ICJ Advisory Opinion On Climate Change
'The Advisory Opinion is incredibly significant. It is a defining moment for climate litigation and state responsibility on climate change', says Jessica Palairet, Executive Director of Lawyers for Climate Action NZ Inc.
'The 133-page judgment of the United Nations' top court found that:
Greenhouse gas emissions have unequivocally caused climate change, which is an existential threat.
States have legal duties to reduce emissions and regulate businesses' climate impacts.
Granting fossil fuel exploration licenses or providing fossil fuel subsidies may constitute a breach of international law.
States have to act in line with limiting warming to 1.5°C - not 2°C. States have to exercise due diligence and do everything possible to avoid causing significant harm to the climate system.
States' obligations on climate change extend beyond climate treaties, also encompassing many other areas of international law, including human rights law, environmental law, and laws restricting cross-border harms.'
'The Advisory Opinion is non-binding, but it carries significant legal and moral weight. It provides an authoritative statement on states' obligations under international law that will be used by courts around the world, including in New Zealand, as they ask whether governments are meeting their legal obligations', says Palairet.
'In New Zealand, the Advisory Opinion is also of particular importance given our Free Trade Agreements with the European Union and United Kingdom require us to effectively implement the Paris Agreement. The Advisory Opinion provides greater clarity on what effectively implementing the Paris Agreement entails'.
'This Advisory Opinion provides a beacon of hope at a time when we are witnessing both the devastating impacts of climate change and backsliding from many countries, including New Zealand.'
'Our Government is set to make a series of important decisions on climate change in the coming weeks, including whether to cut our 2050 biogenic methane target to 14%. This judgment calls into question whether such a decision would be consistent with our international obligations, which require us to aim to limit warming to 1.5°C'.
'It also raises sharp questions around the Government's repeal of the ban on offshore oil and gas exploration, and recent announcement that it will provide $200m in co-investment for new gas fields. The ICJ has now made clear that this could constitute a breach of international law'.
'Today's opinion would not be here without the work of the Pacific Islands Students Fighting Climate Change, and the support of Pacific Island states, including Vanuatu. It is an incredible story of Pacific leadership on the world stage.'
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
NZ Herald
17 hours ago
- NZ Herald
Cambodia calls for ceasefire amid deadly border clashes with Thailand
A pagoda damaged by Thai artillery is pictured in Oddar Meanchey province on July 25. Thailand's acting Prime Minister Phumtham Wechayachai warned that cross-border clashes with Cambodia that have uprooted more than 130,000 people "could develop into war", as the countries traded deadly strikes for a second day. Photo / AFP Listening to articles is free for open-access content—explore other articles or learn more about text-to-speech. A pagoda damaged by Thai artillery is pictured in Oddar Meanchey province on July 25. Thailand's acting Prime Minister Phumtham Wechayachai warned that cross-border clashes with Cambodia that have uprooted more than 130,000 people "could develop into war", as the countries traded deadly strikes for a second day. Photo / AFP Cambodia wants an 'immediate ceasefire' with Thailand, the country's envoy to the United Nations said on Friday, after the neighbours traded deadly strikes for a second day, with Bangkok also signalling an openness to talks. A long-running border dispute erupted into intense fighting with jets, artillery, tanks and ground troops on Thursday, prompting the UN Security Council to hold an emergency meeting on the crisis on Friday. 'Cambodia asked for an immediate ceasefire – unconditionally – and we also call for the peaceful solution of the dispute,' said Phnom Penh's UN ambassador Chhea Keo after a closed meeting of the council attended by Cambodia and Thailand. A steady thump of artillery strikes could be heard from the Cambodian side of the border on Friday, where the province of Oddar Meanchey reported one civilian – a 70-year-old man – had been killed and five more wounded. More than 138,000 people have been evacuated from Thailand's border regions, its health ministry said, reporting 15 fatalities – 14 civilians and a soldier – with a further 46 wounded, including 15 troops.
Otago Daily Times
21 hours ago
- Otago Daily Times
Councillor brushes off Israeli woman's hate crime accusation
Nandor Tanczos A Whakatāne district councillor says he was both surprised and amused to learn from police he had been accused of a hate crime by a woman in Tel Aviv, Israel. On July 13, Whakatāne-Ōhope ward councillor Nandor Tanczos shared a link on his personal Facebook page to an online petition calling for United Nations special rapporteur Francesca Albanese and the doctors of Gaza to be nominated for a Nobel Peace Prize. The United States imposed sanctions on Ms Albanese, an outspoken critic of Israel's military offensive in Gaza, this month. Mr Tanczos said the petition was created in the wake of Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu's nomination of US President Donald Trump for the prize. The prize is awarded annually to the person who has "done the most or the best work for fraternity between nations, for the abolition or reduction of standing armies and for the holding and promotion of peace congresses". Mr Tanczos said he had also posted some "anti-genocide stuff" about the war in Gaza. The councillor regularly shares news articles, opinion pieces and his own views on the conflict via his personal Facebook page. He said he was contacted through his Facebook page by a woman in Tel Aviv who accused him of anti-Semitism and said she had two children in the Israeli Defence Force (IDF) who were "good people". Mr Tanczos responded to her, explaining he had nothing against Jewish people, only against the current actions being taken in Gaza by the IDF. Three days later, he said he received a courtesy call from the Whakatāne police. "The woman rang them from Tel Aviv to complain about my social media posts." Mr Tanczos said he was surprised to learn that opposing what he believed to be genocide was a hate crime in her eyes. He said he was assured by the police officer that phoned him they had looked into his online activity and informed the complainant no crime had been committed. "The police were great. It was just a courtesy call to let me know what had happened. It actually made me laugh to think that someone from Tel Aviv would go as far as reporting me to the New Zealand Police about this." Mr Tanczos said the experience would not stop him from expressing his opinions on Facebook. "I don't have any hesitation in denouncing Israel's actions in Gaza. I'm not anti-Semitic." Police were not available to comment but a senior media adviser from police national headquarters said she did not think such complaints were common. - By Diane McCarthy ■LDR is local body journalism co-funded by RNZ and NZ On Air.
RNZ News
a day ago
- RNZ News
Which countries recognise the state of Palestine. What would statehood look like?
By Zena Chamas Moroccans chant slogans and wave the Palestinian flag during a march to express their solidarity with the Palestinians in the Gaza Strip, in Rabat on 19 July, 2025. Photo: AFP As of 2025, there are about 147 countries that officially recognise the state of Palestine. France is set to recognise a Palestinian state at the United Nations General Assembly in September, bringing the total to 148 countries. Currently, there is no Palestinian state. Instead, there are the Occupied Palestinian Territories, which include Gaza, the West Bank and East Jerusalem. Only the Jewish state - Israel - exists. Some Palestinians live in Israel as citizens. Others live as refugees in Lebanon, Syria and Egypt. As of March 2025, the state of Palestine has been recognised as a sovereign nation by 147 of 193 member states of the United Nations, about 75 percent. In 2024, a group of UN experts called on all United Nations member states to recognise the State of Palestine, in order to bring about an immediate ceasefire in Gaza amid the Israel-Gaza war. Since then, nine countries - Armenia, Slovenia, Ireland, Norway, Spain, the Bahamas, Trinidad and Tobago, Jamaica and Barbados - formally recognised the State of Palestine. Most of the Middle East, Africa and Asia recognise Palestinian statehood. On Thursday (local time), France's President Emmanuel Macron announced that France would recognise a Palestinian state in hopes it would bring peace to the region. In response to Macron's move, Netanyahu said that such a move "rewards terror and risks creating another Iranian proxy". "A Palestinian state in these conditions would be a launch pad to annihilate Israel - not to live in peace beside it," Netanyahu said in a post on X. In other parts of Europe, Slovenia, Malta and Belgium are yet to recognise Palestinian statehood. Australia, New Zealand, the United States, Canada, Japan and South Korea also do not. Australia does not recognise a Palestinian state. On its website, the Department of Foreign Affairs and Trade states Australia is: "Committed to a two-state solution in which Israel and a future Palestinian state coexist, in peace and security, within internationally recognised borders." Public outrage as the Palestinian death toll has climbed has been followed only slowly by official statements from governments reluctant to criticise Israel - until now. The Australian Palestine Advocacy Network (APAN) has argued that Australia symbolically recognising Palestinian statehood would mean "establishing a formal diplomatic relationship with Palestine". Australia currently has an ambassador to Israel, but only a representative to Palestine. In recent comments, Prime Minister Anthony Albanese did not refer directly to recognising Palestine, but pointed to Australia's long-standing ambitions around recognition. "Recognising the legitimate aspirations of the Palestinian people for a state of their own has long been a bipartisan position in Australia," Albanese said. "The reason a two-state solution remains the goal of the international community is because a just and lasting peace depends upon it. "Australia is committed to a future where both the Israeli and Palestinian peoples can live in peace and safety, within secure and internationally recognised borders." Last year, Foreign Minister Penny Wong indicated Australia was considering recognising a Palestinian state as part of a peace process, rather than at the endpoint. This week, Australia joined 27 other countries demanding an immediate end to the war. In November 2024, Australia voted in favour of a draft United Nations resolution recognising "permanent sovereignty" of Palestinians and the Golan Heights to natural resources in the Occupied Territories for the first time in more than two decades. A total of 159 countries voted in favour of the draft resolution in a UN committee, including Australia, the United Kingdom, New Zealand, France, Germany and Japan. The State of Palestine was formally declared by the Palestine Liberation Organisation (PLO) on 15 November, 1988. It claims sovereignty over the West Bank, including East Jerusalem, and the Gaza Strip. According to senior lecturer in law at the University of South Australia, Juliette McIntyre, a state has certain defining features under international law. These features include a permanent population, a determinate territory, an "effective" government and the capacity to enter into relations with other states. "In some ways, the most important thing is recognition by other states - this enables entering into diplomatic relations, and membership of international organisations," McIntyre said. She added that the governance of a Palestinian state could look like "free and fair elections for all Palestinians exercising their right of self-determination". "It is up to the Palestinian people to elect their representatives and decide on their form of governance," she said. Recognising a Palestinian state could mean the beginning of a "two-state solution" where both a Jewish state and an Arab state would exist at the same time. "A two-state solution requires two states. Israel's occupation of Palestinian territory has been found to be unlawful. "Recognition of Palestine is not hostile to Israel, Israel is an established state and recognition of Palestine does nothing to impact on this," McIntyre said. The two-state solution is still widely regarded by world leaders as the only way to end the conflict, but is not as popular in Israel and parts of the occupied Palestinian territories. "The territorial integrity of both states should be respected, and new borders could only come about by treaty agreement between both states," McIntyre said. What are the one-state and two-state solutions? Photo shows Benjamin Netanyahu stands in front of two Israeli flags. Benjamin Netanyahu stands in front of two Israeli flags. On Wednesday, Israel's parliament, the Knesset, voted 71-13 in favour of annexation of the West Bank, raising questions about the future of a Palestinian state. The non-binding vote was backed by members of Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu's right-wing coalition, as well as some opposition members of parliament. In a recent post on X, Netanyahu said: "Let's be clear: the Palestinians do not seek a state alongside Israel; they seek a state instead of Israel." Both Netanyahu and other members of Israel's parliament have shown their lack of support for a two-state solution. This year, the UN, which largely supports a two-state solution, will hold an international conference on the question of Palestine and the implementation of the two-state solution in New York from 28 to 29 July. The United States has opted out of attendance. - ABC
