Warren County judge acquits Wayne Local treasurer, daughter on all charges in strong ruling
Warren County Judge Timothy Tepe said he was granting a motion to acquit Ronald L. James, 69, of tampering with records, theft in office and having an unlawful interest in a public contract; and Jenae M. James, 43, of felony theft.
The rule used by Tepe allows judges to conclude that evidence submitted by the prosecution is insufficient to convict the defendants before the case goes to the jury.
The motion was filed by the defense after the prosecution presented its case and granted before the defense presented theirs.
The case before acquittal
Ronald James was initially accused of using his office, which he held at the district for 24 years, to direct money to his daughter and give a school contract to a business partner.
Warren County Prosecutor David Fornshell said in October 2024 that Ronald James was accused of diverting money given to the district for hosting ACT testing during the COVID-19 pandemic to his daughter, who he said had allegedly already been paid.
Fornshell said that Ronald James was also accused of working for a local garden center and steering business projects for the district to that company.
The investigation involved a special audit from the Ohio Auditor of State.
Ronald James resigned from the district in 2022, citing "personal and professional reasons" for the decision.
According to the attorney for Jenae James, she was placed on paid administrative leave during the investigation but placed on unpaid leave once she was indicted.
Judge Tepe's statement
In his statement, Tepe was deeply critical of the prosecution's case, saying that he found none of the witnesses credible except for the owner of the garden center.
He was specifically critical of former Wayne Local Superintendent Pat Dubbs, who the judge said came across as a "lazy superintendent who didn't even know how to operate the system," adding that he thought Dubbs' memory was very selective during his testimony.
He even said that he believed Dubbs was just trying to "cover his own butt" with his statements.
"Very disappointing," Tepe said.
He was also specifically critical throughout the closing statement of former school board president Jim Byers, saying that after listening to the witnesses, "It became abundantly clear that Dr. Byers had a personal axe to grind with Mr. James."
Regarding the allegations of redirecting ACT testing funds, he said, "It was very clear that the arrangement with ACT that was made in advance was for the additional services that Ms. James was to provide."
"There was no theft that occurred," he said, adding that the district was never owed the money, and the funds were always due to Jenae James.
Speaking about the allegations that Ronald James had funneled business to the garden center he works for, Tepe said he had heard no evidence, other than from Byers, that James exerted any influence over the school board to adopt the contract. He said he heard conflicting testimony over who had presented the contract to the board, pointing out that the business owner, the only witness he felt was credible, said it was former superintendent Dubbs.
"The state has wholly failed in convincing this court," Tepe said.
The judge suggested that if it were not for the way that Byers had "spoon-fed" information to investigators, the case may not have even gone to trial.
He said it was "very disappointing" emails critical to the case were not turned over to either the defense or the investigator in a prompt manner, though he said he was unclear if the delay was due to the state of Ohio's investigator or due to Byers.
"The court is certainly in favor of eliminating government waste, but this last day and a half has been a waste," Tepe said.
From the defense: Case never should have gone to trial
When reached for statement, John D. Smith, attorney for Ronald James said, "I think the acquittal is the statement," adding that the charges should never have been brought, and saying it was an "absolute disgrace" that the case progressed and took Jenae James out of her classroom.
Kevin Hughes, attorney for Jenae James, echoed Smith's sentiments, saying that it was an "awful, terrible experience" for both father and daughter.
Hughes said getting a Rule 29 motion granted is very difficult, adding that for the judge to grant it meant there was no evidence the charges were true.
He also echoed the judge's criticism at the delay of crucial emails being provided, saying they were only delivered the Thursday before trial, which began on the following Monday.
Ultimately, Hughes emphasized Jenae James's award-winning work as a teacher for the district. She was one of three 2022 Project Excellence winners at the district.
He also pointed to the ACT testing whose funding was at issue in the trial, saying that she ran ACT testing at the school before the COVID-19 pandemic and during the lockdowns was the only one in the area to do so, preparing test rooms for more than eight times the normal number of students.
"It was a true shame they got drug through this," he concluded.
From the family: Isolated, ostracized after case opened
Ronald James said he had a long career with the school district, starting in 1998 and including his role as the district treasurer as well as a coach, announcer and volunteer to teach some classes.
Speaking about the case, he insisted that there was no basis for the charges, saying the ACT payments were documented and approved by the district, and that he only put the district in touch with the garden center, and didn't have any input on the decision to choose them to complete work at the school.
After the investigation and indictment, James said he felt isolated and ostracized by the school community.
James said he was thankful to all the good board members but said that the school district's success was due to its teachers, including his daughter, as well as its parents.
From the board: Hope Waynesville can move forward
When contacted, former superintendent Dubbs provided the following statement: "This trial was limited to two very specific incidents that occurred years ago and in which I had very limited involvement. However, I can say with certainty that I testified truthfully and to the best of my memory regarding the events. I respect the judge's ultimate decision and hope that the Waynesville community can now move forward from this and focus on the important mission of educating children."
Former school board president Byers did not immediately respond to attempts to contact him.
From the prosecution: Respecting the court's decision
When reached about the case, Warren County Prosecutor David Fornshell replied, "Obviously, the court viewed the evidence differently than what the state auditor's office did and what our office did. But that happens sometimes. That's our justice system. We respect the court's decision."
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Hill
5 hours ago
- The Hill
Executions are up in 2025 — should death penalty abolitionists change their tactics?
Earlier this month, Florida executed Michael Bell for murdering two people in 1993. He was the eighth person put to death there this year. Bell's execution would have attracted little attention but for the fact that it was the 26th of this year so far — one more than the total number executed all last year. For death penalty abolitionists, this is a discouraging milestone. What's more, there are 10 more executions currently scheduled to occur before Dec. 31. That would make 2025 the year with the most executions since 2015, when 28 people were put to death. This year is also on pace to be the fourth in a row in which the number of executions has risen since the low point during the COVID-19 pandemic, when only 11 people were executed. For the last decade or so, those opposed to capital punishment have been repeating the same mantra as a way to mark the progress of their campaign to end state killing in this country: The number of executions is down. The number of new death sentences is also down. And public support has fallen sharply from historic highs 30 years ago. Each of those developments has been fueled by what I have called 'the new abolitionism.' Instead of emphasizing abstract moral arguments against capital punishment, new abolitionists focus on the death penalty's unreliability as a deterrent and the prospect of executing innocent people. They highlight the pervasive racial discrimination that marks every stage of the death penalty process and the frequency with which executions are botched. So, the question naturally arises: Is the spike in executions so far this year a sign that the abolitionist campaign is running out of steam? If so, is it time for a change in tactics? The answer to both questions is no. We can see why by probing more deeply into the reasons executions have increased this year, as well as examining trends in death sentences and public opinion. We also have to understand that the road to the abolition of capital punishment will not be uniform or smooth. Like other political and legal campaigns, it will move toward its goal in an irregular pattern: two steps forward, one step back. This year's increase in the number of executions is one of those backward steps. Almost half of them have occurred in just two states, Florida and Texas. Driven by a pro-death penalty governor, who has made the death penalty a top priority, Florida executed six people in 2023 but only carried out one execution last year. Texas led the way in 2023 with eight executions, and followed up by putting five more people to death in 2024. But this year, other states, like Indiana, which had paused executions because they have been unable to secure reliable supplies of the drugs needed to carry out lethal injections, rejoined the group of states carrying them out. Some revised their lethal injection protocols or even authorized other execution methods. However, in the Hoosier State, officials do not seem anxious to open the execution floodgates. Republican Gov. Mike Braun has said about capital punishment, 'There are legislators that wonder if it's still relevant. … I'm going to listen to them, the courts, and the broader discussion in general.' And even as Indiana resumed executions, its prosecutors are not pursuing new death sentences. In fact, no one has been sentenced to death there since 2013. That is an increasingly common pattern in states where capital punishment is still an authorized punishment. It is important because the number of new death sentences is a better indicator of capital punishment's status and future than is the number of executions. And new death sentences remain at historic lows. According to the Death Penalty Information Center, there have been only ten new death sentences concentrated in just six states — Alabama, California, Florida, Idaho, Louisiana and Oklahoma. That total is down nearly 30 percent from the same period last year, when there were 14 new death sentences. Abolitionists can also take heart from the fact that surveys of the American public, which indicate that support for the death penalty, at just 53 percent, is at a 50-year low. Abolitionists have shone a spotlight on the grim realities of the death penalty's day-to-day administration, and this has paid dividends in changing the national conversation about capital punishment. And in spite of the increase in the number of executions this year, it remains true that the more people learn about the death penalty, the less they like it.
Washington Post
6 hours ago
- Washington Post
Temu accused by EU regulators of failing to prevent sale of illegal products
LONDON — Chinese online retailer Temu was accused by European Union watchdogs on Monday of failing to prevent the sale of illegal products on its platform. The preliminary findings follow an investigation opened last year under the bloc's Digital Services Act . It's a wide-ranging rulebook that requires online platforms to do more to keep internet users safe, with the threat of hefty fines.
Los Angeles Times
8 hours ago
- Los Angeles Times
These L.A. moms solved a cold case murder. It ‘revolutionized' their lives
'The Carpool Detectives,' a true crime mystery that reads like a novel, begins in the liminal moment before the COVID-19 pandemic shut down the country and concludes on an upbeat note two and a half years later: Four L.A. moms with no law enforcement training have solved an icy cold case and moved on to their next, buoyed by newfound purpose. But as Chuck Hogan's book and conversations with the unlikely crime solvers today make clear, there were plenty of bumps along the way — from dead ends to a potential intruder at one of their homes mid-investigation. 'We went through phases where we felt like we hit a wall,' says Marissa Pianko, a former forensic accountant. Pianko first learned about the stalled investigation into an older couple's death during a journalism class and became determined to get to the bottom of it, inviting three acquaintances to help solve the case. 'I think each one of us had a time by which we were like, 'OK, are we really continuing with this?'' 'There were lots of ups and downs,' concurs Nicole Landset Blank, a political opposition research pro turned book researcher who is seated at the very same table in Pianko's backyard where the team figured out the perpetrator of a double homicide. Samira Poulos, a puzzle-loving digital advertising project manager who stepped back from her career when she became a mom, and Jeannie Wilkinson, a former entertainment industry research exec, both nod their heads in agreement as their fellow sleuths describe the sometimes-fraught nature of their first investigation. The quartet is still a bit apprehensive about solving a case that involved organized crime and is worried that the book might expose their families to harm. To get around their concerns, some of the details about the case have been changed in 'The Carpool Detectives' and each of the four detectives is referred to by first name, like a character in a novel. Reading along, it can be easy to forget that the underlying case is based on real, not fictional, murder. The basic details of the cold case at the heart of 'The Carpool Detectives' are this: An older couple living a seemingly comfortable life in the L.A. suburbs mysteriously disappeared a couple decades ago. Victims of an apparent road accident, their bodies were found a few months later near their wrecked SUV in a mountainous area. After more than a year, the L.A. County Sheriff's Dept. moved the vehicle due to evidence that the couple's death was suspicious. Although the investigation was covered in the media, it soon faded away. Until, that is, four moms — who became such close friends that they now can finish each other's sentences — started looking into the case a decade later. As 'The Carpool Detectives' recounts, the women sought out the help of sometimes-reluctant police officers and the victims' family members, bumbling at times as newbie investigators. Many dead ends and a visit to the crime scene later, the women finally figured out whodunnit. 'It was two and a half years before we really broke it, and it was completely different than we thought it was going to be in the beginning,' Pianko says. 'And how law enforcement thought it would be,' Landset Blank says. For Wilkinson, the biggest surprise was law enforcement's reaction upon hearing that the mom squad had cracked the case. 'I feel like we really did truly earn respect,' she says, exuding pleasure at the thought. The book chronicling their investigation grew out of another pandemic dynamic: socially distanced get-togethers with pals. 'We had a friend who, during the COVID time, we would meet in the driveway for drinks or whatever, and she said, 'This would make an amazing story,'' Poulos recalls. This being L.A., that friend mentioned the quartet's investigation to her boss at the production company 3 Arts Entertainment, and a podcast was discussed before a book deal was put together. The challenge: finding an author who could nail the crime-solving narrative while changing some of the details for privacy and security reasons. The women met with some writers, but nobody clicked until Hogan. Hogan was at a cocktail party before the 2023 Edgar Awards, where he was nominated for his last novel, 'Gangland,' when his literary agent told him about the project and stipulations associated with it. 'I said, 'You need someone like me, who knows crimes and can get creative,'' recalls Hogan, who co-created FX's 'The Strain' with Guillermo del Toro and wrote the book that inspired the Ben Affleck film 'The Town.' Though he had never written nonfiction before, he was looking for a challenge, and the project intrigued him. After meeting with the women in L.A., he realized the underlying story about the women that solved the case was more resonant than the crime itself. 'It's a story of four women who really found themselves at a crossroads in life — as many people do — and this search for identity that manifested itself in this cold case investigation that they then went on to incredibly solve, a case that the police hadn't been able to crack,' Hogan says in a Zoom conversation from his home in the Boston area. 'This is a one-of-a-kind story.' To do it justice, he met with the women and their families, retracing some of their investigative steps during a one-week visit. 'We took him to the scene of the crime,' Pianko says. 'Took him to a couple of different locations where we went looking for blood splatter—' 'Our favorite seafood restaurant,' interjects Landset Blank with a less bloody location. Next, the women 'gifted' Hogan all their information about the case. That included extensive research and saved texts, but no recordings or social media documentation. Their copious documentation proved invaluable to Hogan, who could get incredibly specific in some places and lean on creativity as needed elsewhere. 'I had literally reams of information and rough timelines via text messages that they had saved, and all sorts of things,' says the author. Then it was a matter of shaping all that information — about the case and the individual women — into a compelling narrative. 'There were a lot more dead ends and red herrings that would bog down readers,' Hogan observes. The newbie crime solvers — and their families — undeniably experienced some rough patches over the course of their sleuthing, but none of them were daunting enough to deter them from diving into another investigation when a detective they had been working with brought over a trunk full of possibilities. Now, with 'The Carpool Detectives' arriving Tuesday in bookstores, the crime solvers are closing in on a suspect for an even bigger case — this one involving a potential serial killer of around 20 women during the 1970s and '80s. The choice of time frame and the victims' gender were both deliberate. 'Let's take this case that's about women and try to get some closure and justice for them,' Poulos says they decided. Victims being unidentified was another reason why the women wanted to take on the case, Wilkinson continues. Beyond that, 'it felt safe,' due to the potential age of the killer this many decades later. Whatever happens with their second case, Pianko is glad she saw that news clip about the missing couple in her journalism class pre-COVID. Solving the case 'really revolutionized my life,' she says, admitting to being simultaneously excited and nervous about the Random House book's impending release, given some personal details included in it. 'It changed the entire trajectory of my life — it gave me meaning in a way that I hadn't had meaning in a long time.' 'These three women have become like family,' notes Landset Blank, who earlier this year leaned on the trio when her family's house burned down in the Palisades fire. 'We went through a lot more than just solving the case.'
