Jane Street action fraudulent; soon we will know if other entities were involved: Ravi Hegde
(You can now subscribe to our
(You can now subscribe to our ETMarkets WhatsApp channel
, Founding Partner,, says Jane Street is accused of manipulating stocks and futures by exploiting the correlation between derivatives and stocks, leading to excessive trading and a reversal of their positions at favourable prices. SEBI has levied Fraudulent and Unfair Trade Practice (FUTP) regulations due to the potential inducement of common investors through these activities.Yes, this is an interim order which has been based on their prima facie understanding of what the facts are and in fact trading excessively in stocks and futures is not new to Sebi. If you remember, the earlier chairman of SEBI had passed a similar order in the matter of Infosys where they had identified that there is a strong correlation between derivatives and the underlying stocks.Now, strangely, in this order they say that if Jane Street makes this payment with Sebi, the trading restrictions will be vacated. Now just imagine how the index moved and they have identified only some cases during the investigation period. We do not know how the investigation will succeed as to what are the other trades, or on which other days they have traded this.Right now, there is no question of challenge because this is an ex parte order and a hearing is allowed. But trading in such high volumes is really absurd. I do not know whether Sebi will take the assistance of other regulators abroad to understand what is the correlation, because enforcement of this order now becomes a challenge. Nobody knows whether that money is still with them or whether it has been deployed in other trades. It is still a grey area at this stage.: Essentially, if you trade aggressively in either stocks or futures, per se it is not a violation. But what Sebi understood is, in patch one, people were trading excessively, taking trading positions where they were aggressively buying in Nifty where, of course, they did not find anything lucrative.On the very second day, in the second patch, they used to square it off. That makes no essential or any economic sense because they were incurring losses. Sebi then analysed the days the underlying indexes moved up they used to trade, taking the position closer to the expiry where they could leverage over this. Now, a common investor will not know what is the real reason why the indexes are shooting up. In short, they took advantage of the correlation between the derivatives and the stocks, manipulated the stocks and futures in such a manner that they were excessive traders. They reversed their whole position and the index was up. So they traded at a favourable price. That is basically what has happened.Yes, absolutely. We have Fraudulent and Unfair Trade Practice (FUTP) regulations. In anything relating to purchase, sale, or issuance of security, if there is anything which has the capacity to induce a common investor to trade, that amounts to fraud. Therefore, regulation three and four of the FUTP regulations has been levied. Even for FPIs, the nature of the trades, the manner in which the FPIs are required to trade, have been flouted.A common investor would not know if an underlying aggressive position has already been taken. The investor thinks okay this stock is going up, let me trade. Now, this inducement is because of fraudulent activities. That is why the FUTP regulations were triggered. Interestingly, while SEBI still says that there was a caution letter issued by NSE, the period is only from January 2023 to March 2025. We do not know as to what else would come up because the investigation is still pending and SEBI in its wisdom will understand if there is any other correlation as well, whether any other entities are involved, and whether brokers are involved in synchronization of trades or reversal of trade. So, there are larger issues to be looked into.Now, they have identified only these five persons because they saw concentration of trading between these entities. Over a period of time, we will come to know whether any other entities are also associated. It is per se a fraud. The definition is very clear.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Economic Times
24 minutes ago
- Economic Times
Cipla Q1 Results: Cons PAT rises 10% YoY to Rs 1,298 crore, revenue up 4%
(What's moving Sensex and Nifty Track latest market news, stock tips, Budget 2025, Share Market on Budget 2025 and expert advice, on ETMarkets. Also, is now on Telegram. For fastest news alerts on financial markets, investment strategies and stocks alerts, subscribe to our Telegram feeds .) Subscribe to ET Prime and read the Economic Times ePaper Sensex Today. Top Trending Stocks: SBI Share Price, Axis Bank Share Price, HDFC Bank Share Price, Infosys Share Price, Wipro Share Price, NTPC Share Price
Economic Times
24 minutes ago
- Economic Times
Mark Matthews on why FTA with UK, US trade deal shouldn't matter much for India
Live Events You Might Also Like: Most excited about these business segments in next 1-2 years: Raamdeo Agrawal (You can now subscribe to our (You can now subscribe to our ETMarkets WhatsApp channel MD,, believes the India-UK FTA will have a small impact on India. He hopes it will encourage a US trade deal before August 6. A US deal could boost the stock market. Matthews anticipates a US tariff for India between 15% and 20%. He considers US trade less crucial for India than for other nations.: I do not know what the impact will be for the UK economy, but it is not big for India as you know UK trade is an extremely small part of India's overall economy. But what I would say is that it should be a boost for sentiment because they have been doing these talks for about three months and hopefully will put pressure on the government to do the trade deal with the United States before the August 6th deadline. That would be a much needed boost for the stock market if that comes I would expect it to come in somewhere between 15% and 20% with 20% being the ceiling for the Southeast Asian countries like the Philippines and Indonesia. They are at 19% and then 15% was the recent trade deal with Japan. So, that is the range I am looking for. If it was above 20%, then I would be disappointed, I do not know about the market. Unlike Japan or the Philippines, trade with the US is not material for the Indian economy. I find this is frankly more noise than substance.: I like two things. First, I like the fact that the sector is down almost 20% so far this year. It is not across the sector but there are pockets of very deep value. This is a place in India where you can find deep value. And the second thing is that the guidance from management in the most recent quarterly results was largely positive, looking for better times ahead. So, those are the two reasons why we like it.I am sorry I do not have a view on that, but I can tell you what we think about the consumer space. It will be a beneficiary of the Rs 1 lakh crore tax breaks that were announced in the Budget back in February and we should start to see that filter through, but also the one percentage point cut in the RBI's rate since the last five months – these two forces should be beneficial for the entire space, especially for bigger ticket items like autos and property.I think I was wrong and I remember that conversation. It is probably higher than when we last spoke. I felt that it was overbought because at that time it was up about 25% from the beginning of the year. Now, it is up about 28%. I think what I told you at the time is I preferred the idea of buying stocks in Hong Kong relative to gold. So, I suspect on that basis, it might have been the right call. Hong Kong stocks have done better than gold since we last met. But yes, if you look back over the last 100 years, gold's return is on average 5% a year in US dollars. So it has been a very fine investment, but it does move in spurts and we have just had one of those big spurts over the last two I would have thought it was due for a break, and it continues to go up. Long-term, the thing that speaks in favour of gold is that most central banks do not have enough of it and they would like to diversify away from a very heavy concentration in dollars. In fact, there was a survey that came out last month that showed off all the assets that the major central banks of the world said they intended to increase their allocation to over the next 5 to 10 years, gold had the largest vote in there will be a steady buyer of gold from central banks, but they do not tend to chase the price. They tend to be very calm and steady in their buying of it. I do not want to ramble, but what I am trying to say is I still feel that it is overbought in the short term, but longer term it should continue to demonstrate that attribute of going up about 5% per year over the long term.
Time of India
37 minutes ago
- Time of India
European shares slip as auto stocks weigh, investors eye US-EU trade talks
Live Events (You can now subscribe to our (You can now subscribe to our ETMarkets WhatsApp channel European shares retreated on Friday, giving back gains from the previous session, as automobile stocks weighed and investors awaited updates on EU-U.S. trade talks ahead of U.S. President Donald Trump 's tariff deadline next pan-European STOXX 600 index was down 0.6% at 548.16 points, as of 0712 GMT, after hitting a six-week high on Thursday. Still, the index remained on course for modest weekly FTSE 100 dropped 0.4%, pulling back from its all-time peak reached on regional bourses were also in the the market, European automobile stocks led the sectoral decline with a 1.4% drop, pressured by Valeo after the French car parts supplier cut its full-year sales outlook. Its shares slumped 12.4%.Volkswagen fell 2.4% after Europe's biggest carmaker lowered its outlook on tariff woes. Traton, a truck unit of Volkswagen, came under pressure with an 8.1% slump after it slashed its full-year other stocks, Puma's shares slumped 18.7%, falling the most in the STOXX 600, after the German sportswear brand cut its full-year outlook and reported weaker-than-expected quarterly a week filled with trade discussions, investors cheered agreements with Japan, Indonesia and the Philippines, while hopes for a U.S.-EU deal remain as negotiations with the bloc continued.
