
Boy died of sepsis after call handler said condition wasn't life-threatening
Kayleigh Kenneford called 111 on the evening of July 7 2022, because her three-year-old son Theo Tuikubulau was unwell.
For the previous 36 hours, he had been gradually getting sicker and sicker with a high temperature, flu-like symptoms, breathing difficulties and was reluctant to drink or eat.
He had already been admitted and discharged from Plymouth's Derriford Hospital the previous day with a suspected upper respiratory infection.
Devon coroner's court has heard that 999 calls to the South West Ambulance Service Trust and to the 111 service use different pathways for grading emergencies.
The ambulance trust's Advanced Medical Priority Dispatch System (AMPDS) graded Theo's breathing difficulties as a category one on July 6, while the 111 service's NHS Pathway ranked similar symptoms as a category two the following day.
Ambulance took 90 minutes
This meant crews took 90 minutes to reach Theo after Ms Kenneford first phoned for an ambulance shortly before 11pm on July 7.
Theo was taken back to Derriford – arriving shortly after 1am – where he died a few hours later from sepsis, caused by an 'invasive' Strep A infection.
Jon Knight, head of emergency operations at the South West Ambulance Service Trust, had reviewed the 111 call and was asked what would have happened if it had been made to his employers.
'My belief is based on the trigger phrase that the patient was fighting for breath at the time, it would have triggered a [category one] through the AMPDS system,' he said.
Mr Knight said he was dealing with 'hypotheticals' as to how quickly a category one ambulance that night would have reached Theo.
'It is really hard to commit to a time,' he said.
'It certainly would have been quicker than 90 minutes, would be my belief.
'I think with the right set of circumstances – if you didn't have an ambulance available in the area and you were bringing one from Derriford Hospital – you are probably looking at 30 minutes.'
'Manage patient expectation'
Louise Wiltshire, assistant coroner for Devon, asked Mr Knight about the evidence of Ms Kenneford in which she said she was told by the 111 call handler an ambulance would not be long.
'What I can tell you is within the training with our own service, we would not ask or allow our colleagues to give people average or any sort of indication of ambulance response time,' he replied.
'What we say to patients is: 'An ambulance has been arranged for you. It will be with you as soon as possible. If your condition changes or worsens in any way, call us back immediately.'
'We try to manage patient expectation in that way and give them a very clear instruction to call us back, regardless of timescale.'
Mr Knight told the inquest that having reviewed documents relating to Theo's care that evening, the ambulance crew recognised he was seriously unwell and immediately took him to Derriford Hospital.
'I think the crew made all the appropriate and correct decisions in their decision to leave the scene and take Theo to hospital,' he said.
The hospital was also alerted in advance that the ambulance was coming and staff were waiting for him, Mr Knight said.
'I absolutely support all of the decision-making that was made at the time,' he added.
'Could have come in 30-33 minutes'
Andrew Morse, representing Theo's family, suggested if the call on July 7 had been assessed as a category one then he could have potentially arrived at the hospital by 11.45pm.
'On balance, given the testimony I've already given to the coroner, I think that that's a reasonable assumption,' Mr Knight replied.
The inquest heard there was a paramedic crew who could have reached Theo within 33 minutes had his call been graded as category one.
Megan Barker, Mr Knight's deputy, said: 'At best guess, if we compared that to the resource that did go approximately an hour-and-a-bit later, it would have taken them around 30 to 33 minutes to get to Theo.
'We can guess that they would have spent a similar amount of time with Theo, so likely have had a hospital arrival time of about 30 minutes later.
'That puts us around maybe 12.10am.'
Hashtags

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles


BBC News
36 minutes ago
- BBC News
'Hardline' BMA blocks emergency pleas for strike doctors to work
NHS bosses have criticised the British Medical Association for its "increasingly hardline" approach in rejecting emergency requests for striking doctors in England to return to work.A system known as 'derogation' is in place whereby the NHS can ask for resident doctors, who are taking part in a five-day walkout, to cross the picket line where patient safety is at of Sunday evening, 18 requests by hospitals for derogations had been rejected in this strike - the twelfth in the long-running pay dispute - with nine BMA said while it was ready to respond to emergencies, poor planning and the push to continue non-urgent care in this strike had stretched staffing too much. However, NHS England accused the doctors' union of putting safety at risk, criticising a "remote BMA panel" for "second-guessing" doctors on the ground who were trying to look after patients.A central committee of senior BMA doctors makes decisions on each derogation England said it was particularly worried about a number of requests relating to cancer care being turned it said the BMA was sitting on some requests for hours, with some rejected because hospitals would not pay striking doctors premium rates to come back this strike started, the BMA had only agreed to five derogations during the whole dispute. 'Rigorous' Among the requests agreed was a doctor to work at Nottingham City Hospital's neonatal intensive care unit over the BMA members were also brought in to work a night shift at the Northern General in the BMA rejected a request by Milton Keynes Hospital for a doctor to carry out prostate cancer checks. In that case the BBC understands a doctor did return to work under their own volition.A BMA spokesman added: "It remains our position that this agreement will be available for the NHS to rely upon should a safety-critical, urgent event occur."That process is there day and night throughout industrial action, and we remain ready to respond to any emergency requests."However, we need to be clear that the purpose of this agreement is not to facilitate the continued delivery of non-urgent care at the same time as senior doctors are covering for residents taking industrial action, as trusts simply do not have enough senior doctors to do that safely."NHS England sources said it was particularly disappointed with the rejections as the national organisation was now vetting every request from hospitals to ensure a consistency in approach between different request, they said, was based on "rigorous assessment"."We absolutely recognise the legal right for people to strike, but we also recognise that it's essential to maintain as many services for patients as possible," they five-day strike by resident doctors is due to run until 07:00 on Wednesday morning.


The Sun
36 minutes ago
- The Sun
Mum's shock after learning real reason behind ‘unbearable' gum pain and the signs to look out for
A MUM was left surprised after her unusual dental complaint turned out to be a sign she had started the menopause. Angela Cook, 49, started to experience "unbearable" gum pain whenever she ate and couldn't understand why. 1 The mother-of-one endured "intense" gum ache, particularly around her molars, when eating hard or chewy foods. Enjoying her favourite treats – humbug sweets, sugar cane and apples – was "impossible", and soon eating everyday meals became just as agonising. Given the nature of the problem, she visited a dentist – opting to go private and was told the discomfort was likely due to ageing. Angela had been experiencing typical menopausal symptoms such as hot flushes and mood changes 12 months prior to this in 2021 – at the age of 45, but she hadn't made the connection. It was only when she happened to overhear a discussion on the radio about menopause and gum health that everything "clicked into place" – and she realised she was going through the menopause. She shared her story after a poll of 1,000 women yet to go through menopause, commissioned by CanesMeno, found 19 per cent consider it to be a mystery. Signs of ageing There are 50 recognised signs of the ageing process - including dental problems, a symptom 89 per cent aren't aware can develop during the climacteric. Hormonal fluctuations, particularly a drop in oestrogen during menopause, can cause gums to become inflamed, bleed and ache, according to experts. Determined to find a solution, Angela started researching online for possible treatments and came across "gum massaging" on YouTube ≠ gently rubbing the gums underneath each tooth with her fingers after flossing, once a day. She started doing it daily in June 2022 and noticed an "instant difference". Angela, a psychologist from Banbury, Oxfordshire, said: "I never had any tooth or gum problems before the menopause – dentists would tell me how healthy my teeth were. "So, this was a massive surprise. "It left me in great pain and apprehensive about eating food that had to be chewed, so I was desperate for anything that would help take away the pain I was in, even if it was a little. "I felt relieved when I came across the radio segment – I didn't feel so alone.' Fiona Phillips opens up about the heartbreaking real reason behind marriage troubles after 'blaming menopause' Due to the massaging, over time, her symptoms gradually improved, and Angela still massages her gums weekly to maintain her gum health and prevent flare-ups. While she still experiences occasional aching, the episodes are far less frequent and no longer dominate her life. She also still experiences hot flashes, "few and far between", as well as occasional night sweats. 'The risk of gum ache curbs my cravings' Angela, married to Matthew Cook, 57, a builder, and mum to daughter, Dee, 14, said: "I still experience aching from time to time, but not so much. "I miss eating humbug sweets and sugar cane, but the risk of having the gum ache, like before, curbs my cravings." It comes after further research by CanesMeno of 1,000 females who are going or have been through menopause found 52 per cent didn't feel prepared for the ageing process. With 52 per cent of all women polled – both those who have and haven't experienced the ageing process believing more needs to be done to educate women on it. Similarly, 48 per cent think the wider public needs to be better educated on the topic, while 35 per cent wish they'd been taught about menopause at school, university, or college. Carried out through OnePoll, the study found 21 per cent of everyone polled believes the menopause is a taboo subject. And 75 per cent of those who have gone through the ageing process admitted they avoided talking about their symptoms with others. Angela added: "It wasn't until I heard it discussed openly that I realised it was even a thing. It made me feel validated – there was a reason for what I was experiencing.' A spokesperson for CanesMeno, which has launched a training programme to educate Boots pharmacists on the signs of the menopause, said: 'It's still somewhat of a mystery for many women – perhaps even for those who have experienced it. 'People will have their perceptions of what they think the menopause is, but it impacts those going through it many ways, way beyond what they might expect. 'And this study highlights some of these ways – sadly there is a bit of a knowledge gap and we want to change that.' When does the perimenopause start? The perimenopause is a natural stage of life. In most people it will happen naturally between the ages of 45 and 55 and last for a few months to several years. It can even last a decade or more. During the perimenopause, your hormone levels change and your ovaries start to produce fewer eggs. Once you haven't had a period for 12 months or more, you've officially reached the menopause. Some people start experiencing the perimenopause before they are 40. This can be as a result of medical treatments, such as surgery to remove the ovaries, but sometimes there's no cause. If you think you're experiencing the perimenopause before you're 40 then you must speak to your doctor. Source: Bupa


Daily Mail
an hour ago
- Daily Mail
Skincare lovers are scrambling to buy the 'BEST antioxidant on the market' - now 20% off in sitewide sale
Daily Mail journalists select and curate the products that feature on our site. If you make a purchase via links on this page we will earn commission - learn more Some of the most talked about skincare products on the market have been slashed in price thanks to the Skin Rocks Summer Sale. The Skin Rocks most recent launch, The Hyperpigmentation Serum sold out almost immediately, with jaw-dropping before and afters and clinically proven results. But you don't have to wait until it comes back to kick-start the best skin of your life. Skin Rocks The Antioxidant, 30ml If you're looking to target visible signs of premature ageing and if you've overdone it in the sun and are starting to see signs of hyperpigmentation, the Antioxidant is for you. Clinically proven to prevent premature ageing and defend your skin, The Antioxidant is more than your bog-standard vitamin CA. Powered by highly effective antioxidants, this helps shield your skin from environmental damage and UV light for luminous and healthy skin. £56 (save £14) Shop Having won over 10 industry awards and with over a whopping 13,000 five-star reviews, this is a skincare line that's worth every bit of the hype. And with 20 per cent off sitewide, there's never been a better time to shop. Founded by skincare expert and aesthetician Caroline Hirons, Skin Rocks has become one of the most trusted beauty brands in the industry, known for its clinically-proven formulas and expert advice. Cutting through the noise when it comes to skincare, Skin Rocks has become a trusted destination for skincare that actually works with guidance that's clear and concise. If you're not sure where to start then you can rest assured that the internal team that includes facialists, biochemists and chemists have made all winners. Bestsellers from Skin Rocks include The Antioxidant which is clinically-proven to decrease the appearance of red spots in four weeks. And you can it (and more) with 20 per cent off thanks to the sitewide sale. Skin Rocks The Moisturiser, 50ml If your skin is looking dull, then perk it up with this dry skin busting moisturiser. With ingredients such as pro-vitamin D3, ceramides, hyaluronic acid and squalane, this deeply hydrates whilst the whipped texture feels lightweight on the skin. £46.40 (save £11.60) Shop Skin Rocks Retinoid 1, 30ml From targeting fine lines to breakouts, the Retinoid 1 can kick your skincare up a gear. An entry-level vitamin A serum, the gentle serum is a great one for those who have never used a retinoid or have reacted badly in the past. Helping to boost skin clarity and promote a smooth, even and radiant skin tone, this is well worth adding to your lineup. £52 (save £13) Shop Skin Rocks The Support Oil, 30ml Dry, sensitive skin with redness? Enter the Support Oil. The Support Oil is a nourishing, gentle oil with jojoba, macadamia and sunflower oils blended in a 100 per cent plant-derived pure squalane-based formula. If you're skin is playing up then this will help soothe and plump in equal measure. £48 (save £12) Shop Skin Rocks The Gentle Acid, 150ml If you're looking to feel more confident going makeup-free this summer, then you can tackle discolouration, dullness and uneven skin tone with the brand's AHA + PHA Exfoliating Acid Toner. A powerful yet gentle, hydrating exfoliating toner has been designed to help leave your skin looking smooth, radiant and even. A serious glow giver, use in either the AM or PM, up to three times a week. £39.20 (save £9.80) Shop