logo
What Wildfire Emissions Mean for Canada's Climate Progress

What Wildfire Emissions Mean for Canada's Climate Progress

Canada News.Net30-06-2025
As Canadians are all too aware, the return of spring and summer also marks the return of wildfire season. This summer has already seen devastating wildfires impact people in communities across the country, including the Prairie provinces, British Columbia, eastern Ontario, and the territories. Smoke from these fires has affected air quality in many cities in Canada and the U.S. midwest and northeast regions. Officials have warned that this year's season is on track to the second worst on record, in terms of areas burned.
Wildfires are both a symptom and an accelerant of climate change, writes Ross Linden-Fraser at 440 Megatonnes. A symptom, because while no single wildfire is exactly caused by climate change, they are made likelier and more intense by the increasingly dry and hot conditions of Canada's changing climate. And wildfires accelerate climate change too, as they are massive sources of carbon emissions.
Because accounting for those emissions can be complex, Linden-Fraser takes a deeper dive into how Canada counts wildfire emissions and what that means for the country's climate progress.
Every year, Canada's National Inventory Report on greenhouse gas emissions contains an entry for the carbon dioxide released by wildfires. These emissions are tracked but not counted towards Canada's official greenhouse gas targets-more on that in a moment.
As Figure 1 shows, the numbers fluctuate significantly, but they can be enormous.
Canada's 2023 wildfires are the most pointed example. According to the latest National Inventory Report, they released nearly 1 gigatonne-or one billion tonnes-of carbon dioxide from Canada's forests. That's a staggering sum that far exceeded the total emissions from all other sources in Canada in 2023. If Canada's forest wildfires were a country, they would have been the world's eighth-largest emitter that year.
The emissions data for Canada's 2023 forest fires are all the more sobering considering that they are incomplete. They are not wrong, but they are not designed to count everything.
There are three main categories of wildfire emissions that Canada does not count.
First, it does not estimate the emission of gases other than carbon dioxide. Though that is the most significant gas released by wildfires, these fires release other gases, including methane-a powerful greenhouse gas.
Second, Canada's estimates of wildfire emissions only reflect the impact on forests. There are fires on other landscapes like prairies or wetlands, but the inventory does not currently estimate them. Some of these landscapes, like peatlands, are recognized as particularly important stocks of carbon. Fires are likely releasing carbon from some of these lands, but they are not currently tracked in the country's inventory
The third category of uncounted emissions is more abstract. These are emissions from what are called unmanaged lands. The reason that they go uncounted has to do with the international accounting rules that apply to emissions from forests and other landscapes. These emissions fall into a category known as land use, land-use change, and forestry emissions, or LULUCF. Countries are only required to report LULUCF emissions from managed lands, meaning areas subject to direct human intervention through agriculture or parks (or fire suppression).
Every country has some flexibility to decide what counts as managed land, and in Canada more than 30% of forest lands are considered unmanaged. There is currently no official way to measure the carbon stored or released on this territory.
All of this means that there are additional wildfire emissions in Canada that are not being officially estimated. And there is a case for tracking emissions from other gases, other landscapes, and unmanaged forests. Doing so would be useful for understanding the impacts of fires on Canada's natural landscapes, and those emissions on the atmosphere.
But even if Canada was estimating these emissions, none of them would show up on the country's balance sheet.
Canada's official report on greenhouse gases dutifully records LULUCF emissions, but excludes them from the country's total emissions. Canada is not alone: the country follows standard international guidance for how these inventories accounted for.
Part of the rationale for excluding LULUCF emissions is that they are often due to causes that are largely out of direct human control, such as forest fires and insect outbreaks. LULUCF emissions are also more uncertain to estimate than emissions from other sources like vehicles or industry. On top of that, these emissions are so variable that they could obscure other trends in the inventory over which countries have more direct control.
This arrangement for reporting emissions may seem strange, given emissions from forest fires will amp up the severity of global warming, but it's founded on a logic rooted in clarity and responsibility. The global emissions accounting system is intended to focus countries on the emissions that can be most accurately estimated and most easily controlled by national action. (There are also critiques of how Canada accounts for the emissions it does estimate, but the estimates themselves are generally considered reasonable).
What does all this mean for Canada's climate progress?
It's obvious that wildfires are a significant problem for Canadians as well as for the climate. And just as rising temperatures make the fires worse, so too do the fires worsen climate change.
Adaptation measures, including forest management programs to reduce the spread of wildfires and policy changes that reduce the risk to communities, are clearly necessary.
But adaptation alone still leaves the larger problem of the emissions from fires that will burn anyways. If those emissions cannot easily be addressed, what is to be done? The scale of the threat leaves only one good option: for societies to reduce the emissions that they can control.
It is precisely because some emissions cannot be easily avoided that we must tackle the emissions we can reduce. Climate mitigation cannot stop all wildfires, but it can slow their advance, and put limits on a problem that-if left unchecked-would not stop growing. Every gram of carbon that can be kept out of the atmosphere compensates for every gram that is emitted. Every ounce of mitigation mitigates.
The message of Canada's wildfires is not that there is little meaning to our efforts. It is that those efforts are more necessary than ever.
Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

Ottawa advised to set up office to track UFOs
Ottawa advised to set up office to track UFOs

Winnipeg Free Press

time4 days ago

  • Winnipeg Free Press

Ottawa advised to set up office to track UFOs

The truth is out there — and the Sky Canada Project say the federal government should create an office to get to the bottom of UFOs. Chief science adviser Mona Nemer said 37-page report titled 'Management of Public Reporting of Unidentified Aerial Phenomena in Canada,' has attracted 'more public anticipation than any project in the history of this office. 'Numerous individuals and organizations have stepped forward to offer their assistance,' Nemer said. ALEX BRANDON / THE ASSOCIATED PRESS FILES A video of a UAP is paused for display during a hearing of the House Intelligence, Counterterrorism, Counterintelligence, and Counterproliferation Subcommittee hearing on 'Unidentified Aerial Phenomena,' on Capitol Hill in the U.S. in May 2022. 'Rarely does anyone mistake a flock of geese flying in V formation for a fighter squadron flying at high altitudes, but sometimes what is being observed in the sky is not immediately clear and a person may wonder if what they are seeing is a natural phenomenon, a new type of aircraft or something else altogether.' The report by the Sky Canada Project, which is led by the chief science adviser's office, found in a survey it commissioned, that one in four respondents 'personally witnessed a UAP in their lifetime. However, only 10 per cent reported their sightings and 40 per cent of respondents would not know whom to contact for reporting.' One of the report's 14 recommendations is that a federal department or agency must manage unidentified aerial phenomena data from the public. 'This service would collect testimonies, investigate cases and post its analyses publicly,' the report says. 'It would proactively inform Canadians about UAPs.' The report says Transport Canada should encourage pilots, cabin crew and air traffic controllers to report sightings of UAPs 'without fear of stigmatization' as well as analyze the reports to give pilots explanations to 'reduce distractions during flights.' Nemer could not be reached for comment. Winnipegger Chris Rutkowski, an expert on UFOs who publishes the annual Canadian UFO Survey, said he was one of the consultants on the report and went to Ottawa to share his expertise and statistics with Sky Canada Project scientists. 'I'm relatively optimistic they will designate an office,' Rutkowski said. 'They did have such an office until 1995 in the National Research Council. 'They had a contingent of investigators and the RCMP and all of their detectives assisted. But it finished in 1995 when the NRC stepped from an interest in meteors to the CanadArm and Canadians in space. So for 30 years there hasn't been any organized collection of any cases whatsoever.' Rutkowski said that left just his volunteer-based organization and it continues to receive reports. He said Manitobans reported 30 UFOs last year while nationally 1,008 reports were made. 'There have been 25,000 cases since we've been doing the survey since 1989,' he said. Rutkowski said a federal office would be beneficial in other ways, and not just to counter disinformation. 'There is a need to keep track of cases,' he said. 'And, with our now challenging political state, there is a push for greater defence and security. One could argue this may fall under defence.' Sundays Kevin Rollason's Sunday newsletter honouring and remembering lives well-lived in Manitoba. Philip Ferguson, founding director of the University of Manitoba's Space Technology and Advanced Research Laboratory (STARlab) and an associate professor in the department of mechanical engineering, said setting up a federal office to track UAP's 'is a great idea.' 'We live in a time today when people are able to make their own UFOs,' he said. 'Drones are more ubiquitous today than they were even five years ago.' Ferguson, who is also president of the Canadian Aeronautics and Space Institute, said it doesn't mean the office would only receive reports from people who believe they have seen aliens from another plant. 'UFO or UAP does not mean an alien,' he said. 'It means they have seen something that they don't know what it is. With where our technology is, I do think it is important to have a uniform location for where Canadians can report these things.' Kevin RollasonReporter Kevin Rollason is a general assignment reporter at the Free Press. He graduated from Western University with a Masters of Journalism in 1985 and worked at the Winnipeg Sun until 1988, when he joined the Free Press. He has served as the Free Press's city hall and law courts reporter and has won several awards, including a National Newspaper Award. Read more about Kevin. Every piece of reporting Kevin produces is reviewed by an editing team before it is posted online or published in print — part of the Free Press's tradition, since 1872, of producing reliable independent journalism. Read more about Free Press's history and mandate, and learn how our newsroom operates. Our newsroom depends on a growing audience of readers to power our journalism. If you are not a paid reader, please consider becoming a subscriber. Our newsroom depends on its audience of readers to power our journalism. Thank you for your support.

Climate scientists calculate role human-caused climate change plays in shifting weather extremes Français
Climate scientists calculate role human-caused climate change plays in shifting weather extremes Français

Cision Canada

time6 days ago

  • Cision Canada

Climate scientists calculate role human-caused climate change plays in shifting weather extremes Français

GATINEAU, QC, July 17, 2025 /CNW/ - Environment and Climate Change Canada is committed to climate research into how and why the country's climate has changed over the decades. Research like this will help us predict future changes and provide Canadians with a deeper understanding of how human-caused climate change affects extreme weather events, like heat waves and cold snaps. This summer, climate scientists are using the Rapid Extreme Weather Event Attribution system to analyze heat waves across Canada to determine how CO2 and other emissions from human activities impacted extreme heat. During the summer of 2024, climate scientists analyzed the 37 most extreme heat events across Canada. In all cases, they found that the heat waves were likely because of climate change. This summer, human-caused climate change already made two heat waves in Canada much more likely to occur. This means that human influence on the climate made the following events at least two to 10 times more likely to occur: Yukon (June 20 to 23) Peak daily high temperature during the heat wave: 22.0 °C Degrees above normal daily high temperature: 6.5 °C Alberta (May 28 to 31) Peak daily high temperature during the heat wave: 28.8 °C Degrees above normal daily high temperature: 11.3 °C Analysis of how weather events are linked to human-caused climate change relies on advanced climate models and observations to compare today's climate with what existed in the pre-industrial era (1850 to 1900). Comparison allows climate scientists to answer the question, "What role did human-caused climate change play in this event?" and provides concrete results that can be quickly understood. This past winter, climate scientists also piloted a new function to analyze climate change's impact on cold weather events. As the global climate continues to warm, extreme cold temperatures are becoming less frequent. This work provides Canadians with direct insight into how human-caused climate change and its devastating impacts are affecting their lives and weather today and see these changes as they unfold. Canadians are encouraged to regularly monitor weather forecasts, take all weather alerts seriously, and get prepared for weather-related events by developing an emergency plan and being ready to adjust their travel plans. Canadians can download the WeatherCAN app to receive weather alert notifications directly on their mobile devices. Alerts help Canadians prepare to face severe weather events, save lives, and reduce the impacts on property and livelihoods. Quotes "With this important work, our scientists are proving that the changing climate plays a significant role in severe weather. Rising global temperatures are creating longer dry seasons and hotter conditions, which in turn increase the risk of wildfires. This knowledge helps us so we can work together to protect our environment, our communities, and our future." – The Honourable Julie Dabrusin, Minister of Environment and Climate Change "During this demanding and challenging wildfire season, it's clear that more extreme natural disasters and severe weather events are becoming increasingly common. Before the mid-1990s, Canada had seen just three disasters that caused over $500 million in damages—now, we're seeing disasters of that scale almost every year. As events like wildfires, heat waves, and smoke become more frequent, it's important to understand the risks to yourself, your family, and your community. Visit Get Prepared for practical steps you can take to stay safe. The well-being of Canadians will always be our top priority." – The Honourable Eleanor Olszewski, Minister of Emergency Management and Community Resilience and Minister responsible for Prairies Economic Development Canada Quick facts In January, climate scientists analyzed a two-day cold snap in western Ontario. The coldest temperature recorded during the extreme cold event was -34.0 °C. Extreme climate-related weather events are becoming more frequent, severe, and costly. 2020, 2021, 2022, and 2023 rank in the top 10 years based on insurance claims, surpassed only by the 2016 Fort McMurray fires, the 2013 flooding in Calgary and Toronto, and the 1998 Quebec ice storm (source). Environment and Climate Change Canada is the country's official source for weather information and severe weather warnings and is committed to providing Canadians with accurate and timely weather information, including severe weather alerts. The latest forecasts and severe weather warnings are available through Environment and Climate Change Canada's weather website and the WeatherCAN app (available for Android and iOS devices). Contacts Media Relations Environment and Climate Change Canada 819-938-3338 or 1-844-836-7799 (toll-free) [email protected] Environment and Climate Change Canada's X page Environment and Climate Change Canada's Facebook page Environment and Natural Resources in Canada's Facebook page Environment and Climate Change Canada's LinkedIn page Environment and Climate Change Canada's Instagram page SOURCE Environment and Climate Change Canada

Is Suzuki right that it's 'too late'? We are in an era of simultaneous wins and losses
Is Suzuki right that it's 'too late'? We are in an era of simultaneous wins and losses

National Observer

time11-07-2025

  • National Observer

Is Suzuki right that it's 'too late'? We are in an era of simultaneous wins and losses

I didn't mean for it to happen. I was watching a Disney show on my laptop with my 10-year-old son. But when the show ended, and I closed the tab, the next open tab filled my screen. It was an article from iPolitics with the neck-throttling headline: ''It's too late': David Suzuki says the fight against climate change is lost.' 'What?' cried my son. 'David Suzuki said that!' I was caught off-guard. 'It's complicated,' I stammered, that last refuge of scoundrels. 'He is wrestling with some despair after trying for so many years.' He's in good company. Truth is, the article caught many of us off-guard, if my social network is any indication. Some of its readers concur, while others were angry. 'I'm really annoyed about that Suzuki thing. It's irresponsible,' a colleague texted me. 'He is saying out loud the private thoughts that many of us have all the time,' wrote Devika Shah, executive director of Environment Funders Canada on LinkedIn. 'It was a tough read, but we humans are where we are. For my fellow climate peeps who think he is wrong to say this — please recognize that he's earned the right.' All of us who work on climate have long walked a razor's edge between hope and despair, and the last few months (or years) have made it near impossible to keep one's balance. But I would put the current predicament differently. While we all know Suzuki as a communicator, he is firstly a scientist and is speaking some basic scientific truths. He's also trying to sound an alarm and rouse us out of a collective stupor, and he's not wrong to want to do that — while polling indicates Canadians are worried about climate change, we are clearly not as scared as we should be. The scientific community as a whole is worried. The situation is grim — temperature increases are happening faster than predicted, extreme weather events are escalating, planetary boundaries are being breached. The assaults on the people and places we love aren't a distant threat somewhere else, sometime in the future — they are here and now. Governments throw in the towel I, too, am losing faith. All of us who work on climate have long walked a razor's edge between hope and despair, and the last few months (or years) have made it near impossible to keep one's balance. We are all wrestling with the jarring and growing disconnect between climate events and our politics. President Trump's brutal roll-back of climate actions south of the border is throwing us all for a loop. But even in our own country, our federal and provincial governments are acting like a bunch of surrender monkeys, walking away from their climate commitments. Our official climate plans are in a shambles and riddled with incoherence, as governments continue to approve new fossil fuel infrastructure while abandoning carbon pricing, emission caps and, potentially, vehicle mandates. The defeatism is hard to take. The complicated psychology of now All that said, I would put the current predicament differently than saying it's 'too late.' More accurately, it both is and isn't too late. Those of us trying to move the public to action must hold with care the collective psychology of the moment, and engage in responsible truth-telling. For example, the leaders we most remember from the Second World War were outstanding communicators who managed to walk a difficult line — they were forthright with the public about the severity of the threat, while still managing to impart hope. That's what this moment requires. We are motivated by a complicated and highly personal mix of hope and fear, love and anger. All of which needs to be tapped to win this fight. There is no place for false optimism. But as the climate scientist Kate Marvel says, this battle for our lives doesn't need optimists, it needs heroes — people of courage, which she defines as, 'the resolve to do well without the assurance of a happy ending.' Ten years ago, the countries of the world signed the Paris Agreement and committed to do what they could to keep global temperature rise below 1.5 degrees Celsius. Sadly, on that score, it is indeed too late. Admitting this defeat is not something that should be done nonchalantly; it is a brutal indictment of us all. In Paris, the rallying cry of Pacific Island nations and others from the Global South was '1.5 to stay alive.' That threshold is indeed existential for them, and we have failed them. But the climate fight is not something we either win or lose. As the saying goes, it functions as a 'matter of degrees.' Each incremental increase in temperature comes with devastating losses to the people and places we love. But it is also the case that each incremental increase we prevent saves millions. While we are already witnessing the death and destruction that comes with 1.5 degrees, a 2-degree world — which can still be prevented — will be that much worse, while a 3-degree world is unimaginable, and a 4-degree world is not one any of us would want our children and grandchildren to inhabit. To not continue to do everything we can to avoid that next incremental increase is obscene. The awkwardness of the current period is that, for the next many years, we are going to experience both losses and wins simultaneously. Yes, we need to be eyes wide open to the devastating extreme events now underway. But we also need to be alive to the hopeful trends: China looks to have peaked its GHG emissions, years ahead of schedule; Europe is driving down emissions much faster than Canada; in Norway, 97 per cent of new vehicle sales are now zero-emission; in the UK, emissions are now lower than at any time since the start of the industrial revolution in the late 1800's; and around the world, the adoption of renewable energy is exploding. The point being, the struggle to tackle the climate emergency is a steep climb down, not a cliff. This September, the global climate movement will be trying to recapture some of the lost momentum of recent post-pandemic years. At rallies across Canada and around the world, under the banner ' Draw the Line,' people are being invited to shake off their feelings of isolation and join this call: 'Floods, droughts, storms and heatwaves are getting worse. Food and energy costs are going up while a few billionaires profit and prop up the industries that harm people and pollute our lands, air and waters. Indigenous leaders from the Amazon to the Pacific have spoken out: our future is at stake. To solve this crisis, the answer is us — the people… This September we will come together to draw the line against injustice, pollution, and violence — and for a future built on peace, clean energy and fairness. This world is ours. This is our line to draw.'

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into a world of global content with local flavor? Download Daily8 app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store