Lucy Letby supporter claims neo-natal unit where baby serial killer worked was 'not fit for purpose'
Michele Worden said redundancies led to a loss of senior staff and plumbing issues created a 'perfect storm' for care failings.
The former advanced nurse practitioner left the Countess after being made redundant in 2007, four years before Letby started working and eight years before her killing spree began.
She told the Nursing Times that when the unit was downgraded in around 2006 and stopped caring for very premature babies under 27 weeks, senior nurses were replaced with junior staff who were asked to care for infants 'above their capabilities [and] training.'
She said: 'It wasn't just the neonatal unit that wasn't fit for purpose, the whole maternity and paediatric and gynaecology… was not fit for purpose.
'The problems with the sewage and blocked sinks were not just [on] the neonatal unit, it was on the labour ward, it was all over.'
Ms Worden said she believed the situation at the Countess of Chester was 'no different' to other NHS hospitals where maternity scandals have been uncovered in recent years.
'Hopefully Lucy will be exonerated,' she said. 'Chester is no different than Shrewsbury, Nottingham, Morecambe Bay. Women and children's healthcare has never been a high priority.'
Letby, 38, is serving 15 whole life terms after being convicted of the murder of seven babies and attempted murder of seven more, including one baby girl she tried to kill twice.
Plumber Lorenzo Mansutti, estates manager at the Countess, was the only witness called by Letby in her defence at her Manchester Crown Court trial.
He admitted drainage problems were a 'weekly' issue at the hospital's 50-year-old Women's and Children's Building and told the jury that he remembered an incident when raw sewage backed up into sinks in the intensive care nursery.
But he said it was a 'one off' and insisted that at no point were staff unable to wash their hands because the hospital had 'backup' portable handwashing units on site. The problem was not logged as a formal incident, so no exact date for the incident could be found.
Letby's trial heard that none of the seven babies who died collapsed due to a bacterial infection associated with poor sewage.
Cheshire police are continuing to investigate the former nurse and last year confirmed they had questioned her in prison in connection with more baby deaths.
But, following a presentation from 14 international experts in February, who claim none of the babies were murdered but died due to poor care, there has been a continued chorus of people questioning the safety of her convictions.
Letby has twice applied and been refused leave to appeal, but her new legal team have submitted a file of evidence to the Criminal Cases Review Commission, the body that investigates potential miscarriages of justice, in a last ditch attempt to get her convictions overturned.
They claim the testimony of lead prosecution expert Dewi Evans was biased and that he changed his mind over the method of murder of one of the children murdered by Letby, a boy known as Baby C. Dr Evans has denied this and the Court of Appeal has already dismissed claims he was not suitably qualified or lacked independence.
Yesterday it emerged that Dr Evans, who has been subjected to intense trolling online from Letby supporters, had been involved in an online row with one of them - an anonymous statistician who Dr Evans accused of being motivated by a sexual attraction to Letby.
According to the statistician, Dr Evans wrote: 'You seem very intense, and it's not unusual for men to have the hots for pretty young blonde females. A nursing uniform is a turn-on for some by all accounts.
'I would suggest you need to get out more, find yourself an available pretty young blonde female, with/without nursing credentials. But one who doesn't go to work intent on murdering her patients.'
The statistician said it was 'absurd' to say he believed Letby was innocent because she was 'blonde and pretty' and insisted he had come to that view after reviewing the transcripts of the trial.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Telegraph
13 minutes ago
- Telegraph
I didn't vaccinate my children with the MMR jab – but now I'm having regrets
Olivia*, 56, lives in west London with her husband and twins aged 14. Their oldest son, 19, is at university I'm neither a hippy nor someone who set out to make 'alternative' choices. Yet nearly two decades ago, when my eldest was born, I decided not to vaccinate him with the MMR jab. And when his twin siblings arrived four years later, I made the same decision for them. Admittedly, this is something I've kept quiet about over the years. I never even told my own mother as I knew she would worry – and disapprove. Yet today, reading the heartbreaking news that a child has died in Liverpool after contracting measles, I'm feeling anxious and now questioning whether I did the right thing. At the time, it didn't feel radical; it was instinctive. It just did not feel right to inject my precious, much longed-for babies with a live vaccine. I was also influenced by a close friend who was passionate about natural health and homeopathy. She was someone I trusted – intelligent and thorough – and her arguments about the pharmaceutical industry's vested interests made me think. The MMR jab was first introduced in the UK in 1988, so I didn't have it myself, (though I do know my mother would have given it to me had it then been an option). I remember getting both mumps and measles but these illnesses were part of childhood I believed – unpleasant but survivable. My eldest did eventually catch mumps, and he was fine. I can't pretend that I wasn't affected by reading the claims of the now disgraced British doctor, Andrew Wakefield. His paper in The Lancet infamously suggested there was a link to the MMR jab and autism. While The Lancet completely retracted the paper in 2010, and his claims were struck off before then by many, the controversy made me wary. Raising my young family in west London, I was surrounded by several other parents dealing with autism diagnoses. Unlike measles, where I didn't know anyone affected, autism felt more of a threat. So, with my husband's backing, I didn't vaccinate them. I honestly don't remember ever feeling bullied by my healthcare professionals at the time. Doctors never challenged me, however over the years when I've taken them for the inevitable A&E trips (broken fingers and the like) I have been asked whether they're 'up to date with their jabs' and I've had to explain my decision. I don't think I was even met with raised eyebrows any time, because it's common, especially in London where (according to statistics in from 2021-2022) one in five haven't been inoculated by the time they're aged three. I vaguely recall it being discussed at baby groups with other mums and I kept quiet. I suppose I sensed there was a stigma, but I also felt it was a private decision for me to make. My children all attended local state school, and teachers and other parents at the school gate never once asked me and it never came up in conversation. I would have been honest if it had despite not advertising the fact. It's most likely they would have assumed I'd ticked the box like everyone else. I've never been a militant anti-vaxxer, and all our family had the Covid jabs when the pandemic struck. I didn't hesitate about that because – like the rest of the country back then – I was frightened of Covid, this unknown new virus which killed. But things change. Every time news hits about a new outbreak of measles I get anxiety. The first time I felt anything close to regret about my decision was when my eldest went off to university, and there was doubt. Was I putting him at unnecessary risk? I even contacted our GP to see if we could arrange the vaccinations before she left. They never got back to me, I never chased and life moved on. But moments like this – tragic stories of unvaccinated children dying – bring back the uncertainty. I know people will claim I've been irresponsible, and now I am wondering if I should have made a different decision. The good news is that I can still get them vaccinated. My oldest of course will have to make his own decision now he's an adult. But I plan to talk to him – as well as the 14 year olds – about getting the jabs. If something were to happen to my children because of my decision, I would never forgive myself. Yet back then, with the knowledge I had, I believed I was making the best choice I could. Isn't that the uncomfortable truth about parenting? You make your decisions out of love and fear and instinct, and sometimes you only know if they were right years down the line. The death of a child is something I can't ignore. I hope that other people, like me, who might be less sure of themselves now might re-think their decisions. Far more important then being 'right' is the chance to say another child from dying from an illness that can be prevented.
Daily Record
36 minutes ago
- Daily Record
Good Morning Britain's Dr Hilary Jones updates fans on hospital stay as he admits he's 'delighted'
TV doctor Dr Hilary Jones is recovering after undergoing a hip replacement operation at a private hospital - and is encouraging others to travel hundreds of miles if it means avoiding lengthy NHS waiting lists ITV's Dr Hilary Jones has been recuperating in hospital after journeying 180 miles to receive treatment - all to sidestep a lengthy waiting list. The 72-year-old telly doctor is urging others to also travel hundreds of miles, if necessary, to avoid enduring pain while waiting for a local facility to provide treatment. Dr Hilary, who has previously discussed his need for a hip replacement, aims to raise awareness that private medical facilities can be accessed by NHS patients at no cost to receive treatment more promptly. By taking advantage of this lesser-known service, it could potentially alleviate some of the pressure on NHS hospitals. The star - known for his appearances on ITV shows such as Lorraine and Good Morning Britain - is shining a light on NHS Patient Choice, which he used to find a hospital with virtually no waiting list for treatment. Patient Choice is an NHS service that allows individuals to search for private facilities, hospitals and other providers they can access. Private hospitals can even be accessed as long as they offer the same service as the NHS - with patients granted access without being charged for it. Dr Hilary, who represents Practice Plus Group, opted to utilise a new hospital in Birmingham for his treatment, enabling him to receive care more quickly. As reported by the Express, the TV personality shared: "It was 180 miles from my home to Birmingham, but as it's a new hospital and it's a private hospital that treats NHS patients, they could get me in very quickly just with a referral from my GP," reports the Mirror. "I'd do it again in a heartbeat for faster, quality care and highly recommend it. Patient Choice gives people real power - they just need to know it's there. The NHS App is going to be developed further to make this easier, and you can speak to your GP about your choices. You can choose to be referred to a private hospital at the outset, or you can switch hospitals like I did if you're facing delays locally. "It's free for the patient and costs the NHS no more than if that same patient had their op at an NHS hospital. For people like me, who are lucky enough to be mobile despite needing an operation, it makes complete sense to find a hospital that can do your operation sooner so you can get on the road to recovery sooner. "People don't want to be on a waiting list. They want to get on with their lives. Every single person that looked after me was amazing and couldn't have done any more. I am delighted with the result so far." His decision to use the facility follows a survey commissioned by Practice Plus Group and conducted by OnePoll. The survey asked 1,000 adults experiencing chronic discomforts, including those seeking surgery, about their preferences. The findings indicated that most would be willing to travel an average of 60 miles for prompt treatment within three to four weeks, or 49 miles if the wait was six to eight weeks. In fact, 10% disclosed they'd gladly journey over 200 miles to secure an NHS procedure within a month. In the previous year, Dr Hilary shared insights into his own surgical experience and emphasised that the public had alternatives for quicker treatment. Reflecting on his hip replacement, he stated via the Practice Plus Group website: "I know from my own hip replacement surgery that these 'routine' and 'non-urgent' operations are truly life-changing. Living with pain and not being able to do the things you love is exhausting and debilitating." Moreover, he noted: "Fast access to surgery, if this is what you need, will help you re-gain your mobility, your fitness and quality of life. It's no surprise therefore that going private has become more and more common since the pandemic and is no longer considered just for the rich. But many people are unaware they can also go to a private hospital as an NHS patient, free of charge, and often sooner than waiting for NHS hospitals." He went on to say: "Under the NHS constitution you have a legal right to choose which hospital to have your NHS treatment in, and this often includes private hospitals. If your GP, physio or other healthcare professional says they're going to refer you to a consultant at a hospital in Birmingham, ask for a list of options so you can compare waiting lists and locations. "You also have a right to switch from one hospital waiting list to another if you've been waiting for more than 18 weeks for surgery and can travel out of your area. My advice is always to discuss your options with your GP to help you get back to your best as soon as possible."
Edinburgh Live
an hour ago
- Edinburgh Live
ITV's Dr Hilary Jones pictured in hospital bed after huge op as he gives top tip
Our community members are treated to special offers, promotions and adverts from us and our partners. You can check out at any time. More info ITV's Dr Hilary Jones has been recuperating in hospital after journeying 180 miles to receive treatment, thereby bypassing a lengthy waiting list. The 72-year-old television medic is urging others to consider travelling significant distances if it means avoiding prolonged discomfort while awaiting local treatment availability. Dr Hilary, who has previously spoken about his need for a hip replacement, aims to raise awareness that NHS patients can access private medical facilities free of charge to expedite their treatment. This lesser-known service could potentially alleviate pressure on NHS hospitals. The celebrity doctor, known for his appearances on ITV shows such as Lorraine and Good Morning Britain, is drawing attention to NHS Patient Choice, which he used to locate a hospital with minimal waiting times. Patient Choice is an NHS service allowing individuals to search for accessible private facilities, hospitals and other providers. Private hospitals can be accessed provided they offer the same services as the NHS, with patients granted entry without incurring any charges. TV personality Dr Hilary utilised a new hospital in Birmingham, courtesy of Practice Plus Group, for expedited treatment. Speaking to the Express about his decision, the TV doctor said: "It was 180 miles from my home to Birmingham, but as it's a new hospital and it's a private hospital that treats NHS patients, they could get me in very quickly just with a referral from my GP," reports the Mirror. He expressed his satisfaction with the experience by saying, "I'd do it again in a heartbeat for faster, quality care and highly recommend it. Patient Choice gives people real power - they just need to know it's there. The NHS App is going to be developed further to make this easier, and you can speak to your GP about your choices. You can choose to be referred to a private hospital at the outset, or you can switch hospitals like I did if you're facing delays locally." Moreover, he pointed out the financial benefits: "It's free for the patient and costs the NHS no more than if that same patient had their op at an NHS hospital. For people like me, who are lucky enough to be mobile despite needing an operation, it makes complete sense to find a hospital that can do your operation sooner so you can get on the road to recovery sooner." Dr Hilary also touched upon the common desire to avoid long waiting lists, adding, "People don't want to be on a waiting list. They want to get on with their lives. Every single person that looked after me was amazing and couldn't have done any more. I am delighted with the result so far." His turn to the clinic was influenced by a study from Practice Plus Group, which enlisted OnePoll to canvas the views of 1,000 adults troubled by persistent maladies and those seeking surgical relief. The survey uncovered that most are ready to journey an average of 60 miles for treatment within three to four weeks, or trek 49 miles if the wait is between six and eight weeks. Intriguingly, 10% expressed they'd venture over 200 miles if it meant snagging an NHS operation slot within a month. In the previous year, Dr Hilary divulged insights from his own experience with surgery, simultaneously drawing attention to an expedited avenue for the public to access similar medical care. He articulated through a statement on the Practice Plus Group's website, "I know from my own hip replacement surgery that these 'routine' and 'non-urgent' operations are truly life-changing. Living with pain and not being able to do the things you love is exhausting and debilitating." He added, "Fast access to surgery, if this is what you need, will help you re-gain your mobility, your fitness and quality of life. It's no surprise therefore that going private has become more and more common since the pandemic and is no longer considered just for the rich. But many people are unaware they can also go to a private hospital as an NHS patient, free of charge, and often sooner than waiting for NHS hospitals." He went on to say: "Under the NHS constitution you have a legal right to choose which hospital to have your NHS treatment in, and this often includes private hospitals. If your GP, physio or other healthcare professional says they're going to refer you to a consultant at a hospital in Birmingham, ask for a list of options so you can compare waiting lists and locations. "You also have a right to switch from one hospital waiting list to another if you've been waiting for more than 18 weeks for surgery and can travel out of your area. My advice is always to discuss your options with your GP to help you get back to your best as soon as possible."
