Prison Service rejects call to review policy for prisoners on death of close relatives
The recommendation by the Office of the Inspector of Prisons comes from an investigation into the death of a 27-year-old male in Wheatfield Prison on January 8th, 2023, and a subsequent decision by the IPS to impose a condition on a visit by two of the deceased's brothers to see his body in a funeral home.
Advertisement
Both men declined the offer of compassionate temporary release because of the restriction that no other relatives could be present if they attended the funeral home for a private escorted visit to pay respect to their brother.
Relatives of the prisoner, identified only as Mr B, expressed deep dissatisfaction to OIP investigators about the restriction on the two brothers getting to see their sibling's body.
They claimed it was a very difficult time for everyone and particularly the two brothers in Wheatfield who they believed required emotional support from other family members.
Mr B was an enhanced prisoner on an incentivised regime serving a 17-month prison sentence in a shared cell in Wheatfield at the time of his death.
Advertisement
The OIP was informed by Mr B's wife and other relatives that he was in good mood and sounding 'nice and normal' in a number of phone calls from a contraband mobile phone to friends and family shortly before he was found unresponsive in his cell.
The report showed Mr B's cellmate alerted prison staff after waking up shortly before 1.15am and finding him unresponsive.
However, efforts to resuscitate Mr B were unsuccessful and were discontinued approximately 55 minutes later.
Prison medical records showed that Mr B had no history or current intentions of deliberate self-harm when assessed by healthcare staff after he was transferred to Wheatfield from the Midlands Prison in November 2022.
Advertisement
He had no medical referrals, prescribed medicine or hospital visits and was not subject to special monitoring in the six months before his death.
The OIP noted that the prisoner governor and chaplain relayed the news of Mr B's death to his two brothers at 7.45am.
They were both relocated together to a shared cell, while Mr B's cellmate was allowed to meet them to offer condolences and to discuss events.
The governor informed the OIP that arrangements were also put in place for Mr B's brothers to access healthcare and psychology services as well as being provided with additional phone calls.
Advertisement
The governor and chaplain also attended the home of the deceased's wife at 9am to offer their condolences and to answer any questions that they could.
The OIP noted that the family appreciated the in-person visit but expressed disappointment that they were not allowed to physically embrace Mr B's two brothers at their first family visit following his passing as they were only permitted a screened visit which prevented physical interaction.
However, Wheatfield's governor said the families of both prisoners visited at the same time and were permitted to engage with each other during the visit which would not normally be permitted.
The governor said the visit took place in the visiting area where there is a half partition between visiting booths and a low dividing panel between the visitor and prisoner.
Advertisement
In making its recommendation for a review of compassionate arrangements, the OIP said the unexpected death of a son and sibling is a painful experience in any circumstances 'all the more so if the deceased and some of his siblings are imprisoned at the time.'
The OIP said it was not aware of any individualised security concerns that required Mr B's relatives to be prohibited from physically comforting his incarcerated siblings whether in Wheatfield or at the funeral home.
Ireland
Irish Prison Service urged for halt of extra court...
Read More
The watchdog acknowledged the efforts by prison staff to be compassionate to the prisoner's family.
It noted that no recommendations were made by the IPS following a critical incident review of Mr B's death.
However, the IPS rejected the OIP's recommendation and claimed the prisoner's family were not prohibited from physically comforting his incarcerated siblings.
It added: 'The Irish Prison Service assesses its capacity to make compassionate arrangements for prisoners and their families on a case-by-case basis, based on operational and security constraints.'
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Independent
an hour ago
- The Independent
Warning issued for common artificial sweetener that can interfere with cancer treatments
A popular sugar substitute may interfere with certain cancer treatments, according to new research. The University of Pittsburgh and UPMC Hillman Cancer Center have released new research suggesting that using sucralose — a popular sugar replacement used by those trying to lose weight or manage their blood sugar levels — may make it harder to the body to respond to certain cancer treatments. According to the research, patients with melanoma and non-small cell lung cancer who consumed high levels of sucralose responded worse to immunotherapy and had worse survival rates than individuals whose diets had low levels of the artificial sweetener. The research also revealed a potential pathway for counteracting the potential negative effects of sucralose. The researchers found supplements that boost the levels of amino acid arginine actually counteracted the negative effects of the sweetener on immunotherapy treatments in mice. That approach could be pursed in further clinical trials to see if it can be used in humans. Doctor Abby Overacre, assistant professor in the Department of Immunology at the University of Pittsbugh and UPMC Hillman said in a statement that finding ways around forcing dietary changes is a worthwhile course of action, especially for cancer patients who are already dealing with the burden of the disease. 'It's easy to say, 'Stop drinking diet soda,' but when patients are being treated for cancer, they are already dealing with enough, so asking them to drastically alter their diet may not be realistic,' she said. 'We need to meet patients where they are. That's why it's so exciting that arginine supplementation could be a simple approach to counteract the negative effects of sucralose on immunotherapy.' The study, which used testing on mice, found the negative effects were potentially caused by disruption to gut bacteria by the artificial sweetener. It found that sucralose caused a shift in the composition of the gut bacteria in mice which allowed for an increase in bacteria that degrade arginine. The increased arginine resulted in reduced levels of the amino acid in blood, tumor fluid, and stool. 'When arginine levels were depleted due to sucralose-driven shifts in the microbiome, T cells couldn't function properly,' Overacre said. 'As a result, immunotherapy wasn't as effective in mice that were fed sucralose.' Diwakar Davar, associate professor of medicine at the University of Pittsburgh and a medical oncologist and hematologist at UPMC Hillman, was a collaborator on the study and noted that the negative effects of sucralose was consistent across a range of treatments for a variety of cancer types and stages. He said that prebiotic supplements could theoretically be developed specifically for cancer patients with high levels of sucralose in their blood to help mitigate the negative effects. The researchers hope to pursue a clinical trial to determine whether or not boosting arginine through supplements will counteract the effects of the sucralose. They also plan to expand their research to look at the effects of other artificial sweeteners — such as aspartame, saccharin, xylitol, and stevia — on the immune system and on cancer treatments.
The Sun
an hour ago
- The Sun
Prolonged hot weather may be fuelling rise in obesity rates, study suggests
BLAME your belly on the sunshine, say scientists - as hot weather makes us gain weight. A study in Australia estimated that someone's risk of being obese increases by 0.2 per cent for every day of the year that is warmer than 30C. Sweltering summer days might slow our metabolism by wrecking our sleep, put us off exercising, and have us reaching for fattening fizzy drinks to cool off. The UK has enjoyed an early start to summer this year, with eleven 30C days so far. The Met Office says 2025 is one of only three years on record to have had so many by July – with 2018 and 1976. Research led by the University of Adelaide compared rates of obesity and weather across eight Australian states between 2006 and 2022. It found citizens in the hottest areas were more likely to be obese and as an area's temperatures increased so did the number of fat people. Writing in the journal Economics & Human Biology, the study authors said: 'High temperatures can make outdoor activities and physical activities less appealing, leading to a sedentary lifestyle which has been shown to increase obesity. 'Further, extreme temperatures can cause heat-related sleep disturbances that influence metabolism. 'Temperature shocks can also affect the body's metabolism and appetite. 'High temperatures may suppress appetite in the short term, but can also lead to increased consumption of high-calorie, sugary beverages for cooling and hydration.' Two thirds of British adults are overweight and about 30 per cent are obese, raising their risk of cancer, dementia and heart diseases. I put my 11-year-old daughter on fat jabs after she got bullied for her weight - people judge me but I don't care The researchers suggested people in areas that are normally cold – such as the UK – might be more vulnerable. They added: 'We find that the effects of extreme temperature on obesity are more pronounced for people living in states with general cold climates and for older people compared to younger people.' 1
Times
8 hours ago
- Times
I fixed fractured medical practice teams after injuring my back
Rachel Bothwell grew up helping out in the family business, a medical practice in Arklow, Co Wicklow. Her father looked after the patients; her mother looked after the practice. She studied business and French at Trinity College Dublin followed by a postgraduate diploma in fashion buying and retail management at Technological University Dublin, going on to work as a womenswear buyer in Dunnes. In 2018, with four years' career experience under her belt, she packed it in to go travelling for two years. Just weeks in, while in Tanzania, she got a call from her parents to say her father had been diagnosed with cancer. She returned home immediately to take over the management of his busy practice, shepherding a team of 15 staff and locums through a period of unprecedented change. Not only was the business forced into a sudden generational shift due to the absence of its senior GP partner and its practice manager — her parents — but no sooner were they through that than the pandemic hit. Despite, or perhaps because of, all the massive upheaval, Bothwell took the opportunity to overhaul the practice's systems, strengthening its financial analysis and control and generally improving its overall health. More importantly, her father recovered too. 'He's all better,' she says. Despite having grown up around the practice, she was surprised at how challenging it was to run it. 'I had no idea how complex it was going to be, even though it was extremely well run.' Bothwell managed the crisis with aplomb, but then she is made of stern stuff. On holiday in 2019 in Bolivia, she fractured her back in a car crash and soldiered on, not seeking medical attention until she got home. Call it the medical equivalent of the cobbler's kid. When finally forced to rest up and recuperate from her injury, she used the time to build a website for her father's practice. She also signed up for a diploma in practice management at the Irish College of GPs. The course gave her a ready-made network of fellow practice managers, which proved invaluable when Covid hit and practices across the country struggled to adapt. 'I had this group of 20 women in a WhatsApp when Covid hit, and it just occurred to me that other practice managers around the country don't have that kind of access to a network,' she says. 'GPs have networks, nurses have all sorts of Facebook groups and WhatsApp groups, but practice managers really didn't have anywhere to go for that kind of support. For example, if I asked my mum for information about something she'd point me to a circular [from the HSE] from 1995 in a cupboard. It was really hard to access up-to-date information.' It prompted her, in the spring of 2021, to set up GP Practice Ally. She started out simply pulling together information for practices and putting it online, initially anything to do with the state's general medical services scheme. She then created a community forum, which from day one started receiving questions — and answers — from users. Her instinct was correct: practice managers did want help. GP Practice Ally now supports more than 2,000 practice managers and GPs, representing 75 per cent of Irish practices. It provides subscription-based on-demand resources such as webinars, templates and toolkits for almost everything, including health and safety and human resources. It also offers in-person training and onsite consulting. It publishes an annual general practice diary, a monthly newsletter and is the country's leading website provider for practices, designing and maintaining more than 100 GP websites around the country. 'Each is custom built and includes features such as online payment and booking systems, prescription ordering, practice policies, patient forms and regularly updated resources, ensuring a seamless experience for both patients and staff,' Bothwell says. The company won outstanding small business of the year at the 2025 Small Firms Association awards. Bothwell attributes its rude good health to the clarity of its mission. 'We empower practice teams so they can focus on what they do best: delivering excellent patient care.'
