Terminal breast cancer patients denied life-extending drugs
Charity Breast Cancer Now has issued an urgent plea to Health Secretary Wes Streeting, demanding "immediate action" to dismantle current spending restraints.
The organisation is also calling for the NHS spending watchdog, the National Institute for Health and Care Excellence (Nice), to lower its threshold for what it classifies as a "very severe health condition."
Nice's severity modifier, introduced in 2022, is designed to give greater weight to treatments for more severe illnesses, increasing the likelihood of their recommendation for NHS use.
However, Breast Cancer Now argues that the current criteria are too stringent, potentially preventing thousands of women from accessing vital therapies.
According to Nice, the process raises the threshold for what it considers to be a cost-effective treatment, meaning it can give more expensive drugs the green light.
However, a new report from Breast Cancer Now claims the system means women with incurable breast cancer with months to live may be told their condition does not qualify for the most severe rating.
The call comes after it emerged that the life-extending drug Enhertu will not be made available for women with incurable breast cancer on the NHS in England and Wales.
In November, Nice said talks with manufacturers AstraZeneca and Daiichi Sankyo over the price of the medication had broken down for the third time with no agreement.
Claire Rowney, chief executive at Breast Cancer Now, said: 'The terrifying reality is that unless urgent action is taken thousands of women in the UK with incurable secondary breast cancer could be denied access to vital life-extending treatments because of an unfair system.
'We're talking about patients missing out on access to cutting-edge, effective treatments that could give them more time to be there for special moments such as birthdays or seeing their children or grandchildren start school.
'Treatments, such as Enhertu, that patients in other countries, including Scotland, can access, giving them the chance to live longer.
'Women with secondary breast cancer tell us they feel their lives are being deprioritised by the changes to the system.
'We will not stand by and witness more drugs being rejected or not taken forward, when the devastating cost is thousands more people with secondary breast cancer across England, Wales and Northern Ireland having their lives cut short.'
Paula Van Santen, 50, was diagnosed with secondary breast cancer in July 2022, two months after her diagnosis of primary breast cancer.
The mother-of-three, from Banbury in Oxfordshire, said: 'Secondary breast cancer has changed the lives of both myself and my family beyond belief. Coming to terms with my diagnosis is the hardest part because I've had to grieve for the life I had, but also the life that I'm not going to have.
'If a new drug can give me another six months, if it gives me another year, it's worth it.
'It could allow me to see my daughter get to 21, see my children get married or meet grandchildren. Just to have a picture with a grandchild so they would know that I existed would be so precious. That's what this could give.'
Main symptoms of breast cancer in women
NHS
Ms Rowney called for 'change' and said Mr Streeting should scrap 'opportunity-cost neutral' restraints.
Opportunity cost neutrality in the Nice severity modifier aims to ensure the new system does not require more or less overall NHS funding than the old one.
According to the Breast Cancer Now report, this is 'at the root of the issues with the modifier'.
It added: 'It pits end-of-life cancer treatments against other severe conditions like cystic fibrosis in a way that's reductive and unfair to patients. And, ultimately, it creates barriers to the approval of drugs for advanced cancers.'
Ms Rowney said: 'The system for deciding whether drugs are approved for use on the NHS must change now.
'We're calling for immediate action from Wes Streeting, Secretary of State for Health and Social Care, to urgently scrap 'opportunity-cost neutral' restraints and for Nice to lower the bar for what it defines as 'a severe condition'. And we stand ready to work with them.'
Dr Samantha Roberts, chief executive of Nice, welcomed the report from Breast Cancer Now, saying: 'The independent analysis we commissioned recently showed the new severity weighting is working as intended and expected.
'It is able to be applied more widely – for example to treatments for cystic fibrosis, hepatitis D and Duchenne muscular dystrophy – and has contributed to an increase in positive decisions for cancer medicines and non-cancer medicines.
'And other breast cancer treatments have been recommended since we introduced the severity modifier – including for advanced breast cancer.
'We remain deeply disappointed that we were unable to recommend Enhertu for HER2-low advanced breast cancer. We know this was devastating to all those hoping for a different answer.
'It remains the only breast cancer treatment we have been unable to recommend in seven years.'
A Department of Health and Social Care spokesperson said the upcoming 10-year health plan will 'transform the NHS and improve care for those facing cancer'.
'This includes rolling out DIY screening kits for cervical cancer, more radiotherapy machines in every region and opening more Community Diagnostic Centres closer to where people live,' they added.
'We know how disappointing it is to many families that the manufacturers of Enhertu are unwilling to sell this life-extending treatment to the NHS at a fair and reasonable price. Our door remains open to supporting the introduction of medicines at a cost-effective price.'
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Independent
23 minutes ago
- The Independent
Climate change could bring tropical diseases to UK
Climate change is driving tropical infectious diseases like dengue and West Nile Virus northwards into Europe as pathogens thrive in hotter, more humid conditions, with fears the danger could spread to the UK. Researchers project a potential five-fold increase in chikungunya and dengue outbreaks by 2060, with 2024 dengue cases in Europe already surpassing the cumulative total of the previous 15 years. The spread is linked to the Asian tiger mosquito, a vector for dengue, chikungunya, and Zika, which is now established in several European countries including France, Germany, and Spain. Beyond vector-borne diseases, altered climate conditions, such as floods, also increase the risk of waterborne illnesses by disrupting water treatment and distribution. Experts recommend reducing greenhouse gas emissions, enhancing surveillance, controlling mosquito and tick populations, increasing vaccinations, and educating the public to manage these growing health threats.
Daily Mail
24 minutes ago
- Daily Mail
Father desperately tried to save life of son, five, when he suffered fatal allergic reaction after eating biscuit at school, inquest hears
A father desperately tried to save his five-year-old son's life as he suffered a fatal allergic reaction after eating a biscuit at school, an inquest has been told. Peter Blythe arrived at Barnack Primary, in Stamford, Lincolnshire, to discover his son Benedict unconscious on the floor and staff frantically trying to revive him. He has now been giving evidence at the inquest, describing at Peterborough Town Hall his efforts to help. The tragedy unfolded on December 1 2021 when Benedict, who was allergic to dairy, eggs, peanuts, sesame and chickpeas, vomited during breaktime. Mr Blythe said: 'Benedict was dying in front of us and I could not believe what was happening.' The retired RAF senior aircraftsman immediately began CPR but struggled to clear mucus blocking Benedict's airway. Music teacher Dave Read, who was working outside the reception class at the time, saw Mr Blythe enter the room and then heard him yell - then stepped in to assist, having been trained in first aid. Mr Read said: 'It seemed the right decision to take over CPR, as Mr Blythe was crying - but he was not in any way doing a bad job. 'Everyone was working together to do the right thing. At the time, the CPR felt like it was working.' Mr Blythe and school staff continued to perform CPR for between 10 and 15 minutes before paramedics arrived. Benedict's mother Helen got there just two minutes later, at the same time as an air ambulance. The child was taken to Peterborough City Hospital but was pronounced dead shortly before 1pm on the day he was taken ill. Benedict had not previously shown signs of an allergic reaction and teaching assistant Sophie Brown said she assumed the sickness that day was related to an illness earlier in the week, the inquest has heard. She did not recall him asking for his blue asthma inhaler - adding that if he had, then she would have taken it as a sign he was having an allergic reaction and fetched his epi-pens immediately. Benedict vomited for a second time 10 minutes later and his class teacher Jenny Brass took him outside to get some fresh air - and it was at this point he collapsed. Ms Brown told the inquest: 'I heard Jenny shouting my name and she was carrying Benedict inside. 'He was floppy and appeared to be unconscious. His skin was grey-blue which I took to mean he was in shock and I immediately got his bag and administered his EpiPen.' She added that she could feel Benedict breathing and placed him in the recovery position - and then when he stopped breathing she began to perform CPR. Paramedics and his father had been called and Mr Blythe arrived shortly afterwards. Benedict was one of three children in the class with known allergies - though Ms Brown said she had not seen any written allergy management plan for him. She had received online anaphylaxis training and online and in-person training on how to use an epi pen, the inquest was told. The jury heard that Benedict, who lived in Stamford with his parents and younger sister Etta, had eaten a McVities gingerbread biscuit as a break time snack, which he had brought in from home. He had refused a carton of oat milk and drank water instead. Benedict's mother Helen Blythe was among those giving evidence on the opening day earlier this week of the inquest into the death of her 'kind-souled' son'. She told how he was 'not just a child with allergies' but 'a whole universe', as she paid tribute to the boy as 'curious, funny, kind and loving - adding: 'The world should have been safer for him.' Elizabeth Gray, the area coroner for Cambridgeshire and Peterborough, has addressed a jury at Peterborough Town Hall considering a verdict in the inquest. She informed the court how Benedict as kept home from school on November 30, shortly before his death, because he was unwell and had vomited the previous night - but he went to school as normal on December 1. The coroner said Benedict ate a biscuit during that school day which he had brought from home and was then offered oat milk by a class teacher but declined to drink it. The inquest is scheduled to continue for the rest of the week, with other school staff and health professionals lined up to give evidence.
Sky News
24 minutes ago
- Sky News
Princess of Wales reveals pressure to put on 'brave face' after cancer diagnosis
The Princess of Wales has spoken of the pressure to put on a "brave face" after being diagnosed with cancer and the intense expectations to "crack on, get back to normal" once treatment is finished. What felt like her most personal and extensive public reflections on her recovery journey to date came as she met fellow patients at a cancer wellbeing centre at Colchester Hospital, helping to plant roses in a garden designed to help visitors find peace. It follows recent media coverage about her decision not to attend Royal Ascot two weeks ago. The Princess is in remission from cancer and the palace has consistently insisted there would be flexibility around her public engagements as she continues her recovery. Appearing to address the issue herself, Kate said: "There is a whole phase when you finish your treatment. Everybody expects you to be better - go. You're done, you should be back. But it's not the case at all." Speaking to other cancer patients and volunteers, she added: "You put on a sort of brave face, stoicism through treatment, treatment's done, then it's like 'I can crack on, get back to normal', but actually the phase afterwards is really difficult. You're not necessarily under the clinical team any longer, but you're not able to function normally at home as you perhaps once used to." Describing a first diagnosis as "a very scary journey", she explained how in recovery it feels like "you have to find your new normal and that takes time". Speaking to a volunteer who had also been through her own cancer diagnosis, Kate said: "It's life-changing for anyone, through first diagnosis or post-treatment and things like that, it is a life-changing experience both for the patient but also for the families as well. "And actually, it sometimes goes unrecognised, you don't necessarily, particularly when it's the first time, appreciate how much impact it is going to have. You have to find your new normal and that takes time… and it's a rollercoaster, it's not one smooth plain, which you expect it to be. But the reality is it's not, you go through hard times." The wellbeing centre was built outside of the main hospital building, but close enough that patients can easily find it. 1:24 Many newly diagnosed patients at Colchester Hospital now visit the centre immediately for counselling and advice. They also provide holistic treatments, including reflexology. The princess, speaking to therapist Amanda Green during a walkabout in heavy rain afterwards, said she had not yet tried reflexology but had had acupuncture as part of her own health journey. 2:27 Repeatedly praising the focus on "mind, body and spirit" that the centre provides, Kate said "someone to help talk you through that, show you and guide you through that sort of phase that comes after treatment, I think is really valuable." Talking about how difficult it can be for patients to know where to find support she said: "To have a place like this, to have the support network, through creativity and singing or gardening, whatever it might be, is so valuable and it's great this community has it, it would be great if lots of communities had this kind of support." The visit came with a donation of 50 'Catherine's Rose' plants, which she helped to plant in the garden surrounding the wellbeing centre. Named for the princess by the Royal Horticultural Society, the funds from sales of the plants go to the Royal Marsden Cancer Charity.
