Barefoot Investor reveals why the Albanese government is addicted to spending
Pape, best known as the Barefoot Investor, noted record-low interest rates during Covid had encouraged governments around the world to go on a spending binge.
Under the heading - Why Governments Are Addicted to Debt - he noted in his column that bond markets ultimately decided how much politicians could borrow.
These are the investors who lend governments money.
'For decades, cheap borrowing has allowed politicians to dodge making hard decisions,' he said.
'Yet with inflation back and interest rates rising, the bond market's getting twitchy again. And no politician wants to actually admit that everything's fine… until it isn't.'
When interest rates rise, so do bond yields - or the annual interest payments governments borrowing money have to pay back to those lending it money.
While yields have fallen since the Reserve Bank started cutting interest rates again, higher government spending means more government interest payments.
Treasurer Jim Chalmers last week became touchy when asked at the National Press Club about government spending being at the highest level since 1986 outside of the Covid pandemic.
'It's not the highest spending since the 80s. I know that you mean absent Covid, but I think it's unusual that we absent Covid,' he said.
'Quite frequently I'll hear we've got the weakest growth in 40 years, or we've got the highest spending. That's not true.'
Under Labor, government payments are set to make up 27 per cent of gross domestic product in 2025-26.
This is lower than the 32.1 per cent level of 2020-21 during the height of Covid, when the federal government effectively paid workers to stay home during lockdowns with JobKeeper payments and a temporary doubling of JobSeeker unemployment benefits.
'Let's not forget that we had spending as a share of the economy almost a third,' Chalmers said.
Chalmers argued Labor had been economically responsible by ending the former Coalition government's low and middle-income tax offset after coming to power in 2022.
'And some of those things that we didn't extend when we came to office, they were difficult at the time, some of that spending,' he said.
'We had a lot of people calling for us to extend the fuel excise change, the LMITO was ended by our predecessors but we got called on to extend it.
'And so that spending that was almost a third of the economy during Covid, we got it down to less than a quarter of the economy in 2022–23.'
Labor trimmed government payments to 24.8 per cent of the economy in 2022-23, and 25.2 per cent of GDP in 2023-24, when it also managed to deliver two consecutive surpluses.
These were the first surpluses since 2007 and the first for a federal Labor government since 1989, thanks to higher iron ore prices.
But gross government debt is set to surpass the $1trillion mark during the next financial year, and make up more than a third of the economy, with Treasury forecasting no return to surplus in coming years.
Chalmers did his PhD thesis on Paul Keating as prime minister.
Under Bob Hawke, Keating was also the treasurer who cut government spending so its proportion of GDP would fall from 27 per cent in 1986-87 to 22.9 per cent of GDP in 1989-90.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Reuters
an hour ago
- Reuters
Big central bank rate cuts slow with tariffs and politics in headlights
LONDON, July 24 (Reuters) - The pace of central bank rate cuts is slowing as early movers near the end of their easing cycles while sticky inflation keeps others cautious. Politics both domestic and international is another complication for central bankers, particularly in the United States, where President Donald Trump continues to muse publicly about firing Federal Reserve chair Jerome Powell. Here's where 10 big central banks stand on the monetary policy path. Bets that the Swiss National Bank will use negative interest rates to tackle the seemingly unstoppable rise of the safe haven franc have faded after it kept benchmark borrowing costs on hold at 0% in June. Traders have since put 75% odds on another pause in September and speculate the SNB has started intervening to weaken the franc. The Bank of Canada is widely expected to hold steady for now as U.S. tariff tensions contribute to a baffling economic outlook, with growth contracting as inflation rises and trade war disruptions to consumer behaviour muddle the outlook further. Money markets expect that the formerly dovish central bank, which implemented 225 basis points (bps) of cuts in the nine months to April, will keep rates at 2.75% on July 30. Sweden's central bank cut its key rate to 2% from 2.25% last month, and minutes from that meeting said policy could be eased again this year if growth disappoints and inflation remains tame. The Riksbank has been one of the more aggressive central banks, with 200 bps of cuts since May 2024. The Reserve Bank of New Zealand held rates steady earlier this month but said it expected to loosen monetary policy if price pressures continued to ease as forecast. The RBNZ has cut rates by 225 bps already this cycle. The European Central Bank left interest rates unchanged on Thursday after cutting eight times in a year, biding its time while Brussels and Washington negotiate over trade. Its main policy rate is currently at 2% down from 4% a year ago, and inflation is back at the ECB's 2% goal. Markets see around an 80% chance of a final 25 bp cut by year end but that depends on whether policymakers fear inflation might fall too far below target. That in turn depends on a trade deal and whether the euro continues to appreciate. The Fed meets next week, with markets all but certain it will remain on hold despite heavy pressure from Trump to make significant rate cuts. Trump appeared close to trying to fire Powell last week, but backed off with a nod to the market disruption that would likely follow. Further rate cuts are anticipated later this year and investors see roughly a 50% chance of a 25 bps reduction in September. A move then had been seen as likely until last week's data showed inflation rose to 2.7% year-on-year in June. The Bank of England meets on Aug 7. Markets expect a 25 bps rate cut even after data last week showed a surprise jump in inflation and a less-dramatic-than-feared cooling in the labour market. Sticky inflation means the Bank of England has been more cautious than most with easing. Markets price two, 25 bps rate cuts by year-end -- including an August move. The Reserve Bank of Australia is cautious too and surprised markets earlier this month by holding rates steady at 3.85%, saying it wanted to wait to confirm inflation will continue to slow. It was a rare split decision, but Governor Michele Bullock said the disagreement was more about timing and, if inflation continues to slow, the bank remains on an easing path. At least two more 25 bps cuts are priced by year end. Norway's central bank cut rates by 25 bps to 4.25% last month, its first reduction since 2020. The Norges Bank has been the most cautious among developed market central banks, and data this month showing core inflation at 3.1% reinforced this stance. Only one more cut this year is fully priced. The Bank of Japan, the sole central bank in hiking mode, has had its task complicated by uncertainty around U.S. tariffs and Japanese politics. Prime Minister Shigeru Ishiba has denied media reports he decided to quit. However, after Japan and the U.S. struck a trade deal this week, BOJ governor, Shinichi Uchida, signalled conditions for resuming hikes may start to fall into place. Uchida said the deal had reduced uncertainty and increased the likelihood Japan will sustainably hit its 2% inflation goal - a requirement for further rate increases some policymakers say.
Reuters
an hour ago
- Reuters
US business activity rises; tariffs fuel inflation concerns
WASHINGTON, July 24 (Reuters) - U.S. business activity picked up in July, but companies asked higher prices for goods and services, supporting economists' views that inflation will accelerate in the second half of the year mainly because of tariffs on imports. Despite the increase in activity this month, the survey from S&P Global on Thursday also showed sentiment among businesses remained downbeat, which it said "primarily reflected broad-based concerns over tariffs and cuts to state funding following recent federal government policy changes." Consumer prices increased by the most in five months in June, with solid rises in the costs of tariff-exposed goods like household furnishings and supplies, appliances, sporting goods and toys, signaling that President Donald Trump's broad import duties were starting to have an impact on inflation. S&P Global's flash U.S. Composite PMI Output Index, which tracks the manufacturing and services sectors, increased to 54.6 this month, the highest level since December, from 52.9 in June. A reading above 50 indicates expansion in the private sector. The improvement came from the services sector, where the flash PMI surged to 55.2 from 52.9 in June. Economists polled by Reuters had forecast the services PMI inching up to 53.0. The survey's flash manufacturing PMI dropped to 49.5, the first contraction since December, from 52.9 in June. Manufacturing received a bump from front-loading of activity ahead of tariffs as well as from the protectionist nature of the duties. But S&P Global noted that "any protectionist benefits of import tariffs were often outweighed by concerns over higher prices and rising costs." Economists polled had forecast the manufacturing PMI easing to 52.7. The survey's measure of prices paid by businesses for inputs edged up to 61.9 from 61.2 in June. The price gauge for services inputs jumped to 61.4 from 59.7 in June. While the pace of price rises for manufacturing inputs slowed, nearly two-thirds of manufacturers in the survey reporting higher costs attributed those to tariffs. The survey's measure of prices charged by businesses for goods and services ticked up to 58.6 from 58.1 in June. The prices charged gauge for services increased to 58.2 from 57.2 in June. About 40% of service providers reporting higher selling prices explicitly mentioned tariffs, while just under half of their counterparts in manufacturing blamed the import duties. The increase in business activity and elevated price gauges at face value argue against the Federal Reserve resuming interest rate cuts this month. Trump is demanding the U.S. central bank reduce borrowing costs, citing among others the struggling housing market. The Fed is expected to keep its benchmark overnight interest rate in the 4.25%-4.50% range, where it has been since December, when it meets later this month. "The rise in selling prices for goods and services in July, which was one of the largest seen over the past three years, suggests that consumer price inflation will rise further above the Fed's 2% target in the coming months as these price hikes feed through to households," said Chris Williamson, chief business economist at S&P Global Market Intelligence. The survey also suggested the labor market remained stable early in the third quarter, though factories shed jobs. New orders received by businesses increased this month, though both goods and services exports declined. The weakness is likely because of trade tensions and the Trump administration's immigration crackdown. Data and anecdotal evidence have shown fewer tourists visiting this year.
The Guardian
an hour ago
- The Guardian
UK firms cutting staff at fastest pace since February as economy struggles
UK businesses are cutting jobs at the fastest pace since February in response to higher taxes and global uncertainty caused by Donald Trump's tariff threats, according to a closely watch survey of the private sector. The flash S&P Global purchasing managers' index (PMI) for July showed a decline in fresh orders, hitting jobs and dragging down growth. According to the report: 'Survey respondents widely commented on the need to reduce headcounts in response to higher payroll costs and subdued customer demand.' Posing a dilemma for the Bank of England as inflation remains above its target, the early snapshot of activity this month showed manufacturing growth was static while sales in the services sector weakened. Central bank officials meet in a fortnight and are widely expected to cut interest rates from 4.25% to 4% to lift the UK's stuttering economy. Surveys of UK businesses have shown that extra employment taxes in the last budget and Trump's tariff threats have slowed the economy. The most recent official estimates show the economy contracted in April and May. The latest figures showed unemployment nudged up to 4.7% in May, hitting the highest level in four years, while wage growth slowed for a third consecutive month, and employers cut back on hiring. However, inflation is running at 3.4%, above the Bank's 2% target. Threadneedle Street has forecast that prices growth is unlikely to fall significantly until next year. According to James Smith, an economist at ING, the latest survey figures 'perfectly encapsulate the headache the Bank of England faces right now'. The flash S&P Global PMI, which covers the services and manufacturing sectors, dropped from 52 to 51 in July. A figure above 50 indicates expansion. Most of the drop was blamed on the services sector, which fell from 52.8 to 51.2, while the manufacturing output index rose to 50. Smith said: 'Higher payroll taxes and a chunky rise in the national living wage back in April are exerting more significant downward pressure on staffing numbers, according to the latest PMI. 'But the PMI also suggests these policy changes are keeping upward pressure on prices. We've seen hints of this in the [inflation] data, principally in food, where inflation rates have picked up over and above what we've seen in the eurozone. Pressure on staffing costs also likely explains the stickiness in hospitality inflation through the spring.' Sign up to Business Today Get set for the working day – we'll point you to all the business news and analysis you need every morning after newsletter promotion The PMI report said export sales decreased for the ninth consecutive month, 'albeit to the least marked extent since January'. Firms said the uncertainty created by Trump's tariff threats was a factor along with competition from Chinese companies shut out of the US by high levies on many goods. Looking ahead, businesses said they expected the global turmoil to calm down and interest rates to fall, making them optimistic about the next 12 months. They also predicted that a recent increase in household savings would reverse and that the more benign outlook would encourage consumers to begin spending again. Chris Williamson, the chief business economist at S&P Global Market Intelligence, said the survey showed the UK economy was struggling to expand as it moved into the second half of the year. 'Output growth weakened to a pace indicative of the economy growing at a mere 0.1% quarterly rate, with risks tilted to the downside in the coming months,' he said.
