How a race for electric vehicles threatens a marine paradise
In a statement published online, Indonesia's Ministry for the Environment said: "Raja Ampat's biodiversity is a world heritage that must be protected. "We pay great attention to mining activities that occur in the area."But photographs - taken by Global Witness as part of an investigation - appear to show environmental damage already done. Aerial images show forest loss and sediment run-off into waters that are home to biodiverse coral reefs.Global Witness told the BBC that land use for mining, across multiple small islands in the archipelago, increased by 500 hectares - equivalent to about 700 football pitches - between 2020 and 2024.
Some conservationists, including the organisation Greenpeace, are concerned that the government's decision could be reversed by legal action by the mining companies. And one company that operates on Gag island, which has particularly rich deposits of nickel, has been allowed to continue its operations. The government said it would order the "restoration of the ecological impacts that occur" there.Coral reef conservationist and ecologist Dr Mark Erdmann told BBC News that he was "blown away, and so happy" about the government's decision to revoke the mining permits."This is the global epicenter of marine biodiversity," he told BBC News. Dr Erdmann has worked in Raja Ampat for more than two decades and is one of the founders of a shark rewilding project there called Reshark. He added: "It was a voice of outrage form Indonesian people that made the government pay attention."But this ecological controversy is an example of how the demand for the metals needed to power battery technology - for electric cars and other low carbon energy sources - can damage the environment.
Indonesia now accounts for more than half of the world's nickel mine production, according to a report last year by the Institute for Energy Economics and Financial Analysis.And while the beauty and biodiversity of the Raja Ampat has drawn attention to mining activity there, mining has been linked to ecological damage elsewhere too. A 2024 study by Forest Watch Indonesia found a link between the loss of forests associated with mining activity and increased local flooding and landslides.
Increasing demand for so-called critical minerals is shaping economic decisions around the world. It was the driving force for President Trump's recent executive order to jumpstart the mining of metallic nodules from the deep sea in international waters. It is a move that China has called illegal. Dr Erdmann pointed out that balancing economic growth with environmental protection was a particular dilemma for Indonesia. "It has a lot of nickel - one way or the other, some of it's going to come out of the ground," he said. Dr Michaela Guo Ying Lo from the University of Kent led a study in 2024 of the impact of mining on local communities in Sulawesi, the large Indonesian island that has most of the country's nickel deposits. That concluded that mining activity reduced poverty slightly, but that there was significant "worsening of environmental well-being" including increased local water and air pollution. "Indonesia is positioning itself globally in the nickel market," Dr Lo told BBC News. "But it's important not to forget what's happening locally."
Imam Shofwan, an environmental campaigner from an organisation called Jatam, based in Jakarta, told BBC News: "They say nickel is a solution to the climate crisis. But it's causing deforestation and destroying farmland."He also pointed out to the BBC that low-lying coastal areas, where some nickel deposits are found, are some of the places most vulnerable to the effects of climate change, including rising sea levels. Dr Erdmann commented: "The nickel dilemma is a horrible one. "Mining is always going to be environmentally impactful and we all tend to think that electrification is a good idea. But what is the acceptable damage that we're willing to see?" The BBC contacted the Indonesian government for comment, but did not receive a reply.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Daily Mail
5 hours ago
- Daily Mail
Scientists discover Earth has two new seasons
Experts have warned that 'haze season' and 'trash season' are now part of Earth's annual climate rhythm, disrupting ecosystems and redefining the calendar. The new seasons are now recurring every year, driven entirely by human activity and posing serious threats to public health, marine life, and global ecosystems. Haze season occurs annually across parts of Southeast Asia, when thick smoke blankets the region, causing hazardous air quality and widespread health concerns. Most of the haze comes from intentionally set fires, massive burn-offs used to clear land for agriculture in countries like Indonesia and Malaysia. A similar pattern has been found in the US as California 's wildfire season, once limited to the hottest months, now begins in spring and extends well into December. Meanwhile, in Bali, a different kind of season unfolds each year from December to March. As monsoon winds shift, ocean currents carry staggering volumes of plastic waste ashore, burying beaches under piles of garbage. This 'trash season' has become so consistent that locals can now predict it down to the month. Similar events have been seen in the Philippines, Thailand, and even along the US East Coast, where the Gulf Stream and other currents push floating debris toward Florida and the Carolinas, especially during summer. To better understand and describe the shifting climate rhythms, the research team analyzed decades of satellite imagery, weather data, and local reports. They've even introduced a new vocabulary to define the evolving seasonal patterns: extinct seasons, arrhythmic seasons, and syncopated seasons. The haze season in Southeast Asia typically starts in June and runs through September. The smoke often drifts across borders, enveloping cities in Singapore, Thailand, and beyond in a toxic cloud that can last for weeks. The researchers led by the London School of Economics and Political Science said that this 'is caused by the widespread burning of tropical peatlands in regions of Malaysia and Indonesia and is now considered an annual event in equatorial Southeast Asia, impacting the health and livelihoods of millions.' This season has also been appearing in northern India every winter, as the monsoon season ends and crop burning begins, often intensified locally by Diwali festive burning. The US has also become accustom to hazy skies each summer as parts of the norther east were blanketed with smoke over the weekend, sparking air quality alerts in New York and New Jersey. In 2023, smoke from record-breaking Canadian wildfires engulfed the Midwest and East Coast, turning skies orange over New York City. Events like this are becoming more frequent as wildfire seasons across North America grow longer, hotter, and more intense, researchers warned. 'Looking beyond emergent atmospheric seasons of the Anthropocene, marine pollution seasons are also surfacing, quite literally, as observed on the beaches of Bali, Indonesia,' the study reads. 'Here, floating plastic waste, either washed off the land by heavy rainfall or dumped into the oceans, is blown by strong monsoonal winds onto the southern beaches of the island province from December to March.' The new season has forced governments to employ hundreds of seasonal workers and volunteers to assist with clean-up each year. In March, Bali revealed that over 3,000 tons of ocean debris and trash landed on its shores during the most recent monsoon season. Such pollution on the East Coast of the US, specifically in areas like New England estuaries, tends to peak during the summer months. This is likely influenced by factors like increased precipitation during this season, leading to greater runoff and transport of land-based plastics into coastal waters. According to the study, some traditional seasons have also vanished. In alpine regions like the Andes and the Rocky Mountains, the once-predictable winter sports season is collapsing due to a severe lack of snow. In the northeast of England, seabirds like kittiwakes have stopped returning to breed at their usual time, breaking a natural cycle communities have depended on for generations. Other seasons like spring and summers have shifted out of sync. These are 'arrhythmic' changes, when spring comes too early, or summer overstays its welcome, describing the natural cycle is falling out of sync. For example, breeding and hibernation cycles across Europe are now starting weeks earlier than they used to. Similarly, wildfire and hurricane seasons are lengthening in North America and the Pacific, disrupting planning and preparedness. Then there are 'syncopated' seasons, which have not vanished or moved, but have intensified. A clear case is Europe's summer. Ever since the 2003 French heatwave killed thousands, scientists have noted that summers across the continent are not just hotter but more dangerous. These seasons follow the usual rhythm, but with a harder, more unpredictable beat. In this case, the season did not disappear, it became dangerously amplified. That makes it syncopated, which is the pattern still exists, but the beat is harder and more unpredictable.
BBC News
8 hours ago
- BBC News
River Deerness otters 'sign of a resilient ecosystem'
Regular sightings of otters on a river are a sign of a healthy local ecosystem, a charity has Wear Rivers Trust said evidence of the mammals living on the River Deerness in County Durham showed the area was home to a diverse range of wildlife.A local resident spotted otters 38 times on his trail camera last year, while environmental groups regularly find otter droppings - known as spraints - in the charity's volunteering and engagement office, Daniel Rutland, said the "apex predators" were a "flagship species" and their presence meant there were lots of other animals around. "Being apex predators they need a good food supply - that's the reason they're there," he said. "Everything from plants through to insects and fish need to be there to be sufficient food for the otter." 'Good news' As well as being a sign of a strong ecosystem, otters also increase biodiversity by eating fish, which feed on insect larvae, allowing insects such as dragonflies to Rutland said it was hard to know how many otters lived there because their territories often covered 12 to 18 miles (19.3 to 28.9km) of a riverbank."It could be just one or two otters or a family that cover the whole river and with a really healthy river you could have more than that," he said. "But we'll take the good news and enjoy it." Despite the positive signs of wildlife, The rivers trust estimates only about 15% of rivers in England are ecologically River Deerness was last tested by the Environment Agency in 2019 and was given a poor rating for its ecological quality."There's a long way to go yet to be able to say that any water course is healthy," Mr Rutland said. "But nature is resilient and we just celebrate every sign that there's life and there's recovery." Follow BBC North East on X, Facebook, Nextdoor and Instagram.
Daily Mail
10 hours ago
- Daily Mail
Scientists discover two alarming new seasons on Earth that return every year
Experts have warned that 'haze season' and 'trash season' are now part of Earth's annual climate rhythm, disrupting ecosystems and redefining the calendar. The new seasons are now recurring every year, driven entirely by human activity and posing serious threats to public health, marine life, and global ecosystems. Haze season occurs annually across parts of Southeast Asia, when thick smoke blankets the region, causing hazardous air quality and widespread health concerns. Most of the haze comes from intentionally set fires, massive burn-offs used to clear land for agriculture in countries like Indonesia and Malaysia. A similar pattern has been found in the US as California 's wildfire season, once limited to the hottest months, now begins in spring and extends well into December. Meanwhile, in Bali, a different kind of season unfolds each year from December to March. As monsoon winds shift, ocean currents carry staggering volumes of plastic waste ashore, burying beaches under piles of garbage. This 'trash season' has become so consistent that locals can now predict it down to the month. Similar events have been seen in the Philippines, Thailand, and even along the US East Coast, where the Gulf Stream and other currents push floating debris toward Florida and the Carolinas, especially during summer. To better understand and describe the shifting climate rhythms, the research team analyzed decades of satellite imagery, weather data, and local reports. They've even introduced a new vocabulary to define the evolving seasonal patterns: extinct seasons, arrhythmic seasons, and syncopated seasons. The haze season in Southeast Asia typically starts in June and runs through September. The smoke often drifts across borders, enveloping cities in Singapore, Thailand, and beyond in a toxic cloud that can last for weeks. The researchers led by the London School of Economics and Political Science said that this 'is caused by the widespread burning of tropical peatlands in regions of Malaysia and Indonesia and is now considered an annual event in equatorial Southeast Asia, impacting the health and livelihoods of millions.' This season has also been appearing in northern India every winter, as the monsoon season ends and crop burning begins, often intensified locally by Diwali festive burning. The US has also become accustom to hazy skies each summer as parts of the norther east were blanketed with smoke over the weekend, sparking air quality alerts in New York and New Jersey. In 2023, smoke from record-breaking Canadian wildfires engulfed the Midwest and East Coast, turning skies orange over New York City. New York City may experience a new 'smoke season' as a result of recurrent and increasingly severe forest fires in the northeast of the North American continent Events like this are becoming more frequent as wildfire seasons across North America grow longer, hotter, and more intense, researchers warned. 'Looking beyond emergent atmospheric seasons of the Anthropocene, marine pollution seasons are also surfacing, quite literally, as observed on the beaches of Bali, Indonesia,' the study reads. 'Here, floating plastic waste, either washed off the land by heavy rainfall or dumped into the oceans, is blown by strong monsoonal winds onto the southern beaches of the island province from December to March.' The new season has forced governments to employ hundreds of seasonal workers and volunteers to assist with clean-up each year. In March, Bali revealed that over 3,000 tons of ocean debris and trash landed on its shores during the most recent monsoon season. Such pollution on the East Coast of the US, specifically in areas like New England estuaries, tends to peak during the summer months. In alpine regions such as the Andes and the Rockies, the once-reliable winter sports season is disappearing due to lack of snow This is likely influenced by factors like increased precipitation during this season, leading to greater runoff and transport of land-based plastics into coastal waters. According to the study, some traditional seasons have also vanished. In alpine regions like the Andes and the Rocky Mountains, the once-predictable winter sports season is collapsing due to a severe lack of snow. In the northeast of England, seabirds like kittiwakes have stopped returning to breed at their usual time, breaking a natural cycle communities have depended on for generations. Other seasons like spring and summers have shifted out of sync. These are 'arrhythmic' changes, when spring comes too early, or summer overstays its welcome, describing the natural cycle is falling out of sync. For example, breeding and hibernation cycles across Europe are now starting weeks earlier than they used to. Similarly, wildfire and hurricane seasons are lengthening in North America and the Pacific, disrupting planning and preparedness. Then there are 'syncopated' seasons, which have not vanished or moved, but have intensified. A clear case is Europe's summer. Ever since the 2003 French heatwave killed thousands, scientists have noted that summers across the continent are not just hotter but more dangerous. These seasons follow the usual rhythm, but with a harder, more unpredictable beat. In this case, the season did not disappear, it became dangerously amplified. That makes it syncopated, which is the pattern still exists, but the beat is harder and more unpredictable.
