Harry lawyers must disclose ‘payment' documents in Mail publisher case
They have accused the publisher of conducting or commissioning unlawful activities such as hiring private investigators to tap phones, 'blagging' private records, and burglaries to order.
The group also includes actress Sadie Frost, campaigner Baroness Doreen Lawrence and politician Sir Simon Hughes.
ANL denies the allegations and is defending the legal action, previously describing the claims as 'lurid' and 'simply preposterous'.
At a hearing in May, lawyers for ANL asked the court in London to order the group's legal team to 'search for and disclose any documents that relate to payments, royalties or inducements paid, provided or offered, or any demands or threats made, in order to obtain documents, information or other co-operation'.
Antony White KC, for ANL, said a limited number of documents had been disclosed, which showed that 'payments were made or offered' to 'procure evidence and invoices'.
In a ruling handed down on Friday, Mr Justice Nicklin said: 'I am satisfied that documents held by the claimants that can support a case that a witness has been paid or offered other inducement for their evidence, whether directly or indirectly, should be disclosed.
'That is because there is a real prospect that Associated will be able to rely upon this evidence to attack the credibility of such witnesses.
'Ultimately, the issue of whether the payment or inducement does affect the credibility of any witness is a matter to be resolved at trial.'
Sir Elton John and his husband David Furnish are part of the legal action against Associated Newspapers Limited (PA)
He added: 'In this case, the stance adopted by the claimants has been undermined by their inconsistent and incoherent approach to disclosure of documents relating to payments to potential witnesses and/or other inducements.'
Mr Justice Nicklin also ordered that lawyers for the claimants should conduct searches to identify and hand over documents ANL could rely on 'in advancing a case that potential witnesses have been given or offered financial incentives to provide information or evidence in support of allegations' of unlawful information gathering (UIG).
The group bringing the case had asked the judge to order ANL to unredact some of the documents the company had provided for the legal proceedings.
Mr Justice Nicklin ordered that 'targeted' un-redactions be made where necessary to assess whether certain journalists had a pattern of engaging in UIG.
He said: 'In my judgment, considering Associated's denials of wrongdoing, the claimants are entitled to explore whether they can advance a case, with a real prospect of success, that the pleaded journalists have a propensity to engage in UIG.'
A trial of the claims is expected to start in January and last for nine weeks.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Independent
11 hours ago
- The Independent
Number of British acts playing at festivals in Europe plummets after Brexit
The number of British music acts performing at major European festivals has significantly decreased since Brexit, with an average fall of a quarter compared to pre-Brexit levels (2017-2019). Analysis of four major festivals, including Benicassim, Lollapalooza, Rock en Seine, and Roskilde, revealed Benicassim experienced the largest drop, with 58 per cent fewer British acts. Industry leaders and musicians, including Elton John, have highlighted that increased paperwork, red tape, and costs are creating a 'logistical nightmare' for touring artists. Organisations like Best for Britain, the Independent Society of Musicians, and UK Music warn that these barriers are damaging opportunities for artists, impacting the UK's £7.6bn music industry, and diminishing its cultural influence. There are urgent calls for the government to address these challenges and work with European partners to implement solutions, with Labour's manifesto also committing to sorting out issues for touring musicians.
The Independent
12 hours ago
- The Independent
Number of British acts at European music festivals plummets since Brexit
Elton John is among those who have warned that the UK's departure from the EU has caused a 'logistical nightmare' and placed 'leg irons' on travelling musicians. Last year he warned the issue risks jeopardising artists' futures and the UK's status as a cultural force, saying he was 'horrified'. Now new figures show fans in France, Spain, Germany and Denmark will miss out as the number of British acts on the bill in some of Europe's biggest festivals plummets. The analysis found that, on average, the number of British musicians who have played, or are scheduled to play, European festivals this summer has fallen by a quarter, compared to 2017-2019. The study looked at four major music festivals – Benicassim in Valencia, Lollapalooza in Berlin, Rock en Seine in Paris and Roskilde Festival in Denmark. Overall Benicassim saw the biggest drop, with 58 per cent fewer British acts taking to the stage in Spain, the analysis by Best for Britain found. Industry leaders and musicians have highlighted that increased paperwork and costs are still damaging opportunities, particularly to take up last-minute slots. At the same time, British venue operators have warned of their struggle to attract EU-based artists. Earlier this year hundreds of music industry professionals signed an open letter to Sir Keir Starmer and the EU's Ursula von der Leyen calling for action. Naomi Smith, Chief Executive of Best for Britain, which campaigns for closer UK-EU ties, said: 'From legends like the Beatles, Queen and David Bowie, via Britpop stars Oasis and Blur, to modern icons like Amy Winehouse, Adele and Raye, Britain is world-famous for our incredible musical legacy – with live performances the lifeblood of the industry. 'Barriers for touring artists are bad news: for acts, audiences, and ultimately hurt the UK's vibrant £7.6bn music industry, meaning a further hit to our squeezed economy, not to mention the dimming effect on our soft power around the world. The government must urgently examine what scope there is to address these challenges - and work with our partners in Europe to implement solutions.' Deborah Annetts, the chief executive of the Independent Society of Musicians, said: ' Brexit is bad for UK musicians, European events and live music lovers across Europe. As this research shows, opportunities for emerging as well as much-loved acts are disappearing, which is a situation that cannot continue. 'Labour's election manifesto committed to sorting out the issues for touring musicians following Brexit.' UK Music chief executive Tom Kiehl said: 'The rising costs and extra red tape involved in touring the EU post-Brexit is a huge challenge for the whole UK music eco-system, ranging from musicians and artists to technicians, engineers and crew.' Earlier this year the Independent also revealed t hat Brexit had created a 'mind blowing' 2bn extra pieces of paperwork - enough to wrap around world 15 times. Brexit is also on course to cut UK trade by 15 per cent, the government's independent financial watchdog has warned.
Daily Mail
20 hours ago
- Daily Mail
Billy Joel finally reveals what sparked 'bad blood' with Elton John
Billy Joel says he and old friend Elton John are in a good place now, but at one time there was 'bad blood' between the two. The Piano Man singer, 76, who has admitted that his alcoholism destroyed his marriage to Christie Brinkley, 71, revealed in part two of the documentary Billy Joel: And So It Goes, which debuted on Friday, that a comment by John to Rolling Stone in 2011 that Joel needed rehab rubbed him the wrong way. 'Elton had made a comment that he thought I needed real rehab,' the Pressure singer said in the film. 'He chalked it up to, "Oh, he's a drunk." And that really hurt me,' he explained. 'I said "wait a minute? Don't you know me better than that?" And there was bad blood for a little while,' Joel said of the conflict, adding, 'There was a dovetailing of things that happened during that time.' In the Rolling Stone article Joel and John were fresh off a recent leg of their Face to Face tour, which they began doing in 1994, and the Tiny Dancer artist blamed Joel's battle with the bottle for several cancellations. 'He's going to hate me for this, but every time he goes to rehab they've been light... I love you Billy, and this is tough love,' the Rocket Man artist, who has also previously grappled with an addiction to alcohol and cocaine, told the outlet. Joel went to rehab in 2005 at The Betty Ford Clinic at the insistence of his then-wife Katie Lee and quickly returned to touring. He and Lee divorced in 2009. The Honesty artist said in the documentary that he felt 'clobbered' after John's comments and he hit 'rock bottom.' 'I was disillusioned with what I thought it was all supposed to mean,' he told the audience. 'It was like all the signs were pointing to me: Enough. And I wrote this letter to the band. "I don't want to do this anymore. I'm gonna stop."' The two men patched things up a couple of years later when John and writing partner Bernie Taupin were inducted into the Songwriters Hall of Fame. 'Mr. Joel, I haven't seen you tonight, but I love you dearly,' he said while accepting the Johnny Mercer award. When Joel later took the stage to introduce the band Foreigner, who were also being inducted he answered, 'Is Elton still here? By the way? We're OK, Call me. It's the same phone number.' In 2023, Joel told the Los Angeles Times he had quit drinking alcohol 'a couple of years ago.' 'It wasn't a big AA kick. I just got to a point where I'd had enough. I didn't enjoy being completely inebriated, and it probably created more problems in my life than I needed.' Joel has taken a break from touring so he can receive treatment for a condition called normal pressure hydrocephalus, which has affected his balance among other things. The two men made up in 2013 at the Songwriters Hall of Fame ceremonies; Pictured in Oakland, CA in February 2010 Earlier this week, Joel was riding in a limo in New York City when he happened upon a pedi-cab that was playing one of his songs. He shocked the driver and his passengers when he rolled down the window to say Hi Earlier this week, Joel was riding in a limo in New York City when he happened upon a Pedi-cab that was playing one of his songs. He shocked the driver and his passengers when he rolled down the window to say Hi. 'We're in a New York State of Mind…always,' he wrote next to the clip. 'Thank you very much again for stopping and making our day,' the owner of Central Park Airlines wrote. 'It's my customers birthday today & she said she had the best birthday ever ( thanks to you smile ☺️ ) RESPECT. If you ever want a pedicab ride - just say when & I'll make my limousine ready.' Both episodes of Billy Joes: And So It Goes are available on HBOMAX.
