‘Political masterclass': Bilawal showered with praise for his collected responses to Karan Thapar
Responding to a query, the former foreign minister dismissed Indian allegations of Islamabad's supporting terrorist outfits to conduct cross border attacks.
He said: 'Pakistan does not willingly permit […] the groups you mentioned or any group to conduct terrorist attacks outside of Pakistan but also within Pakistan.'
Bilawal apprised the journalist that Pakistan itself had been victim of terrorism for years and years and had lost more than 90,000 precious lives while battling this menace.
The world is well aware that Pakistan faced the brunt of terrorism over the past many decades, he said.
'Pakistan is fighting and has been fighting the largest inland war against terrorism. We've lost 92,000 lives altogether. Just last year, we lost more than 1,200 civilian lives in more than 200 different terrorist attacks.
'At the rate at which terrorist attacks are taking place just this year alone, if they continue at this pace, this year will be the bloodiest year in Pakistan's history.'
Reminiscing the murder of his mother, former prime minister Benazir Bhutto, he said, he too was a victim of terrorism.
'I feel the pain of the victims of the Pahalgam terrorist attack. I understand the trauma that their families are experiencing in a way more than many others can ever imagine.'
He said following the Pahalgam attack, PM Shehbaz Sharif right away stated that Pakistan is 'willing to be part of any impartial international inquiry into the incident, our hands are clean.'
'We had that sort of confidence. It was the Indian government that rebuffed that offer. To this day, the Indian government has not shared with Pakistan or the international community.'
People were pleasantly surprised by the way Bilawal handled the journalist's allegations with his cool and calm demeanour, which has particularly been lauded against Thapar's frothing at the mouth while abortively and interruptingly trying to grill the PPP legislator.
Political commentator Nadeem Farooq Paracha said: 'Karan Thapar lost a large chunk of his journalistic credibility when interviewing Bilawal. All he had as 'questions' was rhetoric moulded by the Modi regime. He constantly interrupted Bilawal, and started to foam in the mouth when Bilawal kept his cool and stuck to facts. These 'icons' of Indian journalism are being exposed one by one. They just can't swallow the fact that militarily and diplomatically, 'shining India' was delivered a swift knockout blow by Pakistan.'
A social media activist, Mansoor Ahmed Qureshi loved how Bilawal schooled Thapar by saying, 'We are not destined to be enemies. Let's not damn our future generations to fight forever.'
PPP MNA Sharmila Faruqui said, 'Bilawal Bhutto didn't just hold his ground, he dismantled Karan Thapar, point by point. Calm, clinical, and utterly unshaken. This wasn't an interview. It was a political masterclass.'
A journalist Farzana Shah said facing Thapar, the PPP chairman turned tough questions into a diplomatic slamdunk, proving his grip on global affairs.
Singer Ali Zafar also loved Bilawal's responses in the interview, saying, 'As we enter a new era of awareness and intelligence, old ways lose their grip. One day, children of this land may ask, was it true India and Pakistan were once enemies? That people couldn't even meet or listen to each other? Why didn't they just hug it out and resolve their issues sooner by communicating? Who taught them to hate so deeply? This generation can choose peace. And it can be beautiful.
Senator Sherry Rehman said: 'Amazing grace by @BBhuttoZardari in this 'quarrelsome interview' with a constantly interrupting Karan Thapar. He didn't lose his cool or poise for one minute, despite the hectoring anchor with a single point agenda.'
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Business Recorder
2 hours ago
- Business Recorder
No evidence Pahalgam attackers came from Pakistan, says ex-Indian home minister
Demolishing propaganda of Indian Prime Minister Narendra Modi's government, former Home Minister of India P. Chidambaram has said that the Pahalgam attackers could be homegrown terrorists and there was no evidence that they came from Pakistan. Speaking to The Quint, Chidambaram also said the Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP) government was unwilling to disclose what investigation the National Investigation Agency (NIA) has done all these weeks into the terrorist incident. 'Have they (NIA) identified the terrorists or where they came from? For all we know, they could be homegrown terrorists. Why do you assume they came from Pakistan? There is no evidence of that,' he added. Pahalgam attack: India's refusal to formation of global investigation body The Congress leader has come under attack by the ruling party leaders and supporters over his this statement, which has brought down the narrative on which's basis India waged a days-long war against Pakistan and attacked the latter's civilian population. It should be noted that in April 2025, an attack in the tourist area of Pahalgam in Indian Illegally Occupied Jammu and Kashmir (IIOJK) resulted in the loss of 26 lives, after which India launched 'Operation Sindoor' against Pakistan. Senator Sherry Rehman said Chidambaram's statement on Pahalgam attack exposed the false narrative of the Indian government. 'India should reflect on its internal issues and security failures. No evidence has ever been presented proving Pakistan's involvement in the attack,' she said, reminding New Delhi of Pakistan's repeated demand to provide evidence about Islamabad's alleged involvement in the attack. Following Chidambaram's statement, the ruling party of India, the BJP has been continuously criticising the Congress. Several BJP leaders have interpreted Chidambaram's statement as giving a clean chit to Pakistan in the Pahalgam incident. Countering the BJP's attack over his statement, the former Indian home minister said the 'worst kind of troll' is one who suppresses a full interview and uses two sentences to paint the speaker black. 'Trolls are of different kinds and use different tools to spread misinformation. The worst kind is a troll who suppresses the full recorded interview, takes two sentences, mutes some words, and paints the speaker in a black colour,' he wrote on his X account.
Express Tribune
11 hours ago
- Express Tribune
Govt bans land travel for Arbaeen pilgrims
Listen to article The federal government banned the overland travel for pilgrims heading to Iraq for the Arbaeen, citing security concerns in the restive Balochistan province, Interior Minister Mohsin Naqvi confirmed on Sunday. Naqvi said that the decision had been taken after consultations with the Foreign Ministry, the Balochistan government, and the security agencies, adding that the pilgrims would be allowed to travel to Iraq only by air. Arbaeen, marking the 40th day of mourning after Ashura, sees millions of pilgrims, including thousands from Pakistan, travel to Karbala, Iraq, annually. Traditionally, many Pakistani pilgrims journey by road through Balochistan and Iran. However, due to the deteriorating law and order situation in the province — including increased terrorist attacks by Indian proxy outfits — the government deemed the move necessary for public safety and national security. "After extensive consultations with the Ministry of Foreign Affairs, Balochistan Government, and security agencies, it has been decided that Zaireen will not be allowed to travel to Iraq and Iran by road for Arbaeen this year," Naqvi posted on X. "Zaireen will, however, be able to travel by air. Prime Minister Mian Muhammad Shehbaz Sharif has directed authorities to arrange maximum flights to facilitate their pilgrimage in the coming days," he added. "This difficult decision was taken in the interest of public safety and national security." On the direction of Prime Minister Shehbaz Sharif for arranging flights to facilitate the pilgrims, the Pakistan International Airlines (PIA) announced four special flights from Karachi between August 8 and 11, with return flights from Najaf scheduled from August 18 to 21. According to a PIA spokesperson the fare has been set at Rs212,000 per person, and the ticket sales had started. He added that more flights could be scheduled if necessary. Officials said passengers traveling by air individually will have to be sponsored by local people, otherwise they cannot enter Iraq. Meanwhile, private airlines have sharply increased fares, with tickets now ranging between Rs300,000 to Rs350,000. Tour operators estimate group travel expenses at $1,400 per pilgrim, compared to just $550 for land travel. This has raised fears that tens of thousands of low-income pilgrims might be unable to afford the journey. Salars — pilgrim group leaders — argue that the ban that has been announced just 15 days before Arbaeen has caused significant financial losses. They said that many people had already made advance payments for visas, vehicle certifications, and hotel bookings. They demanded that the government allowed supervised bus convoys under security agencies' protection or provide alternative transport arrangements. "This loss isn't borne by the rich but by the poor," a pilgrimage organiser told The Express Tribune on condition of anonymously. He questioned why the ban wasn't announced earlier during a recent trilateral meeting between Pakistan, Iran, and Iraq, where travel restrictions were discussed. During a meeting with Prime Minister Shehbaz Sharif, Naqvi briefed him on Balochistan's security situation and the new pilgrim policy. The prime minister directed for the initiation of the Gwadar Safe City project to enhance security in the region. Naqvi emphasised the need for better pilgrim management. Starting next year, he said, the pilgrims will only be allowed to travel under officially registered group organisers, with special embassy-issued visas required for independent travel. This system aims to curb illegal travel and overstaying issues. Meanwhile, Naqvi also visited Quetta and Azad Kashmir. In Quetta, he paid tribute to martyred soldiers at the Frontier Corps headquarters, praising their sacrifices in maintaining peace. Later, in Muzaffarabad, he met the family of Major Rab Nawaz, a martyred officer, and offered condolences.
Business Recorder
13 hours ago
- Business Recorder
Sindh Tenancy Act amendments favour landlords: Khaskheli
HYDERABAD: Peasants and rural workers in Sindh continue to face numerous challenges, including the absence of social security coverage and occupational health and safety protections. Despite existing laws prohibiting bonded labour, a total of 1,012 bonded labourers were released from the illegal captivity of landlords and brick kiln owners in 2024 alone. These concerns were highlighted by Akram Khaskheli, President of the Hari Welfare Association, in a statement issued on Sunday. Khaskheli said that the Sindh Tenancy Act, 1950, has been in place for 74 years, but the amendments made over the years, particularly in 2013, favoured landlords (e.g., the Section 17 amendment shifted 100% of expenses to peasants). The high costs of inputs and limited or no irrigation water have created serious issues for sharecropping peasants. The rules for the Sindh Bonded Labour System (Abolition) Act (SBLSAA), 1992, were not notified in 2024. The draft rules remained with the Provincial Law Department and were accessible to the Provincial Home Department, but were not made publicly available. He also highlighted that the Sindh Women Agriculture Workers Act (SWAWA), 2019 has been passed which aims to protect the rights and welfare of women agricultural workers in Sindh. The rules for this law have not been passed thus this law is not being implemented. He said that according to HWA's annual report on peasants rights in Sindh, most members of the Sindh assembly are feudal lords or originate from feudal families, often misrepresented as agriculturalists and businesspersons. Nine members are identified as agriculturalists and 23 as landlords; many of these are also landowners. Similar patterns are observed in the National Assembly, particularly among PPP members, where many are actual landowners, but their true professions are concealed. A significant number of Sindh Provincial Assembly members represent feudal families, who form the core base of the PPP in Sindh. In 2024, a total of 1,012 bonded labourers were released from the custody of landlords and brick kiln owners in the agriculture and brick kiln sectors in Sindh. Of these, 620 bonded labourers (children, women, and men) were released from agriculture across various districts. Sanghar and Umerkot reported the highest numbers, with 194 and 206 individuals, respectively. In 2024 alone, 392 bonded labourers were released from the brick kiln sector, with Umerkot (125) and Sanghar (85) being the districts with the highest releases. Over 12 years (2013-2024), 12,005 bonded labourers were freed, comprising 32% men, 33% women, and 35% children. He further stated that over 6.4 million children are out of school in Sindh, many engaged in severe child labour, depriving them of education, health, and protection. Out of 1.7 million bonded labourers, approximately 700,000 are children suffering inhumane conditions, mainly in agriculture. The report also highlighted that rural Sindh is heavily affected by dacoit culture and crime. Hari leaders blame feudal lords and landowners for contributing to this issue, claiming they have destroyed Sindh's agriculture sector, especially sharecropping peasants and farm workers. HWA has collected details of tribal conflict in Sindh and revealed that from October 1 to December 31, 2024, 88 murders and thousands of injuries occurred in approximately 60 reported cases. Shikarpur district had the highest number of murders (31), followed by Ghotki (12) and Kashmore (7). It showed that other districts, such as Sukkur, Larkana, and Khairpur, reported lower numbers of murders (6-8), while Naushero Feroze, Jamshoro, and Dadu had fewer incidents. Copyright Business Recorder, 2025
