logo
School curriculum rewrite had serious problems, managers considered using AI to help

School curriculum rewrite had serious problems, managers considered using AI to help

NZ Herald5 days ago
They said they still had not seen a clear definition of the term 'knowledge-rich' as it applied to the New Zealand curriculum.
The Education Ministry told RNZ content of the English and maths curriculum was 'consistent with knowledge-rich curriculum design principles' but it failed to provide a definition of knowledge-rich despite being asked for one.
The latest leak followed a series of disclosures of internal documents that prompted the ministry to hire a KC to investigate where they were coming from.
A 'programme status report' sighted by RNZ said the introduction of a new process for developing the curriculum posed an 'extreme' issue to the work.
'The new delivery process is adding complexity to both internal and external delivery and review procedures as we do not have a clear definition of a knowledge-rich curriculum and what it looks like in a NZ context,' it said.
'There is no international comparison we can pick up and use.'
Elsewhere, the document said lack of an agreed definition was affecting all learning areas of the New Zealand Curriculum (NZC) and Te Marautanga o Aotearoa (TMoA), the curriculum for Māori-medium schools.
'Both the NZC and TMoA curricula lack a clear design framework for defining a knowledge-rich curriculum. This absence of a design point is impacting the development of all learning areas, as continuous refinement and clarification are required,' it said.
'Options are now being looked at to bring in overseas experts to help us develop templates and frameworks for the curriculum which we can then apply.'
The report said the programme was in red status for the month of February.
It said the key challenge was the lack of a constant template for the work it was producing.
The document said even if the ministry resolved that problem it still faced challenges including having to revise its work due to changing expectations, lack of a clear and consistent understanding of the term 'knowledge rich', and lack of a design framework.
The status report warned that governance groups associated with the rewrite were ineffective because they provided conflicting advice and their feedback was not always followed.
It said stakeholders had different expectations about the use of mātauranga Māori in the curriculum and contributing groups lacked skills and experience.
The ministry told RNZ it was developing the curriculum framework, Te Mātaiaho, to be consistent with a knowledge-rich curriculum.
It said since last year its work on defining a knowledge-rich curriculum was informed by several sources and a literature review had been commissioned.
However, it did not provide any definition, despite being asked for one.
The ministry told RNZ the curriculum rewrite was currently at red status after being in amber status in the previous two months.
'Due to the scale and complexity of this work, shifts between Amber and Red status are expected. The Ministry actively manages programme risks using its risk management framework, with mitigation strategies in place, regularly monitored, and escalated when necessary,' it said.
It said the work had 10 high risks, 25 moderate risks and five low risks.
Curriculum being 'built as the plane was flying'
Post Primary Teachers Association vice-president Kieran Gainsford told RNZ teacher subject association leaders met recently and were worried about a lack of clarity about key terms such as the 'science of learning' and 'knowledge-rich curriculum'.
Gainsford said teachers had been saying for some time it was critical that the curriculum was clear.
'If even officials aren't sure of what they mean by the terms of science of learning and knowledge-rich curriculum, knowledge-rich in particular, then it leads to the question of how on earth are schools and teachers supposed to know what they mean by that,' he said.
He said the ministry was yet to publish a clear definition of the term knowledge-rich and it needed to be crystal-clear.
'At the moment we're trying to respond in many cases to stuff that's poorly defined and that leads to debate or discussion that isn't particularly fruitful,' he said.
Principals Federation president Leanne Otene said it was clear to primary and intermediate principals the curriculum was 'being built as the plane was flying'.
She said a knowledge-rich curriculum would define what needed to be taught at each level of learning, but the ministry had not delivered on that.
Otene said parts of the published curriculums read like they had been cut and pasted from elsewhere.
Association of English Teachers president Pip Tinning said the problems outlined by the ministry documents were not normal for curriculum development.
She said the ministry had not explained knowledge-rich in terms of the English curriculum or its definition of the science of learning.
Meanwhile, a separate Education Ministry document from December last year titled 'Options for change to the curriculum regulatory system' showed plans to allow the Education Minister to set different curriculum expectations for different types of schools.
The document said the power could be useful to help schools better support their students.
'For example, there could be a pedagogy that only schools and kura with technology hubs must use, or a curriculum statement that applies specifically for kura kaupapa Māori,' the document said.
The document said education sector groups were largely supportive of the plans, which would ensure the curriculum was reviewed and updated regularly.
Manager raised possibility of using AI
A document about the Science curriculum outlined shortcomings with the existing curriculum which the ministry said resulted in overcrowded lessons and few children enjoying the subject and continuing it at university.
It said the curriculum needed to be revised to help students understand science in day-to-day life and other countries were changing their science curriculums for similar reasons.
A senior manager's briefing to ministry staff raised the possibility of using AI to write some of the material underpinning the curriculum.
The manager said they could use AI to synthesise the curriculums of countries such as Singapore, NSW, British Columbia, with New Zealand information almost instantly.
They said it could also ensure the use of consistent language between curriculum documents.
Asked about the use of AI, the ministry told RNZ: 'The ministry is exploring how artificial intelligence tools can support curriculum development, particularly by analysing and synthesising information from international curricula and related knowledge frameworks. AI is not being used to directly write curriculum content but may assist with background research and insights.'
-RNZ
Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

Firefighters extinguish fire at Auckland's Westgate Mitre 10, search for hot spots
Firefighters extinguish fire at Auckland's Westgate Mitre 10, search for hot spots

RNZ News

time10 hours ago

  • RNZ News

Firefighters extinguish fire at Auckland's Westgate Mitre 10, search for hot spots

Smoke could be seen from one of the roller doors at Westgate Mitre 10. Photo: Calvin Samuel / RNZ A fire at a Mitre 10 hardware store in West Auckland is now out. The fire at Mitre 10 Mega Westgate near Whenuapai was reported at 6.40pm on Saturday to Fire and Emergency. A spokesperson said eight fire trucks were still at the scene shortly before 9pm, ventilating the building and monitoring for hot spots. Firefighters outside Mitre 10. Photo: Calvin Samuel / RNZ In total 17 fire trucks were sent, including three ladder units, a spokesperson said earlier. The building, which was 200 metres long and 80m wide was described as heavily smoke logged. Fire crews were sent from West Harbour, Kumeū, Te Atatū, Auckland City, Henderson, Parnell, Avondale, Greenhithe, Ellerslie. Firefighters inspecting where the smoke came from. Photo: Calvin Samuel / RNZ An on-duty pharmacist close by said he heard the sirens and fire trucks after 7pm but couldn't see any flames. The pharmacist said he could see an aerial appliance had its ladder in the air but he couldn't see any water going onto the building. An RNZ video journalist at the scene said the fire looked well contained after 8pm with no major visible smoke or flames. It was extinguished before 9pm. Photo: Calvin Samuel / RNZ They said a lot of trucks and personnel were coming and going out of an entry to the timber yard. "A small amount of smoke is visible coming out of one of the roller doors near a loading dock." Sign up for Ngā Pitopito Kōrero, a daily newsletter curated by our editors and delivered straight to your inbox every weekday.

Firefighters at scene of blaze at Auckland's Westgate Mitre 10
Firefighters at scene of blaze at Auckland's Westgate Mitre 10

RNZ News

time10 hours ago

  • RNZ News

Firefighters at scene of blaze at Auckland's Westgate Mitre 10

Photo: Googlemaps Firefighters are responding to a fire at a Mitre 10 hardware store in the Auckland suburb of Westgate. Emergency services were alerted to the blaze at 6.40pm Saturday, and 17 fire trucks were sent, including three ladder units, a Fire and Emergency spokesperson said. The building, which is 200 metres long and 80m wide was described as heavily smoke logged. Do you know more? Email iwitness@ Fire crews were sent from West Harbour, Kumeū, Te Atatū, Auckland City, Henderson, Parnell, Avondale, Greenhithe, Ellerslie. An on-duty pharmacist close by said he heard the sirens and fire trucks after 7pm but couldn't see any flames. The pharmacist said he could see an aerial appliance had its ladder in the air but he couldn't see any water going onto the building. He counted at least five fire trucks at the scene and said the Mitre 10 Mega was currently closed. An RNZ video journalist at the scene said the fire looked well contained after 8pm with no major visible smoke or flames. They said a lot of trucks and personnel were coming and going out of an entry to the timber yard. "A small amount of smoke is visible coming out of one of the roller doors near a loading dock." Sign up for Ngā Pitopito Kōrero, a daily newsletter curated by our editors and delivered straight to your inbox every weekday.

Greer Twiss the ‘Godfather' of contemporary New Zealand sculpture: Laura Vodanovich
Greer Twiss the ‘Godfather' of contemporary New Zealand sculpture: Laura Vodanovich

NZ Herald

timea day ago

  • NZ Herald

Greer Twiss the ‘Godfather' of contemporary New Zealand sculpture: Laura Vodanovich

In a way I grew up with Twiss, with his work Karangahape Rocks, 1967-69, strongly influencing my young sense of art in public spaces - it was a work that arrested my attention and I would stop and ponder it often. Sculptor Greer Twiss died earlier this month. Photo / Greg Bowker While I was working at Auckland Museum, a project initiated by Outdoor Sculpture 2001, and supported by the Edmiston Trust, installed sculptures throughout the Auckland Domain. Marquette's of these sculptures, including Twiss's work among other significant names in the artworld, were displayed at Auckland Museum in 2004. Some magnificent and striking sculptures were created as part of this initiative, but it was Twiss' work Grafting, that was my very favourite. Grafting is a series of 10 sculptures in the fernery, part of the Wintergardens in the Auckland Domain. These works include nine native birds and a pear tree, each complete with a label typical of those used on specimens you might find in a museum. The individual labels include the Latin, te reo Māori and English 'common' name for each bird, but for the tree just the word pear along with Twiss's signature. Woven through this work you can detect his interest in the colonial period through his use of three forms of classification identifying each native bird. For the pear tree, introduced to Aotearoa by missionary Samuel Marsden, Twiss dispenses with the three names and strips this specimen to just the one common name, pear. His exploration of the colonial period and the 'dialogue between the natural situation and the imposed brought into the situation' has seen him create a number of works on this theme. In 2020 his agent, Jane Sanders, reached out to us to say Twiss would like to offer a work to the Hawke's Bay Museums Trust Tai Ahuriri collection and we were delighted to accept his generous offer. The work, Hobson's Baggage, 1995, is another sculpture exploring the colonial theme. Toni MacKinnon, art curator at the time, wrote that 'Greer Twiss' sculpture brings objects together in unexpected ways… Queen Victoria is loaded into an old suitcase, there is a flag that has no way of fitting into the case, and a watering can! And what is the little lamp about?' Twiss of course made sense of this, pondering what Hobson might have bought in his luggage including, possibly, a bust of Queen Victoria. In his eyes the items all represent something including authority, cultivation and the law. It is a wonderful work to have in our collection and another way in which Twiss has positively influenced my personal relationship with artworks in Aotearoa.

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into a world of global content with local flavor? Download Daily8 app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store