One of the residents in our apartment block is spying on everyone. What can we do?
Many residents feel uncomfortable or intimidated. This has been discussed with him, and his response has been to tape record such conversations. Can he use the common area to scrutinise and record, invading the privacy of, and in the process, intimidating his fellow residents in this way?
The management company has a role to play in this case where an owner is acting in a way that breaches the covenant of quiet enjoyment that others have a right to. This level of surveillance and monitoring creates a hostile environment and amounts to harassment of others in the development.
When it comes to effectively regulating the behaviour of individuals in a communal space such as a multi-unit development, the only remedy available to the management company is to rely on the various laws to deal with the situation.
READ MORE
This owner is in breach of data protection law and the criminal law, and from the information provided in this query, the management company has already engaged with solicitors on the matter.
The General Data Protection Regulation (GDPR) is applicable in Ireland and these regulations protect an individual's privacy, even in the common areas of an apartment block. The actions of this owner who is recording people's activities and collecting data such as car registration numbers counts as processing personal data. This activity is illegal under GDPR as the owner is using the data to file complaints.
Section 10 of the Non-Fatal Offences Against the Person Act 1997 deals with the offence of harassment by any means. The provision is aimed at people who, without lawful authority or reasonable excuse, persistently follow, watch, pester, beset or communicate with others.
Sanctions by the courts include a maximum sentence of seven years' imprisonment. If residents are feeling intimidated by this owner, they should individually report the matter to the
Gardaí
and the management company should also report this to Gardaí.
Aisling Keenan is a property managing agent, consultant and an associate member of the Society of Chartered Surveyors Ireland
This owner is engaging in behaviour which is unreasonably interfering with others, and it amounts to private nuisance that can be dealt with through the courts. It may also amount to a case of antisocial behaviour where the Gardaí may speak with the individual, and issue a behaviour warning. Under the Criminal Justice Act 2006, Gardaí can give a formal warning if someone is causing trouble. They may also apply for an Antisocial Behaviour Order (ASBO) or arrest the individual.
The management company will have established house rules that all owners and residents must adhere to which typically include standards in the common areas etc. If there are no rules to deal with this type of behaviour, the management company should consider introducing such rules and having the amendments adopted at the annual general meeting or an extraordinary general meeting.
Aisling Keenan
is a property managing agent, consultant and an associate member of the
Society of Chartered Surveyors Ireland
Do you have a query? Email
propertyquestions@irishtimes.com
This column is a readers' service. The content of the Property Clinic is provided for general information only. It is not intended as advice on which readers should rely. Professional or specialist advice should be obtained before persons take or refrain from any action on the basis of the content. The Irish Times and it contributors will not be liable for any loss or damage arising from reliance on any content
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Irish Times
a day ago
- Irish Times
Circle K manager's alleged Garda threat saw homeless man pick up human faeces with bare hands, WRC told
A Circle K worker who said his manager told him to 'be a man' and supervise the cleaning of a bathroom where a homeless man picked up human faeces with his bare hands has been awarded €1,000 for harassment at the Workplace Relations Commission (WRC) The worker, Siddarth Thirunavukkarasu, was eventually ordered to clean up the rest of the mess, despite the fact that he felt unwell, the WRC was also told. Mr Thirunavukkarasu brought a complaint under the Employment Equality Act 1998 against Circle K, where he was employed as a shop supervisor at its Belgard filling station in Tallaght, Dublin 24. He stated in his statutory complaint that he was 'bullied and discriminated against' by a manager at the store, Julita Howe, when he was 'forced to clean human waste without proper training or equipment' on 14th May, 2024. Ms Howe disputed that she made the 'be a man remark', the tribunal heard. READ MORE The claimant's case was that after he discovered faeces in a customer bathroom, Ms Howe confronted 'the person in question', a homeless man who was outside the filling station. Mr Thirunavukkarasu submitted that Ms Howe 'threatened to report [the homeless man] to the Garda if he didn't clean it' and that the man 'reluctantly agreed'. He said that despite complaining of discomfort and nausea due to the smell, his manager 'insisted' Mr Thirunavukkarasu supervise the homeless man in the bathroom. The complainant said he was experiencing 'nausea' because of the smell, and that his discomfort was heightened when he saw the homeless man 'handling the mess with his bare hands'. Ms Howe instructed him to give the man gloves and a blue towel and 'hold the toilet door open and watch' to 'ensure it wasn't smeared everywhere', the complainant told the WRC. How the wealthy are buying up land to avoid inheritance tax Listen | 22:03 He said he refused again and told his boss he 'could not stand the smell'. Ms Howe replied: 'Come on, be a man,' Mr Thirunavukkarasu told the WRC. His case was that Ms Howe 'forced' him to watch the man clean while she 'stayed away' and avoided the situation. Ms Howe eventually ordered him to clean up the rest of the mess, despite the fact he felt unwell, the tribunal heard. Dajana Sinik, of the Irish Business and Employers' Confederation (IBEC), appearing for Circle K, submitted that Mr Thirunavukkarasu had failed to exhaust internal company procedures, as he had filed his claim with the WRC in September 2024 while its investigation was still going on. The grievance investigator, company human resources (HR) officer Sara Murphy, found that the 'be a man' remark attributed to Ms Howe could not be substantiated as there was no witness to the exchange and Ms Howe 'disputes this claim', Ms Sinik said. However, an assistant store manager, Zahida Mustaq, had confirmed to the investigation 'that Ms Howe's behaviour and language were indeed inappropriate' and that Mr Thirunavukkarasu was asked to clean the toilet because the homeless man had not done so 'adequately', the tribunal heard. Ms Murphy did conclude that the manager 'should have recognised that the homeless man was not of sound mind to carry out this task properly', it was submitted. 'Asking the complainant to take over – despite him voicing his concerns and expressing his discomfort – was not in line with the [company's] dignity and respect policy,' Ms Sinik further submitted. Ms Sinik told the WRC that the company had a zero-tolerance approach to bullying and harassment and had acted reasonably by investigating the complaint. She said it had met its obligation to 'take reasonably practicable steps to prevent and address harassment'. The tribunal heard that prior to raising his formal grievance, the complainant had asked for a transfer back to a different Circle K store in Tallaght, which was granted. Adjudication officer Jim Dolan concluded that there was 'no act of discrimination or victimisation' against Mr Thirunavukkarasu. However, he wrote in his findings that the manager 'told the complainant when he objected to escorting the drunk man in cleaning the toilets: 'Come on, be a man''. Mr Dolan said it was 'very difficult to disagree' with Mr Thirunavukkarasu's case that this amounted to harassment, and ordered Circle K to pay €1,000 in compensation.
Irish Independent
a day ago
- Irish Independent
Louth communities ‘devastated by gangland, rural and drug crime'
Deputy Paula Butterly welcomed the news this week that Local Community Safety Partnerships are to be launched across the country, including one new LCSP for Louth. It will replace the former Joint Policing Committee, wound up in 2024 following recommendations that multi-agency structures are put in place to bring together key stakeholders including An Gardai Siochana, local residents, businesses, state agencies and community groups. The Fine Gael TD said she had 'consistently called for a Community Safety Partnership because the challenges our communities face cannot be solved in isolation. Only by coming together—sharing information, coordinating responses, and working strategically can we create lasting change.' She added: 'In recent years we have seen a shift in the manner of crime being committed within the county. We have seen gangland and rural crime, not to mention drug crime within the county devastating communities and trying to tear them apart.' The establishment of new local community safety partnerships are 'not only crucial to towns like Drogheda and Dundalk, but also to Ardee and Dunleer in their hinterlands, as well as the smaller villages like Castlebellingham, Tallanstown and Louth,' said Deputy Butterly. 'We must make sure that work is followed through and local authorities begin the process of establishing their LCSPs, identifying members and laying the groundwork for the community safety plans involving collaboration between statutory and community partners.' Meanwhile Sinn Fein Deputy Ruairí Ó Murchú, who had pressed justice ministers about the delay in establishing the LCSPs, welcomed the news that the partnerships are to get up and running. Deputy Ó Murchú said: 'While I welcome the establishment of the partnerships, I raised the issue of membership of the partnerships with the Minister for Justice previously and the need for clarity about how people are selected for it.' 'We are told there will be seven councillors from each local authority area and we will need to know how they are going to be picked and what the level of engagement there will be for Oireachtas members. I would want to see three in Louth, one each to cover Dundalk, Drogheda and Ardee, which was one of the advantages of the JPCs, and this would need to be considered in the context of the establishment of the partnership in Louth.' ADVERTISEMENT Learn more Fianna Fail TD for Louth, Erin McGreehan, has welcomed the introduction of new Local Community Safety Partnerships. She added: 'Community safety has been an important topic for me. Having had engagement with the Minister on several topics such as community safety, seeing that engagement being followed with action is promising.' Each LCSP can hold as many meetings as needed but they must hold at least 6 meetings annually. Deputy McGreehan explained that new measures introduced this week will allow members of the public to attend one of these meetings, while Oireachtas members and all locally elected public representatives will have opportunities to engage by attending at least one also. She called on relevant stakeholders across Louth 'to engage with the new Local Community Safety Partnership, to ensure that public safety can be targeted and efficient.' 'The purpose of these new Partnerships is to ensure we target issues and ensure community safety efficiently. We want to hear from all relevant stakeholders on the issues around safety across Louth.' Funded by the Local Democracy Scheme
Irish Times
2 days ago
- Irish Times
A week before her death, Sarah Montgomery gave scans of her unborn baby boy to her daughters
On New Street in Donaghadee, Co Down, greengrocer Peter Wallace recalls how Sarah Montgomery always wanted to help people. It is Tuesday lunchtime in the small coastal town, three days since the 27-year-old mother of two was found dead in her home less than a 10-minute walk away. She was eight months pregnant. This is the town where Ms Montgomery grew up, where her young daughters attend her former primary school and where she helped fundraise for the local lifeboat charity of which her grandfather, Arthur Arbuckle, was once a crew member. READ MORE 'She was well known and a lovely girl, very quiet,' Mr Wallace, owner of Grattan's family greengrocers, says. 'She was a carer for her two brothers and adored her girls. They were so well-mannered when they came into the shop and always so well turned out.' On Tuesday evening, police confirmed a 28-year-old man had been charged with murder and child destruction. Just a week before her death, Ms Montgomery gave pictures of scans of her unborn child, a baby boy, to her daughters. There was great excitement about their new baby brother, Mr Wallace says. 'Our business put a post on social media yesterday to express our condolences. The response was unbelievable. The town is in complete shock,' he says. Blue teddy bears are propped up on bouquets of flowers with handwritten sympathy messages outside Ms Montgomery's home on Elmfield Walk. Police cordons remain in place around the property where more flowers are laid throughout the afternoon. At 2.15pm on Saturday, police received reports of an unconscious woman with a serious injury inside a house in the Elmfield area. Officers and paramedics attended. Ms Montgomery was pronounced dead at the scene. At the other end of New Street on Tuesday, staff at a chemist shop say they are struggling to come to terms with her death. Ms Montgomery was a regular customer and 'always spoiling her girls'. 'Being a mother and grandmother myself, this has really hit home,' says one staff member who did not wish to be named. 'I saw Sarah a week before she died. She was just a lovely person from a lovely family. She lost her parents a few years ago. 'She would have been in here four times a week. A great mother who loved her wee girls and was always buying them hair bobbles and treats. She was a great sister too.' Around the corner, a book of condolence has opened at a coffee shop. A young mother wipes away tears as she reads some of the messages. Outside, an elderly woman on a walking stick shakes her head in disbelief. 'Sarah came to the coffee shop all the time with the girls. Them two kids were her world and it's absolutely heartbreaking,' she says. 'Nothing like this has ever happened in this town, it is just devastation. Honestly, I can't say enough about her. She was one of life's nice people.' On the laneway leading to Elmwood Park, a woman carries a bunch of roses to place outside Ms Montgomery's home after work. 'Everybody knows everybody in this town. We can't stop thinking about her and her children,' she says.
