Education Department layoffs: Why Supreme Court's decision is ‘willfully blind' and ‘naive', judges explain
The layoffs 'will likely cripple the department', Joun wrote. While the majority did not explain its decision to back Trump, Justices Sonia Sotomayor, Ketanji Brown Jackson, and Elena Kagan were quick to publish their dissent.
'When the Executive publicly announces its intent to break the law, and then executes on that promise, it is the Judiciary's duty to check that lawlessness, not expedite it,' Sotomayor wrote.
'It hands the Executive the power to repeal statutes by firing all those necessary to carry them out,' the three justices further added. 'The majority is either willfully blind to the implications of its ruling or naive, but either way the threat to our Constitution's separation of powers is grave."
Meanwhile, Education Secretary Linda McMahon said it's a 'shame' it took the Supreme Court's intervention to let Trump's plan move ahead.
'Today, the Supreme Court again confirmed the obvious: the President of the United States, as the head of the Executive Branch, has the ultimate authority to make decisions about staffing levels, administrative organization, and day-to-day operations of federal agencies,' McMahon said in a statement.
Earlier on Monday, over 20 states sued the administration over billions of dollars in frozen education funding for after-school care, summer programs and more.
Education Department employees who were targeted by the layoffs have been on paid leave since March, according to a union that represents some of the agency's staff.
Joun's order had prevented the department from fully terminating them, though none had been allowed to return to work, according to the American Federation of Government Employees Local 252. Without Joun's order, the workers would have been terminated in early June.
The Education Department had said earlier in June that it was 'actively assessing how to reintegrate' the employees. A department email asked them to share whether they had gained other employment, saying the request was meant to 'support a smooth and informed return to duty.'
The current case involves two consolidated lawsuits that said Trump's plan amounted to an illegal closure of the Education Department.
One suit was filed by the Somerville and Easthampton school districts in Massachusetts along with the American Federation of Teachers and other education groups. The other legal action was filed by a coalition of 21 Democratic attorneys general.
The suits argued that layoffs left the department unable to carry out responsibilities required by Congress, including duties to support special education, distribute financial aid and enforce civil rights laws.
(With AP inputs)
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Mint
26 minutes ago
- Mint
Leading economies must work together to fix imbalances, or face instability, says BOE's Bailey
The U.S., China and other leading economies should work together to agree on a set of national policies that will help narrow the large imbalances that now threaten the global trade system, Bank of England Governor Andrew Bailey said. In an annual speech to bankers, Bailey said Tuesday that President Trump's tariffs represent 'a generational change" in the global trade system that threatens to weaken economic growth. 'They are by no means the first such shifts, even if they are the most sudden and fundamental in the post-war era," he said. The central banker said that while barriers to trade and subsidies to favored businesses contribute to the trade imbalances that have prompted Trump's tariffs, they are not the underlying causes. Repeating a view long held by international economists, Bailey said that while China pursues policies that suppress consumer spending, the U.S. runs budget deficits that are too large to allow for a sustained narrowing of its trade deficits. 'The U.S. does need to explain how it can regard its internal imbalance as sustainable and its external imbalance as not so," he said. 'And China needs to explain how it will tackle its persistently weak domestic consumption." Bailey called on the International Monetary Fund to 'be creative in deploying its convening power" in helping the U.S., China and other leading economies settle on 'mutually-agreed policies which mitigate risks associated with excess imbalances." The central banker referred to a 2006 initiative that saw the IMF consult with China, the eurozone, Japan, Saudi Arabia, and the U.S. on ways to narrow imbalances, yielding a number of policy pledges that have yet to be fulfilled. At the time, China said it would pursue measures to boost domestic demand, while the U.S. said it would cut government borrowing. 'There is merit here in reflecting on the lessons from the 2006 Multilateral Consultation exercise, and what could work better in future, " Bailey said. The alternative to working out fixes together is a period of instability for the global economy as the U.S. sets the new terms for global trade, the central banker warned. 'How to reconcile an open world economy with national interests is a very old issue," he said. 'The rules of the process have to be accepted and the imposition of rules by one player, however dominant, isn't a recipe for sustained stability." Bailey warned that countries with large current account deficits tend to come under more pressure from financial markets than countries with surpluses because they rely on foreign financing that can be withdrawn or become more expensive. And while the U.S. has long been spared those pressures because of the U.S. dollar's role as the leading reserve currency, it may not be so indefinitely, Bailey warned. 'This financial market pressure point is relevant notwithstanding the reserve currency argument, simply because it is very hard to judge the limits of sustainability," he said. 'We have seen market disturbance this year. We have to be highly alert to financial stability risks—something that I can assure you we are following closely."
&w=3840&q=100)
Business Standard
28 minutes ago
- Business Standard
India's Russian oil imports up slightly in January-June, shows data
India's oil imports from Russia rose marginally in the first half of this year, with private refiners Reliance Industries Ltd and Nayara Energy making almost half of the overall purchases from Moscow, according to data provided by sources. India, the world's third-largest oil importer and consumer, received about 1.75 million barrels per day of Russian oil in January-June this year, up 1 per cent from a year ago, the data showed. The two private refiners have term deals to buy Russian oil, while state companies rely on purchases from the spot market. India's purchases of Russian oil sold at discounted rates surged after Western nations imposed sanctions and stopped buying oil from Moscow over its invasion of Ukraine in 2022. Earlier this week, US President Donald Trump threatened sanctions on buyers of Russian exports unless Moscow agrees a peace deal within 50 days. Indian refiners expect that any move by Trump is unlikely to disrupt oil supplies but could wipe out the thinning discount on Russian crude, as traditional and new suppliers ramp up output, refinery officials told Reuters. In January-June, Russia continued to be the top supplier to India, accounting for about 35 per cent of India's overall supplies, followed by Iraq, Saudi Arabia, and United Arab Emirates. The United States was the fifth-largest oil supplier to India, up from the sixth position it held a year earlier, the data showed. India plans to raise energy imports from the U.S. as it prepares for a trade deal with Washington to avoid stiff U.S. import tariffs. Overall, India's oil imports in January-June rose by 4.3 per cent to about 5.2 million bpd, the data showed. In June, India's Russian oil imports rose 17.4 per cent to about 2 million bpd from the previous month, dragging down the share of Middle Eastern producers and the Organization of the Petroleum Exporting Countries.
India Today
28 minutes ago
- India Today
Did secret agent Melania Trumpenko turn Trump against Putin?
Ukrainians have a new agent to thank, Agent Melania Trumpenko. The First Lady of the US has now entered memedom after US President Donald Trump said FLOTUS played a key role in his apparent shift in attitude towards Russia and its President Vladimir Putin. The "enko" suffix being attached to Melania is a common Ukrainian patronymic, often meaning "descendant of" or "son of".advertisementDuring a meeting at the White House on Monday with Nato Secretary General Mark Rutte, Trump said his wife had helped point out Putin's duplicity."My conversations with him [Putin] are always very pleasant. I say, isn't that a very lovely conversation? And then the missiles go off that night," Trump said. "I go home, I tell the first lady: I spoke with Vladimir today. We had a wonderful conversation. She said: Really? Another city was just hit."Slovenian-born Melania Trump, who grew up in the former Yugoslavia, has long appeared more supportive of Ukraine than her husband, who in February this year even called Volodymyr Zelenskyy a "dictator".Yugoslovia, including Slovenia, broke away from the Soviet Union in 1948. Slovenia attained independence from Yugoslavia in after Russia's full-scale invasion of Ukraine in 2022, Melania urged her social media followers to donate to the Red Cross, calling it "heartbreaking and horrific to see innocent people suffering".Following Trump's latest remarks on July 14, social media users responded quickly, and humorously, by thanking the First Lady for her apparent CHEER 'AGENT MELANIA TRUMPENKO' ON SOCIAL MEDIAOne person posted a photo of "Agent Melania Trumpenko" wearing a blazer with a Ukrainian trident insignia, the same outfit she wore during Trump's oath ceremony, but edited with the Ukrainian face is half-shaded by a large hat, giving the impression of an undercover operative stationed in the White House, subtly working in Ukraine's favour.A Ukrainian magazine, Business, reported that "there is a lot of love on social media tonight for Melania Trump" after the US announced it would send Patriot air defence systems to quickly picked up on the "agent" joke after Trump mentioned her role."Melania's Yugoslav secret agent training kicking in," wrote one user."Anyone thinks it's a coincidence that Melania Trump is from an ex-Soviet Union country Slovenia? A Russian hand-picked for Agent Krasnov aka Trump," said another."Our Man Melan. Ukrainians have praised 'undercover agent' Melan Trumpinski,' read another tongue-in-cheek not everyone was amused."You are lying animals. The Ukrainian propaganda machine, fully controlled by Zelensky's Office, has completely degraded. Yesterday, Trump was your 'Kremlin agent,' 'Krasnov's puppet,' a 'threat to democracy.' Today, he's your hero because he sent weapons. And Melania in a vyshyvanka for your PR show. This isn't just pathetic, it's disgusting, humiliating, and hypocritical. Shame on you," one user responded angrily.- EndsMust Watch
