LCCI rejects 37AA, describes it as ‘black law'
LAHORE: The Lahore Chamber of Commerce and Industry, trade and industrial associations, at a press conference at LCCI, have rejected 37AA and called it a 'black law' that would severely damage the business climate in Pakistan.
LCCI President Mian Abuzar Shad, Vice President Shahid Nazir Chaudhry, former Presidents Mian Anjum Nisar, Muhammad Ali Mian, representatives of various trade and industrial associations spoke on the occasion.
LCCI President Mian Abuzar Shad said that Clause 37AA empowers tax authorities to arrest any taxpayer merely on suspicion of tax fraud, even without concrete evidence. This clause is nothing less than a sword hanging over the heads of the entire business community.
He said that prior to this clause the definition of tax fraud had already been broadened extensively, encompassing a wide range of actions, from minor accounting mistakes to misinterpretation of law. The new clause now grants excessive and unchecked powers to FBR officers, enabling harassment and potential abuse.
The LCCI President said that business community has unanimously rejected this clause and are calling for its complete withdrawal. Such sweeping powers not only violate basic principles of justice but also infringe upon the constitutional rights of taxpayers. It will scare off investors and damage the trust that businesses have in the system.
Mian Abuzar Shad said that reputations of the businesses are at stake and arresting company officers, especially on mere suspicion, would bring serious disrepute and operational disruptions to large enterprises.
He said that following country-wide backlash, the government made a minor amendment to Section 37AA saying that arrest can only occur if there is a tax loss exceeding Rs50 million and upon the approval of a three-member committee. However, LCCI firmly rejected this amendment as well.
'Even with the amendment, the law remains draconian. The fact that arrest powers can be exercised without concrete evidence or judicial oversight is unacceptable,' Mian Abuzar Shad added.
LCCI Vice President Shahid Nazir Chaudhry said we have always advocated for business-friendly policies. But laws like Section 37AA will only create new challenges for an already struggling economy. Entrepreneurs will be discouraged and investment will decline further.
Former Presidents Mian Anjum Nisar and Muhammad Ali Mian urged the government to immediately withdraw Clause 37AA saying that unless business leaders are given breathing space, Pakistan will not be able to achieve the ambitious economic goals outlined in the budget.
They said that the government has set a GDP growth target of 4.2% and an export target of $35.3 billion but laws like these will make such goals impossible to achieve,' they warned.
All the representatives of trade and industrial associations unanimously and forcefully reject Section 37AA. The participants of the Press Conference said that we are not criminals. We are the backbone of the economy. This clause must be rolled back immediately so that we can focus on reviving Pakistan's economy instead of defending ourselves against unjust and arbitrary harassment.'
They said that the LCCI's powerful stand reflects growing unrest in Pakistan's business circles over heavy-handed and impractical taxation policies. If the government truly wants economic revival, it must abandon such oppressive clauses and create a trust-based tax environment.
Copyright Business Recorder, 2025
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Express Tribune
5 hours ago
- Express Tribune
Govt reverses tariff cuts on imports
Listen to article The federal government has approved a partial reversal of its earlier decision to completely abolish or reduce regulatory duties on about 285 imported products in the next fiscal year, partially rolling back a move that had placed a dozen industries at a disadvantage. Previously, the government had planned to abolish or substantially reduce regulatory duties on approximately 1,984 tariff lines under a new policy aimed at slashing protection for local industries by 52% over five years. According to sources, of these tariff lines, 285 will now undergo further changes, and new duties will be notified by Monday. The Tariff Policy Board on Friday approved the rationalisation of regulatory duties on finished goods. This will also reduce the projected revenue losses from the tariff rationalisation plan — from Rs200 billion to Rs174 billion. The original intent was to cut import duties on raw materials and semi-finished goods. However, the government also ended up reducing duties on finished goods, which are locally produced. While there is consensus that industries should not receive undue protection, completely exposing them to Chinese competition was also deemed unwise, given the need to protect jobs. Sources said the government has moved a summary for cabinet approval via circulation. Once notified, the Federal Board of Revenue (FBR) will issue a statutory regulatory order on Monday to revise duty rates. "This was a much-needed U-turn, as the previously finalised duty rates had placed local industries on a path to closure," said a member of the steering committee. He added that the government has decided the regulatory duty reduction in the first year will be lower than initially planned. For example, instead of eliminating the regulatory duty on polyester fiber entirely, the product will now be subject to a 2.5% duty. Under the revised policy, the average applied tariff rate will decrease from 20.2% to 9.7% over five years — a 52% drop. Initially, the government had planned for the average tariff rate to fall to 15.7% in the first year, cutting the protection wall by 22.3%. This was to be achieved by reducing the average customs duty to 11.2%, additional customs duty to 1.8%, and regulatory duty to 2.7%. Sources said the decision was reversed after some members of the steering committee informed Prime Minister Shehbaz Sharif that, contrary to the assumptions of faster export growth, exports might grow slowly — potentially eroding Pakistan's already thin foreign exchange reserves. The original tariff reduction plan was prepared by both foreign and local consultants, who, critics say, lacked knowledge of ground realities. The secretary commerce told the National Assembly Standing Committee on Finance that macroeconomic projections — such as higher export growth and slower import increases — were prepared by the World Bank. Following revisions, the number of tariff lines on which regulatory duties will not be changed in the first year has increased from 828 to 970. As a result, 142 tariff lines are being moved to slabs currently charged at 20% or less. Earlier, the government had planned a 20% reduction in regulatory duties on 602 items. Now, the one-fifth reduction will apply to only 538 tariff lines, with 64 lines excluded from this round of cuts. A major change affects the original plan of a 50% reduction in regulatory duties. Instead of halving duties on 551 tariff lines, the government will now apply the 50% reduction to about 473 lines. The remaining 78 lines — mostly related to finished goods — will see no change. Rana Ihsaan Afzal, the Prime Minister's Coordinator on Commerce, said the ultimate goal of reducing average tariffs to 9.7% over five years remains intact, although the pace has been slowed in the first year. According to the plan, the government will eliminate additional customs duties in four years, regulatory duties in five years, phase out the 5th Schedule of customs law in five years, and reduce the number of tariff slabs to four, with a maximum rate of 15%, also within five years. The World Bank's model projected that exports would grow by 10-14%, while imports would increase by only 5-6%. However, the State Bank of Pakistan and some cabinet members disagreed with these assumptions. When asked about the projections during a National Assembly Standing Committee on Finance meeting last week, Finance Minister Muhammad Aurangzeb said, "These are assumptions — some may work and some may not." The committee was informed that revenues would grow by 7-9%, compared to an estimated Rs500 billion loss under static calculations. For the next fiscal year, the FBR's net revenue gains from the tariff rationalisation will now rise to Rs74 billion. Prime Minister Shehbaz Sharif had constituted a steering committee, chaired by Muhammad Aurangzeb, to oversee the implementation of the new tariff policy. After receiving feedback from stakeholders, the committee informed the prime minister that a majority of its members believed the original proposal should be retained. However, it has now been decided that tariff lines initially slated for a complete regulatory duty reduction in the first year will instead face a 50% reduction.
Business Recorder
9 hours ago
- Business Recorder
PBC complains against FBR member
ISLAMABAD: Pakistan Business Council (PBC) has lodged a strong protest with Chairman Federal Board of Revenue (FBR) Rashid Mahmood Langrial against alleged rude behaviour of FBR Member Inland Revenue (Policy) during meetings of the Anomalies Committees. Ehsan Malik, Chairman Anomalies Committee (Business) in a letter to FBR Chairman said that despite repeated requests the meetings of the Anomalies Committees were not called early enough to allow changes in the fiscal bill, nor was the Member IR (Policy) available to start the meeting on time or to attend it for more than ten minutes. 'We were informed that he had urgent matters to attend to. Members of the Anomalies Committee were kept waiting from 2 pm to 2.45 pm on June 24th and then after a ten-minute presence, the Member IR (Policy) was called out, leaving no one from the FBR in the room. Members of the Committee waited for another 45 minutes before starting the discussion. Member IR (Policy) did not join the meeting till its conclusion. 'The Anomalies Committee (Business) was established by you and was composed of the Presidents and CEOs of eleven leading Chambers and business bodies of Pakistan. Besides their own businesses, the members have important matters concerning their constituents to take care of. Their time is valuable. Keeping them waiting was rude and disrespectful. Only taxpayers can have anomalies in budget proposals, and they must be heard. At my request, the members abstained from resigning and walking out of the meeting. 'I am attaching the minutes of the meeting that we had to conduct without the Member IR (Policy). You will note many anomalies that need to be addressed. Kindly let us know how you intend to deal with these, now that the Finance Bill has been passed. Finally, we appreciate the way the Customs meeting was held.' Copyright Business Recorder, 2025
Business Recorder
9 hours ago
- Business Recorder
Business community leader expresses his views on budget
KARACHI: Convener of the FPCCI Central Standing Committee on Hardware Merchants, Nadeem Ahmed Kushtiwala, stated that peace in the region is vital for Pakistan to increase its share in global trade. He emphasized that the government should have incorporated suggestions from the business community in the federal budget to enhance exports, keep the wheels of industry running, and avoid entrusting local trade entirely to the grip of FBR officials. This, he said, would ensure business growth, higher tax revenues for the FBR, and enable the government to meet its revenue targets. He expressed these views while addressing the fourth meeting of the Central Standing Committee on Hardware Merchants held at the Federation House. The meeting was also attended by Deputy Convener Shaukat Ismail, Tariq Rasheed, Tariq Younus, Hamza Nisar, and Faizan Nasir. Kushtiwala pointed out that the budget lacks any notable tax incentives or facilitation plans for persons with disabilities, special individuals, and senior citizens. He further remarked that no projects or initiatives have been proposed for the development of key sectors such as agriculture, industry, manufacturing, and ports/shipping/logistics, the maritime economy, and exports. He criticized the absence of measures to address the ongoing brain drain, which is significantly harming the country, as nearly 90% of professionally educated individuals are migrating abroad. Kushtiwala also noted that the budget does not increase allocations for essential public services such as education, healthcare, and access to clean drinking water, which are crucial for improving the general quality of life. During the meeting, it was highlighted that no changes have been made to the Valuation Department's ruling system. The high valuation rulings on a wide range of HS Code items are driving up landed costs, severely affecting the export sector; particularly the textile and apparel industries in competing in the international market. Copyright Business Recorder, 2025
