National Development Plan shows the Government is about to bet big on capital expenditure
infrastructure and capital projects by 2030
, and another €175 billion in the five years after that, the
Coalition
is betting heavily that it can achieve a step-change in addressing the infrastructure deficit that has developed in recent years.
If that deficit is the biggest problem facing the State – and the Coalition say constantly this is so – then the Government is planning to solve the problem by throwing a ton of money at it.
Tuesday's announcement
adds more than €30 billion to previous plans, promising a surge of investment, especially in the areas of water, energy infrastructure and housing. A further €175 billion is due to be spent by 2035, though much of that will fall to the next government to make those final decisions.
[
National Development Plan: €275bn to be spent over next 10 years, with housing receiving biggest boost
Opens in new window
]
Spending money – or promising to spend it – is in itself no guarantee of success. Past performance is evidence enough of that.
READ MORE
As
Tánaiste Simon Harris
acknowledged, the real test will be the Government's capacity to deliver the projects within something like the timescale envisaged. 'Our watchword,' said Harris, 'must be delivery … We have to say to [Government] agencies, 'get on with it'.'
But experience suggests this is easier said than done. However, the ability to ensure that Government and its agencies deliver those projects expeditiously now becomes a critical issue for this Coalition.
It has mortgaged its future on transforming the State's infrastructure, especially housing. But those housing units are visible and countable: if the Government fails to deliver 50-60,000 a year, there will be nowhere to hide.
Do Sinn Féin need to change tack after slump in the polls?
Listen |
38:36
In private,
Taoiseach Micheál Martin
has reportedly expressed impatience with the system's failure to move more quickly in response to decisions of its elected leaders. But there is nobody in Irish politics with deeper or broader experience of the system than Martin. Success or failure of the Government – and perhaps his legacy as Taoiseach – depends on his ability to get the machine to produce results. It is a formidable task.
It is complicated by factors outside the Government's control. Chief among them is the uncertain international environment. The European Union and United States stand on the brink of a trade war that has potentially serious consequences for our economy and those corporation tax revenues which will bankroll much of the planned building spree.
Launching their summer economic statement, barely an hour after the National Development Plan announcement, Minister for Finance Paschal Donohoe and Minister for Public Expenditure Jack Chambers admitted that their budget plans would have to be rewritten if US president Donald Trump's 30 per cent tariffs – or anything like that – take effect.
The two men promised a budget package of €9.4 billion in October – a number that means sharp reductions to the recent growth in current spending budgets (but growth all the same). But then they immediately said that number may change if the conditions change. Here's the budget, they said – for now, anyway. This is the world we live in.
Martin, Harris, Donohoe and Chambers were united and unambiguous on one thing: if budgets come under pressure, they will trim current spending growth to safeguard capital budgets.
The principle is a laudable one: taking short-term pain for long-term gain. But what if that short-term pain comes in the shape of severely constrained spending on welfare, pensions, public services and increased taxes?
In recent budgets, the Government was able to cut taxes, increase spending, save money and still run surpluses. That happy era is coming to an end. Tougher choices will soon be unavoidable. With them comes tougher politics.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Irish Examiner
26 minutes ago
- Irish Examiner
The Mick Clifford Podcast: Unpacking the lacking National Development Plan with Louise Burne
The National Development Plan (NDP) review was launched earlier this week to an underwhelming response. An update of the previous plan, the review takes into account the Apple tax escrow fund the Government was eager not to claim, and promises a focus on providing infrastructure essential for housing delivery. Along with the Summer Economic Statement, both announcements this week make a statement about the forthcoming fiscal period, but without clarity on Trump's potential tariff plans—what does it all mean? Standing in for Mick this week, Opinion Editor Deirdre O'Shaughnessy speaks to Political Correspondent Louise Burne about the figures, the ambitions, and the lack of detail at the heart of the plan.
Irish Times
2 hours ago
- Irish Times
Betting tax increase in budget could raise €53m while higher vehicle levies also examined in tax strategy papers
Boosting betting tax in the budget would raise up to an extra €53 million a year for the State, according to Department of Finance officials. The tax take from betting almost doubled to €95 million in 2019 from €52 million the previous year, after the Government increased the rate on all bets placed in the State to 2 per cent from 1 per cent. Increasing the rate by 1 per cent would add a further €53 million a year, while adding 0.5 per cent would yield another €26.5 million, the department's Tax Strategy Group (TSG) report states. Government would collect a further €800,000 if it increased the tax on the commission earned by betting exchanges, which allow customers to bet against each other, to 30 per cent from 25 per cent, the report added. READ MORE But it cautions that those estimates depend on 'the betting market continuing as normal in 2025 and 2026″ with neither bookies nor their customers changing their behaviour. [ Income tax dilemma for Government as VAT cuts could cost €1bn Opens in new window ] 'It is understood the burden of such additional tax increases would mainly impact large bookmaking firms,' it said. Along with the increase in 2019, the Government introduced relief of €50,000, meant to ease the burden on small independent operators, whose share of the market has shrunk rapidly in recent years. The report suggests increasing this relief to €65,000 should the Government decide to boost the tax rate. However, it adds that Revenue officials argue that this would benefit only a handful of businesses, while it would add to the challenge of getting EU state aid approval for such a move. The report notes that three big businesses dominate the market. Although it does not name them, they are Irish-based giant, Flutter Entertainment, mostly through its subsidiary Paddy Power , Boylesports and UK-based Ladbrokes. A Health Research Report found in 2022 that problem gambling had fallen over the previous eight years, but still hit more than 135,000 lives in the Republic. Revenue figures show that betting is growing, but moving increasingly online. In 2019, customers wagered €28.9 million in cash and €23.5 million digitally, including €1.8 million with betting exchanges. In 2023, digital's share was more than €55 million, of a €102.7 million total, while punters bet €46.6 million in cash. Separately, a 1 per cent increase in the higher rates of Vehicle Registration Tax (VRT) is one of the budget options outlined by the TSG papers. It says that if applied across the upper VRT bands – 11 to 20 – covering the price of new and imported used cars, it 'would affect only cars with above-average emissions' and could raise €28 million based on 2024 registrations. The group also suggests increasing the NOx surcharge on new and imported cars by €5 per mg/km, potentially generating another €15.5 million. On Benefit-in-Kind tax (BIK), the paper proposes creating a new zero-emissions category, with rates ranging between 6 and 15 per cent, depending on annual business mileage. A higher VRT rate of 15 per cent is also suggested for vans and light commercial vehicles emitting more than 260g/km of CO2. This would sit above the recently introduced two-band emissions-based VRT system, where the top rate currently stands at 13.3 per cent for vehicles over 120g/km. The TSG notes that future reforms could include emissions-based BIK rates for vans, potentially retaining the current 8 per cent rate for low-emission models, with higher rates for those over a certain CO2 threshold. The latest TSG paper revises a proposal made last year on an additional VRT surcharge based on a vehicle's weight. Modelled on a system currently operated in France and Norway, an additional charge would be imposed on vehicles above a certain weight threshold, with various potential reliefs for the likes of fully-electric or hybrid models. The TSG states: 'It is well documented that the scale of the proposed electrification of the national fleet will entail significant revenue risk, with the growth in EVs expected to erode Exchequer receipts from motor tax, VRT, VAT and fuel excise, particularly if the current tax structures remain unchanged.' It estimates that revenue from taxes on fossil fuel use and related transport will fall by €1 billion by 2030, down from €5.3 billion in 2022.
Irish Times
2 hours ago
- Irish Times
Global markets soar amid signs of progress on US trade deals
Global markets soared on Thursday as investors digested US corporate earnings along with signs of progress in tariff negotiations between the US and its trading partners. Dublin Euronext Dublin was up 1.3 per cent, largely boosted by strong performances from the Irish banks. Bank of Ireland and AIB were up 4 per cent and 3 per cent respectively, with the banking sector generally up across Europe. Ryanair continued its recent rise, climbing 0.7 per cent. Its peer airline Wizz Air finished down 0.5 per cent after it missed first-quarter profit estimates. 'There was a bit activity around the airlines due to that news flow, and Ryanair benefited from that,' said a trader. READ MORE Elsewhere, two heavyweights on the index, food giant Kerry Group and Cavan-based insulation specialist Kingspan, both finished up 0.5 per cent. London Britain's FTSE 100 rose to a record close, boosted by upbeat corporate results and optimism over a potential EU-US trade agreement. The benchmark FTSE 100 closed up 0.9 per cent, while the domestically-oriented midcap FTSE 250 gained 0.6 per cent. The personal care and grocery stores index led sectoral gains, up 2.6 per cent, boosted by Reckitt, up 9.9 per cent, after the consumer goods company raised its annual revenue forecast. Healthcare stocks rose 1.9 per cent with AstraZeneca up 2.1 per cent after the drugmaker's rare immune disorder drug succeeded in an advanced trial. GSK added 1.4 per cent after the US Food and Drug Administration on Wednesday extended its review of the drugmaker's blood cancer drug. Media stocks advanced 2.3 per cent, led by ITV which rose 13.3 per cent after the broadcaster's half-year results beat forecasts. Conversely, precious metal miners fell 1.4 per cent, tracking a drop in gold prices. Endeavour Mining fell 1.3 per cent, and Fresnillo was down 2.1 per cent. Europe Shares on the Continent advanced amid reports the European Union and Washington were close to clinching a tariff agreement, close on the heels of a similar deal with Japan. MSCI's gauge of stocks across the globe rose 3.03 points. The pan-European Stoxx 600 index rose 0.23 per cent, while Europe's broad FTSEurofirst 300 index rose 0.2 per cent. The Dax 40 in Frankfurt gained 0.2 per cent, but the Cac 40 in Paris fell 0.4 per cent. New York The S&P 500 and the Nasdaq hit record highs as big technology stocks rose after Google parent Alphabet's robust earnings, while the Dow was weighed down by losses in IBM, UnitedHealth, and Honeywell. In morning trading, the S&P 500 gained 0.25 per cent; and the Nasdaq Composite gained 0.25 per cent. Alphabet rose 1.9 per cent after it raised its 2025 capital spending forecast, shrugging off trade jitters, and reinforcing investors' confidence in AI investments and returns. Losses in UnitedHealth, IBM and Honeywell weighed on the blue-chip Dow, which fell 0.33 per cent – though it remained close to its December 4th record high. UnitedHealth lost 3.7 per cent. The insurer revealed it's co-operating with a Department of Justice probe into its Medicare practices, following reports of both criminal and civil investigations. IBM dropped 8 per cent as its second-quarter results fell flat with investors, hampered by disappointing sales in its core software division. Honeywell, meanwhile, dipped 4.6 per cent despite topping Wall Street's expectations and raising its annual outlook. Electric vehicle maker Tesla tumbled 9 per cent, as CEO Elon Musk warned of 'a few rough quarters' due to cuts in EV incentives. The stock has fallen about 25 per cent for the year so far. Some of Wall Street's heavyweights were starting to feel the sting of Trump's sweeping tariffs. American Airlines fell 9.2 per cent after forecasting a bigger-than-expected third-quarter loss, hurt by sluggish domestic travel demand. – Additional reporting: Agencies
