‘Ceasefire Saved Pakistan's Skin': Amrullah Saleh On Operation Sindoor Vs Operation Bunyan-Un-Marsoos
For the first time, said Saleh, India shredded the notion that terrorists are separate from terrorist backers and thus targeted both
Afghanistan's Acting President-in-Exile Amrullah Saleh has decoded for CNN-News18 India's Operation Sindoor vs Pakistan's Operation Bunyan-un-Marsoos in the recent military confrontation between the two countries.
'Realising the stalemated status or irrelevance of the UNSC, India didn't seek to request sympathy from the 5 of 1945. Operation Sindoor clearly demonstrated a strong sense of self-confidence and real strategic autonomy and sovereignty," he said.
For the first time, said Saleh, India shredded the notion that terrorists are separate from terrorist backers and thus targeted both.
The notion that certain powerful rogue officers of the Pakistani State authorise terrorist attacks was also shredded, he added.
'This is a new paradigm. Another type of deniability must be invented," Saleh said. 'There was a battle going on and a war being planned. In the midst of the battle, Pakistan negotiated for a loan from the IMF, which surprisingly approved it."
It matters because, most likely, Pakistan isn't fit enough to finance a war but has capabilities to engage in battles, he said. A war can't be won with IMF loans anyway, Saleh said.
'The strategic patience and cultural restraint have a limit. That limit was tested on April 22 by the Lashkar-e-Taiba terrorists. Perhaps they wanted what followed," said Saleh. 'They didn't benefit from their adventure, though. Perhaps they wanted to humiliate India publicly." Pakistan seems to be mentally stuck in 2008, he added.
'Size matters. Every inch of Pakistan was within reach. I always thought the Nur Khan airbase was the best-defended base in Pakistan. It isn't," he said.
The garrison town of Rawalpindi is the heart of Pakistan's military, and its best-known airbase was hit, Saleh pointed out.
'Pakistan lost the monopoly over Islamic fatwa. The Indian Ulema presented a fatwa of their own to their own government," he said. 'Thus, the religious dimension always exploited by Pakistan to earn sympathy from the Muslim Ummah evaporated. Deoband is located in India, by the way."
Keeping secrets in a democratic society is next to impossible, but very little leaked out of India, which shows enormous skills in adhering to principles of operational silence and public unity to assist in the safeguarding of secrets, said Saleh.
'I have seen very little or no visuals from Operation Bunyan-un-Marsoos to comment on," he said. 'Seemingly, it never took off the way it was propagated. The ceasefire saved Pakistan's skin. Pakistani military leadership has made statements and claims over their own achievements, but the Indian skies remained open, flights weren't cancelled, and I haven't seen visuals of missiles landing in Delhi or Amritsar."
Watch India Pakistan Breaking News on CNN-News18. Get breaking news, in-depth analysis, and expert perspectives on everything from geopolitics to diplomacy and global trends. Stay informed with the latest world news only on News18. Download the News18 App to stay updated!
First Published:
May 11, 2025, 17:47 IST
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Indian Express
16 minutes ago
- Indian Express
China begins construction of world's biggest dam over Brahmaputra in Tibet
China on Saturday formally started the construction of the USD 167.8 billion dam over the Brahmaputra river in Tibet, closer to the Indian border in Arunachal Pradesh. Chinese Premier Li Qiang announced the start of the construction of the dam at a ground-breaking ceremony in the lower reaches of the Brahmaputra river, locally known as Yarlung Zangbo, at Nyingchi City, official media reported. The ceremony took place at the dam site of Nyingchi's Mainling hydropower station in Tibet Autonomous Region, state-run Xinhua news agency reported. The hydropower project, regarded as the biggest infrastructure project in the world, raised concerns in the lower riparian countries, India and Bangladesh. The project will consist of five cascade hydropower stations, with a total investment estimated at around 1.2 trillion Yuan (about USD 167.8 billion), the report said. According to a 2023 report, the hydropower station is expected to generate more than 300 billion kWh of electricity each year – enough to meet the annual needs of over 300 million people. It will primarily deliver electricity for external consumption while also addressing local demand in Tibet, which China officially refers to as Xizang. Representatives from various organisations, including the National Development and Reform Commission and the Power Construction Corporation of China and locals attended the ceremony, the report said.
Time of India
16 minutes ago
- Time of India
No One Can Dictate: VP Dhankhar Reacts on Operation Sindoor Lesson, Asserts India's Sovereignty
Vice President Jagdeep Dhankhar delivered a fiery message during his address to Indian Defence Estates Service (IDES) officer trainees, making strong remarks on Operation Sindoor. Without naming Pakistan directly, Dhankhar referred to Bahawalpur and Muridke, known terror hubs, as the sites of targeted actions. He declared that India had 'taught its lesson' and that Operation Sindoor continues with strategic restraint. He emphasized that India remains a land rooted in peace and nonviolence but will never tolerate terrorism. Calling out external narratives, Dhankhar reminded the gathering that no power on earth can dictate India's sovereign decisions. His speech sends a strong message of India's military resolve backed by moral conviction. #jagdeepdhankhar #operationsindoor #jagdeepdhankhar #indiafirst #bahawalpur #muridke #nationalsecurity #indianarmy #indiasovereign #ides #defencespeech #indiandiplomacy #toi #toibharat #bharat #trending #breakingnews #indianews Read More
The Hindu
16 minutes ago
- The Hindu
Arrest of Indian fishermen lays bare uneasy Delhi-Dhaka ties
For the second time in the past one year, Bangladesh has detained Indian fishermen, official sources said on Saturday (July 19, 2025). The development is being viewed by policymakers as a growing 'absence of understanding' between the two sides against the backdrop of a seemingly uneasy relationship between Dhaka and New Delhi. The latest incident took place during the intervening night of July 14 and 15 when 34 Indian fishermen in two trawlers — FB Jhor and FB Ma Mangal Chandi — were apprehended by Bangladesh authorities near the Mongla port. 'As soon as information about the incident was received, our High Commission in Bangladesh took up the matter with Bangladeshi authorities through diplomatic channels seeking immediate consular access. We are constantly pursuing the matter for facilitating the safe and early return of all the fishermen along with their boats,' said an official dealing with the matter. On October 8, 2009, Bangladesh initiated an arbitration to settle the maritime boundary dispute with India, and, in 2014, a settlement was reached through the Permanent Court of Arbitration. But though the maritime boundary was decided, lack of visible markers meant fishermen often strayed across the agreed line in the Bay of Bengal. India and Bangladesh arrested 185 fishermen in the winter of 2024 as bilateral ties plummeted following the overthrow of the Sheikh Hasina government on August 5, 2024. On January 5 this year, these individuals were exchanged when 95 Indian fishermen were handed over by Bangladesh authorities to the Indian Coast Guard. In response, India returned 90 Bangladeshi fishermen on the same day. As a matter of convention, both sides had an understanding that fishermen would have to be protected as they had no means to detect the invisible maritime boundary. Such fishermen who crossed the boundary after the settlement of 2014 would often get detained but as part of an 'unwritten understanding' supported by political leaders on both sides, these individuals would be quickly released as prolonged detention hurts economic prospects of fishermen in this region. However, the incidents of apprehension of fishermen are being interpreted by policymakers as a sign that the earlier 'unwritten understanding' regarding fishermen is no longer being respected. The Hindu was told that Bangladesh is applying the law in a 'stricter' manner which is leading to largescale and prolonged detention of Indian fishermen.
