Crown attorneys' group denounces 'attacks' on justice system during Freedom Convoy, Hockey Canada trials
OTTAWA — The president of the Ontario Crown Attorneys' Association says 'attacks' launched by 'politicians, media and members of the public' in response to two high-profile criminal cases amount to 'affronts to the rule of law.'
Article content
'Be they attacks on prosecutorial independence or sexist attacks on principles of fundamental justice, these actions are affronts to the rule of law,' Donna Kellway wrote in an open letter.
Article content
'Personal attacks on Crowns seeking a significant sentence are nothing less than attacks on prosecutorial independence. These attacks do not — nor will they ever — drive the decisions made by our prosecutors.'
Article content
Kellway said in an email to The Canadian Press that the letter refers to reaction to Crown sentencing proposals in the cases of two people associated with the 'Freedom Convoy' protest and criticism of counsel in the recent Hockey Canada trial based on their gender.
Article content
Several Conservative MPs, along with party leader Pierre Poilievre, have criticized the Crown's approach to sentencing two key organizers of the Freedom Convoy.
Article content
Tamara Lich and Chris Barber, who have yet to be sentenced, were convicted of mischief in April for their roles in organizing the protest, which blockaded streets around Parliament Hill for more than three weeks in early 2022.
Article content
'Let's get this straight: while rampant violent offenders are released hours after their most recent charges and antisemitic rioters vandalize businesses, terrorize daycares and block traffic without consequences, the Crown wants seven years prison time for the charge of mischief for Lich and Barber,' Poilievre wrote on social media last week.
Article content
'How is this justice?'
Article content
In her own social media post, deputy Conservative leader Melissa Lantsman said that if 'the Crown suddenly wants to apply the law – equal application of law would be a good start – but this is political vengeance not actual justice and it's why trust in our institutions is dwindling.'
Article content
Lich's lawyer Lawrence Greenspon said that while he 'liked' what Poilievre had to say, he shouldn't have said it.
Article content
'The separation of church and state, in this case legislature from judiciary, is something that is highly valued in our country,' Greenspon said outside an Ottawa courthouse last week.
Article content
In the Toronto Star, a recent opinion piece by a staff columnist questioned why female lawyers would represent men accused of sexual crimes in the Hockey Canada trial.
Article content
'A lawyer's gender plays no role in determining one's eligibility to participate in either the lawful prosecution or the vigorous defence of any charge in our criminal justice system. To suggest otherwise is to undermine the very principles upon which the rule of law is based,' Kellway wrote.
Article content
'Such attacks show a fundamental lack of understanding of our foundational constitutional principles, including the presumption of innocence, the right to a fair trial and equality.'
Article content
Kellway said Canadians have seen political attacks on the justice system south of the border and must do everything they can to safeguard the system's independence.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
CTV News
an hour ago
- CTV News
Police seize gun, fentanyl, cocaine following drug bust in Hamilton
A Hamilton police cruiser is seen in this undated file photo. (CTV News Toronto) Hamilton police say a man has been arrested and charged following a major drug and firearm investigation in the city's east end. Authorities with the Major Drugs and Gangs Unit arrested the suspect on July 31 near Main Street East and Wellington Street South. Police say the arrest was carried out 'without incident' along with support from the Emergency Response Unit. In a news release, investigators said they executed search warrants at two residences — one near Gage Avenue North and Barton Street East, and another near Main Street East and Spring Street. Officers say they seized a loaded 9mm handgun, approximately 680 grams of fentanyl, 24 grams of cocaine, 19 grams of crystal meth, hundreds of hydromorphone pills, and more than $7,000 in cash. A 33-year-old man from Hamilton has been charged with a series of offences including trafficking, possession of prohibited loaded firearm and proceeds of crime over $5,000. The investigation remains ongoing. Anyone with information is asked to contact the Hamilton Police Major Drugs and Gangs Unit at vicedrug@
National Post
an hour ago
- National Post
From Alberta to Stephen Colbert: An imagined look at who Mark Carney will offer statehood to next
This week, Prime Minister Mark Carney promise to recognize a Palestinian state provided that its leaders can abandon violence and become a liberal democracy — and do so by the end of the summer. Article content Carney's conditions are basically impossible: Gaza remains in control of a literal terrorist organization that refuses to surrender, while the Palestinian areas of the West Bank are in the hands of a Palestinian Authority that has suspended elections since 2005. Article content Article content The other easy critique — and the one being made by the Conservatives — is that it rewards terrorism. For decades, Canada has explicitly rejected unilateral recognition of a Palestinian state, including in a House of Commons vote held just last year. The only reason Carney is breaking with this precedent is because of a series of events that kicked off with the slaughter and mass-rape of hundreds of Israeli civilians on Oct. 7, 2023. Article content Article content At a time when Canada faces threats unlike any since the Second World War, complete national unity is an imperative. This may include the extension of self-determination to regions such as Alberta which pose barriers to this. However, this is predicated on Alberta's agreement to much-needed social and political reforms. If, in the next six weeks, the province can suspend its oil sector, transition its vehicle fleet to 50 per cent EVs and phase out its environmentally destructive beef sector in favour of more sustainable nutritive options such as quinoa or jicama we will recognize a State of Alberta at the 80th session of the United Nations General Assembly. Article content Article content Afghanistan Article content Article content The worsening condition of Afghan women and girls leaves no room for delay in a co-ordinated international action to extend peace and security in the recently established Islamic Emirate of Afghanistan. For this reason, Canada will recognize Afghanistan and its Taliban government and urge our European partners to do the same. That is, if the Taliban government can sign a memorandum of understanding to recognize the systemic equity-hostile dogma of its current policies and commit to hiring marginalized Afghans in at least 11.5 per cent of civil service positions. Article content Puerto Rico and Stephen Colbert Article content Bullies like Donald Trump only understand strength. This is why, in a bold show of diplomatic convening power, Canada will unilaterally recognize Puerto Rico as the 51st U.S. state, and immediately petition Washington to make space for Puerto Rican representatives in its Senate and House of Representatives. We will also be instructing our diplomats to indefinitely continue recognizing Stephen Colbert as host of The Late Show.
CBC
2 hours ago
- CBC
Second man pleads guilty in Edmonton 'Project Gaslight' arson and extortion plot
Social Sharing Another man has admitted he was part of a criminal conspiracy targeting successful South Asian home builders in Edmonton with extortion, arson and drive-by shootings. Manav Singh Heer, 20, pleaded guilty to arson, extortion and conspiring to commit extortion on Friday, about a year after he was among several others arrested in the Edmonton Police Service "Project Gaslight" investigation. Heer admitted he was involved in arsons at homes owned by four local developers, as well as an incident where he shot an airsoft gun at a car where a private security guard was watching over one of the developer's homes. He is the second person to plead guilty in the extortion scheme, which began in fall 2023 and continued into early 2024, with local home builders facing demands for cash, violent threats and torched properties. Another young man pleaded guilty earlier this year, admitting he was a "middle manager" in the conspiracy, directing lower-level members, including Heer, about arson targets and reporting progress to higher-ups. Three others, 21-year-old Parminder Singh, 20-year-old Gurkaran Singh and a youth who was 17 when he was arrested and can't be identified, are still before the courts. The charges they face have not been proven. Alleged ringleader Maninder Dhaliwal is also facing charges, but he's in Dubai, where he allegedly orchestrated the scheme from abroad. Court heard Friday that he is still the subject of an extradition request to send him back to Canada from the United Arab Emirates. Arson involvement The details of Heer's role in the extortion plot were laid out in an extensive agreed statement of facts read in court by Crown prosecutor Breena Smith. Heer was aware of threats against the home builders and demands for money, as well as shootings committed as part of the scheme. In committing the arsons, "He was being paid by the syndicate for his work and he was knowingly doing these things at the direction of or for the benefit of the syndicate," Smith said. One local business owner began receiving threatening messages, which didn't come from Heer, in October 2023. Court heard that a caller claimed to be a member of the Brothers Keepers gang and demanded $500,000, saying he "must have the money as he had a nice home and cars." He subsequently received threats that his whole family would be killed and his house would be burned, with the caller describing the car sitting in his driveway and recounting "intimate details" of his life that seemed to be the result of surveillance. After a drive-by shooting at his home where Parminder Singh was arrested, the developer received a text that said, "You want to play this stupid game? You call the cops, let's see how long you survive." Heer was one of the people who set fire to one of the home builder's properties a few weeks later, in the early morning of Nov. 6, 2023. He was involved in a subsequent attempted arson in Leduc where he and two others were chased off by a private security guard. And he was then part of an attack on a security guard's car where he shot and shattered the rear window of the vehicle as the guard drove away. Other developers were targeted in the months that followed, with Heer admitting he was directly involved in some of the arsons, and had advance knowledge of others where he didn't participate. According to the agreed facts, in one arson associated with the extortion plot in December 2023, the fire jumped to two neighbouring properties in the Cy Becker neighbourhood. Two adults and three children had to be evacuated from one of the homes. A firefighter at the scene searching a house for occupants fell two storeys to the basement when the floor gave way. Court heard he was seriously injured and couldn't work for several weeks. Cellphone, surveillance evidence Police gathered evidence of Heer's involvement in the scheme from a wiretap, recorded Edmonton Remand Centre calls and material discovered on Heer's cellphone. In some cases, other alleged members of the conspiracy filmed the process of setting the homes on fire, and shared it with others in the group. According to the agreed facts, in one group text, Heer said he was paid a little more than $1,000 for one of the arsons, and he continued to do it for the money. In another group chat titled "Not Criminals," Heer and other members of the group talked about creating more "arson teams," getting guns and identifying more home builder targets. WATCH | Extortions orchestrated from India, EPS says: Police say Edmonton area extortions targeting home builders orchestrated from India 2 years ago Edmonton police are investigating 27 events in an ongoing extortion, arson and firearms series affecting the South Asian community in the region. An estimated $9 million in property damage has been reported from the arson and shootings. A list of addresses associated with one developer was found in a note on Heer's cellphone, titled with fire emojis, and police found addresses where arsons took place searched and saved on his phone. Police also discovered a web browser searches for home builders that were targeted as well as the phrase, "How much jail time facing for arsons." Heer was caught several times on surveillance video in the area of arsons, often wearing a "distinctive" pair of red and white striped Nike sneakers that were seized after his arrest. On Friday, Heer additionally pleaded guilty to a dangerous driving offence that took place within the same period as the Project Gaslight crimes on Nov. 25, 2023. Court heard that Heer was driving his father's vehicle on James Mowatt Trail S.W., a road with a speed limit of 60 km/h, at 160km/h. A woman driving with her seven-year-old son in the backseat was attempting to make a left turn in the intersection when Heer crashed into the car, with an EPS investigation finding the impact came at a speed of 124 to 137 km/h. The woman and her son were both injured and taken to hospital, where the boy became unresponsive. Court heard that he underwent emergency neurosurgery, but he was left with a severe traumatic brain injury. According to agreed facts read in that case, he's no longer ambulatory, and lost his vision and likely also his hearing. He will likely require full-time care for the rest of his life. Heer's defence lawyer, Rahul Nanda, has requested a psychological assessment ahead of a sentencing date, which will be scheduled later.
