
Couche-Tard's Failed Bid for Seven & i Sparks Debate Over Japan
The bid was audacious from the start. 7-Eleven convenience stores have one of Japan's most recognizable brands and a takeover would have been the largest by a foreign entity in the country's history. Moreover, the founding Ito family were so opposed to the deal that they turned to one of their archrivals to try and block it.
Still, the government, which has been pushing for companies to take a more investor-friendly approach, did not raise strong political opposition, even though Seven & i had sought greater protection under a law that could have scuttled a deal. While Couche-Tard placed the blame squarely on intransigence from Seven & i's management, the failure of the deal runs counter to the broader trend in the investing landscape, according to Nicholas Smith, a strategist at CLSA.
'Seven & i is just an obstructive character in an ongoing success story,' said Smith. 'Activist trades and shareholder proposals are on fire. Private equity sees Japan as one of the most attractive markets in the world and is hiring aggressively. Management can't afford to relax one bit.'
Stephen Dacus, the new chief executive officer of Seven & i, now has to prove that the Japanese retailer can grow and boost its efficiency on its own. The shares fell 9% on Thursday after Couche-Tard walked away from its bid. The company plans to sell its superstore business for $5.4 billion, and is proposing a ¥2 trillion share buyback and a listing of its US business.
Seven & i's rejection of the deal is a sign of more aggressiveness in Japanese firms, according to Jesper Koll, expert director at Monex Group Inc. 'The issue is not that this is old-style Japan protectionism, quite the opposite,' said Koll. 'This is actually an injection of energy and competitive spirits into a Japan-led management team that is actually very international.'
The history of attempted takeovers of marquee Japanese companies by outsiders is mixed.
KKR, CVC Capital Partners and Blackstone Inc. walked away from a buyout of Toshiba Corp. after meeting stiff resistance from management. Concerns about the valuation, complexity and political nature of the deal were all headwinds that eventually resulted in a consortium led by a domestic fund prevailing.
Hon Hai Precision Industry Co., better known as Foxconn, pulled off a deal in 2016 to take a controlling stake in Japanese electronics maker Sharp Corp. for ¥389 billion. The Taiwanese electronics contract manufacturer had pursued the Japanese company for years. Foxconn founder Terry Gou had lobbied Japanese lawmakers, co-opted banks and sweetened its offer to outmaneuver a Japanese government-backed bidder.
'The implications of today's news will only be understood a year from now, and will hinge on whether management succeeds in accelerating group reforms and turning around the situation in both Japan and the US,' said Michael Jacobs, an investment analyst at T. Rowe Price Japan on Thursday.
Unsolicited offers have quite often met strong resistance regardless of where the prospective buyers come from.
Japanese motor maker Nidec Corp. made an unsolicited bid for Makino Milling Machine Co., shocking many Japanese companies that had never imagined they could become a takeover target by a Japanese firm. Nidec, like Couche-Tard, withdrew the bid earlier this year due to strong opposition. In another closely watched case, Taiwan's Yageo Corp made a takeover bid for Shibaura Electronics, prompting a counter bid from Japanese rival Mineba Mitsumi Inc.
Others argued that the failure of the Couche-Tard deal had nothing to do with the nationalities or cultures of the companies involved. The issue was simply money and Couche-Tard's ¥6.77 trillion bid simply wasn't enough.
'Seven & i did what any US company would do,' said Jamie Halse, CEO & CIO at Senjin Capital Pty Ltd. 'It was up to Couche- Tard to put in a knockout offer.'
With assistance from Kanoko Matsuyama and Reed Stevenson.
This article was generated from an automated news agency feed without modifications to text.

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles


Time of India
an hour ago
- Time of India
Now, Bhumre's driver gets summoned by income tax department
Chhatrapati Sambhajinagar: Jawed Shaikh, who is employed as a driver with Shiv Sena MP Sandipan Bhumre and his MLA son Vilas, was summoned by the . The department requested his presence along with his books of accounts and documents. Tired of too many ads? go ad free now Jawed Shaikh is already being investigated by the Economic Offences Wing (EOW) about why Mir Mehmood Ali Khan, a descendant of Salar Jung, gifted the driver prime land worth hundreds of crores. On July 3, Shaikh received a fresh summons under section 131(1A) of the Income Tax Act 1961, requesting his attendance in connection with proceedings under the Act in his case. Section 131(1A) grants the I-T department the authority to enforce an individual's attendance, discover and inspect any property, and issue commissions. It also allows the department to examine the assessee on oath and compel the production of necessary books of accounts and all relevant documents. The I-T department warned in its notice that any default by Jawed Shaikh would attract action under section 272A(1)(C) of the I-T Act, empowering the investigation officer to impose a penalty of Rs 10,000 for each default. Jawed Shaikh, a trusted aide of the Bhumres, became the focus of the investigation after Mir Mehmood Ali Khan gifted him prime plots valued at hundreds of crores. There are allegations that Jawed received approximately 8.5 acres in two instalments through hibanama (gift deed). The combined market valuation of these plots is about Rs 500 crores. Documents revealed that both transactions had common witnesses, and the bonds were purchased from the same notary lawyer. Applications to add Jawed Shaikh's name to the PR card for both properties were made on Feb 9, 2023, and his name was recorded on the PR card on May 25, 2023, and June 28, 2024, respectively. Tired of too many ads? go ad free now These prime plots are located in Chhatrapati Sambhajinagar city, where the economic offences wing of the city police is already investigating a related complaint. In the past few weeks, the EOW has recorded statements from Khan, four of his children, and Jawed Shaik. Unsatisfied with their responses, the EOW plans to summon them again to cooperate in the inquiry. Phone calls and messages sent to Jawed for his comments did not elicit any response.


Time of India
an hour ago
- Time of India
UP team extends invitation to Hanwha Grp to invest in state
1 2 3 Lucknow: A delegation led by finance minister Suresh Khanna is attending the ongoing World Expo 2025 in Osaka, Japan, to strengthen economic ties and attract global investments. On the second day, the delegation held detailed discussions with members of the Hanwha Group and invited them to invest in UP. The delegation also toured Hanwha Group's advanced manufacturing facilities in Wakayama, which produce high-quality steel, food products, and other industrial goods. Their engagement with Hanwha's leadership focused on deepening industrial partnerships and encouraging Japanese enterprises to explore UP's investment landscape. An official spokesperson said: "The finance minister extended a formal invitation to the Hanwha Group to establish manufacturing operations in UP. He highlighted the state's world-class infrastructure, investor-centric policies, and availability of a skilled, future-ready workforce. He also emphasised the importance of local employment generation and encouraged Hanwha to recruit talent from UP and contribute to ongoing skill development initiatives. by Taboola by Taboola Sponsored Links Sponsored Links Promoted Links Promoted Links You May Like Up to 70% off | Shop Sale Libas Undo " Meanwhile, an EU delegation led by Vivian Loonela visited the UP Pavilion, exploring strategic partnerships to promote sustainable, experience-rich tourism across the state. As part of its global outreach, Invest UP has set up the UP Pavilion, which is witnessing enthusiastic footfall from investors and international delegates keen to explore the state's business-friendly environment, attractive incentive structures, and rapidly evolving industrial ecosystem, officials said. The spokesperson said that principal secretary, industries and infrastructure development, Alok Kumar assured full institutional support to Japanese investors and reaffirmed the state govt's commitment to facilitating investments in key sectors such as manufacturing, logistics, semiconductor and green energy. This outreach marks another milestone in UP's efforts to position itself as a globally competitive investment destination and strengthen industrial cooperation with Japan, officials said.


New Indian Express
2 hours ago
- New Indian Express
Paddy, wetland conservation Act, three fold growth in IT sector key highlights of VS government
THIRUVANANTHAPURAM: Among the many initiatives undertaken by the VS Achuthanandan-led government from 2006-11, the most remembered one was the legislation to conserve the paddy land and wetland and to restrict its conversion or reclamation. The Act was aimed to promote the state's agricultural growth and sustain its fragile ecological system. Enacted in 2008, the Act intended to curb the indiscriminate reclamation and conversion of paddy land and wetland in the state. The legislation also increased the level of awareness in society against the reclamation of wetlands and the need to conserve them. The legislation was passed after the select committee of the Assembly held 22 sittings across Kerala which were attended by a large number of people. "This Bill received the highest number of suggestions from a wide spectrum of stakeholders and it was also noted internationally," remembered KP Rajendran, who piloted the Bill as the then Revenue Minister. Achuthanandan's detractors would often cite his role in the agitation against computers decades ago. But it was during his tenure as CM that IT exports grew significantly, with the growth even surpassing the national average. "It should be noted that the three fold growth in IT exports was recorded despite the worst global recession of 2008. Besides, the VS government is credited with adding many new IT parks in the state's technological landscape and permitting many IT majors to set up base in the state," said Joseph C Mathew, Achuthanandan's former IT advisor. The idea for the first district IT park in Kerala at Kollam was announced in January 2009 when Achuthanandan was CM and was opened on February 15, 2011. The first phase of Koratty IT Park became operational on October 10, 2009. It was launched as the first IT park in Kerala under the "Hub and Spoke Model," with Infopark Kochi acting as the hub.