Birkenstock cracks down on fakes in India, court-ordered factory visits held, sources say
Birkenstock's case is occurring around the same time other shoemakers are in the news in India. Crocs this month secured a court nod to pursue a nine-year-old infringement case, while Prada is facing heat over showcasing sandals similar to ethnic Indian footwear without initially giving credit to India.
Reuters is first to report the Indian case details related to Birkenstock sandals, which have evolved from a counterculture symbol to a trendy fashion item, and are also popular in India.
In May, Birkenstock filed an infringement lawsuit in the Delhi High Court against four footwear traders, four factories and two unnamed individuals. Its complaint stated an internal investigation found counterfeits were being made in rural areas in and around the tourist hub of Agra, and sold locally and exported to other countries.
On May 26, Delhi judge Saurabh Banerjee issued a confidential order that was only made public on the court's website last week. It said 10 local lawyers were appointed as commissioners to visit the suspected factories.
The judge said commissioners can 'seize, pack and seal the infringing products', and his order included photographs that Birkenstock submitted showing the alleged counterfeit footwear and shoe boxes with the company's branding.
The visits have been completed and reports were submitted confidentially to the judge, the three people familiar with the matter said on Saturday, asking to remain unidentified. The next hearing in the case is set for October 6.
The visits were conducted in Agra, home to the Taj Mahal, and in India's capital New Delhi, the people said, declining to give further details from their inspection.
Birkenstock did not respond to queries from Reuters and its lawyers from Delhi-based law firm Lall and Sethi declined to comment, citing the pending legal case.
In his May order, Banerjee said he reviewed photographs and samples of the alleged counterfeit products in court, and they 'seem like a cheap knock off' of Birkenstock products.
'There is all likelihood of the public getting deceived … The differences, hardly if any, are not something which can be discernable to the naked eyes,' he wrote.
Once popular with hippies, tech enthusiasts and medical professionals, Birkenstock gained widespread attention after Australian actress Margot Robbie wore a pair of pink Birkenstocks in the final scene of the 2023 hit movie 'Barbie'.
In February, a German court said Birkenstock sandals do not qualify as art and are therefore not protected by copyright, dismissing a lawsuit brought by the German company.
In India, Birkenstock footwear for women is priced between $46 and $233.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Express Tribune
3 hours ago
- Express Tribune
Barter trade digital system developed
Pakistan, by contrast, has opted out of the ITA, one of the world's most successful digital trade agreements, whose membership has grown to 86 countries accounting for over 97% of global digital trade.: photo: file Amid persistent challenges in operationalising barter trade agreements with countries such as Russia, Iran and Afghanistan, a Karachi-based technology company has introduced a digital framework aimed at overhauling Pakistan's barter trade mechanism. Galaxefi Solutions, a private tech firm specialising in digital freight workflows, has developed a national-level system called Bartmas (Barter Trade Management System). The initiative seeks to bring transparency, efficiency and coordination to barter-based transactions, a necessity for Pakistan given its limited banking relations with several trading partners due to sanctions and geopolitical constraints. Galaxefi Founder and CEO Asif Pervez said the system is designed to move the country away from outdated manual processes that have made barter trade vulnerable to inefficiencies, mismanagement and policy blind spots. "Barter trade doesn't have to be broken. We just have to stop guessing and start measuring, digitally, transparently and in real time," he said. Bartmas aims to integrate all key national institutions through digital APIs, including the Pakistan Single Window (PSW), Federal Board of Revenue, Ministry of Commerce, National Logistics Corporation (NLC), State Bank of Pakistan (SBP) and other authorities. The proposed digital infrastructure will enable end-to-end visibility of barter journey from the initiation of barter request and customs clearance to escrow fund management and bonded warehousing, ensuring that each step is auditable and centrally traceable. According to Pervez, the process begins with barter requests initiated through a secure online dashboard, followed by real-time inventory checks to prevent domestic shortages. Contracts would be verified in coordination with regional chambers of commerce, such as the Quetta and Zahidan Chambers.
Business Recorder
3 hours ago
- Business Recorder
Carrier becomes latest global firm to sue India over electronic waste rules
NEW DELHI: The Indian unit of U.S. air conditioning giant Carrier has become the latest major firm to sue Prime Minister Narendra Modi's government over electronic waste rules that have hiked the fees manufacturers must pay to recyclers. South Korea's Samsung Electronics and LG Electronics as well as Japan's Daikin and Tata's Voltas have also brought suits, which are set to be heard by the High Court of Delhi on Tuesday. All of the companies are seeking to have the rules quashed. India is the third-biggest generator of electronic waste behind China and the U.S., but the government says only 43% of the country's e-waste last year was recycled. Modi's government in September fixed a floor price that electronics makers must pay recyclers, which manufacturers argue is roughly three to four times higher than what they paid earlier. In a 380-page court filing dated June 3, which has not been disclosed publicly, Carrier said recyclers were willing to continue their work at the older prices and the government should not interfere in private dealings between companies and recyclers. 'The burden of the benefit being given to the recyclers has been put on the producers, which is unfair and arbitrary,' said submissions by Carrier Airconditioning & Refrigeration which were reviewed by Reuters. The submissions added that the rules will impose a 'huge financial burden' on the company. Carrier did not respond to a Reuters request for comment. India's Ministry of Environment also did not respond to Reuters queries. It has previously argued in court that the pricing rules are needed to ensure proper waste disposal and were a 'reasonable' intervention. The new rules mandate a minimum payment of 22 rupees per kilogram to recycle consumer electronics. Such rates are still lower than levels in the U.S where they are up to five times higher, according to research firm Redseer. Carrier reported sales of $248 million in India last year, its highest level since at least the financial year ending March 2020. Its filing said it installed India's first-ever air conditioning system in Jaipur city in 1936.
Business Recorder
3 hours ago
- Business Recorder
Tariff worries, Trump's BRICS swipe spark worst rupee fall in three weeks
MUMBAI: The Indian rupee slumped on Monday as uncertainty about U.S. tariff policies resurfaced with President Donald Trump's threat of a fresh 10% levy on BRICS countries compounding pressure on the local currency alongside peers like South African rand and Chinese yuan. Worries over U.S. trade policies dented risk sentiment across the board, pushing Asian currencies and equities into the red while U.S. equity futures pointed to a weak return from the long weekend. The rupee had declined to a low of 86.0275 per U.S. dollar during the session but pared losses to close at 85.85 per U.S. dollar, down 0.5% on the day, its worst performance since mid-June, when it traded in the shadow of a military conflict between Israel and Iran. In a social media post, President Donald Trump said the U.S. would start delivering tariff letters from 12:00 pm ET (1600 GMT) on Monday. In a separate post, he rolled out a wholly new tariff policy, calling for countries 'aligning themselves with the Anti-American policies' of the BRICS developing nations to be charged an extra 10% tariff, with no exceptions to be granted. Indian rupee ends nearly flat following choppy trading; forward premiums dip It was not immediately clear if Trump's tariff threat would derail trade talks with India and other BRICS nations. The South African rand fell 1% after Trump's threat while the offshore Chinese yuan was down 0.2%. The absence of progress on trade negotiations over the weekend has come as a negative surprise for markets with Trump's BRICS remark especially hurting the rupee, said Dilip Parmar, a foreign exchange research analyst at HDFC Securities. Parmar expects the Reserve Bank of India to step in to support the rupee if volatility remains elevated due to uncertainty on U.S. trade policies. On the day, traders also pointed to strong dollar demand from a large local private bank which pressured the local currency. A fall below the 85.80 level triggered stop-losses and accentuated the day's move, a trader at a state-run bank said. He expects the currency to weaken to 86.50 in the near-term in the absence of positive developments on the trade front.
