Court declares Rooiwal tender invalid
The ruling not only nullifies the R250-million contract but also orders the companies – Blackhead Consulting, NJR Projects and CMS Water Engineering – to repay profits made from the tender to the metro.
The judgment follows years of public outcry, investigative scrutiny, and legal action over the botched contract that left Rooiwal in a state of disrepair.
After the court ruling, Mayor Dr Nasiphi Moya reaffirmed the metro's commitment to clean governance and accountability.
'This judgment affirms what we have long maintained: contracts awarded through unethical and irregular processes undermine service delivery, compromise governance, and erode public trust,' she said.
'We assure the residents of Tshwane that this administration will act decisively to give full force and effect to the order.'
The court has instructed the consortium to submit documentation of project-related expenses within 60 days.
Should they fail to do so, the metro will appoint an independent contractor to determine the actual profits made, which the companies will then be required to repay.
The irregularities surrounding the Rooiwal tender have been under investigation since 2022, when a forensic report concluded that the consortium lacked the required expertise to carry out a project of this magnitude.
The awarding of the tender has since been linked to politically connected businessman Edwin Sodi and five senior metro officials, referred to as the 'Rooiwal Five'. They were removed from their posts but remain embroiled in Labour Court proceedings as attempts are made to reinstate them.
Moya highlighted the progress already made at Rooiwal under new leadership.
'Work to complete the upgrades at the Rooiwal Waste Water Treatment Plant has progressed successfully. Phase 1A was completed ahead of schedule, and Phase 1B is currently underway,' she confirmed. 'We are committed to ethical leadership, clean governance, and delivering services to our residents.'
The DA, which led the coalition government in Tshwane at the time and launched litigation against the consortium, also welcomed the ruling.
'This is a significant victory for clean governance and accountability in the metro,' said Cilliers Brink, DA leader in the Tshwane council.
'Now is the time for the metro to tell the public how far the process has gone to prevent that consortium from ever doing business with the state again.'
Brink emphasised that the attempt to blacklist the Sodi-linked companies was initiated in 2024 under the DA-led coalition.
The process was initially delayed after National Treasury found flaws in the metro's first application. However, the recent court ruling strengthens the metro's position.
'The public deserves to know what measures are being taken to ensure that what happened at Rooiwal never happens again,' Brink added.
'We cannot allow companies with poor track records and political connections to walk away unscathed.'
The Rooiwal debacle has long been emblematic of the challenges facing the metro.
The wastewater treatment plant, which is responsible for supplying clean water to Hammanskraal and surrounding areas, has not been operating optimally for years. Poor workmanship, missed deadlines, and stalling on the site forced the metro to terminate the contract in August 2022.
In a high-profile oversight visit to the Rooiwal and Klipdrift water treatment sites earlier this year, Moya was accompanied by Minister of Water and Sanitation, Pemmy Majodina. The minister did not mince her words about the legacy of the failed project.
'We cannot allow people to do Mickey Mouse work and think they will get away with it,' said Majodina. 'This plant is supposed to provide clean water to our people.'
The consortium's abandonment of the site, followed by the findings of corruption and maladministration, led to the involvement of the Special Investigating Unit (SIU).
While political instability, including shifts in coalition support, hampered previous attempts to enforce accountability, the court's ruling has now given the metro a decisive legal tool to act.
ALSO READ: Call for provision of water tankers as Hartebeeshoek shutdown looms
Do you have more information about the story?
Please send us an email to [email protected] or phone us on 083 625 4114.
For free breaking and community news, visit Rekord's websites: Rekord East
For more news and interesting articles, like Rekord on Facebook, follow us on Twitter or Instagram or TikTok.
At Caxton, we employ humans to generate daily fresh news, not AI intervention. Happy reading!
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
eNCA
4 hours ago
- eNCA
Minister Creecy tables budget before parliament
CAPE TOWN - It was a day for budget votes. Some were more controversial than others after the DA said it would boycott the budgets of at least two departments presided over by compromised minister. It's the final leg of the national budget process because the Appropriation Bill can only be passed if all departmental votes have been agreed to. One of the less controversial budget vote was for transport – although opposition parties criticised none the less.
TimesLIVE
5 hours ago
- TimesLIVE
DA rejects Simelane, Nkabane departmental budgets
The DA has followed through on its threat to vote against departmental budget votes of ministers who are facing allegations of wrongdoing. This after the party this week voted against budgets of the departments of human settlements and higher education led by Thembi Simelane-Nkadimeng and Nobuhle Nkabane respectively. This decision was taken as a direct response to President Cyril Ramaphosa axing trade and industry deputy minister Andrew Whitfield, of the DA, last week for defying his order that none of the members of his executive were allowed to go to the US at the height of the diplomatic tensions between the two countries. The DA in response argued that Ramaphosa had been harsh on Whitfield and that it was not acceptable that he fired him for such a minor transgression while he still kept Simelane and Nkabane in his cabinet. Unlike Whitfield, the DA argued, Simelane was accused of corruption and Nkabane stood accused of lying to parliament. Instead of dealing with the two ministers who were facing serious allegations, Ramaphosa decided to axe Whitfield for going on a trip without getting permission, the DA argued. DA MP Luyolo Mphithi on Wednesday said his party was voting against Simelane's budget vote because of the corruption allegations she was facing. Mphithi said the DA was concerned that instead of firing Simelane, Ramaphosa had moved her from the department of justice to human settlements. 'You'd think that the response to this that the president would have shown minister Simelane the door, he did not. He asked for the report that he stayed with for three months,' said Mphithi. 'And even though the DA sustained pressure asking the president to act, he lacked courage to act and instead decided to dump minister Simelane at human settlements, one of the most important departments for South Africans.' 'It seems that this president does not take an issue with the fact that a person accused of corruption sits in his cabinet and will have to look after a budget of R30bn that is set aside for South Africans,' he said. Ideally, Mphithi said, the DA would not have a problem with voting for the department of human settlements' budget as it relates to people's housing and security but they could not do it because of the allegations faced by Simelane. 'The DA will always support the granting of funds to house the vulnerable at the same time fast-tracking jobs and growth to give many more South Africans the dignity of being able to buy and own their own houses,' he said. 'And though this budget and the department have many challenges under normal circumstances it would be supported. However, we sit with a minister who faces corruption allegations who has not been accountable to the South African public. And it is because of this we struggle support this particular budget.' Mphithi and the MK Party's Thulani Gumede raised several issues with the human settlements budget presented by Simelane, saying it was not dealing with some of the key issues faced by South Africans in the sector. 'A critical examination reveals a fundamental flaw, an overall real decline in the department's budget. None of its five main programmes demonstrates above-inflation increases,' said Gumede. 'This systemic underfunding of human settlements initiatives will inevitably worsen existing backlogs and impair the progressive realisation of adequate housing.' He said his party could not vote for as it would mean they accepted the decrease in allocation. 'I asserted during the committee meeting last week and I reiterate now that this draft budget must be rejected. It's real term decline across key programmes particularly in integrated human settlements and informal settlements upgrading directly contradicts the constitutional obligation to provide adequate housing and the strategic goals of the national development plans,' he said. 'Accepting this budget will constitute a retreat from addressing deeply entrenched structural inequalities and the pressing needs of the vulnerable communities for basic services and dignified living conditions.'
IOL News
6 hours ago
- IOL News
EDITORIAL: It's game over for the DA in the GNU
DA leader John Steenhuisen's announcement that his party, including ministers serving in Ramaphosa's Cabinet, will not take part in the upcoming National Dialogue, is immaterial, argues the writer. Image: Armand Hough/ Independent Newspapers THE DA now has little to no ground to argue against the perception that the ANC has reduced it to a mere bystander in the so-called Government of National Unity (GNU). That is why President Cyril Ramaphosa can fire a DA deputy minister from his executive without being concerned about the political implications for his decision. From the start, the ANC has always been firmly in control of the direction the government takes despite failing to secure enough votes to govern the country as a single party in last year's elections. Ramaphosa knows all too well that the DA's desperation to remain in government runs so deep that it will not retaliate with severe action even when he acts against DA members in the executive. The DA was always going to find it difficult to impose itself in the GNU because it entered the coalition government for the wrong reasons. Its stated objective of keeping the EFF and Zuma's MK Party out of government plays into the ANC's hands. ANC secretary general Fikile Mbalula's utterances that the government won't collapse even if the DA leaves the GNU should be seen as a declaration that the DA's involvement in the GNU is immaterial. Just like DA leader John Steenhuisen's announcement that his party, including ministers serving in Ramaphosa's Cabinet, will not take part in the upcoming National Dialogue. The DA must leave the GNU with whatever little pride it still has. Its role in opposition benches was more effective than it is in this current government. The past 12 months have proved this. Almost all the policies and Bills it opposed remain firmly in place and some of them will be implemented on behalf of the ANC by their ministers. Leaving the GNU will allow it to make a head start in campaigning to win some of the key metros that remain hung. It's there that it should demonstrate its governing strength. It can find inspiration from renowned Pan-Africanist Professor Patrick Lumumba's words when he correctly points out that: 'No matter how good you are…if you stay for too long, you spoil it. A good dancer must know when to leave the stage.' CAPE TIMES
