan Senate legislation shows it has a strong chance of passing. In addition, the Senate proposal appears to reject some cuts proposed by the Trump administration. It also maintains funding levels at the National Park Service, where the Trump administration has proposed 30 percent operations and payroll cuts. A Senate aide told The Hill that the bill includes requirements for staff to carry out the mission of the agency, but does not have an explicit minimum staffing level. Senators rejected an amendment from Sen. Martin Heinrich (D-N.M.) that would require the Interior Department, National Park Service and Forest Service to maintain 2020 staffing levels in a 15-14 party-line vote.

Insurance Commissioner John King suspends campaign for U.S. Senate
Insurance Commissioner John King suspends campaign for U.S. Senate

Yahoo

timean hour ago

  • Yahoo

Insurance Commissioner John King suspends campaign for U.S. Senate

Georgia's Insurance Commissioner is stepping out of the race for U.S. Senate, saying he sees 'little path forward to the nomination.' John King announced in May that he was going to join the ever-growing list of Republicans looking to unseat current Democratic Sen. Jon Ossoff. In a statement posted to social media, King announced on Thursday that he was suspending his campaign. 'I've spent my entire life in the arena as a lawman, soldier, and first Hispanic elected statewide in Georgia, and I'm not done yet. I'm running for re-election as Insurance Commissioner to finish the job I started six years ago, and I'm going to do everything I can to keep Georgia's state offices red,' King said. King served in the US Army National Guard and later became an officer with the Atlanta Police Department and the Doraville Police Department. TRENDING STORIES: Hulk Hogan dies at 71 Rapper GloRilla arrested after drugs found in her metro Atlanta home during burglary GloRilla's attorneys say it's 'unbelievable' she was arrested after burglars broke into her home Doraville promoted King to its chief of police, a role that he served for 17 years. Kemp appointed King as Georgia Insurance Commissioner when former commissioner Jim Beck was removed in 2019. He won re-election in 2022, becoming the first Hispanic statewide elected official in Georgia history. King said he will back whoever wins the Senate Republican nominee, 'who supports President Trump's agenda.' U.S. Rep. Buddy Carter is the top Republican candidate at the moment running in the race. U.S. Rep. Mike Collins appears to be close to announcing his run in the race. Whoever wins the nomination will take on Ossoff, who already has amassed a large war chest for his campaign. Ossoff has raised over $10 million for the quarter and has more than $15 million in the bank, according to Newsweek. Carter has raised just over $1 million, along with a $2 million loan, and ended the quarter with about $4 million. King had only raised $520,000 and ended the quarter with $450,000 in his coffers.

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into a world of global content with local flavor? Download Daily8 app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store