Immigration judge rules U of M grad student can't be deported
An immigration court judge has ruled the Department of Homeland Security cannot deport University of Minnesota grad student Dogukan Gunaydin.
DHS is appealing the ruling.
Gunaydin will remain in ICE custody at the Sherburne County jail as the appeal plays out.
MINNEAPOLIS (FOX 9) - An Immigration Court judge has ruled the Department of Homeland Security (DHS) cannot deport University of Minnesota graduate student Dogukan Gunaydin.
What we know
Gunaydin's case has drawn significant attention to the Trump administration's mass deportation efforts targeting college students with criminal records.
Gunaydin was convicted in a 2023 drunk driving case, and while the Immigration judge found it to be a serious offense, she ruled it doesn't warrant removing him from the U.S.
He has been in Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) custody since his arrest on March 27, will remain in custody as DHS appeals the ruling.
The case has drawn significant attention and several protests.
Dig deeper
FOX 9 has obtained Judge Sarah Mazzie's six-page ruling.
In her ruling, Mazzie sided with the Turkish grad student and his legal team, terminating deportation proceedings against him. DHS is appealing her ruling.
For now, Gunaydin will remain behind bars at the Sherburne County Jail in Elk River.
"The court concludes DHS has not met its burden to establish removability by clear, convincing, and unequivocal evidence. Therefore, the court terminates removal proceedings," Judge Mazzie wrote.
The backstory
Gunaydin has been in ICE custody since March 27 after he was arrested near his off-campus apartment in St. Paul.
The government revoked Gunaydin's student visa and began deportation proceedings against him because of a previous drunk driving offense in which his blood alcohol level was more than twice the legal limit.
DHS argues the 2023 arrest makes him a risk to public safety and warrants returning him to his native Turkey.
Judge Mazzie acknowledged the seriousness of Gunaydin's offense writing, "The facts of this case leave no doubt that [Gunaydin] engaged in dangerous activity. However, the evidence is insufficient to establish he placed a large segment of the general population at risk."
In conclusion, Mazzie found DHS did not meet its burden to deport Gunaydin.
What they're saying
The Department of Homeland Security is appealing the ruling.
"The immigration judge erred in failing to find that driving dangerously while severely intoxicated is criminal activity that endangers public safety and as a result erred in terminating the removal proceedings," wrote DHS attorney Laura Trosen.
While the appeal process plays out, Gunaydin will remain in custody.
FOX 9 previously reported a federal court judge has issued a temporary restraining order barring DHS and ICE from moving Gunaydin out of the district of Minnesota during his case proceedings.
What's next
Gunaydin is scheduled to return to Immigration court on Tuesday for his next hearing.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
New York Post
27 minutes ago
- New York Post
Illegal migrant allegedly murdered teen who tried to stop him attacking his mom: ‘Rapist and cold-blooded killer'
An illegal migrant in Kentucky allegedly murdered a 15-year-old boy when the teen tried to stop him from raping his mom, according to authorities. Mexican national Gildardo Amandor-Martinez, 36, is accused of fatally shooting his girlfriend's son, Luis Lopez, when the teen attempted to thwart the sick sexual assault in their Morehead apartment in the early hours of July 20. The teen's younger sister was also struck and injured. '15-year-old Luis Lopez died trying to save his mother from this criminal illegal alien who was attempting to rape her,' Homeland Security assistant secretary Tricia McLaughlin said in a statement. Gildardo Amandor-Martinez, 36, allegedly killed his girlfriend's son, Luis Lopez, when the teen tried to thwart the sick sexual assault in their Morehead, Kentucky apartment on July 20. The Department of Homeland Security 'Gildardo Amandor-Martinez is a rapist and cold-blooded killer who should have never been in this country.' The Mexican national had returned home from a bar just after 2:30 a.m. when he allegedly tried to have sex with his girlfriend in their bedroom, according to court documents obtained by the Lexington Herald Leader. The mom was screaming and trying to fight him off when her son ran into the room and asked if he should call the cops, authorities said. Martinez allegedly ordered Luis to leave and his mom assured him they'd talk about it in the morning, according to the court papers. Amandor-Martinez, a Mexican national, had returned home from a bar just after 2:30 a.m. when he allegedly tried to have sex with his girlfriend, Aleida Lopez, in their bedroom. Rowan County Coroner's Office After the boy left the room, the alleged perp grabbed a pistol and fired three shots through a closed door — striking Luis and his younger sister. Luis suffered a gunshot wound to the face and was pronounced dead at the scene, while his injured sister was rushed to a nearby hospital for treatment. Amandor-Martinez was arrested and slapped with a slew of charges, including rape, resisting arrest and assault. Immigration and Customs Enforcement has since lodged an ICE detainer for him, which calls for local cops to hold illegal migrants in custody until they can be turned over to the feds. Amandor-Martinez was in the US illegally at the time of the slaying, federal officials said. He allegedly tried to illegally cross the US-Mexico border three times in 2021 under the Biden administration. The alleged killer was eventually able to cross undetected 'at an unknown date and location,' DHS said. 'The Biden administration's open-border policies allowed this monster to walk American streets and commit these evil crimes, including murder, assault, and attempted rape, against a mother and her children,' McLaughlin said. 'ICE has placed an arrest detainer to ensure Amandor-Martinez will not be released onto America's streets and allowed to terrorize American families again.'
Epoch Times
28 minutes ago
- Epoch Times
ICE Looking to Hire Personnel, Offers $50,000 Signing Bonus
The Department of Homeland Security (DHS) has launched a recruitment drive to hire 'brave and heroic Americans' for Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) to tackle illegal immigration, the DHS said in a July 29 statement. The 'Defend the Homeland' recruitment initiative aims to hire individuals as federal law enforcement agents and remove 'the worst of the worst criminal illegal aliens from America's streets,' the statement said.
Fox News
an hour ago
- Fox News
Trump says Ukrainians can likely stay in US following months of uncertainty
President Donald Trump has said he will likely allow Ukrainians who have fled the war with Russia to remain in the U.S., ending months of uncertainty over whether they would be forced to leave. "I think we will, yeah, I do, I think we will," Trump said Tuesday evening from the White House in response to a question by reporters regarding whether he will allow Ukrainians to remain in the U.S. until the war ends. "We have a lot of people that came in from Ukraine, and we're working with them," he added. Concern over the temporary protected status (TPS) afforded to roughly 240,000 Ukrainians who fled the war to the U.S. under the government program known as Uniting for Ukraine (U4U), first implemented in April 2022, has been heightened since the first day that Trump entered office in January when he issued the executive order titled "Securing our Borders." Eight days later, on Jan. 28, the Department of Homeland Security (DHS) confirmed that the order had paused the government program, barring additional Ukrainians from entering the U.S. under those protections. However, even as TPS remained in place for Ukrainians already stateside, concern remained high amid reports in March that the president was considering the removal of this protection status. White House press secretary Karoline Leavitt responded to the reporting by Reuters and called it "fake news" before adding "no decision has been made at this time." However, when asked about the reporting later that day, Trump said, "We're certainly not looking to hurt them. "And I'm looking at that, and there were some people that think that's appropriate, and some people don't, and I'll be making a decision pretty soon," he added. Confusion remained after DHS in April reportedly distributed an email to some Ukrainians under the TPS program notifying them that their status had been revoked, and they would need to leave the country within seven days. DHS later confirmed this was sent in error, but the mistake highlighted the uncertainty that persisted for months. The latest assurances by Trump come as he has grown increasingly frustrated with Russian President Vladimir Putin's continued attacks on civilian populations in Ukraine despite U.S. attempts to forge a ceasefire. Trump on Tuesday also announced that Putin has 10 days to enter into some sort of peace deal with Ukraine or face secondary sanctions on its chief commodity – oil. Neither the White House nor DHS immediately responded to Fox News Digital's questions regarding the president's recent announcement, and it remains unclear if the U4U program could also be reopened to other Ukrainian citizens as the war continues.
