Man who killed Edmonton father at LRT station sentenced to 7 years in prison
Rukinisha Nkundabatware, 52, was attacked at the Belvedere LRT station on the evening of July 9, 2023.
Jamal Wheeler, 29, was charged with second-degree murder in his death.
Jamal Wheeler
Jamal Wheeler
Last November he pleaded guilty to the lesser charge of manslaughter.
According to the agreed statement of facts, Nkundabatware had taken the LRT from Clairview to Belvedere station around 9 p.m. to meet a friend.
The two men were standing on the south side of 129 Avenue south of the transit centre at 9:48 p.m., when an unknown man, later identified as Wheeler, came running from the transit centre and chased after Nkundabatware's friend.
The document says the friend ran from Wheeler, who pulled a knife out of his waistband and stabbed Nkundabatware in the chest before running from the scene.
Nkundabatware was pronounced dead at the scene.
Rukinisha Nkundabatware homicide
A crowd gathers outside Belvedere LRT Station on July 9, 2023 after the death of Rukinisha Nkundabatware.
An autopsy showed a single stab wound that measured 4.5 centimetres by 1.8 centimetres.
It injured his lung, heart, chest wall, as well as skin and soft tissues.
An immigrant from the Democratic Republic of Congo, Nkundabatware came to Canada with his wife and seven children to escape violence at home.
Belvedere death July 9 2023
An Edmonton police officer uses their flashlight to examine a scene at Edmonton's Belvedere Station on July 9, 2023. Police used a sheet to cover what appeared to be a body.
According to the agreed statement of facts, police used CCTV footage from the transit station to identify Wheeler, who had the same colourful sneakers and 'I (heart) P***y' tattoo as the attacker captured on camera.
The court documents show Wheeler admitted to stabbing Nkundabatware in a subsequent police interview, and admitted it was 'objectively foreseeable that death could result from his unlawful act.'
At the sentencing hearing on Monday, court heard Wheeler has a fetal alcohol spectrum disorder diagnosis.
He was born to a mother who suffered from addiction issues and never met his father.
Court heard he has a long criminal history, including previous incidents of targeting transit users.
He has been homeless and unemployed for most of his adult life.
In a victim impact statement read by the Crown, Nkundabatware's son David said he has lived in constant fear since his father's death, especially while using public transit.
He said his life feels broken and his father's death has left a permanent scar.
Wheeler also addressed the court.
'I just want to say that I'm sorry for my actions. I deeply regret what happened,' he said.
The defence asked for a five to six year sentence, while the Crown asked for seven to nine years.
As he read his sentence, Justice Kent J. Teskey spoke directly to Wheeler, telling him his crime had a direct impact on society.
'It causes people to feel unsafe, Mr. Wheeler,' he said.
'When people don't feel safe it has a significant effect on society.'
He reiterated that people have the right to feel safe while using transit.
'They have the right not to have their head on a swivel, not worried about what is going to happen.'
Justice Teskey said he took into account Wheeler's life circumstances when making his decision, but also the severity of the case and Wheeler's criminal history.
'This is a very serious offence,' Justice Teskey said.
'This is not the first time the court has dealt with you.'
With credit for 916 days served, Wheeler will spend another 1,639 days, or 4.5 years in prison.
With files from CTV News Edmonton's Amanda Anderson
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
CBC
15 minutes ago
- CBC
3 people injured in weekend altercations in Dawson City, Yukon
Police in Dawson City, Yukon, are investigating a couple of weekend incidents that left several people injured, including an alleged stabbing that hospitalized a man. Chris MacIntyre has more.
CBC
36 minutes ago
- CBC
B.C. child watchdog urges more progress 1 year after report into 11-year-old boy's torture and death
One year after a landmark report into the horrific death of an 11-year-old Indigenous boy in foster care called for a "complete overhaul" of B.C.'s child welfare system, the province's child watchdog says the NDP government has a long way to go in improving conditions for the most vulnerable. "We can do so much better for children and families," said B.C.'s representative for children and youth, Jennifer Charlesworth. Charlesworth says she's worried that as the province faces a $10.9 billion deficit, key social services that keep families out of poverty and children safe will be cut. "What we worry, because we have seen it many times … is that what gets cut are social programs. What gets cut are the very things that help stabilize and support families through those difficult times," she said. "Poverty has a direct impact on child well-being." Charlesworth was speaking one year after the report into the 2021 death of an 11-year-old boy, who was beaten and tortured by the foster parents who were meant to care for him. That report, Don't Look Away, included recommendations to fix what Charlesworth calls an "outdated, siloed, discriminatory" child welfare system that requires "a complete overhaul." The report detailed the many missteps by the Ministry of Children and Family Development and a number of other agencies that contributed to the child's death. Charlesworth called on the government to create a new child welfare strategy which includes more accountability for child welfare workers and helps First Nations take responsibility for child welfare in their communities. The government has not yet completed the new child welfare strategy and provided no timeline for when it will be done. Charlesworth says action is still needed on providing support to vulnerable families, including preventative services such as a basic income and housing. The report also calls for more work on preventing violence within the home and providing more resources to extended family caregivers. "In the absence of doing the preventative services, we see very expensive services needed to be provided when a child is older, when the family is in a significant state of crisis or when the child has come into care," Charlesworth said. She says, for example, staffed group homes can cost up to $100,000 a month per child. "Surely, we can do much more and much better for many families, with $1.2 million that might [be the] cost [of] the housing of one child with very significant needs, if we backed up the bus." Short-staffing must be addressed, Charlesworth says Charlesworth also says the government must address the short-staffing among child welfare workers that can allow children to fall through the cracks. She says demand outstrips the current workforce capacity in the child welfare system. Jodie Wickens, the minister of children and family development, says her office has added tools for oversight and tracking to make sure social workers are visiting children and youth at least once every 90 days. According to the report, social workers had not visited the 11-year-old or his sister in seven months before he was found badly beaten in February 2021. The child was flown to a hospital in Vancouver, where he later died. The identities of the boy and his sister are protected by a publication ban on children in care, but he is referred to as Colby in the report. Wickens said her ministry has increased its workforce by almost 20 per cent in the last two years to address short-staffing concerns. "So staffing has increased ... but too many workers say they can't fulfil their responsibilities to children with their current caseload," Charlesworth said. First Nations child welfare agreements Wickens says the government has hired a new Indigenous child-welfare director, Jeremy Y'in Neduklhchulh Williams. "He is the first of this kind in the entire country," Wickens told CBC News. He is helping facilitate agreements with First Nations who want to reclaim jurisdiction over child welfare. The province has signed agreements with 12 Nations, and dozens more are being negotiated. Charlesworth says none of those 12 First Nations have consented to oversight from her office. She says she's concerned about the possibility of children falling through the cracks during the "transitional period" when First Nations communities are taking over jurisdiction from government agencies. The Indigenous child-welfare director's role includes ensuring that doesn't happen, says Wickens, and "ensuring that there is communication and co-ordination and that roles and responsibilities are clearly outlined." Charlesworth says new training has been delivered to over 800 child welfare workers to ensure that they are better prepared to work with Nations that are taking over child and family services from the government. Charlesworth also says the government has not done enough to tap into the knowledge of First Nations communities and other community services to find better ways to support children and families. Colby was a member of a First Nation in the Fraser Valley. Colby and his sister were placed in the care of his mother's cousin and her partner. This was despite the mother asking that the kids stay with their grandmother, and despite recorded allegations of sexualized violence involving the cousin's partner. According to the report, Colby asked several times not to be sent back to the home. In 2023, the foster parents were sentenced to 10 years in prison for aggravated assault of the boy and his sister, and manslaughter.
CTV News
an hour ago
- CTV News
B.C. mother ordered to pay over $4K for son's dirt bike thefts, tribunal finds
A mother has been ordered to fork out for her child's wrongdoing after a B.C. Civil Resolution Tribunal determined her to be responsible for her son's involvement in the theft and subsequent damage of three dirt bikes. A decision on the dispute posted July 10 outlines how three Honda dirt bikes belonging to the applicant, referred to as Mr. S, were 'intentionally taken and damaged' in September 2023. The bikes were later found at the home of the mother of one minor, referred to as B, and the home of his friend, EW, after the two had taken them in the night and removed their parts, the decision read. In B.C., a minor is defined as anyone under the age of 19. The tribunal member was tasked with determining whether B or his mother was financially responsible for the damage caused after the mother, named Ms. R, argued she had no financial responsibility for her child's actions. Tribunal member Alissa Reynolds referred to The Parental Liability Act, particularly section 3, which says that if a child intentionally takes, damages, or destroys another person's property their parent is liable for the loss of or damage to the property. Reynolds said Ms. R had a possible defence, however, if she could prove that she both 'exercised reasonable supervision' over her son at the time of the incident, and 'made reasonable efforts to prevent or discourage B's conduct.' Ultimately the defence collapsed after Reynolds noted how B had been 'behaving inappropriately' for several months before the bikes were taken, and that Ms. R hadn't been surprised by the latest actions of her son. Reynolds said Ms. R was unable to provide evidence 'about her house rules, whether B has a curfew, or steps she takes to ensure he is home during the night,' which implied she had not been carrying out a reasonable level of supervision when her son and his friend stole the bikes around 2 or 3 a.m. that morning. The mother also 'did not give any evidence of steps that she took to improve her parenting skills before this incident,' the decision read. Based on those factors, Reynolds found that Ms. R had not established she was reasonably supervising her son on the night of the incident, or 'that she made reasonable efforts to prevent or discourage' his conduct. 'I find that Ms. R is liable for B's actions in damaging the dirt bikes,' she said Ms. R and her son were ordered to pay a total of $4,106.63, in damages within 30 days of the decision being made.
